Why Is People Pleasing Such a Compelling Theme in Fiction? The Actor Who Never Left the Stage

Why is people pleasing compelling in fiction? An actor trapped on a stage by an audience that never stops asking for more must confront the cost of always performing for others.

The Actor Who Never Left the Stage — ornamental gold-lettered story cover

At the end of the second act, while three hundred people waited for him to die, Felix Arden discovered that he could not leave the stage.

The villain had offered him a glass of wine. Felix was supposed to drink from it, stagger toward the window and fall through a painted doorway into the wings. He had rehearsed the sequence so often that he knew precisely which plank would creak beneath his left foot.

He drank the wine.

He staggered.

He reached for the doorway.

It was solid.

Behind him, the woman playing the villain whispered, “Felix?”

He smiled at the audience. It was a habit he had acquired long before becoming an actor.

Then he improvised a line about the remarkable strength of the door.

The audience laughed.

The woman playing the villain did not.

The director signaled from the wings.

Felix tried the door again.

Above the stage, where nobody had installed a sign, five golden words appeared.

THE AUDIENCE IS NOT FINISHED.

Somebody in the balcony applauded.

Felix bowed.

It would later occur to him that bowing had been a particularly unfortunate response.


The play was called A House for the Winter. It concerned a family whose inheritance depended on discovering the whereabouts of an elderly man’s missing brother. Felix played the youngest son, a genial, accommodating character who spent two acts promising things to relatives, leaving them to discover in the final act that he had promised the same house to two different people.

His character died before the discovery could be made.

Felix disliked this ending. He had suggested to the director that the son might instead live long enough to apologize.

The director explained that the death was structurally important.

“Of course,” Felix said.

He used the expression so often that the other members of the company sometimes imitated him.

The director was called Sabine. She had spent fifteen years producing plays in a little theater beside the station. She was rigorous about rehearsal and especially interested in the things actors did when they thought nobody was watching.

Felix gave her very little difficulty.

If she wanted another reading of a line, he supplied it. If an actor was absent, he learned the relevant part. If the company needed someone to attend an interview, he rearranged his afternoon.

He had an excellent reputation.

He also had an unfinished script in the bottom drawer of his desk, a daughter who had learned not to expect him on Saturdays and a shoulder that had been hurting for several weeks.

The pain had nothing to do with the play. He had arranged appropriate medical advice and was trying to follow it. But he found it difficult to explain to Sabine that a proposed change of movement was uncomfortable.

When she asked whether he could manage it, he said yes.

Then he spent the remainder of the rehearsal trying to manage it.

He was proud of his reliability.

There were occasions when it was not entirely clear to whom he was being reliable.


When Felix was fourteen, his father lost his job.

For a while the family’s dinners became quieter. His parents discussed money in the kitchen after the children went upstairs. His older sister, Inez, began spending more time at the library.

Felix discovered that he could make his father laugh by imitating a man who presented a television program about gardening.

He practiced the voice.

At dinner he described the potatoes as though they were an extraordinarily rare species of flowering plant.

His mother laughed.

His father laughed.

Inez laughed too.

For several minutes nobody seemed worried about anything.

Felix loved the experience.

He began looking for other things that would make them laugh. He memorized stories, performed little scenes and learned which subjects were likely to produce a pleasant response.

When his father was particularly quiet, Felix became particularly entertaining.

There was nothing wrong with making people laugh. His family appreciated the affection he expressed through his performances.

But Felix had begun to associate the pleasure of relieving another person’s distress with a responsibility to relieve it whenever he could.

One evening he returned home after an argument at school.

His mother asked how he was.

He began telling her a funny story about the teacher.

Inez listened.

Later, she asked what actually happened.

Felix told her.

She was sympathetic. She did not ask him to make the story funny.

He remembered feeling surprised by this.

He was still learning how to describe himself without first establishing what the listener wanted to hear.


His first professional engagement was in a touring company that traveled between small towns.

Felix played several minor roles. He also helped with publicity, answered questions from visitors and occasionally assisted with arrangements for rehearsals.

He liked the experience of finding a place among people whose work interested him.

He liked being asked to return.

On one occasion an actor asked whether he would exchange a rehearsal time. Felix had arranged to visit Inez that afternoon. He agreed to the exchange and canceled the visit.

His sister was disappointed.

He apologized.

A week later the same actor asked whether another arrangement might be changed.

Felix agreed again.

The actor thanked him.

Years afterward, when Felix read about the dressmaker in The Dress of a Hundred Pockets, he remembered those afternoons. It seemed to him that he had developed a similar collection of pockets, each containing a little promise that somebody else was pleased to have obtained.

One of them held a visit to his sister.

He had not noticed how often that particular pocket remained empty.

At thirty, he married a musician named Daria.

Their daughter, Nell, was born three years later.

Felix loved being a father. He liked making elaborate breakfasts and drawing animals in the margins of Nell’s school notebooks.

He was delighted by her willingness to laugh at his performances.

She was considerably less impressed by his ability to cancel an afternoon they had arranged together and describe the cancellation entertainingly.

At eight, she told him so.

He apologized.

Then he promised to take her to a museum the following Saturday.

The company asked him to attend an additional rehearsal.

He agreed.


By the time Felix joined Sabine’s company, he and Daria had separated.

There were many reasons for the separation. Felix did not believe it would be accurate to attribute it to a single habit, a particular missed appointment or the circumstances of their respective occupations.

They developed arrangements for caring for Nell.

Daria frequently asked Felix to establish whether he could keep an arrangement before agreeing to it.

He found the request rather hurtful.

He wanted her to understand that he intended to keep the arrangements.

She wanted to know whether he actually could.

Nell was seventeen when the company began rehearsing A House for the Winter.

She was interested in making short animated films and had spent much of the preceding year working on one about a dog attempting to find its way around a house whose doors kept changing position.

She asked Felix whether he wanted to see an early screening at her school.

He said yes.

The screening would take place shortly after the play’s opening weekend.

Felix checked the schedule.

He was free.

Then a visitor from another theater expressed interest in discussing the production with several members of the company.

Sabine asked whether Felix could attend the meeting.

He looked at the date.

It coincided with Nell’s screening.

He began explaining the difficulty.

Sabine said that she understood.

She turned toward another actor.

Felix felt a sudden apprehension.

Perhaps the visitor would be interested in offering somebody work. Perhaps Sabine would remember that Felix had been unavailable. Perhaps the other actors would regard his absence as a lack of enthusiasm for the company.

“I could probably arrange it,” he said.

Sabine looked surprised.

“Only if you can.”

He nodded.

The conversation ended.

He had promised two people the same afternoon.

He went home and told himself that he would find a way of providing it.


The theater occupied a building in which people had been performing for more than a century.

There were several stories concerning unusual events associated with its stage. A curtain was alleged to have opened during a performance that nobody had arranged. An actor claimed to have seen a previous cast sitting in the empty auditorium.

The staff generally regarded the stories as part of the building’s history rather than dependable accounts of its properties.

When the golden words appeared, Sabine stopped the performance.

The people responsible for the building examined the circumstances and established the appropriate arrangements for moving the audience out of the auditorium.

The lights came on.

Felix stood beside the painted doorway.

The ordinary exits from the stage were visible. Each acquired the appearance of a solid surface when he approached it.

The woman playing the villain, Farah, was able to leave through one of them.

She returned with Sabine.

Neither could establish why Felix could not follow.

He began to feel frightened.

The appropriate services were contacted, and the people responsible for the theater followed their advice. Felix could communicate with people outside the area, and assistance could reach him, even though the strange phenomenon seemed to prevent him from crossing its boundary.

Sabine told him that the performance was over.

The golden words changed.

THE AUDIENCE EXPECTS ANOTHER SCENE.

Felix stared at them.

The auditorium was empty.

Sabine asked whether he could see anything unusual.

He described the words.

She said that she could see them too.

They made a record of the observation.

Then Felix heard a familiar voice from the back of the auditorium.

“Go on, son.”

It was his father.

His father had been dead for eleven years.


The empty seats began filling.

The people who appeared in them resembled people Felix had known at various stages of his life. Some wore clothes he remembered. Others had faces that were difficult to distinguish.

His father sat in the third row.

A former director appeared near the aisle.

Several seats farther along was Daria, dressed as she had been during the first year of their marriage.

None of the figures appeared to be the actual individuals they resembled. Sabine could speak to Daria by telephone, and Daria was elsewhere. Felix knew that the figures could not establish what those people thought or wanted.

He nevertheless found himself responding to them.

His father asked him to tell the story about the potatoes.

Felix did.

Several people laughed.

The former director asked him to read a speech from a play he had performed twenty years earlier.

He remembered most of it.

The figure resembling Daria asked whether he was going to make breakfast.

Felix looked toward the wings.

He remembered a morning on which he had promised to cook something for the family and left early because somebody called from the theater.

He began apologizing.

The figure did not respond.

Then another person asked him to demonstrate a little routine involving a hat.

He found the hat beside a chair.

He performed the routine.

The audience applauded.

One of the exits briefly appeared open.

Felix walked toward it.

Somebody asked for another performance.

He turned back.

The exit closed.

It took him several repetitions to understand the pattern.

He was not being asked to satisfy one particular person.

He was being asked to satisfy an audience that could always discover another request.


Farah sat beside him during a period in which the figures disappeared.

She brought him some water.

Felix thanked her.

Then he apologized for the interruption to the production.

Farah stared at him.

“You’re stuck on a stage.”

“I know.”

“Why are you apologizing for it?”

He laughed.

He wanted Sabine to know that he was trying to resolve the situation. He wanted the people who purchased tickets to receive something worthwhile. He wanted Farah not to be inconvenienced by the circumstances.

Farah understood the wishes.

She was less interested in his attempts to meet them while he remained trapped.

She asked whether the figures had ever made a request that he declined.

Felix thought about it.

“No.”

“Why?”

He looked toward the auditorium.

He did not know what would happen if he refused.

Farah nodded.

There were real circumstances in which refusing a request could expose somebody to harm. They did not have enough information about the phenomenon to know whether refusal would be harmless.

They discussed the question with the people investigating it. Nobody wanted Felix to undertake an unsafe experiment merely because a story about the theater might make it sound attractive.

The available information suggested that the figures asked for performances but did not physically approach him. The relevant specialists continued assessing the situation.

Felix also discussed his distress with a qualified health professional.

During one conversation, he found himself saying that the most difficult part of the experience was not the appearance of the figures.

It was disappointing them.

He remembered the translator in The Republic of Yes, whose efforts to produce a reassuring statement had made it difficult to communicate something other people needed to know.

Felix had told Farah that he was all right several times that evening.

He was not.

She was glad when he eventually told her.


Nell arrived at the theater the following morning with Daria.

They were able to speak to Felix under the arrangements established for his well-being.

Nell asked what had happened.

He described the figures.

She listened.

Then she said that the situation sounded remarkably like a film she had made.

Felix laughed.

The film about the dog.

He asked whether she had finished it.

“Mostly.”

He wanted to know what happened at the end.

Nell said she was still deciding.

They talked about it.

For the first time in many hours, Felix was discussing something he wanted to hear rather than something he thought somebody else wanted him to say.

Then the golden words appeared.

YOUR DAUGHTER WANTS YOU TO MAKE HER LAUGH.

Felix looked at Nell.

“Do you?”

She stared at the sign.

“No.”

He laughed.

Nell did not.

“Dad.”

He stopped.

She explained that she wanted him to be able to leave the theater. She also wanted to know why he had appeared uncertain about attending her screening.

Felix began describing the meeting Sabine had asked him to attend.

Nell listened.

He told her that he was hoping to arrange both things.

She nodded.

“Did you actually ask me if there was another screening?”

“No.”

“There is.”

He stared at her.

She said that she particularly wanted him to attend the school screening because her friends would be there. But she would rather have known in advance if he could not manage it.

He was astonished by the simplicity of the conversation.

He had spent several days considering ways of pleasing Nell without asking what mattered to her.

Now she was telling him.

He thought of Lydia in The Woman Who Carried Every Key, who discovered that her neighbors could not readily understand her wishes when she consistently told them that providing assistance was no trouble.

Felix had wanted to protect his daughter from disappointment.

He had sometimes protected himself from hearing about it instead.


The figures returned in the afternoon.

The former director wanted Felix to perform another speech.

His father wanted a joke.

A woman resembling a customer he once met in a restaurant asked him to dance.

Felix discussed the circumstances with the people assisting him.

Under the agreed arrangements, he tried responding differently to a relatively modest request.

His father asked for the story about the potatoes.

Felix looked at him.

“I don’t want to tell it now.”

The figure remained silent.

Felix waited.

The golden letters flickered.

A woman in the balcony asked whether he was too tired.

“Yes.”

She nodded.

The former director asked whether he could finish the speech before resting.

Felix considered it.

He could probably finish it.

He did not want to.

“No.”

The figure looked disappointed.

Felix felt the familiar desire to say something that would change its expression.

He waited.

Then somebody laughed.

It was not a particularly unkind laugh.

Another figure asked whether it would be possible to hear the speech tomorrow.

Felix said he did not know.

For several moments the auditorium was filled with the sound of people discussing different things.

The golden letters disappeared.

The painted doorway opened.

Felix did not move immediately.

He was concerned that another request might arrive.

Farah stood in the wings.

She asked whether he was ready to come out.

“Yes.”

He walked toward her.

The doorway remained open.

The people responsible for the theater subsequently restricted access while the unusual phenomenon was investigated. No satisfactory explanation of its operation was established.

Felix was able to return home.

He ate supper.

Then he went to sleep.


The canceled performance was rearranged after the relevant assessments and decisions concerning the building.

Felix took a period away from the company. He continued seeking appropriate support regarding the unusual experience and the longstanding difficulties he described.

Sabine contacted him to discuss the next production.

She asked whether he wanted to return.

He did.

He also wanted to write.

The script in his drawer concerned two sisters who inherited a collection of musical instruments and tried to decide what to do with them. He had completed several scenes and abandoned the project whenever another commitment arose.

He showed Sabine a portion of it.

She liked one of the scenes.

She thought another was too long.

He was disappointed.

Then he asked whether she could explain what she found difficult about it.

They discussed the work.

He did not promise to change every part she disliked.

He did not decide that she had misunderstood the entire project.

He was interested in what she said.

Later he visited Nell’s school.

The meeting with the visitor to the theater had been rearranged for a different day after Felix explained his existing commitment. He had been unable to attend another discussion that evening.

He was sorry to miss it.

He enjoyed Nell’s film.

The dog eventually discovered that one of the doors led into the garden, where another dog was waiting.

Felix laughed.

Then he cried.

Nell smiled.

They went for something to eat.

He remembered the cook in The Last Table at the Feast, who discovered that providing a meal for everybody did not necessarily require her to miss the conversation she most wanted to have.

Felix had spent much of his life providing other people with an experience.

He wanted to be present for some of his own.


Two years later, the company performed his play.

The theater’s investigators had not established a dependable explanation for the golden words, and the circumstances of the incident remained a subject of interest. Felix no longer attempted to use the experience as a rule for deciding what other people wanted.

He was still an accommodating actor.

He liked helping his colleagues.

He sometimes accepted an additional rehearsal.

He also became better at establishing which arrangements were possible before agreeing to them.

Some people found the change inconvenient. A colleague who had been accustomed to asking Felix to replace him on short notice was disappointed when Felix declined.

Felix listened.

He did not dislike the man for asking.

He also did not feel obliged to make the inconvenience disappear.

On the opening night of his play, he sat beside Nell and Inez.

The audience laughed at several things.

It was quiet at others.

One man left before the performance ended.

Felix noticed him.

For a moment he wondered whether the man disliked the play.

He could not establish an answer by watching the empty seat.

Then one of the actresses delivered a line he had rewritten several times.

He liked the way she said it.

He turned toward the stage.

He understood why people pleasing was such a compelling theme in fiction. It could give a character an apparently admirable motive while concealing a conflict that affected almost every choice she made. The wish to be kind, helpful or accepted could become a reason to neglect existing commitments, withhold important information or offer people things they had never requested. A story could make that conflict visible through the difference between what a character said and what she wanted.

The conflict did not require kindness to become a fault.

Felix still loved applause.

He also liked the little silence that followed a satisfying exchange between two characters.

When the performance ended, the actors came forward and bowed.

Felix stood with the people beside him.

He applauded.

Then the lights came on.

Inez asked whether he wanted to join the company for supper.

He was tired.

Nell wanted to go home too.

Felix said that he would see the company another day.

He was pleased that they had invited him.

He was pleased that he had written the play.

He was pleased that the performance had ended.

Outside, the station clock struck eleven.

Felix went home with his daughter.

Editorial note: Original theatrical fantasy and psychological drama. All characters, institutions, places and supernatural events are fictional. People pleasing can provide dramatic tension through the conflict between the wish for acceptance, generosity, personal needs and honest communication. The circumstances in which people express or withhold preferences vary, including situations where disagreement carries genuine risks. Cooperation need not require universal approval. Supportive relationships and qualified professional help may be useful when persistent fear of disapproval interferes with daily life.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top