What Does Loneliness Teach Us About Human Nature? The Room Where Echoes Waited

What does loneliness teach us about human nature? An archivist studying a room that retains echoes discovers the importance of ordinary companionship.

What Does Loneliness Teach Us About Human Nature? The Room Where Echoes Waited

The room repeated the sound of a spoon falling onto a plate, although nothing had been dropped there for twenty-three years.

Ada stopped in the doorway.

A moment later, she heard a woman laugh.

Neither sound was particularly remarkable in a building devoted to the preservation of echoes. What made these two unusual was their proximity. The woman seemed to laugh in response to the falling spoon.

Ada made a note.

Outside the room, her colleague Tomas was pushing a trolley containing six boxes of recording equipment.

“Find anything?”

“A conversation, possibly.”

He looked inside.

The room contained a table, two chairs and a window opening onto a narrow garden. It had been removed from a house demolished when the eastern railway was extended. The city’s museum had reconstructed it using salvaged materials.

Something about those materials retained the echoes of sounds produced in their vicinity. Nobody entirely understood the phenomenon, although several researchers had spent considerable portions of their careers attempting to explain it.

The echoes occurred at irregular intervals.

Sometimes they were barely audible.

Sometimes they made visitors turn toward a doorway expecting somebody to enter.

Ada had been asked to document them before the room opened to the public.

She waited.

The spoon fell again.

The woman laughed.

Then a voice said, “Don’t get up. I’ll find another one.”

Ada smiled.

She had spent most of the previous evening sitting alone at her own kitchen table.

She wrote down the sentence.

It was the first time a sound in the museum had made her wish that she could be part of its history.


Ada was forty-four and had lived in the city for eighteen years. She knew the names of many of its streets and a surprising number of its inhabitants.

She had worked in two libraries, a municipal archive and the museum. She regularly bought vegetables from a man who remembered her preferences remarkably well, considering how often he attempted to sell her something else.

She went to concerts. She spoke to her brother on the telephone. She was on friendly terms with the people in the apartments on either side of hers.

If asked to describe her life, she would have found it difficult to identify anything particularly tragic about it.

The difficulty was that most of her acquaintances belonged to different parts of her day.

The man who sold vegetables did not know that she was worried about her brother’s employment. The colleagues with whom she discussed historical records had never seen the little garden she had attempted to establish on her balcony.

Her neighbor sometimes brought in a parcel addressed to her. They exchanged several pleasant sentences and went back into their respective homes.

She liked these people.

She was also beginning to notice how often she experienced something she wanted to tell somebody and could not immediately think of the person to whom she wanted to tell it.

The feeling was different from the desire for conversation.

There were evenings when she deliberately went somewhere busy. She listened to music, ordered food or walked through streets where shops remained open.

Returning home afterward did not always feel better.

Sometimes the contrast made the apartment seem particularly quiet.

She had been reading a story about a retired dispatcher in The Apartment Above the Last Stop. His daily encounters with people had changed when he retired, and the loss of his familiar routines helped him recognize what he missed.

Ada had not retired.

Her routines were almost exactly as they had always been.

She wondered whether she had been expecting them to provide something they had never quite been designed to provide.


The room had belonged to a woman named Iona Ferris.

She lived in the house for thirty-one years with her sister Miriam, who worked as a bookkeeper. The two women took in lodgers at different times. During one period, a young man studying architecture occupied the upstairs room. Later a cousin and her daughter lived there for several months.

The museum possessed a collection of photographs, several of which showed the room.

It was smaller than Ada had imagined.

There were curtains with a floral pattern, a little fireplace and a cabinet containing plates. One corner was usually occupied by a chair of a particularly unpleasant shade of green.

Ada began making a record of the sounds.

There was the spoon and the laughter.

There was a door closing.

There were fragments of discussion about bread, rain, a missing glove and someone who had apparently become tired of being told what to do with his hair.

Several voices recurred.

She could not always distinguish them from one another.

She enjoyed working at the table with a notebook open, waiting for the next sound.

One afternoon, the room repeated three notes of a song, followed by a man’s voice.

“Again.”

A child attempted the notes.

“Better.”

Ada wrote down the sequence.

Then she listened to the room for another forty minutes without hearing anything at all.

She became interested in the nature of the domestic life that the echoes seemed to suggest.

Nobody appeared to be making a particularly impressive speech.

Nobody was describing an event of great historical importance.

They were returning to subjects, interrupting each other, fetching things and laughing.

Ada realized how seldom the museum acquired records of a person saying something that mattered principally because another person was there to hear it.

There was no obvious reason to preserve the sound of a falling spoon.

She was very glad that somebody had.


At university, Ada had shared a house with three other students.

They were different from one another in quite considerable ways. One rarely washed a plate. Another insisted on buying vegetables without having decided what she intended to do with them.

Ada occasionally found the other inhabitants almost intolerable.

She also found it difficult to remember being lonely in that house.

There were people who wanted to hear whether she had enjoyed a lecture. There were people who would notice that she had stayed in her room all afternoon. Sometimes she would enter the kitchen and find that somebody had made enough soup for another person.

After graduation, their lives developed in different directions.

Ada moved to the city. One friend moved overseas. Another began working unpredictable hours. The third married and became the parent of two children.

They saw each other at increasingly irregular intervals.

Nobody had done anything especially wrong.

Ada still exchanged messages with two of them.

She sometimes composed a long account of something that happened at work, then removed most of the details because she could not imagine why a person who had never visited the museum would want to hear them.

The shorter message seemed more appropriate.

It also contained considerably less of her life.

One day she received a photograph from her former housemate Nell. It showed an extraordinarily unsuccessful birthday cake.

Ada laughed.

She sent a photograph of an equally unsuccessful plant.

They exchanged several messages.

Then each returned to the circumstances in which she presently lived.

Ada did not want to return to the house they had shared. She was quite attached to having a kitchen in which no one left dirty plates in the sink.

She missed the accumulating knowledge that made those friends able to understand a joke before she had explained it.

She wanted something about that closeness without necessarily wanting the circumstances in which it developed.

She did not know how to ask for it.


The museum’s exhibition designer, Leif, stopped by the room one afternoon.

He had been examining the arrangement of the artifacts and was concerned that visitors might be required to remain in the space for too long before experiencing an echo.

Ada explained that the phenomenon was unpredictable.

He nodded.

“What if we have some recorded examples?”

They discussed ways to distinguish the recordings from the sounds that occurred in the room itself.

Then Leif sat down.

He asked whether the spoon and laughter had been recorded.

Ada played him the sequence.

He smiled.

“Sounds like my aunt.”

“Was she called Iona?”

“No, she dropped a lot of things.”

Ada laughed.

He told her about the aunt, who lived in a little coastal town and had recently begun forgetting the names of certain objects. He visited whenever he could. Sometimes they talked. Sometimes they sat together watching the boats.

Ada asked what kind of work the aunt had done.

He told her.

Then he asked whether she wanted to get coffee after the meeting the following day.

“Yes.”

She had almost said that she needed to look at some records.

There were always records she could look at.

Instead she went.

They spoke about the museum, the town at the coast and a collection of photographs Leif had recently found in his father’s house. Ada described the garden on her balcony.

He asked what she was growing.

“Mostly evidence that I shouldn’t be growing things.”

He laughed.

When she returned home, she remembered the conversation several times.

She was surprised by how much pleasure she had found in sharing information that nobody had required her to provide.


The echoes changed in November.

For several days, between the familiar sounds of the spoon and the mysterious song, a voice repeated the words, “Is anybody there?”

The voice was quiet.

Ada listened carefully.

There was no audible answer.

She began wondering whether the room’s history had been less agreeable than the earlier sounds suggested.

Perhaps Iona had been ill. Perhaps someone had left the house. Perhaps a person who was expecting another to return had found herself waiting for a particularly long time.

The room offered no further evidence.

Tomas listened to the recording.

“It could be somebody at the front door.”

Ada looked at him.

“Or somebody looking for a person upstairs.”

“Yes.”

She did not want the sound to be a question asked by somebody at the front door.

She had already imagined a woman sitting at the table, calling into a house that had become unexpectedly empty.

Tomas replayed it.

“We don’t know.”

Ada sighed.

“I know.”

She remembered the archivist in The Violin Beneath the Floor, who had struggled to distinguish what surviving objects revealed from the story she wanted them to tell.

Ada was beginning to recognize a similar difficulty in her own work.

She had wanted the room to be proof that other people had once occupied the kind of life she missed.

Now she wanted its unanswered question to establish that somebody else had experienced her particular form of sadness.

The same scraps of sound had become evidence of entirely different things because her own circumstances had changed.

She returned to the documentation.

For the exhibition, the museum would need to distinguish what could be heard from what could reasonably be established about it.

The distinction seemed important for other reasons as well.


A woman named Saba contacted the museum in December.

Iona had been her great-aunt. She remembered visiting the house as a child.

Ada arranged to meet her.

Saba arrived carrying photographs and a little book of handwritten recipes. She was sixty-eight, wore a green coat and remembered the location of the cabinet almost immediately.

“The plates were here.”

Ada showed her the reconstructed room.

Saba looked around.

“Well, that’s strange.”

They sat at the table.

Saba described the people she remembered.

Iona enjoyed company, she said, but Miriam occasionally preferred to have the house to herself. They had arguments about lodgers and disagreed rather strongly about the ownership of a small cupboard.

There were lively evenings.

There were quiet ones.

Iona experienced a long period of grief after a close friend died. Miriam sometimes worried about her sister, but did not always know what kind of attention she wanted.

Saba remembered Iona asking her to come for tea.

She had enjoyed those visits.

Years later she discovered that her aunt had particularly looked forward to them.

“She always seemed to have people around.”

Ada nodded.

Saba smiled.

“People being around isn’t quite the same as having somebody you want to be around.”

They listened to several of the echoes.

Saba thought the laugh might have belonged to Miriam.

She could not be certain.

When Ada played the unanswered question, Saba laughed.

“That sounds like my father. He was forever arriving without his key.”

Ada laughed too.

They agreed that neither identification could be regarded as established.

Saba looked at the room for a while.

Then she said she hoped the exhibition would make people remember some of the ordinary sounds of the places they had lived.

The room did not need to have been a particularly happy home in order to contain things worth remembering.

Ada thanked her.

After Saba went away, Ada sat at the table alone.

She was glad that the house had turned out to contain a life rather than an answer to her own.


Leif and Ada began getting coffee most Thursdays.

Some weeks one was unavailable.

Sometimes they had lunch instead.

They gradually became friends.

Ada also telephoned Nell and asked whether she wanted to arrange a longer conversation.

Nell did.

During the call, Ada described the echoes, the exhibition and the peculiar properties of the room.

Nell listened.

Then she told Ada about the difficulty of making new friends after changing jobs.

She had known many people at her previous workplace. At the new one, the people were friendly, but she rarely felt sufficiently comfortable to tell them about the things that were troubling her.

Ada was surprised.

She had assumed that Nell’s busy household and frequent photographs reflected an abundance of companionship.

Nell laughed.

“Sometimes I’d like to talk to somebody who isn’t asking where their shoes are.”

They spoke for nearly two hours.

Afterward, Ada realized that she had spent years limiting her accounts of her circumstances partly because she did not want to burden somebody whose life appeared full.

Nell had been doing something similar.

They decided to speak more regularly.

Neither promised that they would always be available.

Both liked the idea of hearing more about the things that happened between their conversations.

Ada thought of the sister in The Winter of the Paper Cranes, whose family had withheld information about their wishes while attempting to protect one another.

It was possible, she reflected, to become so eager to respect somebody else’s busy life that one ceased to offer her an opportunity to participate in one’s own.

This did not mean every person she contacted would want a close friendship.

It did mean she could sometimes ask.


The city library ran an evening reading group.

Ada passed notices advertising it for nearly a year before attending a meeting.

The first discussion concerned a novel she had not particularly enjoyed.

A woman beside her had disliked the same book for completely different reasons.

They argued amiably.

At the end of the evening, Ada asked whether the woman usually attended.

She did.

Ada went back the following month.

Several meetings passed before they began speaking about matters other than the books.

There were people she found particularly interesting and people with whom she had very little in common.

She did not regard the existence of the second group as evidence that the meetings were unsuccessful.

One member, an engineer named Kamal, suggested visiting an exhibition together. Four people agreed to go.

They spent an afternoon looking at paintings, then decided to buy tea.

Ada discovered she liked the experience of being one member of a group that met for a reason neither entirely professional nor entirely personal.

The arrangement did not immediately provide the depth of friendship she sometimes wanted.

It provided opportunities from which something might develop.

She remembered the gardener in The Garden With a Gate, who had needed to recognize that her own needs could deserve a place in the arrangements she made.

Ada had often regarded the desire for closer companionship as a rather embarrassing thing to admit.

She was beginning to regard it as information.

There were things she might do in response.

Some would be available to her and some would not.

It did not mean that she had failed to become sufficiently independent.


The exhibition opened in spring.

Visitors could sit in the reconstructed room and listen. There were recorded examples available, alongside an explanation of what the museum knew and what remained uncertain.

Ada watched a man enter with his teenage daughter.

They sat down.

Nothing happened for several minutes.

The daughter became impatient.

Then the spoon fell.

The woman laughed.

The man looked toward the cabinet.

“My gran had a plate like that.”

His daughter asked about her.

He told her a story.

Ada listened from the corridor.

Later a visitor asked whether the museum could obtain an echo from her former home.

No, Ada explained. The phenomenon was rare, poorly understood and could not reliably be reproduced.

The woman looked disappointed.

Then she described how her son used to run down the stairs on Saturday mornings. She remembered the peculiar rhythm of his feet.

Ada listened.

The woman thanked her and left.

It occurred to Ada that the visitor had brought the sound with her.

The museum had not been required to supply it.

That evening Ada and Leif went for a meal. They discussed the exhibition, the people who had visited and an extraordinarily difficult window in another display.

When she arrived home, she called her brother.

He answered.

She asked how he was.

They talked for some time.

Afterward she stood at the balcony door.

The plants had mostly survived the winter.

She went outside to water them.


A year later, the echoes became less frequent.

The museum continued investigating the phenomenon. Nobody knew whether the room would eventually cease to produce sounds altogether.

Ada was sad about the possibility.

She had become fond of the laughter, the song and even the unanswered question.

On a particularly quiet afternoon she sat at the table while Tomas checked equipment in the corridor.

“Coffee?” he called.

“Yes.”

She got up.

They went downstairs.

Ada had discovered that loneliness could teach people something about the importance of being known, the difference between contact and connection, and the vulnerability involved in allowing others to learn about the parts of their lives that were neither impressive nor especially useful.

People needed different quantities and kinds of companionship. Some preferred considerable solitude. Some had access to the relationships they wanted and some encountered barriers that no single decision could remove.

Her own life had become richer in several ordinary ways.

She did not have a person with whom she shared every part of it.

She had people to whom she could tell different things.

She still sometimes went home feeling lonely.

She was less inclined to regard the feeling as evidence that nobody would ever want to hear from her.

At the café Tomas dropped a spoon.

It struck the edge of his plate, landed on the floor and disappeared beneath the table.

Ada laughed.

He looked at her.

“Don’t get up. I’ll find another one.”

For a moment she thought about the room upstairs.

Then she went back to the conversation they were having.

Editorial note: Original magical-realist fiction. The characters, institutions, locations and supernatural phenomenon are invented. Loneliness can reveal the human need for meaningful connection, recognition and belonging. It is not identical to being alone, and people differ in the relationships and degree of solitude they prefer. Social barriers, life transitions, loss and fear of rejection can affect opportunities for connection. Repeated contact and appropriate support may help, though persistent distress can warrant guidance from a qualified health professional.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top