The bell rang once, and the entire workshop fell silent.
Not because the sound was beautiful. There was a strange vibration at its edge, a second note that seemed to follow the first a little too closely.
In the courtyard, a pigeon abandoned the roof.
Master Havel folded his arms.
“Again.”
Nadia struck the bell with the testing mallet.
The sound returned. A deep, promising note, followed by something that seemed to disagree with it.
Havel looked toward the open doors.
The bell had been commissioned for the new town hall at Merrow. It was supposed to announce the beginning and end of market hours. The unveiling was in eleven days.
Nadia had designed the profile and supervised much of the work. It was the largest commission on which she had held that responsibility.
She had wanted, rather badly, for the first sound to be perfect.
“What do you hear?” Havel asked.
She described the vibration.
He nodded.
“What do you think?”
She looked at the bell.
There were several possible explanations. Some could be investigated without difficulty. Others might require the assistance of the specialists who had worked on the casting.
Instead of describing any of these possibilities, Nadia said, “I think somebody else should look at it.”
Havel lifted an eyebrow.
“Somebody else will. But I’m asking you.”
She wished he had asked practically anybody else.
Nadia grew up in a town famous for a bridge that was not actually within its boundaries.
Travelers came to see the bridge, bought cakes from the shops near the station, and wrote postcards describing the town as much prettier than its inhabitants generally considered it.
Her mother sold fabric. Her father repaired agricultural equipment. On Sunday mornings, a bell from the old church could be heard from almost everywhere in the town.
Nadia was interested in the way its sound changed according to where she stood.
From her bedroom it seemed soft. Near the market it was overwhelming. On the far side of the station, its lower note was sometimes all that remained audible.
When she was fourteen, her science teacher, Mrs. Venn, asked her to prepare a project about sound.
Nadia made several drawings of bells and attempted to explain the differences she had noticed.
On the day she presented the project, another pupil raised his hand.
“How do you know that’s why it sounds different?”
Nadia could not answer.
The teacher explained that the observations were interesting, but that Nadia had not established which factors accounted for them.
It was a useful distinction.
Unfortunately, two pupils laughed.
Nadia remembered the laughter rather more clearly than she remembered the distinction.
For the next two years, she became exceptionally good at providing answers to questions she already knew the answers to.
Questions about which she was uncertain received less attention.
Mrs. Venn noticed the change. One afternoon she asked Nadia why she had ceased bringing her drawings to school.
Nadia said she was busy.
The teacher knew that there was more to it, but Nadia was unwilling to discuss the matter.
Before the end of the school year, Mrs. Venn gave her a book about musical instruments.
Inside the cover she wrote:
An unfinished explanation is not an unworthy question.
Nadia kept the book.
She did not entirely believe the inscription.
The foundry occupied a collection of brick buildings near the river.
Its employees produced several kinds of metalwork, including bells for public buildings, schools and places of worship. Some commissions were small enough to be carried by one person. Others required elaborate arrangements for transport and installation.
Nadia began as an apprentice at nineteen.
She did not initially work on the most substantial bells. She learned to prepare drawings, read technical records and recognize the circumstances in which a decision needed to be referred to someone with more experience.
She liked the workshop.
She liked the sound of rain on the metal roof and the smell of the wood used to make patterns. She liked the way a completed drawing acquired a different significance when somebody began constructing the object it represented.
Havel, who had worked at the foundry for thirty years, was patient in some circumstances and remarkably impatient in others.
He disliked untidy records.
He disliked being asked the same question three times if the answer had been written down on the first occasion.
He also disliked people making decisions about matters they did not understand merely because they were embarrassed to admit uncertainty.
During Nadia’s second month, he examined a drawing she had made and pointed out a dimension she had recorded incorrectly.
She apologized.
He showed her how the error would affect the next stage of the work.
She corrected it.
Later that morning he asked her to prepare another drawing.
She was surprised.
She had anticipated a considerably longer interval between making a mistake and being trusted with something else.
Over the following years, she became skilled at several aspects of the work. She learned from the people who understood different parts of the process. Her drawings became more accurate. She acquired an ear for distinctions between sounds that she had once regarded as identical.
People began asking her questions.
She answered when she could.
When she could not, she found someone who could.
The difficulty did not become apparent until she was asked to supervise a complete commission.
The first commission was for a little school in a village near the hills.
Its bell was modest in size, and the technical requirements were well established. Nadia prepared the necessary work with the assistance of several colleagues and under the appropriate supervision.
Everything went reasonably well.
On the morning of the final assessment, Havel told her that the bell met the agreed requirements.
She was delighted.
Then she thought of the people who had helped.
The pattern maker had made a useful suggestion. A colleague had noticed a discrepancy in the records. Havel had reviewed the specifications.
Perhaps the result told her very little about what she could do.
The following commission also went well.
She remembered the things that made that one comparatively straightforward.
By the time the town hall commission arrived, Nadia had worked at the foundry for nine years. She was respected by people with considerable experience of the trade.
Nevertheless, she had developed a complicated method of interpreting the things that happened to her.
When a piece of work went well, she identified reasons that the result might not be particularly significant.
When a piece of work went badly, she identified reasons that the result might be particularly significant.
The first kind of investigation could continue for quite a long time.
The second often required very little effort.
She had never written down the method.
Had she done so, she might have been surprised by how unevenly she distributed the evidence.
At the beginning of the town hall project, Nadia visited Merrow.
The building stood at one end of an unusually wide market square. The architects had provided a space for a bell above the entrance, and its installation was being arranged through the appropriate engineers and contractors.
Nadia met the people responsible for the commission.
They discussed the purpose of the bell, the requirements for its sound and the circumstances in which it would be used.
An elderly market trader named Sorin accompanied them.
He remembered the town’s previous bell. It had been removed from an unsafe tower many years earlier and was now displayed in a museum.
He described hearing it as a child.
“Wonderful sound.”
Nadia smiled.
“What was wonderful about it?”
Sorin thought for a moment.
“It meant we could go home.”
They laughed.
Later, as she examined the drawings with the architects, Nadia began imagining the people who would hear the new bell. There would be people in the market with things still to do, children on their way home and residents who disliked the idea of another source of noise.
The bell would become a part of lives she could not fully imagine.
She wanted to make something worth listening to.
That desire helped her pay attention.
It also became, at certain moments, a source of considerable difficulty.
She began checking things she had already checked.
She sometimes stayed at the foundry later than she needed to, not because a task required completion but because she disliked leaving a decision alone for the night.
Her friend Ilya, who made instruments at a workshop nearby, asked whether she wanted to get supper.
She declined.
“I’ve got something to check.”
“What?”
She described a calculation that had already been reviewed.
Ilya listened.
“And what are you expecting to find?”
Nadia laughed.
“That it’s right.”
He looked at her.
“Didn’t you find that yesterday?”
She was not particularly pleased with the question.
The first test of the bell brought her worst expectations rather suddenly into the workshop.
After Havel asked what she heard, he arranged for the relevant specialists to assess the result.
The bell was secured in accordance with the foundry’s procedures. No one attempted an improvised adjustment. The team reviewed the records and discussed what additional measurements would help establish the cause of the sound.
Nadia sat with the others.
She understood much of what was being discussed.
She also found it difficult to speak.
When a colleague named Selim asked whether she had noticed anything unusual during a previous stage of the work, she described an observation she had recorded.
He examined her note.
“Useful.”
She waited for another question.
He went back to the records.
Afterward Nadia told Havel that she thought the problem might have been prevented if she had possessed more experience.
“Possibly,” he said.
She stared at him.
He continued.
“Or possibly not. We haven’t established what it is.”
She nodded.
He asked her to prepare a summary of the information available so far.
She went to the office.
For twenty minutes she wrote a document explaining everything she might have done differently.
Then she read it.
The document contained very little information about the bell.
She remembered the archivist in The Room Where Echoes Waited, who had discovered that her expectations could influence the story she constructed from incomplete evidence.
Nadia had been doing something similar.
She had written an explanation of her own inadequacy before the foundry possessed an explanation of the sound.
She began again.
That evening she visited Ilya.
He was repairing the case of an old instrument whose owner had asked him to preserve several marks on its surface.
Nadia sat beside his workbench.
She described the test.
He listened.
“Will they fix it?”
“I don’t know.”
“Do you know what’s wrong?”
“Not yet.”
He nodded.
She waited.
Then she said, “I’m worried they’ll decide I’m not good enough.”
“Who?”
“Everybody.”
He put down his tool.
“Everybody at the foundry?”
“Probably.”
“Everybody in Merrow?”
She laughed.
Then she told him about the things she imagined happening if the commission failed. The foundry would lose money. The unveiling would be delayed. People would remember that she had supervised the work.
Some of these were reasonable concerns.
Others involved elaborate accounts of conversations that had not happened.
Ilya asked what she thought a colleague ought to do in the same circumstances.
She described the importance of obtaining accurate information, reporting the difficulty and working with the appropriate people to resolve it.
He smiled.
“Sounds like a good idea.”
She looked at him.
She had been expecting him to tell her that she was exceptionally talented, that the bell would certainly be repaired and that nobody would ever think badly of her.
There was no way for him to establish any of those things.
What he could do was listen, remind her of the work she already knew how to do and share his supper.
He did all three.
Nadia felt better.
She still felt worried.
For the first time that evening she did not regard the persistence of the worry as evidence that the conversation had failed.
The next morning, Havel showed Nadia a record of several commissions from the foundry’s earlier years.
There were descriptions of defects detected at different stages of production. Several objects had required further work. One had been rejected entirely and replaced. Other records concerned achievements the foundry continued to regard with considerable pride.
Nadia examined a drawing signed by Havel himself.
A note beside it described a failed test.
“What happened?”
He told her.
“Did you know it would fail?”
“No.”
“Did they tell you why?”
“Eventually.”
He laughed.
Nadia had acquired much of her understanding of his abilities by watching him undertake tasks he already knew how to undertake.
She rarely saw the years during which he learned to recognize the problems that now appeared straightforward to him.
He was not suggesting that the records made every mistake acceptable. The foundry depended on careful work, and there were consequences when its products did not meet the requirements.
He was suggesting that an assessment was an opportunity to obtain information.
In the absence of such assessments, some defects would only be discovered after an object was installed.
That would be a rather worse arrangement.
Nadia remembered the bridge inspector in The Bridge of Temporary Names, who had been treating uncertainty in one part of his life as though he ought to possess knowledge he accepted he could not possess in another.
She knew how to investigate a question when it belonged to a drawing.
She was considerably less willing to accept incomplete information when the question concerned her.
Havel asked whether she wanted to continue leading the investigation within the agreed responsibilities.
She said yes.
Then she admitted that she was frightened.
“That’s understandable,” he replied.
He went back to the workshop.
The offer remained open.
The investigation took another four days.
The specialists identified an irregularity that appeared to account for the additional vibration. After reviewing the relevant measurements and the available options, they concluded that the bell could undergo carefully supervised correction within the limits agreed for the commission.
They documented the proposed work.
Nadia helped coordinate the arrangements and discussed the revised schedule with the people responsible for delivering the bell.
The date of the unveiling would need to change.
She had dreaded making that call.
The representative at Merrow was disappointed.
Nadia explained what could be established, what remained uncertain and when she expected to provide further information.
The representative asked several questions.
She answered the ones she could.
They agreed that the installation arrangements would be reviewed once the assessments were complete.
After the call, Nadia sat at her desk.
The conversation had not been pleasant.
It had also not produced the collapse of her career.
She wrote a note of the matters agreed.
Then she went to help Selim find a document.
During the following days, she occasionally became so anxious about the next test that she found it difficult to concentrate.
She began speaking to a counselor through a service she had been considering contacting for some time. Her doubts had affected her sleep and her willingness to pursue opportunities she wanted.
The conversations did not establish that every concern she experienced was unfounded.
They helped her recognize patterns in how she assessed mistakes, success and uncertainty.
Nadia discovered that she often expected herself to answer questions without the assistance she would recommend that a colleague obtain.
She was interested in finding out why.
When the second test took place, the courtyard was empty except for the people involved in the assessment.
Nadia listened.
The sound was different.
The relevant specialists completed their measurements and reviewed the result against the agreed requirements. There were further checks to undertake before the bell could be accepted.
Nadia resisted the temptation to decide what the entire test meant from the first expression on Havel’s face.
She asked about the findings.
They told her.
The bell met the relevant requirements.
She sat down.
Selim laughed.
“You’re allowed to smile.”
She smiled.
There were things she wanted to discuss about the work. There were aspects of the process that they might improve on a future commission. The team prepared a record of what had been learned and considered ways to identify comparable problems earlier.
Nadia contributed several observations.
Some of them were accepted.
One proved less useful than she imagined.
They discussed it.
She found herself enjoying the discussion.
She remembered the mapmaker in The Cartographer of Quiet Streets, who had experienced an ordinary correction as an occasion on which she needed to defend her entire competence.
Nadia’s circumstances were different. She nevertheless recognized the distinction between addressing a particular problem and making a judgment about everything a person was capable of doing.
She was beginning to make that distinction more often.
She was especially pleased when another colleague disagreed with her about the proposed change to a record and she was able to ask why without first apologizing.
The bell was installed at Merrow after the necessary approvals and arrangements were completed.
On the day of the unveiling, Nadia stood beside Ilya in the market square.
Sorin was selling apples.
He waved.
There was a brief speech from a municipal representative, followed by a longer speech from another representative who appeared to regard brevity as a regrettable feature of the first.
Eventually the bell rang.
From where Nadia stood, the sound was a little different from the one she had heard in the courtyard.
It traveled above the shops and returned faintly from the buildings on the far side of the square.
Several people looked up.
Sorin continued arranging his apples.
Ilya smiled.
Nadia was delighted.
She also heard something about the note that made her wonder how a slightly different profile might have sounded.
She laughed at herself.
She could be interested in that question without deciding that the bell had failed.
Later, Havel asked whether she would consider supervising another commission.
Her first impulse was to say she needed more experience.
She considered the actual requirements of the proposed work instead.
She asked several questions.
Then she said yes, provided the usual arrangements for supervision and specialist support were in place.
She thought of the man in The Island of Small Signals, who had learned that the things he feared might happen during an ordinary conversation were not necessarily facts about the person with whom he was speaking.
A similar distinction mattered to her.
The fact that she could imagine failing did not establish that she would fail.
The fact that she succeeded did not mean she would never need assistance.
She would need to listen to both possibilities without allowing either to answer every question in advance.
Years later, an apprentice brought Nadia a drawing.
A dimension was missing.
The apprentice noticed after handing it over and began apologizing.
Nadia looked at the drawing.
“Can you find the dimension?”
“Yes.”
“Good.”
The apprentice remained standing beside her desk.
“Do you want me to do another one?”
“After you’ve finished this.”
The young woman smiled and went away.
Nadia opened a book that had stood on her shelf for many years.
An unfinished explanation is not an unworthy question.
She thought of Mrs. Venn and the children who laughed during the presentation about sound.
She understood now that self-doubt could develop in many different ways. A painful experience, an expectation of perfection, a fear of being judged, or a tendency to notice weaknesses while discounting achievements might all contribute. Some doubt was useful. It could encourage a person to seek information or reconsider a decision.
But doubt became less useful when it supplied an answer before the person had investigated the question.
Nadia still had difficult days.
She still sometimes worried that the next commission would reveal something she had not discovered about herself.
She had acquired a greater willingness to find out what the commission actually required.
Outside, the apprentice was carrying a corrected drawing toward the workshop.
Nadia went to meet her.
Somewhere in Merrow, the bell would ring at the end of market hours.
There would be people who heard it clearly and people who scarcely noticed.
She hoped it would continue doing its work for a long time.
There were other bells to make.
Editorial note: Original historical-style fiction. All characters, businesses, locations and events are invented; the foundry scenes are not technical instructions. Self-doubt may arise from past criticism, fear of failure, perfectionistic expectations, comparison or uncertainty about one’s abilities. It is not necessarily an accurate assessment of competence. Constructive feedback, realistic appraisal of evidence, learning opportunities and appropriate professional support may help when persistent doubt interferes with a person’s goals or daily functioning.



