The Weight of the Choices We Never Made

A literary reflection on the choices we never made, the lives we imagine, the limits of hindsight, and how unrealized possibilities can influence the decisions still available to us.

The Weight of the Choices We Never Made — an old admission letter, suitcase and books on a sunlit railway station bench.

The letter arrived at an address that had not belonged to Daniel for twenty-five years.

His sister found it among a collection of papers their mother had kept in a wooden cabinet. It was an offer of admission to a university in another country, dated the summer Daniel turned nineteen.

He remembered receiving it. He also remembered the conversation that followed, during which he and his parents discussed the cost of traveling, the uncertainty of the financial arrangements and the difficulties his father was experiencing at work.

Daniel had accepted a place at a university closer to home.

In the years that followed, he became a civil engineer, married, raised a family and acquired a considerable attachment to the town where he lived. He rarely thought about the letter.

But as he unfolded it again, he found himself imagining a station in an unfamiliar city, a room in which he might have lived, and the people he might have met had he accepted the offer.

The peculiar thing was that he could imagine missing these possibilities without wishing to exchange his present life for another.

The letter belonged to an unmade decision, yet the possibility it represented had acquired an emotional presence of its own.

There are choices we never made that continue to occupy a small part of our lives. They appear in questions we ask ourselves, in memories of what was once possible, and in stories we construct about the people we might otherwise have become.

The weight of those choices is not always a sign that we chose badly. Sometimes it is evidence that choosing one meaningful direction necessarily meant leaving another unexplored.

The attractive arrangement of an imaginary life

Daniel’s imagined university was a place in which the most interesting features of living abroad occupied considerable attention.

He pictured unfamiliar streets, friendships formed through shared discoveries and the intellectual excitement associated with being introduced to ways of thinking he had not previously encountered.

He did not often imagine struggling to find affordable accommodation or telephoning his family after learning that his father’s circumstances had become more difficult.

This was not an attempt to deceive himself. He simply had very little information with which to construct the ordinary requirements of a life he had never lived.

An imagined alternative can be remarkably easy to inhabit because so much of its inconvenience remains unspecified.

A woman who considered becoming a professional photographer may picture the exhibitions she might have held without calculating how many uncertain months would have preceded them. A man who declined a job in a distant city may remember its promising salary while knowing almost nothing about the relationships he would have formed there.

The alternative exists in a condition that makes favorable details available for our attention without obliging us to supply all the other details.

Meanwhile, our actual lives have no such advantage. We know the difficulties of our workplaces, the arguments that have occurred within our relationships and the disappointing outcomes of decisions that once appeared promising.

As considered in The Lives We Measure Against Others, a visible achievement cannot always tell us enough about the circumstances through which it was produced.

An unrealized possibility offers even less evidence.

Its value may have been genuine. Its costs might also have been genuine.

We can remain interested in what another direction might have offered without treating our ability to imagine its most attractive features as proof that it would have been a better life.

When there was no fair opportunity to choose

At eighteen, Farah wanted to study history.

She had performed well at school, enjoyed working with historical documents and hoped eventually to teach. The nearest institution offering the program she wanted was several hours from the town in which her family lived.

There were no affordable arrangements for accommodation, and her mother needed assistance that nobody else was available to provide.

Farah took a local position in an administrative office.

Many years later, when people asked why she had not pursued her interest, she sometimes replied that she had chosen a different occupation.

The description was accurate in a narrow sense.

It did not convey the considerable difference between the options she had been able to consider and the options that might have been available under other circumstances.

We ought to be careful about treating every unrealized possibility as an abandoned personal ambition.

Some possibilities are removed by illness, financial difficulty, political circumstances or restrictions imposed by other people. A person may have been prevented from continuing an education, accepting employment or forming relationships that were genuinely important to them.

It can be misleading to suggest that the principal difficulty in such situations was a shortage of determination.

The freedom to choose depends upon what can realistically be chosen.

Farah may reasonably regret that she was unable to study history. Her later satisfaction with aspects of her work need not require her to overlook the conditions that made the earlier arrangement impossible.

There is a distinction between finding a meaningful life within limited circumstances and concluding that the limitations were therefore justified.

When we listen to somebody describe a possibility that was unavailable to them, we should leave room for both observations.

Their subsequent life may contain things of considerable value.

They may also have deserved opportunities they did not receive.

The decisions whose consequences we could not calculate

A man named Stephen received two offers of employment shortly after completing his training.

One offered regular hours and a relatively predictable income. The other involved a new enterprise whose future was uncertain but whose work particularly interested him.

Stephen accepted the first position.

Several years later, the enterprise developed into a successful company. He occasionally saw reports about its growth and wondered how different his circumstances might have been if he had joined it.

He knew the outcome now.

He had not known it when making the decision.

This difference can be difficult to preserve when we reconsider a choice whose alternative has subsequently become more attractive.

A decision is made with the information, obligations and uncertainties that exist at a particular moment. Its consequences arrive later, sometimes under conditions that the person making it had little reason to anticipate.

The fact that another decision would have produced a favorable outcome does not establish that it was the more reasonable choice at the time.

Nor does a favorable outcome establish that a poorly considered decision was wise.

In The Things We Learn Too Late, we considered how knowledge acquired through later experience can influence our judgment of circumstances in which that knowledge was not yet available.

Stephen could examine the reasons for his decision. Perhaps he had given insufficient attention to the possibilities offered by the new enterprise. Perhaps his financial commitments made the more predictable position appropriate.

He could learn something from either conclusion.

But he could not fairly make his younger self responsible for anticipating a subsequent history that was still uncertain.

Our knowledge of what happened can help us understand an earlier decision.

It can also make that decision appear considerably simpler than it was.

The people who belong to the lives we did not live

During the conversation about the old letter, Daniel’s sister asked whether he had ever regretted staying in their country.

He said that there were occasions when he wished he had experienced living elsewhere while he was young.

Then he thought about his wife.

They had met at a gathering organized by friends from the university he eventually attended. Their children belonged to a history that would not necessarily have existed under different arrangements.

It seemed strange to compare that history with an imagined alternative.

The lives we might have lived are sometimes constructed by changing one decision while leaving everything else we value in its present condition.

We imagine accepting a different job while retaining the friendships that developed in the workplace we actually entered. We picture moving to another city while preserving relationships that depended upon our remaining where we were.

Yet the significance of a choice frequently lies in its interaction with subsequent choices and circumstances.

A different direction would not merely add another experience to an otherwise unchanged life. It might alter the people we encounter, the commitments we make and the qualities we have opportunities to develop.

As explored in What We Owe to the People We Used to Be, our earlier decisions have helped produce the person who now considers them, along with the relationships and responsibilities that person possesses.

This does not mean that we must approve of every choice because we value something that followed it.

It means that the alternatives are rarely available for comparison in the simple form in which we imagine them.

Daniel did not need to decide that the possibility represented by the letter was unimportant. He also did not have to assume that its fulfillment would have left all the other valuable features of his life intact.

The two histories belonged to different arrangements of circumstances.

Only one had become sufficiently real for him to know the names of the people in it.

What an old possibility is asking of us now

Farah continued reading history long after leaving school.

She borrowed books, attended occasional public lectures and sometimes helped her nephew with assignments. When a local library began organizing a series of discussions about the history of the surrounding region, she considered participating.

At first, the idea seemed inadequate in relation to the ambition she remembered.

She had wanted to undertake a degree. A conversation in a library would not provide an equivalent education.

But she began to wonder whether the difference was a reason not to attend.

There are occasions when an unrealized possibility remains important because it contains an interest that has not disappeared.

A person who once considered working abroad may still want to learn another language or spend an extended period somewhere unfamiliar. Somebody who abandoned an artistic ambition may retain a genuine desire to make things, even when the professional arrangement they originally imagined is no longer attractive.

The earlier possibility can help identify something that deserves a place within the present.

It cannot always tell us exactly what form that place ought to take.

There may be opportunities we can no longer pursue. There may be limitations that continue to matter. A small activity should not be presented as an equivalent replacement for everything an earlier ambition contained.

Nevertheless, a useful question is whether some feature of that ambition remains available in another form.

In The Dignity of Beginning Again, we considered how a new undertaking can offer something worthwhile without reproducing what has been lost.

The same possibility can apply to interests that never acquired their original form.

Farah attended the library discussion.

She disagreed with one of the speakers, asked a question about a document he had mentioned and subsequently obtained a copy of it from the library.

The evening did not erase the years in which she had been unable to obtain the education she wanted.

It did give her something interesting to consider on the journey home.

Allowing the other possibility to remain uncertain

There is a temptation, when discussing important decisions, to arrive at a reassuring conclusion about the life we have lived.

We may tell ourselves that everything happened as it should have happened. We may search for a particular achievement or relationship that makes an earlier disappointment appear indispensable.

Such explanations can be comforting.

They can also require us to make claims about alternatives whose consequences we cannot know.

There are decisions that deserve regret. There are things we would reasonably choose differently if we could return to the circumstances in which we made them. There are injuries and restrictions whose effects cannot be made acceptable merely by identifying valuable experiences that occurred afterward.

On other occasions, two directions may have been genuinely worthwhile, although only one was available for us to pursue.

We need not establish that the unchosen direction would have disappointed us in order to appreciate the direction we took.

The uncertainty may remain.

This is particularly important when an earlier decision continues to influence a present one. Somebody may wish to make an expensive change because they believe it will compensate for an opportunity they declined years before.

The earlier regret deserves attention, but the current decision still needs to be considered within its own circumstances.

Is the proposed undertaking something they presently want? What would it require from them and from the people affected by it? Which of its expected benefits are realistic?

These questions may support the change.

They may also reveal that what the person misses is not the undertaking itself but the sense of possibility associated with an earlier period of life.

There is no need to ask a present decision to prove that an earlier life could have proceeded differently.

It is enough to consider what the present decision would make possible now.

The letter returned to the cabinet

Before leaving his mother’s house, Daniel asked his sister whether she minded if he took the letter with him.

She said that she did not.

At home, he placed it beside several photographs and documents he had retained from his university years. He looked at it occasionally during the following weeks.

He did not discover a definitive explanation of what his life would have been had he accepted the offer.

Instead, he became interested in the person who had read the letter for the first time. That person had possessed a mixture of curiosity, concern for his family and uncertainty about what he was capable of doing.

Some of those concerns had changed. Some remained recognizable.

Perhaps the weight of the choices we never made comes partly from remembering that our lives once contained possibilities whose consequences we will never be able to examine.

We can acknowledge those possibilities without constructing a complete history around them.

We can regret the restrictions that made certain directions unavailable. We can reconsider the assumptions through which we rejected others. We can recognize interests that remain alive and give them a different place in the years we still possess.

And we can appreciate the people and experiences that belong to our actual lives without needing to establish that no other life could have contained anything worthwhile.

Daniel eventually showed the letter to one of his children.

They talked about the university and the circumstances in which he had decided to remain at home. His child asked whether he would still like to visit the city.

He considered the question.

For the first time, the city seemed less like a place in which an alternative version of himself might have lived and more like a place he might actually see.

They began discussing when a visit would be possible.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top