Dear promise of social mobility,
My father polished his shoes for the evening on which I was to receive an award. He put newspaper across the kitchen floor, took the tin of polish from beneath the sink and worked a little of it into the cracked leather. I offered to buy him another pair. He looked at the shoes, looked at me and said that these would take him perfectly well to the school. He had worn them to dozens of weddings. I was embarrassed by my offer before he had finished speaking.
The engineer writing this letter, her family and the school mentioned here are fictional. Their story is an exploration of what can happen after a person has enjoyed an opportunity that changes her social circumstances. I am interested in the distance travelled by someone who has benefited from your promise, and in what she is encouraged to believe about the people at the other end of that journey.
I had grown up in a neighborhood close to a railway yard. My father repaired the interiors of passenger carriages. He came home with small scratches on his hands and very specific opinions about the strength of a hinge. My mother worked in a bakery and could identify the moment when bread needed to come out of the oven before the timer rang. Neither had attended a university. They were both interested in how things worked, and we lived among questions to which they considered an accurate answer quite important.
At school I became particularly fond of mathematics. My teacher lent me books beyond the requirements of the ordinary curriculum and encouraged me to apply for a scholarship. I received one, studied engineering and eventually joined a firm that designed public buildings. My income rose. I moved into an apartment with a view across a park. I could buy my parents a new refrigerator without wondering whether the purchase would leave me unable to pay the electricity bill. Many things that had once required an anxious family discussion became manageable decisions. I am grateful for these changes and for the people who helped make them possible.
But the evening of the award introduced me to a description of my life that I had not prepared myself to hear. The headteacher stood beside the lectern and spoke about my journey from humble beginnings to professional success. Behind him was a photograph of the street where I had grown up. The next slide showed the office in which I now worked. Each image was assigned a clear position in the story. Everyone in the hall understood which one represented a problem and which one represented its solution.
I looked for my father. He was applauding.
There had been things about that street I had been glad to leave. The traffic was loud, our building needed expensive repairs, and the cramped rooms made it difficult to study when several people were at home. I had wanted a different life, and I had worked for one. Nevertheless, as the photograph came into view, I found myself thinking of the old woman who taught me to draw a straight seam, the neighbor who gave me a lift to my scholarship interview and the children with whom I learned to invent games on a narrow strip of pavement. None of them appeared in the accompanying account of the circumstances I had overcome.
We need to speak carefully about the movement you promise. It is one thing to say that a person should not be compelled to inherit her parents’ occupation or income. It is quite another to organize our descriptions of human achievement around the proposition that a person who leaves a particular occupation has become a more valuable human being. The second conviction can settle unnoticed inside the celebration of the first.
My father understood certain aspects of his work far better than I did. Once, when I was a student, I showed him a drawing of a fastening arrangement I had produced for a design exercise. He asked how somebody would reach the fastening when the other components were in position. I had not allowed enough room for the hand holding the tool. The drawing was technically neat. The person employed to assemble the object would have had reason to be considerably less impressed. His question changed the drawing and, eventually, the way I approached more complicated designs.
I recognized in that experience something akin to the inheritance of advantage. What had been passed to me was neither property nor an introduction to an influential person. It was a habit of considering the circumstances in which an object would actually be used. It had been acquired through work that was ordinarily treated as less prestigious than mine. How strange that the knowledge should become more readily admired when expressed in the language of a university graduate.
After the ceremony, a pupil approached me. She wanted to know what she should study if she hoped to get out of the town. We talked for a while about her interests. She liked working with younger children and had thought about becoming a nursery teacher, but a cousin had advised her to choose a profession that would prove she had made something of herself. She was not sure what counted. I had come prepared to tell pupils that they could pursue ambitious goals. I had not anticipated being asked to decide whether a particular ambition was impressive enough.
It seems to me that you have sometimes been offered to young people in a rather narrow form. They are shown a ladder and encouraged to imagine the view from a higher rung. There is good reason to provide access to better paid work and to positions from which people have historically been excluded. Exclusion has real material consequences. Yet a community also needs to consider the conditions of life on the rungs from which it invites everyone to depart. If a child must become a highly paid professional to obtain a safe home, decent working hours and the respect of strangers, then the achievement of that child does not tell us whether the underlying arrangements are satisfactory.
There is also an arithmetic problem in treating advancement as the principal remedy for hardship. A society cannot arrange for every worker to hold a position above all the others. Schools still require people who clean classrooms. Public buildings still need maintenance. Families need people who provide care. Important work does not always lead to increasing professional rank. An individual can escape poor conditions by changing jobs, but that change does not improve the conditions experienced by the next person employed to do the work.
This is why the promise of movement should be distinguished from the promise of improvement. Movement concerns the position someone occupies in relation to others or to an earlier point in life. Improvement concerns the actual quality and possibilities of that life. The two sometimes coincide. Sometimes a person earns a better living without changing occupations. Sometimes someone takes a lower paid position in order to do work that matters more to her. Neither journey is adequately described by its direction on a ladder.
I do not mean that young people should be asked to accept deprivation in the name of loyalty to a community. There is a particular cruelty in telling a child that leaving would constitute a betrayal when the adults around her have been unable to provide the opportunities she needs. The barriers discussed in the idea of fair opportunity deserve removal precisely because a person should be free to discover an interest beyond what is available nearby.
What I object to is the additional instruction, often delivered without anyone noticing it: that the person who has been allowed to leave ought to feel ashamed of having belonged there in the first place.
In the early years of my career, I learned to alter my speech according to the room I had entered. Some of that adjustment was useful. Every workplace has a vocabulary, and learning it can help people communicate clearly. But other changes had very little to do with clarity. I stopped mentioning certain details about home because I did not know whether my colleagues would understand them. When conversations turned to childhood holidays, I became adept at asking questions rather than answering them. Nobody had ordered me to do these things. I was trying to avoid the small surprise that sometimes appeared on a person’s face when an apparently familiar colleague disclosed an unfamiliar past.
My mother noticed this alteration long before I did. She once telephoned while I was having lunch with two colleagues. I spoke to her in the careful, impersonal manner I had begun to use at work. Later she asked whether she had interrupted a meeting. I told her that she had not. We said goodbye, and I sat for some time with the unpleasant recognition that I had made my own mother feel like a visitor to a part of my life in which I had once hoped she would take pride.
People who have moved between social environments may carry considerable knowledge of both. This can become a valuable capacity for translation, for recognizing the assumptions that one group makes about another, and for imagining how a decision will be received outside the room in which it is made. But it can also become the exhausting obligation to present a different version of oneself to each audience. I am learning to use the capacity without accepting the obligation.
The organizers of awards and scholarship programs have a role in this. Their successful participants need not be presented as proof that the institutions surrounding them are already fair. A person’s achievement can be celebrated without deciding what the failure of someone else signifies. As the gap between effort and outcome reminds us, outcomes can conceal the effort of people whose circumstances have not permitted an equivalent result. A single story of advancement can demonstrate that a route is possible. It cannot establish how widely that route is accessible.
And the measures by which we judge social advancement deserve attention. It matters whether a person’s income has increased, whether she can make decisions her parents could not make and whether her children will have access to good education. It also matters whether her parents can grow old without relying on her new income, whether her former neighbors have gained greater protections at work and whether a young person who wants to remain in the town can build a satisfactory life there. These are distinct questions. None is answered simply by placing another successful graduate on a stage.
Before leaving the school that evening, I asked the organizers if I might speak to the pupils again at a later date. I wanted to invite a few people whose occupations were rarely represented in our career assemblies. I thought of the technician who inspected water pipes beneath the city, the woman who ran a neighborhood nursery and a railway worker who had once taught a young engineering student to leave enough space for a hand holding a tool. I wanted the pupils to hear from the people who keep things running, not only about entering different professions, but about the conditions under which they could do good work and live well.
My father and I walked home together. He asked whether I still had the photograph my teacher had taken when I won the scholarship. I told him it was somewhere in a drawer. We talked about finding a frame for it. Then he mentioned a problem with the school hall door, which somebody had needed to lift slightly in order to close. I found myself asking him how he would repair it.
Dear promise of social mobility, keep the roads open. Let children discover worlds their parents have never entered. Give people the means to leave circumstances that limit them, and the freedom to return without having to explain why. But do not ask those who travel far to regard their point of departure as a place inhabited by lesser people.
I want the next child from our street to have a choice of destinations. I also want the street itself to become a better place in which to stay.
With gratitude for every road that opened, and respect for the people who built it,
An engineer who has not outgrown her father’s lessons.



