Why Do People Struggle With People Pleasing? The Dress of a Hundred Pockets

Why do people struggle with people pleasing? A dressmaker whose promises magically become pockets must decide which commitments deserve her time and attention.

Gold-lettered title cover: Why Do People Struggle With People Pleasing? The Dress of a Hundred Pockets

The dress was finished on a Thursday, except for the pocket in which the bride intended to carry her mother’s photograph.

“Could you make room for a handkerchief as well?” the bride asked.

“Of course,” said Mira.

“And my telephone?”

“Certainly.”

The bride’s aunt looked up from a chair in the corner.

“In that case, perhaps another one for the rings.”

Mira knew that the rings were to be carried by the bride’s brother. She also knew that the dress had been constructed from delicate fabric, that three pockets had already been added to its lining and that there was very little time left before the wedding.

“Leave it with me,” she said.

The women thanked her. The bride embraced her, careful not to disturb the unfinished garment.

When they left, Mira stood looking at the dress.

In the silence of the workshop, another pocket appeared.

It grew like a pale envelope beneath the lining, opening slowly from a seam that Mira had sewn herself. She touched it. Inside was a little scrap of paper bearing a sentence in her own handwriting.

Leave it with me.

She drew her hand away.

Across the room, the clock struck six.

She had promised to be at her daughter’s concert at half past six.

She had also promised to finish a jacket, alter two pairs of trousers and telephone a customer whose order was not ready.

For the first time, Mira began to suspect that the workshop had found a way of keeping every promise she made.


Mira had been a dressmaker for twenty-three years.

Her workshop stood in a narrow street behind the covered market of Bellwick. From its window, a person could see the upper portions of several buildings, a balcony whose inhabitants grew extraordinarily large geraniums and a little piece of the sky.

She liked the room.

She had arranged it herself when she established the business, selecting the tables, machines and drawers with an attention to detail her brother considered excessive.

She was especially proud of the wooden cabinet in which she stored the finished garments.

When Mira was young, her mother, Cora, worked from the kitchen of their apartment. Customers came at all hours. Some paid promptly, and some did not.

Cora was a capable dressmaker.

She was also exceptionally reluctant to refuse a request.

A neighbor who needed a garment altered by morning could generally persuade her to remain awake long after the children went to bed. A relative might bring a dress and explain that she would pay when her circumstances improved.

The circumstances sometimes improved.

The payment did not always arrive.

Mira remembered a particular winter when her father had lost his job. Her mother was worried about several bills. Then a customer visited with an urgent request and very little money.

Cora agreed to help.

Afterward she sat at the kitchen table looking at the accounts.

Mira asked why she had accepted the work.

“She needed it.”

“Don’t we need the money?”

Her mother looked at her, then laughed unhappily.

“Yes.”

Mira loved her mother. She admired the kindness with which Cora responded to people who had experienced genuine difficulties.

She did not understand why the needs of a person standing in the kitchen invariably seemed to acquire greater importance than the needs of the people who were already there.


At sixteen, Mira was invited to spend a weekend at the coast with three friends.

She had saved enough money for the journey. Her parents had agreed to the arrangement, and she was delighted.

The day before she intended to leave, a customer came to the apartment with several garments. Cora had accepted another substantial order, and she did not know how she would complete all the work in time.

Mira offered to stay.

Her mother asked whether she was certain.

“Yes.”

She smiled.

She helped with the garments over the weekend.

On Monday, one of her friends showed her a photograph of the sea.

Mira was disappointed. She was also proud that her mother had been able to finish the orders.

The two feelings were perfectly capable of coexisting.

But Mira began to regard one of them as a regrettable failure of generosity.

She had offered to stay. Therefore, she reasoned, she had no right to feel disappointed.

She made a similar calculation whenever her friends suggested something that conflicted with the needs of her family.

Sometimes helping was important to her.

Sometimes she wanted to do something else.

Over the years she developed a particularly effective way of avoiding conflict between the two wishes.

She offered to help before anyone asked her to.

If a relative was about to mention a difficulty, she began considering what she could do about it. If a colleague described a task she had not finished, Mira wanted to take part of it away from her.

When somebody thanked her, she experienced an extraordinary sense of relief.

For a little while she knew what she meant to that person.

She became accustomed to trying to obtain the feeling.


Her husband, Dev, taught at a technical college.

When they first met, she liked the care with which he listened to people’s explanations. He liked the fact that she was willing to spend an entire afternoon discussing a particular kind of fabric.

They married, had a daughter named Rina and eventually moved into a house in the district where Mira established the workshop.

Dev sometimes found her habits difficult to understand.

One Saturday the two arranged to visit an exhibition at the library.

Before leaving, Mira received a telephone call from a customer who wanted to collect a garment at an inconvenient time.

She agreed to open the shop.

Dev offered to change the time of their visit.

Then another customer called.

By four, the exhibition had closed.

Mira apologized.

Dev accepted the apology.

Then he asked whether she had needed to open the shop.

“The first customer was going away.”

“When?”

“Monday.”

“And the second?”

Mira explained.

Dev listened.

He pointed out that they had made an arrangement too.

She became angry.

She told him she could not ignore people just because she wanted to go to an exhibition.

“I didn’t ask you to ignore anybody.”

She looked at him.

He wanted to understand why the circumstances of a person who had requested something that morning seemed to matter more than a commitment the two of them made several days earlier.

Mira had not thought of it in that way.

She thought of herself as someone who was willing to change her plans.

It had taken considerably longer to recognize that other people were frequently changing their plans as a consequence.


The first magical pocket appeared in a coat.

A customer asked whether Mira could complete an alteration by Wednesday. The work would ordinarily require another day.

Mira agreed.

She turned the coat inside out and found an additional pocket near its hem.

Inside was a little note.

Wednesday.

She showed it to her assistant, Noor.

Noor examined the seam.

“Did you put that there?”

“No.”

They took a photograph.

Then the pocket disappeared.

Mira was uneasy. She had been sleeping poorly and occasionally found herself staring at garments without remembering exactly what she had been doing. She arranged to discuss the unusual experience and her exhaustion with a qualified health professional.

She also reviewed the work with Noor, who independently reported seeing the pocket. They considered whether something about the material or their equipment might account for it.

They did not establish an explanation.

The alteration was completed on Wednesday, after Mira remained in the workshop much later than she intended.

Several days later another pocket appeared.

This one contained a sentence she remembered saying to her sister.

I’ll bring the cake.

The garment belonged to a man who wanted his jacket repaired.

There was no obvious connection between the two things.

Mira began keeping a record of the occasions on which the pockets appeared. Some of the notes referred to promises she had made to customers. Others referred to ordinary arrangements with relatives or friends.

The pockets generally disappeared after the corresponding tasks were completed or the arrangements changed in some identifiable way.

There were exceptions.

The process did not provide a reliable account of everything happening in Mira’s life.

But for the first time, the things she accepted responsibility for began occupying physical space in the workshop.

She thought of the parliament clerk in The Parliament of Unfinished Questions, whose unanswered questions accumulated until the chamber could no longer contain them.

Mira wondered how many pockets a garment could hold.


The bride was called Celia.

She had visited the workshop six months earlier with her aunt, a woman named Estelle who possessed extensive opinions about dresses.

Celia wanted a relatively simple garment with a narrow line of embroidery near its hem. Estelle wanted something rather more elaborate.

Mira listened to both of them.

Then she made a drawing containing elements she thought would please each.

Celia looked at it.

“Could we take these off?”

She indicated several decorations.

“Certainly.”

Estelle explained why she liked them.

Mira drew a different arrangement.

Celia looked disappointed.

“Actually, I preferred the first idea.”

Her aunt was surprised.

They discussed it.

Eventually, Celia approved a design closer to the one she had originally described.

Mira was pleased.

She was also uncomfortable because she could not establish whether Estelle liked it.

During the following months, the three met several times.

Whenever Estelle proposed a change, Mira wanted to find a way of making it compatible with Celia’s wishes. She became increasingly reluctant to explain when a change would require additional work, have financial implications or affect the appearance of the garment.

Noor noticed.

One afternoon she asked whether Celia had approved a particular alteration.

“Her aunt likes it.”

Noor waited.

“Does Celia?”

Mira laughed.

“I’ll ask.”

She did.

Celia said she did not want it.

Mira felt a curious disappointment.

She had spent considerable time attempting to find a way of including something neither the bride nor the garment required.

The bride was not angry.

The aunt was not particularly upset.

There were things Celia wanted to wear and things Estelle liked looking at.

Mira had treated the existence of different preferences as a practical problem she was obliged to resolve.


Rina was seventeen.

She played the violin and had been preparing for a concert at her school for several months. The performance would include a short piece in which she played with two other students.

She invited Mira.

Mira accepted immediately.

On the afternoon of the performance, Rina sent a message reminding her that the concert began at six thirty.

Mira replied that she would be there.

Then Celia and Estelle arrived.

They discussed the additional pockets.

Mira said she would finish the alterations that evening.

When the women left, the little note appeared.

Leave it with me.

Mira examined the garment.

Then another pocket appeared beside the first.

Inside was Rina’s name.

She was astonished.

A third pocket contained a note referring to the jacket. A fourth contained a question she had agreed to investigate for her sister.

By the time Noor returned from collecting supplies, the dress had acquired twelve additional pockets.

It could no longer be hung properly.

Noor looked at it.

“How many things have you agreed to do tonight?”

Mira began listing them.

She was surprised that she could not remember all of them.

Noor asked whether any of the customers had been told the work would be finished by a different time before Mira accepted the additional requests.

Several had.

They examined the order records.

The original arrangement for collecting Celia’s dress was Saturday morning. The requested additions were not necessary to complete the agreed design.

The jacket could be collected the following afternoon. The trousers belonged to a customer who would be away until Monday.

Mira looked at the clock.

She could still reach the school before the performance if she left shortly.

She wanted to go.

She also wanted to remain until the pockets disappeared.

She remembered the composer in The Orchestra of Unanswered Letters, who had become so preoccupied with the possibility of another person’s unfavorable judgment that she nearly missed her own concert.

Rina had invited Mira to listen to something she had worked hard to make.

Mira had agreed.

She looked at Noor.

“I need to go.”

“Yes.”

Mira contacted the customers whose arrangements required clarification, ensuring that any proposed changes were agreed rather than simply assumed. Then she completed the necessary closing arrangements with Noor.

She left.


At the school, Rina was standing beside the door of the hall.

She looked relieved when she saw her mother.

Mira apologized for arriving just before the performance.

Rina smiled.

“You’re here.”

The words made Mira happy.

They also made her uncomfortable.

There had been occasions when Rina expected her to arrive somewhere and she had not.

During the concert, Mira watched the three musicians standing beneath the stage lights.

She liked the expression on Rina’s face when she realized the performance was going well.

Afterward, the family went to get something to eat.

Rina described several things that happened during rehearsal. Dev asked about a difficulty the students had experienced with the arrangement.

Mira listened.

Then Rina asked whether she was going back to the workshop.

“No.”

She was surprised by the question.

Rina explained that Mira had occasionally left family events early because a customer needed something.

She had begun assuming that her mother’s participation would depend on whether another arrangement appeared.

Mira wanted to explain that the business was important.

She knew that.

Rina knew it too.

Instead she asked whether her daughter wanted her to stay for the remainder of the evening.

Rina said yes.

They ordered another dish.

Mira remembered the museum curator in The Museum of Broken Promises, whose wish to accommodate opportunities at work repeatedly affected commitments she made to her brother.

She recognized that she had been treating the willingness of her family to understand her circumstances as an opportunity to ask more of them.

After supper, they walked home.

There were still things to do at the workshop.

Mira was glad she was not doing them.


The following morning, she discovered the dress covered with pockets.

Noor had placed it on a table and arranged a cloth over it.

Mira examined the garment.

She could not safely finish the alteration while the additional material remained.

She contacted Celia and requested a conversation.

She explained the practical limitations of the garment and the time available. She described which changes could be undertaken without interfering with the agreed design and which would require a different arrangement.

Celia listened.

Then she laughed.

“I don’t even need the phone pocket.”

Mira was surprised.

Celia explained that her sister would have a bag during the ceremony. The handkerchief could be carried separately. The only pocket she particularly wanted was the one for the photograph.

Mira had spent the previous evening imagining Celia discovering that the dressmaker was unwilling to help her.

The bride appeared relieved that the matter had been clarified.

They agreed on the suitable alteration and confirmed the collection arrangements.

Several pockets disappeared.

Estelle called later.

She wanted to know whether something could still be done about the rings.

Mira explained the limits of the garment and suggested that they discuss the arrangements with Celia.

Estelle sounded disappointed.

Mira felt a familiar desire to find a way of doing the work anyway.

Then she remembered the photograph.

The dress belonged to Celia.

Mira completed the agreed alteration.

She was proud of it.

On Saturday, Celia collected the dress.

Before leaving, she thanked Mira for explaining the options so clearly.

Mira smiled.

The dress had one carefully constructed pocket.

It was enough.


Over the following months, Mira began investigating the ways her commitments were made.

She introduced clearer order arrangements, including realistic completion dates and information about changes to previously agreed work.

She discussed the arrangements with Noor.

There were occasions when they were able to accommodate urgent requests. There were others when doing so would interfere with work they had already accepted.

They learned to explain the distinction.

One customer became irritated when an alteration could not be completed on the day he wanted.

He took the garment elsewhere.

Mira spent much of the evening thinking about the exchange.

She imagined whether she might have arranged the work differently.

She wondered whether he would return.

She was tempted to contact him and offer another arrangement.

Then she examined the actual commitments they had made that day.

The time was not available.

She was sorry to lose the order.

It did not follow that she ought to have accepted it.

She also continued seeking professional support, particularly because the fear of disappointing people had affected her sleep and relationships.

She began examining what she hoped to gain when she agreed to things she did not particularly want to do.

Sometimes the work itself mattered.

Sometimes she wanted to be useful.

Sometimes she felt uncomfortable when another person was unhappy, and agreeing to something was a familiar way of reducing the discomfort.

She thought of the craftsman in The Festival of Unchosen Doors, who had learned that a person’s value did not depend on obtaining a favorable response to an invitation.

Mira was learning something about the other side of that exchange.

She could decline a request without necessarily ending a relationship.

She could recognize another person’s disappointment without assuming she was responsible for removing it.


Her mother visited the workshop in spring.

Cora examined several garments and commented on the excellent condition of the sewing machine.

She had retired many years earlier.

Mira told her about the arrangements she had introduced for completing orders.

Cora smiled.

“Wish I’d done that.”

Mira laughed.

“Really?”

Her mother described an afternoon when she missed a friend’s birthday gathering because she accepted several orders she could not comfortably complete.

She remembered the friend.

She also remembered the garments.

For some reason she had spent years remembering the event as proof that she had been particularly hardworking.

She wished, now, that she had gone to the gathering.

Mira thought about the journey to the coast at sixteen.

She told her mother about it.

Cora remembered the weekend.

She had been grateful for the help.

She had not realized how disappointed Mira was.

“Why didn’t you say?”

Mira laughed unhappily.

She had believed that a genuinely helpful person did not need to mention what she wanted.

Her mother sat beside her.

They talked for some time.

Neither attempted to establish that their earlier choices had been entirely wrong or entirely necessary.

There had been difficult circumstances.

There had also been things they could have discussed differently.


A year after the wedding, a woman brought Mira a coat that needed a repair.

The work was relatively straightforward.

She asked whether she could collect it the following evening.

Mira consulted the records.

There was not enough time.

She explained when the work could be completed.

The woman considered the arrangement, then said she would bring the coat back another week.

Mira thanked her.

After she left, a tiny pocket appeared in the fabric of Mira’s apron.

Inside was a blank piece of paper.

Mira smiled.

She could not establish why the pockets appeared, and the people investigating the unusual phenomenon had not found a satisfactory explanation. The records continued to be examined appropriately.

But she no longer wanted to obtain a particular number of pockets before she felt entitled to close the workshop.

She understood why people could struggle with people pleasing. Being useful could provide a sense of belonging, reduce conflict or help someone feel secure in relationships that mattered to them. Earlier experiences might teach a person to anticipate needs before expressing her own. The relief associated with satisfying a request could make the next request increasingly difficult to decline.

Kindness itself was not the problem.

She wanted to remain kind.

She also wanted her agreements to mean something, including the ones she made to herself.

Noor asked whether she was staying late.

“No.”

Rina was waiting outside.

They had arranged to visit the market.

Mira turned off the light.

There was still room in her apron.

She put her keys into its ordinary pocket.

Then she went downstairs.

Editorial note: Original magical-realist fiction. All characters, places, businesses and supernatural events are invented. People pleasing is an everyday term for patterns of prioritizing others’ approval or needs, sometimes at the expense of personal preferences and commitments. Such patterns may develop through social expectations, fear of conflict or rejection, and previous experiences. Generosity and cooperation are not inherently problematic. Clear communication, realistic commitments, mutual respect and appropriate professional support may help when difficulty expressing needs causes persistent distress.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top