Why Do People Struggle With Healthy Boundaries? The Doorbell at Seven

Why do people struggle with healthy boundaries? A dependable sister discovers that caring for her family need not mean surrendering the right to make her own plans.

Why Do People Struggle With Healthy Boundaries? The Doorbell at Seven

At seven on a Sunday morning, the doorbell rang.

Nadia knew who it was before she reached the hallway. Her brother Martin had developed the habit of arriving with a loaf of bread whenever he wanted something that might otherwise require a telephone call.

She opened the door.

He held up a paper bag.

“Fresh.”

She smiled.

“What do you need?”

He looked offended.

“Can’t a man bring his sister some bread?”

“He can. What do you need?”

There was a pause.

“The children.”

She looked beyond him. His two daughters were sitting in the car, waving at her through the open window.

Martin explained that a colleague had been unable to cover a shift. He had intended to ask Nadia the previous evening, but had come home late and forgotten.

“Just until lunchtime.”

Nadia was supposed to be taking a train at eight twenty. In a town on the coast, a woman called Ruth was waiting for her to arrive with a camera, two sandwiches and a pair of boots.

They had planned the outing for three weeks.

Martin looked at his watch.

“Is that all right?”

Behind Nadia, the kettle clicked off.

She thought of the train.

Then she heard herself say yes.

By eight twenty, she was cutting toast into small triangles while her nieces argued about which plate belonged to whom.

At eight twenty-three, Ruth sent a message.

Missed you at the station. Everything okay?

Nadia began typing an explanation.

Then she deleted it.

She was not quite sure how to explain an emergency that had happened to somebody else and become hers before she had finished making tea.


Nadia had been the reliable person in her family for so long that reliability no longer seemed to them like something she did.

It was something she was.

When her mother needed a lift, she called Nadia. When Martin’s printer stopped working, he brought it to Nadia. When their cousin Sophie was organizing a birthday dinner, she asked Nadia to find a suitable restaurant, contact the guests and establish whether the birthday person’s new partner ate fish.

Nadia was good at all these things.

She worked as the administrator of a small architectural practice. Her colleagues appreciated her ability to arrange appointments, manage records and remember details that other people had forgotten.

She genuinely enjoyed helping people.

She also enjoyed photography, walking, reading books with excessively long titles and spending the occasional afternoon in a place where nobody knew she owned a car.

These interests were becoming difficult to maintain.

On the previous Tuesday, she had left work at six and driven directly to her mother’s house to move a cabinet. On Wednesday, she helped Martin complete a form. On Thursday, Sophie telephoned while she was preparing supper and asked whether she could collect a parcel the following morning.

Each request was fairly small.

Together, they occupied most of the available spaces in her week.

She was thirty-nine, lived alone and had no children. Several relatives appeared to regard these facts as evidence that she possessed more hours than they did.

Nadia had occasionally attempted to correct this impression.

The conversations usually ended with somebody explaining why the particular favor they were asking would not take very long.

Most did not.

The difficulty was not the duration of any single request.

It was her growing inability to decide what happened to the hours between them.


When she was sixteen, her father became seriously ill.

For a period, the household depended on a complicated arrangement of medical appointments, assistance from relatives and the efforts of her mother, Ellen, who was also working part-time.

Nadia helped with shopping and meals. She collected Martin from school. She learned how to make several simple dishes and became unusually competent at deciding whether a household had enough milk.

Her father eventually recovered sufficiently to return to some of his previous activities.

The arrangements changed.

Nadia continued helping.

There was nothing inherently unreasonable about the responsibilities she had taken on. The family was grateful, and several relatives had done a great deal for her as well.

What became more difficult to recognize was that the circumstances under which she had acquired these habits no longer existed.

At university, she continued returning home frequently. When she began working, she arranged her holidays around family events. Occasionally she was disappointed when somebody failed to offer a similar degree of assistance.

She did not usually say so.

She had developed a particularly elaborate method of demonstrating that she needed nothing: she waited until she urgently needed something, then became distressed that nobody had noticed.

Ruth, who worked with her at the architectural practice, had once described this arrangement as an inefficient form of telepathy.

Nadia laughed.

She recognized herself in the description.

Recognition had not yet made it easier to do anything differently.


On Monday morning, Ruth placed a photograph on Nadia’s desk.

It showed a line of fishing boats beneath a remarkable sky.

“Thought you’d like it.”

Nadia examined the photograph.

She was delighted by it.

She also felt a little angry.

Ruth had gone to the coast without her, as they had agreed she should if Nadia could not make the journey.

“Beautiful,” Nadia said.

“Was a lovely day.”

Nadia put the photograph down.

Ruth asked what happened.

She explained.

“Did you tell Martin you had plans?”

“No.”

“Why not?”

Nadia began describing Martin’s work situation.

Ruth listened.

Then she asked the question again.

Nadia looked toward the window.

“He was already outside.”

“Right.”

“And the girls were there.”

“Right.”

She laughed unhappily.

“I suppose I didn’t want to disappoint anybody.”

Ruth thought for a moment.

“You disappointed me.”

Nadia looked at her.

Ruth smiled.

“Not in a catastrophic way. But I was looking forward to going with you. You were looking forward to it too.”

Nadia had considered disappointing her brother. She had considered disappointing her nieces. For some reason, she had treated disappointing Ruth as a consequence that required less attention.

She remembered the groom in The Name on the Guest List, who had spent years avoiding disagreements with his mother while creating difficulties for the person he believed he was protecting.

He had discovered that avoiding one person’s discomfort could mean transferring it to somebody else.

Perhaps she had been doing something similar.

In this case, some of the discomfort had been transferred to herself.

She apologized to Ruth.

Then they arranged another outing.


The opportunity to behave differently arrived on Wednesday.

Her mother telephoned.

She wanted to visit a garden center on Saturday. Nadia usually drove her there.

“Can you collect me at ten?”

Nadia had arranged to attend a photography workshop at eleven.

She looked at her calendar.

“I can’t on Saturday morning.”

There was a pause.

“Why?”

“I’ve got something booked.”

“Oh.”

Her mother asked whether she could make it later in the day.

Nadia could.

They agreed to go at four.

The entire conversation lasted less than two minutes.

Nadia spent another twenty minutes thinking about it.

She wondered whether her mother was upset. She wondered whether she ought to have explained the workshop. She considered telephoning again to make sure their arrangement was satisfactory.

Then she noticed that she had responded to an ordinary scheduling question as though she had announced that she was leaving the country.

On Saturday, she attended the workshop.

It was rather good.

At four, she collected her mother.

Ellen was wearing a green coat and wanted to buy a particular variety of lavender.

They spent an enjoyable hour at the garden center.

As Nadia drove home, she realized her mother had not mentioned the fact that she had been unavailable earlier.

She felt relieved.

Then she felt a little foolish.

She had been anticipating an argument that did not occur.


Not all the conversations went as easily.

The following week Martin asked whether she could collect his daughters from school on Friday.

She had agreed to meet a friend after work.

She explained that she was unavailable.

Martin sounded surprised.

“Can you move it?”

“No.”

“It’s only for an hour.”

“I know.”

He told her that arranging somebody else would be difficult.

She believed him.

She also knew that if she agreed to rearrange the meeting, she would be doing something she did not want to do because her own plans were apparently the easiest ones to change.

She told him she hoped he could find an arrangement.

For a moment he was quiet.

Then he said, “You’ve been a bit funny lately.”

She felt an immediate urge to demonstrate that she was the same person he had always known.

She nearly offered to collect the children after all.

Instead she asked what he meant.

“Normally you don’t mind.”

She thought of the many occasions on which she had said she did not mind while privately feeling quite differently.

“Sometimes I do mind.”

He gave a short laugh.

“All right.”

The call ended.

Nadia went to the kitchen.

She felt awful.

A boundary, she had imagined, would produce a sensation of considerable personal freedom. This one had produced something much closer to the feeling she experienced after making an error at work.

She took down a cup.

She remembered the woman in The Table With One Extra Leaf, who had declined a family gathering rather than accept an exclusion she considered unfair.

The decision had not made the woman immediately happy.

Nadia understood why.

A person could make a choice for a good reason and still dislike the effect it had on a relationship.

She made tea.

Then she carried on with her evening.


Martin found another person to collect the girls on Friday.

He told Nadia this in a message containing no additional information.

She replied that she was glad.

The next Sunday, he arrived without warning.

This time there was no bread.

He wanted help assembling a desk in the children’s bedroom. The manufacturer had supplied several items whose purpose he could not identify.

Nadia had set aside the morning to sort photographs.

She told him she could help on Tuesday evening, not today.

He looked into the hallway.

“You’re not going anywhere.”

“No.”

“Then why can’t you?”

She felt a sudden anger.

She had spent years allowing other people to determine whether the things she wanted to do counted as commitments.

“I’ve made plans.”

“What plans?”

“My own.”

He stared at her.

For several seconds she wanted to say something considerably less polite.

Instead she repeated that she could help on Tuesday if it suited him.

Martin left.

Nadia closed the door and returned to the photographs.

For twenty minutes she could not concentrate.

She had wanted the morning to herself. Now it was partly occupied by the conversation she had just had.

She understood that setting a limit did not guarantee the immediate enjoyment of whatever the limit was intended to protect.

She would need practice at both things: saying what she was available for, and allowing herself to use the time that remained.

Eventually she began arranging the photographs.

By noon she had made several decisions about a small exhibition she hoped to submit work to.

She was pleased with the result.

She did not require Martin to be pleased with it too.


Her mother invited her to dinner in March.

Martin was there.

So were the girls, who were making an extraordinary amount of noise with a collection of plastic animals.

After supper Ellen asked whether Nadia was unhappy about something.

Nadia looked at her brother.

Then she explained that she had been feeling tired and resentful. She wanted to spend some of her free time on her own interests. She was trying to be clearer about what she could and could not offer.

Ellen looked troubled.

“You could have told us.”

“Yes.”

“Why didn’t you?”

Nadia considered this.

There had been occasions when she tried to explain. There had also been occasions when she accepted requests without saying that she would rather not.

She told them both things.

Martin said he had never intended to take advantage of her.

She believed him.

She also told him that his intentions did not determine how much time she was able to give.

He looked at his plate.

“It’s difficult with the children.”

“I know.”

She asked whether they could discuss arrangements in advance, rather than assume she could provide care whenever another plan fell through.

There were times, she said, when she would be delighted to have the girls.

She wanted those times to be chosen, not discovered on a Sunday morning when she opened the door.

Ellen asked what would happen if there was a genuine emergency.

Nadia smiled.

“Then we’ll deal with a genuine emergency.”

They discussed the distinction.

Not every unexpected inconvenience was an emergency. Not every request had to be refused because it arrived unexpectedly. They could still help one another.

She wanted the possibility of saying no to be part of the arrangement.

For a while Martin appeared irritated.

Then one of the girls brought him a plastic horse and asked him to repair its leg.

He examined it.

“I don’t think I can fix this.”

She accepted that explanation and went to find another animal.

Nadia nearly laughed.

The adults continued talking.


There were habits she had developed outside the family too.

At work, a colleague often brought her documents requiring attention immediately before she was due to leave. She usually stayed late to complete them.

One afternoon she explained that she had finished the tasks agreed for that day and would review the additional documents in the morning, unless their manager needed to reprioritize the work.

The colleague looked disappointed.

Then he took the documents back.

At home, Nadia began noticing how often she apologized before expressing a preference.

Sorry, I’d rather go somewhere else.

Sorry, I can’t stay that late.

Sorry, I don’t really want to discuss that.

Sometimes an apology was appropriate. Sometimes she had inconvenienced somebody or made an error. But she had begun adding apologies to sentences describing ordinary choices, as though the choices themselves required forgiveness.

She did not want to become insensitive.

She wanted to distinguish being considerate from presenting every preference as a small offense.

Ruth invited her to see an exhibition.

Nadia said she would rather visit a different one.

Ruth readily agreed.

They went.

On the way home, Nadia thought of the friends in The Weather Inside the Tent, whose increasing closeness had accidentally introduced expectations neither had agreed to.

A good relationship did not require two people to be available to each other at every moment.

She had known this when she thought about other people’s lives.

She was learning to include her own life in the same understanding.


In early summer, Martin’s circumstances changed.

He arranged a more predictable working schedule, though there were still occasional difficulties. Ellen offered to collect the girls on certain afternoons, and he discussed other options with their mother.

Nadia agreed to spend one Saturday a month with them.

She particularly enjoyed those Saturdays.

On the first, they went to a museum. On the second, they made a cake whose decoration was ambitious and whose structural integrity was questionable.

She returned the girls home at the agreed time.

Martin thanked her.

Then he asked whether she would be able to stay for supper.

She looked at her watch.

That evening she had no particular plans.

“Yes,” she said.

She meant it.

During supper, Martin told her that he had been rather annoyed when she first started declining his requests.

She laughed.

“I noticed.”

He smiled.

“I think I was used to not having to work it out.”

She nodded.

He apologized for arriving without asking.

She thanked him.

They discussed the new arrangements.

It did not mean that their relationship would never become difficult again. He would occasionally ask for something she could not give. She would occasionally agree to something and later wish she had considered it more carefully.

But she was becoming better at recognizing the difference between helping and making herself responsible for preventing every difficulty in his life.

She remembered the woman who learned to let birds return to the wild in The Birds We Cannot Keep. Care did not require a person to retain control of everything that happened to somebody they loved.

Nor did it require the person offering care to become permanently available.

Martin brought out the cake.

The girls inspected it with considerable pride.

Nadia had another slice.


The photography exhibition opened in September.

Nadia contributed six images of the coast, including one taken on the second outing she and Ruth eventually made together.

Ellen attended.

Martin came with the girls.

They stood in front of Nadia’s photographs and spoke about them, occasionally asking questions she was pleased to answer.

Her mother particularly liked a picture of an empty bench overlooking the sea.

“It’s very peaceful.”

“Yes.”

“Where is it?”

Nadia told her.

“We could go sometime.”

“I’d like that.”

She smiled.

Then she suggested a date on which she was available.

They agreed.

There had been a time when she would have taken the invitation as an obligation to arrange the outing immediately, before her mother had an opportunity to become disappointed.

Now it was simply a pleasant possibility.

The following Sunday, at seven in the morning, the doorbell did not ring.

At eight, Martin sent a message asking whether she was free for coffee later.

She was planning to spend the afternoon working on photographs.

She suggested meeting on Wednesday.

He said Wednesday was fine.

Nadia made breakfast.

She opened the curtains.

The day had not acquired its value by being empty of other people’s needs. There would be occasions when she wanted to help and occasions when she could not. People she loved would continue to have difficulties that she could not solve.

She would sometimes be disappointed by their decisions, and they would sometimes be disappointed by hers.

She no longer believed that disappointment was sufficient evidence that a relationship was failing.

She put her camera in its bag.

At nine, she left the house.

There was a place beside the river where the light would be particularly interesting that morning.

She had promised herself she would go.

This time, she did.

Editorial note: Original fiction. All characters, places and events are fictional. People may struggle with healthy boundaries because of learned caretaking roles, fear of rejection, family expectations or uncertainty about how to express their needs. Boundaries describe what a person is willing or able to participate in; they are not a means of controlling others. Respectful, clear communication and realistic agreements may support relationships, although another person’s approval is not guaranteed. Where setting boundaries could expose someone to intimidation, violence or retaliation, safety planning and appropriate independent support take priority.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top