At the age of forty-seven, Helen bought a secondhand sewing machine.
She placed it on the table in the small room where her family stored things they had not yet decided whether to keep. There were boxes of photographs beneath the window, an unused exercise bicycle and a cupboard containing several years of household documents.
She cleared enough space to work.
For a long time, Helen had wanted to learn how to make clothes. At first, she had imagined doing so after completing a qualification. Later, she had expected to begin when her children were older. Then there had been a period when her mother required considerable assistance.
Some of those circumstances had made the idea genuinely impractical. Others had become reasons to postpone a decision long after their significance had diminished.
When a colleague asked why she had finally bought the machine, Helen began explaining that she had reached a point in her life at which the purchase seemed reasonable.
She stopped halfway through the explanation.
Nobody had asked her to justify it.
She had become so accustomed to presenting the things she wanted as dependent upon a favorable set of circumstances that doing something simply because she had decided it was worthwhile felt unfamiliar.
The years we spend waiting for permission are not always years spent waiting for somebody to say yes. Sometimes they are years spent waiting for a sense that our reasons will be sufficiently convincing to an audience that may not even exist.
The permissions that once mattered
A child who wants to cross a busy road needs somebody to consider whether the journey is safe. A young employee learning a complicated procedure may need approval before making a change whose consequences affect other people.
There are good reasons why permission occupies an important place in our early experiences of decision-making.
The authority of another person can protect us from difficulties we are not yet equipped to anticipate. It can also help coordinate activities in which several people possess legitimate interests.
But the experience of repeatedly requiring authorization can leave habits that outlast the particular arrangements for which those habits were useful.
A woman who has become financially independent may still feel obliged to explain modest purchases to relatives who once supported her. A man who has spent years receiving instructions at work may find it difficult to make decisions in a different employment arrangement, even when that arrangement explicitly gives him authority to do so.
The difficulty is not simply a lack of information about the freedom now available. Sometimes it concerns the unfamiliar experience of making use of that freedom.
In The People We Become in Different Rooms, we examined how the histories of our relationships can influence the behavior that feels possible within them.
A person may have acquired considerable independence in one part of their life while continuing to experience other decisions through expectations that developed much earlier.
Helen could authorize expenditure at the office where she worked. At home, she had become accustomed to evaluating her own interests according to the extent to which she could accommodate them without inconveniencing anyone.
The transition between those arrangements was more complicated than purchasing a sewing machine.
When approval becomes the measure of a reasonable choice
A young man named Isaac had received an offer to study a subject he had enjoyed for several years.
The program was affordable. He had examined the timetable, considered his employment prospects and discussed the practical arrangements with the people who would be affected by his decision.
Nevertheless, he continued asking acquaintances what they thought he ought to do.
Some encouraged him to accept. Others suggested a qualification with more familiar career prospects.
Each conversation seemed to introduce another reason to delay a decision that he was otherwise quite capable of making.
Seeking advice was sensible. The difficulty was that Isaac was asking the conversations to provide something more than useful information.
He wanted the possibility of making a choice without subsequently being regarded as responsible for its less desirable consequences.
Approval can offer a temporary substitute for confidence in our own judgment. If enough people agree with a decision, it can feel as though there is less risk associated with making it.
But agreement does not necessarily change the conditions under which the decision will be experienced.
The people encouraging Isaac might have been making judgments about careers they would personally enjoy. The people advising against the program might have possessed very different financial obligations or expectations of professional life.
Their observations could be informative without determining the answer.
As explored in The Hidden Hunger for Approval, another person’s favorable opinion can acquire influence beyond the information that opinion actually provides.
It may be helpful to distinguish two questions: whether somebody has identified a consideration we ought to examine, and whether they are prepared to endorse the conclusion we eventually reach.
We can benefit from the first without always obtaining the second.
Nobody else could promise Isaac that he would never regret enrolling. Nor could he guarantee that declining the opportunity would leave him without regrets.
At some point, he needed to decide which of the uncertainties he was willing to live with.
The obligations that really do belong in the decision
Not every delay is evidence that somebody has become unnecessarily dependent upon permission.
Imagine a parent who wants to leave a demanding job and establish a small business. The proposed change would affect the household’s income and the financial security of several people.
It would be unreasonable to dismiss those considerations as merely the resistance of people who do not understand the parent’s ambitions.
The decision concerns a collection of shared arrangements. Other household members may have accepted commitments on the assumption that the existing income would remain available.
There are questions about savings, health coverage, childcare and the distribution of risk that deserve serious discussion.
Personal agency does not mean that all decisions concerning our lives belong exclusively to us.
It means, in part, developing an accurate understanding of which interests are legitimately involved and which expectations have acquired influence without a comparable justification.
A decision about spending an evening learning to draw differs from a decision to commit the family’s savings to an uncertain investment. Leaving an established organization differs from abandoning responsibilities that the organization has no reasonable opportunity to redistribute.
The distinction matters because the language of independence can sometimes obscure genuine obligations, just as the language of responsibility can obscure unnecessary restrictions.
A person who wants to make a change can ask what consequences the change would create, who would experience those consequences and whether a fair arrangement is possible.
Those questions may reveal that postponement is prudent. They may also reveal that the imagined objections are considerably larger than the actual practical difficulties.
For Helen, the sewing machine required a modest purchase and a reorganization of a room. She was not proposing to abandon the responsibilities around which her household was organized.
The amount of explanation she believed was necessary had little relationship to the degree of disruption involved.
Waiting until a desire becomes impressive enough
A woman who enjoys singing with friends considers joining a local choir.
She hesitates because she does not expect to become a particularly accomplished singer. She already has a demanding occupation, and the activity is unlikely to provide a recognizable professional advantage.
When somebody asks what she would gain from joining, she finds herself offering explanations involving confidence, communication skills and the possible benefits of learning to perform before an audience.
These might be genuine advantages.
But they are not the reason she first considered the idea.
She likes singing.
There are interests we delay because we have difficulty establishing that they deserve to occupy time in a life organized around more readily justified activities.
The interest may not produce income. It may not develop into an admirable accomplishment. It may not provide anything that can be described as an investment in a more successful future.
In The Beauty of an Ordinary Life, we considered the significance of experiences that do not need to distinguish themselves through exceptional achievement.
The desire to spend time doing something we enjoy can belong to that part of human life.
Of course, time and resources are limited. An activity may have costs we need to consider, and there may be periods in which other commitments deserve priority.
But the fact that an undertaking has no impressive destination does not by itself establish that it is an unreasonable use of the time available to us.
Helen did not expect to establish a clothing business. The first skirt she attempted to make was uneven, and she spent a considerable portion of an afternoon correcting a mistake she had made while attaching the waistband.
She found the process interesting.
That was not an inadequate reason to continue.
The conditions that keep moving
There had been a time when Helen believed she would begin sewing after her children no longer needed help with their homework.
When that period arrived, she became concerned about saving for their education. Later, after her mother died, she told herself that she ought to devote more attention to the administrative responsibilities she had previously neglected.
Each expectation contained something reasonable. Together, they had created an arrangement in which an ordinary interest was permanently dependent upon the arrival of a quieter life.
There is a difficulty with waiting until no more important task appears to be competing for our attention.
The circumstances in which we live continue producing tasks.
A household acquires repairs. A workplace changes its procedures. Relationships develop new needs, and the activities that once seemed urgent are often replaced by activities whose urgency is equally convincing.
The experience of completion can therefore be difficult to locate.
This does not mean that we should ignore genuine emergencies or attempt to pursue every interest at once. It means that the absence of a perfectly convenient beginning may not provide enough information to determine whether a beginning is possible.
An interest might be given one afternoon rather than an entire weekend. An educational ambition might initially be explored through a single course. A difficult conversation might begin with an observation rather than an attempt to settle the future of a relationship.
In The Things We Learn Too Late, we considered the possibility that knowledge acquired after an opportunity has disappeared may still influence the choices that remain.
There is a related question for the opportunities that have not yet disappeared: what part of an undertaking is actually available to us now?
Helen had no need to wait until she could devote several months to learning how to make clothes.
She needed a machine, a place to put it and a somewhat manageable first project.
The distinction between those requirements and the circumstances she had imagined was substantial.
When freedom is costly
There are people whose decisions really are subject to arrangements that give others considerable control over their lives.
A worker may have little flexibility over their hours. A person dependent upon relatives for housing may face serious consequences if they refuse a demand. Somebody living within a coercive relationship may reasonably fear what will happen if they attempt to exercise an ordinary degree of independence.
It would be misleading to describe every such circumstance as a private difficulty with confidence.
Some people are not merely waiting to feel authorized. They are living within conditions in which the exercise of freedom carries material risks.
The responses appropriate to those conditions may involve assistance from trusted people, access to services, legal advice or practical changes that establish greater security. In some circumstances, caution is necessary while a person considers how to proceed safely.
A discussion of personal agency ought to make room for these differences.
We cannot measure another person’s courage simply by observing whether they have made a decision we would have found relatively easy to make.
Nor should the person who has a considerable degree of independence assume that everybody else possesses the same opportunities.
There may be ways in which people with authority can reduce unnecessary dependence upon their approval. Employers can give employees clearer decision-making responsibilities. Families can discuss financial arrangements without using them as a general entitlement to control another adult’s choices. Communities can provide opportunities for learning that do not require resources available only to a relatively small group.
The freedom to make a meaningful decision depends partly on the person making it and partly on the conditions under which it is made.
Recognizing those conditions can help us distinguish between the permissions we can stop seeking and those restrictions that require a more substantial change.
The afternoon she had made available
Several months after buying the sewing machine, Helen invited her sister to visit.
They had lunch and afterward went into the small room where Helen had been working.
Her sister examined the clothes she had made and asked whether she intended to take a course.
Helen said that she might. She had found some useful books and was enjoying the opportunity to learn at her own pace.
Her sister asked whether she thought she would eventually sell anything.
Helen explained that this was not something she was particularly interested in doing.
The conversation moved on to other subjects.
Later, she remembered how often she had imagined needing to offer a more substantial explanation for the activity. The years of preparation she had believed necessary had not produced an argument that everybody would find convincing.
They had chiefly produced years in which the interest remained something she intended to pursue.
Perhaps there is no simple point at which a person becomes entirely free of the desire for approval.
We live among other people, and their observations can matter to us. Our decisions have consequences that sometimes deserve careful discussion. There will be occasions when waiting is wise and occasions when assistance makes a choice possible that would otherwise be unavailable.
But not every interest requires an audience to establish its legitimacy.
Not every decision needs to be postponed until it can be made without uncertainty.
And not every portion of a life needs to be defended through the promise of what it will eventually produce.
Helen returned to the sewing machine the following afternoon.
There was still a considerable amount she did not know.
For the first time in years, she was learning it.



