An Open Letter to the Gap Between Effort and Outcome

Two fictional market growers prepare their stalls with equal care but return home with very different earnings. Through an unsold crate of peaches and an unexpected conversation, this letter considers the uncertain relationship between effort and reward, the dignity of work that does not succeed, and the limits of judging people solely by results.

An Open Letter to the Gap Between Effort and Outcome in dark serif lettering on vintage parchment.

Dear gap,

You became visible to me on a Saturday afternoon in the shape of twenty-three unsold peaches. They lay in a wooden crate beneath my market table, still carrying the faint warmth of the day. Across the aisle, another grower was folding the cloth on an empty stall. We had arrived at roughly the same hour, and both of us had spent the previous months attending to our trees. He had sold his fruit. I had not sold mine. I wondered how much of that difference I should understand as a judgment upon my work.

The market and growers in this letter are fictional. I have placed us in an imagined town because the questions that surround an unsuccessful day are sometimes easier to approach through a small, ordinary event. We are accustomed to seeing the rewards of an action. We are less accustomed to seeing all the work that did not produce its intended reward.

I had risen early to prepare the fruit. My daughter helped me sort the peaches, and we placed the ones with marks on their skins in a separate crate, where customers could buy them at a lower price. I checked the straps securing the load and drove to the town while the morning was still cool. By the time the first customers arrived, I had already performed a considerable part of a working day.

My neighbor at the market was called Sami. His orchard stood on the other side of the valley. He knew his trees well and was particularly attentive to the way the fruit should be presented. I liked speaking with him because he could explain a difficulty without making the person who had encountered it feel foolish. When he sold the last of his peaches, I was pleased for him. I was also painfully aware of what remained beneath my table.

Several events had contributed to our different results. A temporary change to the entrance of the market had directed more customers past his stall. His variety of peach was familiar to people in the town, whereas mine was less familiar. He had received a request from a cafe owner who bought a substantial quantity. I had spent part of the morning explaining that the pale skin of my smaller fruit did not mean that it was unripe.

There were things I might have done better. A clearer sign would have helped. I could have contacted several customers in advance rather than assuming they would come to the market. I had sometimes been too confident that the quality of the fruit would be understood without explanation. Examining those decisions was useful. It was not useful to imagine that correcting every one of them would necessarily have produced the result Sami achieved.

In the evening, my daughter asked whether I would grow a different variety the following year. She was not blaming me. She wanted to know what the experience had taught us. I found that I was reluctant to answer. The trees were healthy, and their fruit was good. Yet I had begun to feel as though their failure to produce a satisfactory income that day revealed something about my ability to make decisions.

The earlier letter about the concept of merit distinguishes achievement from the history of opportunities that contributes to it. My question is about the uncertainty that enters even after a person has acquired the necessary skills and has been given a reasonable opportunity to exercise them. Sometimes an intelligent plan does not work. Sometimes an imperfect plan happens to encounter favorable circumstances. We need ways of learning from results without pretending that results reveal everything about the decisions that preceded them.

At the next market, a storm unexpectedly shortened the trading day. Several stallholders returned home with baskets they had expected to empty. Nobody explained our difficulties through an absence of commitment. The reason for them was visible in the water running down the pavement. The following week, when customers were fewer than expected for reasons we could not see, some of the same people began criticizing themselves.

I found that contrast instructive. A cause becomes easier to acknowledge when it can be observed. When it cannot, we are tempted to assign the entire outcome to the person standing beside it. This temptation is particularly powerful when we possess an account of somebody else’s success and would like the account to provide a reliable method for producing our own.

A friend who sold bread encouraged me to present the peaches differently. Her suggestions were sensible, and I tried some of them. We also discussed whether the market committee could restore the customary entrance or make the new route clearer. That question belonged to the organization of the market rather than to the quality of either grower’s work. We were able to discuss it without suggesting that Sami had done anything wrong by benefiting from the position of his stall.

The letter concerning the accumulated effects of ordinary arrangements is relevant here. The location of an entrance can affect whom customers encounter first. A market authority may have legitimate reasons for modifying access. But when sales figures are later used to evaluate the desirability of particular stalls or varieties, the authority should remember the conditions it helped establish. What appears to be an independent measure of customer preference may partly reflect the route customers were given.

Dear gap, I have noticed that you are often absent from stories told about successful people. We begin with their early difficulties, describe their determination, and arrive at the result that proves the determination was worthwhile. Such stories can offer valuable encouragement. The trouble begins when we forget that another person may have performed similarly thoughtful and persistent work without reaching the final scene.

The missing story is not necessarily more important than the successful one. It is simply necessary if we wish to understand a relationship between actions and outcomes rather than describe the actions of people selected because their outcomes were favorable.

I continued attending the market. On some mornings my preparations were excellent and the results disappointing. On others I made several mistakes and still returned home with little fruit. Over time I acquired knowledge about what different customers wanted and which arrangements were more likely to work. The knowledge mattered. It did not give me complete control of the circumstances in which I would use it.

That is one reason the value of careful work should not be described as a guarantee. Careful work can improve the quality of a product, reduce foreseeable problems, and make certain favorable outcomes more likely. Those are substantial reasons to perform it. They remain substantial even when the outcome of a particular day is unfavorable. A person deciding whether to continue should examine the pattern and the available alternatives, not treat a single result as a complete verdict.

The earlier reflection on the relationship between metrics and judgment reminds me that a number can be indispensable without being sufficient. Our sales totals helped us determine whether the market was financially sustainable. I could not afford to ignore them merely because I believed in the quality of my fruit. But the total did not identify the cause of every difficulty or tell me which response would be sensible. Those questions required observations, conversation, and a willingness to distinguish evidence from an explanation.

There were periods when continuing with an unsuccessful arrangement would have been irresponsible. Some of the fruit I produced had little demand in our immediate market, and I eventually changed how much of it I offered there. I found another buyer for part of the crop and decided not to expand that part of the orchard. I do not regard those decisions as surrender. The lesson of uncertain outcomes is not that all plans deserve endless loyalty. It is that a decision to revise a plan need not become a declaration that the person who made it was deficient.

Institutions can help preserve this distinction. An employment programme should examine whether the work it encourages is connected to realistic opportunities. A lender should consider credible risks instead of assuming that confidence alone will produce a favorable result. An organization evaluating its employees should distinguish the matters they could influence from those over which they had little control. None of these distinctions removes the need to evaluate performance. They give the evaluation a more defensible purpose.

I think of the fear of falling and the importance of the conditions under which a person can recover from disappointment. A grower who can survive an unsuccessful season has more freedom to learn from it. Another grower may have to abandon a promising undertaking after one difficulty because there is no money left with which to attempt the next. If we want people to take thoughtful risks, we should pay attention to the arrangements that make thoughtful failure survivable.

Those twenty-three peaches did not go entirely to waste. We ate some at home and shared others with neighbors. I remember my daughter cutting a particularly fragrant one over a plate so the juice would not run onto the table. She said it was a pity more people had not tasted them. I agreed. The fruit possessed qualities that its appearance in an unsold crate did not erase. Its financial result mattered to our household, but the result was not a complete description of the thing we had grown.

I hope you will remain visible, dear gap, whenever somebody is tempted to explain a person’s entire life through what they have achieved. Let us examine effort with care, improve the methods available to us, and hold people responsible for the decisions they genuinely make. Let us also recognize that work enters a world containing other people’s choices, changing circumstances, and events nobody can arrange in advance.

I will take another crate to the market next Saturday. I will prepare the fruit thoughtfully and pay attention to what I have learned. I will hope to return with an empty crate. If I do not, I will have something to investigate rather than a reason to conclude that my work had no value.

With respect for the harvests we tend and the weather we cannot command,

A grower who still believes in the trees

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top