What We Owe to the People We Used to Be

A literary reflection on our relationship with our younger selves, the ambitions and habits we inherit from them, and the responsibilities that remain as we change.

What We Owe to the People We Used to Be — an antique piano, sheet music and a faded childhood photograph in warm afternoon light.

When Ruth sold her piano, she found an envelope beneath the lid of the piano stool.

It contained a photograph of herself at seventeen, standing outside the entrance to a music school. On the back, in handwriting she scarcely recognized as her own, she had written the names of three composers and a sentence about the musician she intended to become.

She remembered the afternoon on which the photograph had been taken. She had been wearing a coat borrowed from her sister and was worried that the shoes she had chosen made her look younger than the other applicants.

She had been accepted by the school. She had studied there for three years, performed at several small concerts and eventually discovered that the professional life she had imagined was not quite the life she wanted.

Now, at sixty-one, she worked in a business that supplied instruments to schools. She had raised two children, maintained a number of friendships and continued playing the piano, although less frequently in recent years.

A smaller apartment made keeping the instrument impractical.

As the men who had bought it carried it through the doorway, Ruth found herself thinking about the girl in the photograph.

Would that girl have been disappointed by the arrangement of her life? Would she have understood the decisions through which it had acquired its present form?

These were questions without a possible conversation through which they could be answered.

Nevertheless, they mattered to Ruth.

What do we owe to the people we used to be, whose intentions helped bring us here but whose understanding of the world was necessarily more limited than the one we possess now?

The ambitions that gave us a beginning

When we look back upon an abandoned ambition, it is tempting to evaluate it principally according to whether it was fulfilled.

A boy who hoped to become an architect may eventually work as a teacher. A woman who spent years studying a language may never live in the country that first attracted her interest. Somebody who developed a business plan in early adulthood may ultimately decide that another form of employment suits their circumstances better.

If the ambition is regarded solely as a proposed destination, the years spent pursuing it can appear to belong to an unsuccessful undertaking.

Yet an ambition can influence a life in ways that survive the abandonment of its original purpose.

The boy who wanted to become an architect may have acquired a lasting interest in how towns are designed. The woman who studied a language may have discovered literature and friendships that would otherwise have been unavailable to her. A person who prepared to establish a business may have learned to examine financial commitments more carefully.

These developments need not be regarded as consolation prizes.

They are part of the actual history of a life, rather than the history that would have existed if its earlier intentions had been fulfilled.

In When Life Does Not Follow the Plan, we considered why a change of direction does not necessarily make the efforts that preceded it meaningless.

The same distinction matters when we remember a younger self.

Ruth had not become the musician she imagined when the photograph was taken. But the knowledge she acquired at music school continued to influence her work, her enjoyment of music and the relationships she established with other people.

The girl outside the school had given her something more substantial than an unfulfilled prediction.

She had given her a reason to begin.

The promises whose circumstances have changed

A man named Philip remembers an agreement he made with himself when he was twenty-five.

He had recently entered a profession in which advancement frequently involved moving between cities. He decided that he would never allow familiarity with a particular place to prevent him from accepting an opportunity.

At the time, the promise expressed a reasonable concern. Philip had seen people decline opportunities they genuinely wanted because moving elsewhere seemed inconvenient or frightening.

Twenty years later, however, his circumstances had acquired features absent from the arrangement within which he made that promise.

His partner had established a career in their town. His children attended schools in which they were reasonably happy. His father lived nearby and required increasing assistance.

Philip received an offer of employment in another city and remembered his earlier determination not to let attachment to a place influence such decisions.

The promise was no longer easy to interpret.

Should he regard remaining where he lived as a failure of loyalty to his younger self? Or should he recognize that the earlier decision had been made before some of the people whose interests now mattered had entered his life?

We sometimes speak of remaining true to ourselves as though an authentic intention, once identified, deserves permanent authority over the decisions that follow.

But an intention may express something more important than the particular action through which we once expected to fulfill it.

Philip’s earlier promise expressed a wish not to be governed by fear of unfamiliar circumstances. He could take that wish seriously without concluding that every opportunity involving relocation deserved to be accepted.

Perhaps the more faithful response was to examine whether he genuinely wanted the new job and whether its benefits justified the changes it would create.

His younger self had been concerned about a particular kind of restriction.

That concern did not require him to overlook the value of relationships that had not yet existed.

What the younger person could see from there

A woman remembers how impatiently she had treated a relative during a family difficulty many years earlier.

She now understands that her relative had been dealing with pressures she had scarcely considered. Certain remarks she made at the time seem unnecessarily severe, and she wishes she had responded with greater generosity.

It is reasonable for her to examine those memories.

There may be a conversation worth having, or an acknowledgment that could help repair some part of the relationship.

But the way we examine an earlier decision matters.

We possess information now that was not necessarily available to us when that decision was made. We may understand the consequences more clearly because we have witnessed them. We may have encountered similar circumstances ourselves and developed a different appreciation of their demands.

As explored in The Things We Learn Too Late, there is a distinction between knowledge that could reasonably have been obtained and knowledge that develops only after further experience.

It would be unfair to use that distinction as a general excuse for previous conduct.

Sometimes we ignored information because it conflicted with what we wanted to believe. Sometimes we treated other people’s concerns as unimportant despite having adequate reasons to take them seriously.

But not every limitation of an earlier understanding was a deliberate refusal to see.

We can ask what the person we were actually knew, what they had reason to investigate and what they could reasonably have anticipated.

These questions do not require that we reach a favorable conclusion.

They allow us to reach a more accurate one.

The woman may discover that her earlier behavior was unfair even after its circumstances have been considered. She may also discover that some of the certainty with which she now criticizes herself depends upon information she could not have possessed.

The purpose of remembering an earlier self need not be to establish either their innocence or their guilt.

It can be to understand the decisions that helped produce the life we now inhabit.

The habits that once served another purpose

There had been a period in Ruth’s early adulthood when she worked in a restaurant while attending music school.

She was careful about money. She repaired things rather than replacing them and avoided commitments that might require her to borrow. Her caution was appropriate to circumstances in which a relatively small unexpected expense could affect her ability to continue studying.

Decades later, even when her circumstances had become more secure, she sometimes found it difficult to spend money on things she could readily afford.

She would postpone replacing an uncomfortable chair or decline an invitation that involved a modest expense, then realize that she had not actually examined whether the expenditure would create any difficulty.

A habit can continue long after the circumstances that made it useful have changed.

A person who learned to remain quiet in an argumentative household may carry that practice into relationships where disagreement is treated more considerately. Somebody who developed an ability to accept additional work during a period of financial insecurity may continue doing so after their employment has become more stable.

These patterns do not necessarily deserve contempt.

They may have helped a previous version of ourselves navigate a genuinely difficult arrangement.

But recognizing their earlier usefulness does not require that we preserve them indefinitely.

In The Years We Spend Waiting for Permission, we examined how restrictions experienced in one period of life can influence the decisions that feel available in another.

An important part of changing a familiar habit can involve identifying the question it was once intended to answer.

Is the present arrangement sufficiently similar to the earlier one that the habit remains useful? Are there risks we still need to consider? Are there new opportunities that the old response makes difficult to recognize?

Ruth could appreciate the care with which she had managed her limited resources at twenty without requiring her present circumstances to resemble those circumstances.

There was something worth retaining in that younger person’s resourcefulness.

There was also something worth examining in the restrictions she had learned to impose upon herself.

When the past contains a person we would rather forget

Not everybody recalls their earlier character with affection.

A person may remember having been dismissive toward people whose circumstances differed from their own. They may have participated in an arrangement they now regard as unfair or expressed convictions that they subsequently came to understand differently.

Such memories can create a particular temptation: to describe the person responsible as somebody we no longer recognize.

There is a sense in which the description may be accurate. Our beliefs and behavior can change considerably.

Nevertheless, declaring that an earlier version of ourselves was entirely different may conceal responsibilities that have not disappeared along with the beliefs through which we once justified our actions.

If a person harmed somebody, the eventual abandonment of the attitude associated with that harm does not establish that nothing remains to be addressed.

A correction may still be necessary. There may be practical consequences to remedy or an apology worth offering, when doing so is appropriate and respects the other person’s wishes.

In The Courage to Change Our Minds, we considered why revising a conviction can become the beginning of taking responsibility rather than its conclusion.

That observation applies to the history of our character as well.

We need not regard the worst thing we once did as the fullest description of who we are now.

Nor should we use our present understanding to establish that the earlier action belongs to a life for which we no longer bear any responsibility.

Maturity can involve being able to say both that we would not make a particular decision now and that we were the people who made it then.

There is a difference between recognizing that somebody has changed and pretending that their history has ceased to exist.

The interests we have not entirely left behind

Several weeks after selling the piano, Ruth met a friend who had recently begun attending a small series of concerts at a local library.

Her friend asked whether she would like to accompany her.

Ruth accepted.

The performers were young, and the audience occupied a collection of chairs that had been arranged in a room ordinarily used for meetings.

During one of the pieces, she remembered practicing a difficult passage while preparing for an examination at music school.

The memory was unexpectedly pleasant.

She did not wish to repeat the examination. She had no particular desire to return to the intense practice schedules around which her days had once been arranged.

But she discovered that her interest in hearing how somebody else approached the composition remained very much alive.

There are activities we stop pursuing because the version of them available to us has become unsuitable.

A person may leave a competitive sport after recognizing that its demands are excessive while still enjoying opportunities to participate less formally. Somebody who abandons an ambition to write professionally may continue finding satisfaction in writing letters or recording family stories.

The relationship we once had with an interest does not have to be the only relationship we will ever be able to have with it.

Sometimes a change of scale makes an activity available again.

Sometimes a change of purpose matters more.

The person who once treated an interest as a possible occupation may discover that it becomes enjoyable when it no longer needs to provide an income. Somebody who once approached an undertaking as a means of receiving recognition may find other reasons to participate in it.

We do not need to reproduce an entire earlier arrangement in order to give one of its valuable features a place within the present.

Ruth’s days at music school were over.

Her relationship with music was not.

The photograph in the new apartment

Ruth placed the photograph on a shelf beside several other objects she had brought from her old house.

She did not regard it as evidence that she had failed to become the person she was supposed to become.

Neither did she attempt to establish that the girl in the photograph would have approved of every important decision she had subsequently made.

The girl’s knowledge of the world was limited in ways Ruth could now recognize. She possessed ambitions that had changed, fears that had diminished and expectations about relationships whose consequences she could not possibly have anticipated.

But she had also possessed courage, curiosity and a willingness to undertake something difficult.

Those qualities deserved to be remembered without making the particular future she imagined into an obligation that the older woman was required to fulfill.

Perhaps what we owe to the people we used to be is neither unquestioning loyalty nor continual criticism.

We owe them the accuracy of an account that takes their circumstances seriously. We owe the people affected by their actions whatever responsibility remains ours to exercise. And we may owe ourselves an effort to recognize the interests, capacities and aspirations that have not entirely disappeared.

There are choices we would make differently now.

There are promises whose meaning has changed.

There are things we were right to abandon, and things whose importance we recognize only after a considerable period of neglect.

The earlier versions of ourselves cannot tell us what to do with that knowledge.

We can, however, avoid treating them as though their only function were to supply a collection of mistakes against which we measure our present understanding.

For without their efforts, limitations and uncertain beginnings, the person making those measurements would not possess precisely the life from which they are being made.

On the afternoon of the next concert, Ruth took her coat from the cupboard and walked toward the library.

She had not decided whether she would buy a smaller instrument for the apartment.

She was looking forward to the music.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top