An Open Letter to the Fear of Falling

A fictional bicycle mechanic is offered a place in a training course that could change his working life, but accepting it would expose his household to expenses it cannot easily bear. His letter to fear considers why caution is not always a failure of ambition and what makes a meaningful risk possible.

An Open Letter to the Fear of Falling printed in dark serif lettering on vintage parchment.

Dear fear,

The application lay beneath a bicycle wheel for most of March. I had filled in my name, my address, and the details of the work I had done since leaving school. There was nothing complicated about the remaining questions. I had been offered a place in a course that would teach me to service more demanding equipment. My difficulty was not deciding whether the course interested me. It was deciding whether my household could survive the possibility that it would not lead to better work.

I write from an imagined bicycle repair shop. The mechanic, course, family, and circumstances described in this letter are fictional. They are a way of considering the kind of fear that cannot be separated from the ordinary business of making sure people have somewhere to sleep and enough money to buy their food. You have been called my enemy, fear. I am not certain that the description is entirely fair.

My sister believed I should accept the course. She had watched me take apart damaged bicycles and restore them to use, sometimes after another person had concluded that the work was not worth attempting. She knew how much pleasure I took in discovering why something had stopped functioning. She thought I would enjoy learning alongside people who understood the mechanisms I had not yet encountered. She was right about my interests. Neither of us disputed the value of learning.

The course occupied several afternoons each week. Those afternoons were also among the busiest hours at the shop. My employer was willing to adjust my schedule, but he could not promise that my earnings would remain the same. The fee was partly covered by an award. Travel, meals, and the remaining expense would belong to me. My household had enough to meet its ordinary obligations and very little with which to address an unexpected one. We had recently replaced a leaking pipe, and the envelope containing our reserves was thinner than I liked.

When my sister told me that I was capable of succeeding, I thanked her. She had answered a question I had not asked. I was not primarily wondering whether I possessed the ability to learn. I was wondering what would happen if I learned everything the course offered and the employment I hoped to obtain did not become available. There was a difference between the risk of being disappointed and the risk of discovering that a month of rent had become difficult to pay.

I recognize something of our situation in the distinction between stability and privilege. A dependable reserve does not merely protect a person after something has gone wrong. It can change the decisions that person feels free to make beforehand. Two people can receive the same invitation and understand its benefits equally well while confronting quite different possible consequences. The invitation may cost them the same amount. Their ability to recover from an unfavorable result is not necessarily the same.

You sometimes spoke to me in the language of my father’s habits. He had worked for a small transport company and kept a record of every significant expense in a notebook. As a boy I thought the notebook represented an excessive interest in things that should not concern a child. Only later did I discover that he had used it to decide whether a pair of new shoes could be bought without leaving a bill unpaid. His caution had protected us. It had also narrowed some of the ambitions he permitted himself to consider.

I do not want to inherit his every judgment simply because I understand the reasons for it. The circumstances in which a habit developed may change. A person who once had very little room for error can continue experiencing danger after some of the danger has receded. You are sometimes slow to recognize that distinction, fear. You can remember an earlier difficulty more convincingly than I can imagine a new possibility. That is a reason to examine what you say, not a reason to refuse to hear you.

A customer named Julian brought a bicycle in for repair while I was considering the course. We had spoken before about the work he did as an electrician. He told me that he had taken several months away from regular employment to undertake additional training. I asked how he had arranged the financial side of it. He said he had lived with his parents for part of that period. His experience did not make his achievement less admirable. It helped me understand why advice about courage often arrives without a complete account of the conditions that made a courageous decision possible.

I thought of the question of what merit can honestly explain. An institution may recognize the people who complete a demanding course without knowing much about those who never entered it. The successful participants have supplied effort deserving of recognition. But the absence of the mechanic who stayed behind at his bench does not establish that he lacked the qualities they demonstrated. It may establish only that he could not accept the particular distribution of risk offered to him.

The coordinator of the course contacted me a few days before the deadline. She wanted to know whether I intended to accept. I told her about the practical difficulties and asked whether the timetable could be arranged differently. She explained that the instructors had other commitments and that the number of possibilities was limited. I appreciated that she did not pretend the problem could be solved through an encouraging conversation. She offered information about a later session and put me in contact with an employer who had previously recruited graduates.

The employer described several kinds of work for which additional training would be useful. He could not guarantee a position. I would not have trusted him if he had. But his explanation helped me distinguish the hope that had brought me to the application from the opportunities that were reasonably likely to exist after completing it. I also discussed the timetable with my employer and worked out which hours might be available at the shop. I wanted a decision based on the best information I could obtain rather than on either a promise of success or an image of disaster.

The financial calculation remained uncomfortable. I decided not to enter the first course. Instead, I arranged to apply for the later session while setting aside what I could and seeking details of the available assistance. My sister was disappointed, although she understood my reasons. I was disappointed too. I knew that the decision preserved some of the security we had and cost me a period of learning I would have enjoyed. There was no way of making the two consequences disappear by choosing a more flattering description.

The earlier letter about the unequal distribution of risk helps me see why the design of such opportunities matters. A course provider cannot guarantee the future of every participant. It can consider whether the arrangements unnecessarily exclude people who have limited freedom to absorb a loss of earnings. Predictable schedules, accurate information about costs, appropriate financial assistance, and credible connections with employment can make an opportunity more usable without promising an outcome that nobody controls.

These arrangements help people take responsibility for their choices. They do not remove the need for responsibility. I would distrust a programme that concealed the difficulties of a profession merely to attract more applicants. I would also distrust one that congratulated itself on being open to everyone while treating the ability to leave paid work as a natural characteristic of a serious student. The conditions of participation deserve the same attention that is given to the quality of the instruction.

There is something else I want to say to you, fear. A life protected from every possible loss can become quite a small life. I have sometimes declined things that I could have managed. I have used a distant possibility of trouble to justify remaining in a familiar arrangement long after its advantages began to diminish. I am learning to distinguish those moments from the decisions in which the consequences of failure really would have exceeded what I could reasonably absorb. Both errors deserve attention. Neither is corrected by telling myself that caution is always wisdom or that courage is always virtue.

The account of the cost of remaining quiet reminds me that declining to express a wish has consequences of its own. I had nearly returned the application without explaining why. The coordinator might then have assumed that I was uninterested. My employer would not have known that a different schedule could matter to me. Even if I never attend the course, they now possess information that may influence an arrangement offered to a person in similar circumstances. A wish need not become an immediate commitment before it deserves to be heard.

The application no longer lies beneath the wheel. I keep it in a folder beside the notebook in which I record my earnings. I have not filled in a promise to attend the later course. I have written down the date on which applications open, the questions I still need answered, and the amount I would need to reserve for the period of training. It is a modest plan, and it may need to change. What matters to me is that I can imagine the decision in terms more useful than the choice between bravery and surrender.

I hope institutions will look carefully at the people who appear reluctant to accept their invitations. Some may genuinely prefer a different life. Some may be uncertain about their abilities. Others may understand the value of the invitation and have no dependable place to land if its promised benefits fail to arrive. Those are different circumstances. An institution interested in widening opportunity should want to know which of them it is encountering.

Dear fear, you may accompany me when the next application opens. I will not ask you to remain outside the shop while I make my decision. But I will ask you to speak precisely. Tell me which consequence you anticipate, how likely it seems, and what resources might help me bear it. Then give me room to consider what I might gain. I want to be neither a prisoner of the ground beneath my feet nor a person obliged to pretend that falling cannot hurt.

With respect for the distance between a risk and a ruin,

A mechanic who is still learning how to leave the ground

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top