The Lives We Measure Against Others

A literary reflection on social comparison, personal timelines and the hidden circumstances that shape our lives, asking what progress means beyond other people's milestones.

The Lives We Measure Against Others — two winding paths above a misty mountain valley at sunrise.

On a Saturday in late September, Adrian attended a reunion at the school he had left seventeen years earlier.

For the first hour, it was exactly the sort of evening he had hoped for. A former classmate remembered a joke he had forgotten. Two teachers were still able to recognize him, and somebody had brought photographs in which nearly everyone appeared to be wearing clothes they would now prefer not to discuss.

Then the conversation turned to the years that had followed.

One friend had established a business. Another had recently moved abroad. Somebody Adrian remembered as being particularly shy was now responsible for a substantial organization. A woman he had once helped with mathematics was preparing to send her eldest child to university.

Adrian had come to the reunion reasonably satisfied with his life. He worked in a small architectural practice, rented an apartment he liked and spent much of his free time caring for his father and learning to play the piano.

On the train home, he began to feel unexpectedly behind.

Nothing had happened to his employment, his apartment or his relationship with his father during the evening. What had changed was the company in which he had been considering them.

There are occasions when another person’s achievements reveal possibilities we would genuinely like to pursue. There are also occasions when they make a life that was previously acceptable appear insufficient, without establishing what is actually missing from it.

The imaginary timetable

When people are young, the institutions around them often provide a recognizable sequence of transitions. Children of similar ages move between classrooms at similar times. Examinations are held on particular dates. Graduation brings a group of people to the end of a shared undertaking.

It is understandable that some of us carry this expectation of synchronized progress into adulthood.

But after the common timetable ends, the circumstances shaping individual lives become increasingly different.

One person begins a family early. Another spends a decade looking after a relative. Someone enters employment with financial obligations that make a risky career decision impractical. Someone else receives assistance that makes exactly the same decision possible.

These differences do not prevent us from comparing where people eventually arrive. They do make it difficult to interpret the comparison fairly.

An achievement at thirty may have been supported by conditions absent from the life of a person who reaches a similar point at forty. Conversely, somebody who had considerable advantages may have confronted difficulties that were invisible to their acquaintances.

The problem is not that age and timing never matter. Some ambitions genuinely are affected by time, health, financial commitments or other practical constraints. There are occasions when accepting that a window of opportunity has changed is necessary.

The problem arises when we turn a common age into evidence of common starting conditions, and then treat different outcomes as though they emerged from the same examination.

A school reunion can revive the expectation that the people who once occupied adjacent desks should have reached comparable destinations.

But adulthood has never been administered by a single school calendar.

A photograph of somebody else’s conclusion

Adrian remembered a conversation with his friend Daniel, whose business had grown substantially in recent years.

Daniel had described the opening of a second office. What Adrian had not known until later was that the first office had nearly closed twice. Daniel had borrowed money from relatives, worked for periods in which he could not pay himself a salary and depended on his partner’s income while the business became established.

None of that diminished the accomplishment.

It did, however, change the meaning of the comparison Adrian had been making.

We often encounter the visible conclusion of an undertaking without knowing much about the sequence of decisions, assistance and difficulties that preceded it. Even when people describe those earlier circumstances, they may naturally select the details that lend themselves to a coherent account.

There is nothing necessarily dishonest about this. A conversation over dinner is not an exhaustive financial history. A photograph of a new home is not expected to include an explanation of every agreement that made its purchase possible.

But the information available in these encounters cannot always support the judgments we draw from it.

As explored in The Difference Between Knowing and Understanding, facts about an experience may be accurate without providing a complete understanding of what it was like to live through it.

We can congratulate somebody on an accomplishment without turning their announcement into an evaluation of our own decisions.

And we can ask thoughtful questions about how they achieved something without assuming that their path can be reproduced under conditions they did not encounter.

Borrowing a destination we did not choose

A woman who enjoys working in a public library meets a former colleague who has become a senior executive.

For several days afterward, she considers whether she should pursue a management position. She imagines the increase in income, the greater recognition and the satisfaction of being able to describe a more impressive professional history.

When she begins examining the actual responsibilities of such a position, however, she notices that it would involve considerably less of the work she currently enjoys.

She would spend less time with readers and more time managing budgets, personnel and organizational decisions. Some of those activities interest her. Others do not.

She may eventually decide that the change is worthwhile. But she has discovered that the attractiveness of an achievement when described by somebody else can differ from the attractiveness of the daily life it entails.

An ambition can acquire urgency through comparison before we have examined whether the conditions associated with it suit us.

This is especially important because we experience our own lives primarily as a succession of ordinary days. We experience the lives of many other people through their most readily described distinctions.

A job title can be announced in a sentence. The work associated with it may occupy thousands of hours.

The decision about whether to pursue a similar position deserves consideration of those hours, not merely the sentence through which we would eventually describe it.

In The Beauty of an Ordinary Life, we considered the significance of familiar experiences that rarely attract exceptional attention. Comparison can make such experiences difficult to appreciate when their value is not easily communicated in an announcement.

Before adopting another person’s destination, it may be worth asking what we would actually do after arriving there.

When comparison identifies a genuine absence

It would be too simple to suggest that every uncomfortable comparison should be abandoned.

Imagine two employees who perform similar work within an organization. One discovers that the other receives substantially better compensation despite having comparable experience and responsibilities.

The comparison may reveal unfairness. It may provide information necessary to negotiate a different arrangement or investigate why such a difference exists.

In another situation, seeing somebody pursue an artistic interest might remind a person of an ambition they have repeatedly postponed. The discomfort that follows may concern a genuine wish rather than the desire to possess something impressive.

Instead of treating envy as evidence of a defective character, we can sometimes examine what it is pointing toward.

Is the desired improvement greater financial security? More freedom over how time is spent? An opportunity to learn? A relationship in which a certain kind of companionship is available?

These questions matter because the visible achievement that provoked the comparison may represent only one means of obtaining something we value.

A person who envies a friend working overseas may discover that what they principally desire is independence from a restrictive household arrangement. A person who envies a colleague’s promotion may be less interested in exercising authority than in receiving adequate recognition for work they already perform.

The original comparison has then provided useful information, but its usefulness depends on our willingness to investigate beyond the first emotional response.

There is a difference between wanting another person’s life and recognizing something in their life that we would like to make possible within our own.

The second can lead to an ambition chosen with greater care.

The years that cannot be entered in a résumé

During several years of Adrian’s early adulthood, his father’s health had required increasing attention.

He had declined opportunities involving frequent travel. He had sometimes arrived at work tired. There were projects he might have undertaken had the family’s circumstances been different.

When former classmates spoke about their professional histories, Adrian found it difficult to describe those years.

There was no single accomplishment that summarized them. His father had not recovered completely, and the practical arrangements they had established continued to require attention.

Yet the absence of a clear conclusion did not mean those years contained nothing of consequence.

Our methods of describing progress tend to favor outcomes that can be identified and placed on a calendar: a qualification, a promotion, a completed purchase, a marriage or the opening of a business.

Other undertakings are less easily represented in that form. A parent may spend years supporting a child through difficulties whose eventual improvement cannot be attributed to one particular event. A person may gradually rebuild stability after a financial loss. A family may adapt to circumstances that are unlikely to change.

We should be careful here not to romanticize responsibilities simply because they are difficult. Some people have sacrificed opportunities under arrangements that should have been fairer. They may reasonably regret the choices that were unavailable to them.

But regret about constrained circumstances is different from concluding that the years spent within them were empty.

The Quiet Cost of Always Being Strong considered the difficulty of recognizing the effort involved in preventing problems from becoming visible. Such effort can leave very little material for the public account of a life.

It still belongs to the history of that life.

A person does not have to describe every difficult responsibility as a triumph. They also do not need to erase it when considering how they arrived at their present circumstances.

A standard that changes whenever we reach it

Several years before the reunion, Adrian had hoped to secure stable employment in architecture.

When he obtained it, he regarded the development as substantial. Later, he wanted greater involvement in the design of projects. By the time that opportunity arrived, he had begun considering whether he should eventually establish a practice of his own.

A changing ambition is not inherently troubling. Greater knowledge of a field often produces new interests.

But there is a particular kind of dissatisfaction that arises when the significance of an accomplishment depends upon what other people have accomplished afterward.

Under those conditions, reaching a destination can alter the group against which we compare ourselves. The new employee begins comparing their career with experienced colleagues. The new business owner becomes familiar with businesses substantially larger than their own.

The standard moves, and the earlier achievement is reconsidered as though it had never been adequate.

In Why Happiness Is Never Enough, we examined the distinction between the continuing value of an improvement and the emotional familiarity that develops after it occurs. A moving comparative standard can obscure that distinction.

It may help to retain an accurate account of what a particular change was intended to accomplish.

Did it make housing more secure? Did it reduce uncertainty about income? Did it provide an opportunity to undertake work that previously seemed inaccessible?

Those benefits can remain significant even when another ambition becomes possible.

We need not prohibit ourselves from wanting more. We can, however, resist the idea that wanting more is sufficient evidence that everything we have already achieved deserves a lower evaluation.

The obligations we inherit from an audience

At the reunion, somebody asked Adrian whether he intended to open his own architectural practice.

He began explaining that he liked his present work, then noticed himself searching for a more impressive conclusion to the explanation.

He had not been asked a hostile question. His former classmate appeared genuinely interested.

But Adrian was aware of a familiar pressure to present his current circumstances as preparation for something larger.

There are forms of satisfaction people sometimes feel obliged to defend because they do not fit recognizable ideas about progress.

Someone who chooses to remain in a position they enjoy may be asked why they are not pursuing advancement. Someone who moves to a smaller home to reduce expenses may encounter questions that imply the change represents a reversal. A person whose relationships and interests provide a satisfying life may feel pressure to establish a more readily understood measure of success.

It is worth distinguishing between advice that helps us examine a decision and an expectation that we should be able to make every decision look ambitious to other people.

Some decisions will disappoint people whose opinions matter to us. Others will be difficult for acquaintances to understand because they do not possess enough information to interpret them.

We cannot entirely prevent that.

We can try to ensure that an answer we provide during a social conversation does not acquire more influence over our future than the practical consequences of the decision itself.

A life is lived for considerably longer than it is explained.

What the comparison had left out

On the Sunday following the reunion, Adrian visited his father.

They went to a nearby shop, returned with groceries and discussed whether a particular shelf could be moved closer to the kitchen window.

Later that afternoon, Adrian played part of a piece he had been learning on the piano. The movement was still too difficult for him to perform without several interruptions.

He thought about Daniel’s business and the possibility of taking on more responsibility at work. Some of the questions raised during the previous evening deserved further examination.

He also noticed that he was no longer especially interested in the question of whether he had fallen behind.

There was no single destination against which all the different undertakings in his adult life could reasonably be measured.

He could assess his financial circumstances, his professional ambitions and the quality of his relationships. There might be improvements worth pursuing in each of them. He did not need to combine those assessments into a verdict delivered by the careers and households of the people who had once shared his classroom.

Other lives can offer encouragement, practical information and examples of things we had not previously imagined.

They become less useful when we ask them to establish the value of everything that has happened in our own.

Adrian returned to the piece of music.

He was still learning it. That was a sufficiently accurate description of where he was.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top