What Does Family Disapproval of Love Teach Us About Human Nature? The Orchard on Both Sides of the Wall

What does family disapproval of love teach us about human nature? Two neighbors fall in love across an orchard wall that has divided their families for decades.

What Does Family Disapproval of Love Teach Us About Human Nature? The Orchard on Both Sides of the Wall

The first apple fell on the wrong side of the wall.

It was a small, uneven fruit, yellow where the sun had reached it and green beneath the leaves. Mariam picked it up from the path, rubbed the dirt from its skin and put it in the basket she was carrying.

“That’s ours,” said a voice behind her.

She turned.

Her grandfather was standing beside the kitchen door.

“It’s on our side,” she said.

“The branch is on their side.”

She looked at the branch. It had grown over the wall during the summer. Several apples hung above the garden, apparently uninterested in who owned the ground beneath them.

“Shall I throw it back?”

Her grandfather frowned.

“Don’t be clever.”

Mariam placed the apple on the wall. A few moments later, a man appeared in the neighboring garden, reached up and took it.

“Thank you,” he called.

She recognized him.

Isaac Vale had returned to the village three weeks earlier. He was a horticulturist, the grandson of the woman her grandfather had not spoken to in thirty-six years.

Mariam was supposed to dislike him.

She had been finding this increasingly difficult.

The orchard had once belonged to one family.

In the years after the old farmhouse was divided into two properties, the orchard was divided as well. A stone wall ran between the houses and continued through the trees, taking several awkward turns before reaching the lane.

The ownership of the properties was properly recorded. The history of the disagreement between their occupants was considerably less clear.

According to Mariam’s grandfather, Hamid, the Vales had refused to honor an arrangement concerning a shared water supply.

According to Isaac’s grandmother, Joan, Hamid’s father had made an unreasonable demand when the old well stopped working.

There had been letters. There had been meetings. Someone had moved a gate without consulting someone else. A solicitor had been involved.

Nobody in the younger generation had seen all the documents.

Nevertheless, Mariam could remember a time when her grandfather objected to her accepting a glass of lemonade from a child who lived next door.

She had been eight.

The child had been Isaac.

He moved away with his parents not long afterward, and Mariam remained in the village. She studied civil engineering, worked in the city and returned several years later to help her mother establish a small business producing preserves from the family orchard.

She liked the village. She disliked the tendency of some of its inhabitants to regard a person born elsewhere as a visitor after thirty years.

Isaac returned because Joan was considering selling part of her land. He wanted to help her assess the condition of the orchard and understand what options might be available.

Mariam encountered him at a meeting of the local growers’ association.

They recognized each other.

“You owe me a glass of lemonade,” he said.

She laughed.

Their conversation lasted forty minutes.

On her way home, she found it amusing that the most substantial exchange she had ever had with a member of the Vale family had concerned soil drainage.

She did not mention it at supper.

The summer had been unusually dry.

Several trees in both orchards showed signs of stress. Mariam wanted to improve the irrigation arrangements on her family’s property, and Isaac was interested in how the neighboring land had been managed over the years.

They began exchanging information about their observations.

At first they met in public places: the growers’ association office, the market, the library. There was no reason not to meet. Their work overlapped. They were two people with a great deal to discuss.

One evening they went for coffee.

Isaac told her about the years he had spent working for a botanical garden. He described the difficulty of helping visitors understand why the older specimens could not all be kept alive indefinitely.

Mariam told him about a bridge she had helped assess, whose previous repairs had created problems that were not immediately visible.

They talked until the café closed.

Outside, he asked whether she would like to have dinner the following week.

“Yes,” she said.

She went home pleased.

Then, while making tea, she imagined telling her grandfather.

The pleasure diminished.

She was thirty-one years old, had lived independently for most of her twenties and was responsible for decisions involving considerable sums of money.

Yet the possibility of her grandfather’s disapproval could make her feel like the child who had accepted a glass of lemonade.

She found the persistence of this feeling interesting.

She also found it exhausting.

Her mother, Saira, was the first person she told.

They were preparing labels in the little building behind the farmhouse, where the preserves business operated. Saira was trying to determine whether an unfortunate crease in a label could be concealed by adjusting its position on the jar.

“I’m seeing Isaac Vale,” Mariam said.

Saira stopped.

“Seeing?”

“Going out with him.”

She put the jar down.

“Oh.”

Mariam waited.

Her mother asked how long it had been happening.

“Not long.”

“And you’ve thought about what your grandfather will say?”

“Of course.”

Saira looked out at the trees.

“Perhaps wait a little before telling him.”

“Why?”

“Until you know whether it’s serious.”

Mariam considered this.

There were reasonable reasons not to announce every romantic possibility immediately. She hadn’t told her mother about several dates she had been on in the city.

But she knew that the proposed delay had a particular purpose in this instance.

“If it’s serious,” she said, “will that make him more pleased?”

Saira smiled reluctantly.

“Probably not.”

She told Mariam about an afternoon many years earlier when Joan had helped her carry groceries home after she injured her ankle. Hamid found out and became angry.

Saira had been annoyed with him.

She had also been living in his house, with two small children, while her husband worked away for several weeks at a time. The easiest way to conduct the remainder of the week was not to argue.

She had chosen the easier way.

“I suppose we all became quite good at that,” she said.

Mariam remembered the family in The Table With One Extra Leaf, whose desire to avoid an uncomfortable dinner had depended upon asking one person to make an uncomfortable sacrifice.

“I’m not asking you to tell him for me,” she said.

Saira nodded.

They returned to the labels.

Isaac had already told Joan.

Her reaction was to ask whether Mariam liked gardening.

He told her that she liked some kinds of gardening.

“Good.”

Then, after a pause, she added, “Your grandfather wouldn’t have liked it.”

Isaac looked at her.

“Wouldn’t he?”

“No.”

She continued reading the newspaper.

He asked why.

“Because of the business with the water.”

“What actually happened?”

Joan folded the newspaper.

She told him the version he had heard during childhood. The original arrangement concerning the well was informal. When the pump failed, there was disagreement about who would pay for repairs and whether one household had used more water than the other.

The disagreement became entangled with other grievances.

Joan believed Hamid’s father had spoken to her husband in a humiliating way during a meeting.

Her husband refused to attend a second meeting.

Soon afterward, the two households established separate arrangements.

“Which of them was right?” Isaac asked.

Joan shook her head.

“I expect they both thought they were.”

He laughed.

She did not.

She remembered what it had been like to see her husband return from the meeting, angry and embarrassed. She remembered his sleeplessness while the letters were being exchanged and her own difficulty managing the household when every ordinary conversation ended in a description of what the neighbors had done.

To her, these memories were not an interesting historical puzzle.

They concerned somebody she had loved.

Isaac understood that now.

He also understood that he had inherited a collection of conclusions without having inherited the experiences that produced them.

He did not think he could reasonably be expected to live as though those experiences had been his own.

Hamid heard about the relationship at the market.

A man selling tools mentioned seeing Mariam and Isaac in a restaurant in town.

Hamid asked whether they had been discussing work.

The man shrugged.

“Looked like they were enjoying themselves.”

That evening, Hamid waited until Saira finished clearing the kitchen and asked Mariam to sit down.

“Is it true?”

She knew immediately what he meant.

“Yes.”

He looked toward the neighboring house.

“You know what those people are like.”

“Which people?”

“The Vales.”

“Isaac?”

“All of them.”

Mariam asked whether he had recently spoken to Isaac.

He said there was no reason to.

She asked whether he knew anything about Isaac’s conduct that concerned him.

Hamid looked offended.

He told her what his father had endured. He described the years during which his mother could not walk down the lane without remembering several unpleasant encounters.

He said the family had not forgotten.

Mariam listened.

She had heard some of these accounts before. Others were new.

She did not dismiss them.

Then she told him that Isaac had been a small child when the events occurred.

Hamid said she was being naive.

“People don’t change.”

“He hasn’t had to change. He wasn’t involved.”

Her grandfather stood up.

“Your grandmother would be ashamed.”

The sentence hurt more than anything else he had said.

Mariam’s grandmother had taught her to bake bread, encouraged her to apply for university and given her a collection of books when she moved away. She had been dead for eight years.

Mariam could not ask what she would think of Isaac.

She did not want her memory to become an instrument for deciding who could sit beside her at dinner.

She left the room.

For the following fortnight, Mariam and Isaac spoke less often.

She told him what had happened.

He was angry.

He suggested that her grandfather was being ridiculous.

Mariam immediately defended him.

Isaac looked surprised.

“I thought you agreed.”

“I do. About this.”

She tried to explain.

Her grandfather had helped her mother when Mariam’s father died. He had collected her from school, taught her to graft a branch and taken her to the hospital when she broke her wrist.

These things did not make his present behavior acceptable.

They did make it difficult to hear him described as though nothing else were true about him.

Isaac apologized.

Then he told her that he was not prepared to enter a relationship in which he would be treated as a representative of people he had scarcely known.

She understood.

They sat on a bench outside the library.

Mariam remembered the story of a wedding shaped by expectations nobody had explicitly agreed to. She had assumed much of the difficulty lay in the failure of two people to discuss their future.

Now she saw another possibility: two people might discuss their future carefully and still find that others had been discussing it for years.

She did not know whether she and Isaac would eventually marry.

She knew that deciding whether to continue seeing him was already difficult enough without asking the relationship to resolve a dispute that began before either of them was born.

They agreed to keep seeing each other.

They also agreed not to turn every meeting into a discussion of their families.

Isaac invited her to an exhibition the following Saturday.

She accepted.

They spent most of the afternoon arguing cheerfully about an unattractive sculpture.

In September, a storm damaged the upper section of the orchard wall.

Several stones fell onto the neighboring path. The damaged section could be seen from both houses.

Mariam advised her mother to keep people away from it until its condition had been appropriately assessed.

Joan asked Isaac to arrange a professional inspection.

The ownership and responsibilities relating to the wall needed clarification before permanent work could proceed. Copies of the relevant documents were obtained, the condition was assessed and an estimate prepared.

Hamid objected to the possibility of meeting Joan.

Saira told him that she was willing to handle the practical arrangements.

He said that was not necessary.

“Then you can handle them,” she said.

For the first time in several years, Mariam heard her mother speak to him in a tone she used with customers who were attempting to return a jar they had already emptied.

Hamid stared at her.

The following afternoon he attended a meeting at the growers’ association office. Joan was there. So were the people responsible for the properties and the surveyor advising them.

Mariam and Isaac attended only to discuss information relevant to the trees.

The meeting was not pleasant.

Hamid disagreed with Joan about a previous repair. Joan disagreed with him about a collection of stones removed several winters earlier.

The surveyor brought the conversation back to the damaged wall.

Eventually a practical plan was agreed, subject to the necessary permissions and documented arrangements.

Nobody reconciled.

Nobody apologized for the quarrel over the water.

But the meeting ended with the work able to proceed.

Joan put on her coat.

Hamid held the door open.

She thanked him.

Mariam found herself unexpectedly moved by the exchange.

She was also aware that there was no need to make it mean more than it did.

During the repair work, several old papers were found in a drawer at Joan’s house.

There were bills for parts, letters between the families and a handwritten note recording an agreement about the cost of maintaining the original well.

Joan offered to let Hamid see copies.

He accepted.

The papers did not settle the old dispute.

They established that both households had contributed to previous repairs. They also established that some of the events remembered by the families had occurred in a different order from the order in which they were usually described.

Hamid was particularly surprised by a letter his father had written.

It was polite.

In it, his father proposed a compromise that Hamid had always understood to have been rejected immediately. An attached note suggested that the compromise had in fact been considered for several weeks.

He read the letter again.

Saira made tea.

“Does this change anything?” she asked.

He looked at the page.

“I don’t know.”

She did not press him.

Mariam thought of the fictional keeper in The Garden of Glass Birds, who discovered how readily a community could turn an uncertain record into evidence of another person’s disloyalty.

The letters were real evidence.

But even real evidence had limits.

They could not establish what either family had felt during the years of the dispute. They could not tell Mariam whether her grandfather had ever considered speaking to Joan.

They could, however, unsettle the idea that the story everybody remembered was the only possible account of what had happened.

For a while Hamid appeared less certain.

Then he became angry again.

Change was not a straight path through the orchard.

In October, Isaac received an offer of work at a horticultural research center in another region.

He told Mariam during dinner.

She congratulated him.

Then she became quiet.

“How far?”

“Three hours, probably.”

She smiled.

“That’s going to be inconvenient.”

“Yes.”

They discussed the possibilities.

Mariam did not wish to abandon the preserves business, which she and her mother were developing. Isaac had spent several years hoping to find work of the kind being offered.

Neither wanted the relationship to become a reason for declining an opportunity before considering what it might involve.

They were not entirely sure what arrangements would suit them.

When Mariam told Saira, her mother asked whether this meant the relationship would end.

“No.”

“Your grandfather will be pleased.”

Mariam felt suddenly angry.

“I’m not trying to win something against him.”

Saira looked startled.

Mariam had come to realize that opposition from her family could become a source of pressure in both directions. At first she felt she ought to leave Isaac to keep the peace. Later she occasionally felt that leaving him would prove her grandfather right.

Both possibilities gave somebody else’s judgment an inappropriate place in her decision.

She remembered the friends in The Last Seat on the Night Train, who discovered that affection did not automatically resolve the practical differences between the futures they wanted.

She wanted to be with Isaac.

She also wanted to remain free to decide, in the future, whether their relationship was suitable for both of them.

She told her mother this.

Saira listened.

Then she said she hoped the work went well.

Mariam thanked her.

Hamid became ill during the winter.

It was not a serious illness, but for several weeks he was unable to perform some of his usual work in the garden.

One morning Isaac knocked on the door to ask whether Saira needed help moving several heavy containers that had been left in the path.

Saira accepted.

Hamid watched from the window.

Isaac moved the containers, spoke to Saira about the arrangement of the trees and went home.

He did not come inside.

The following week he visited the orchard to collect equipment belonging to his grandmother.

Hamid was sitting beside the kitchen door.

“Did you take the job?” he asked.

Isaac stopped.

“Yes.”

“Good.”

He looked surprised.

“Thank you.”

Hamid examined the trees.

“Your grandfather knew a lot about them.”

Isaac smiled.

“So I’ve heard.”

They talked for five minutes about an old variety of pear that had apparently grown near the wall before either of them could remember it.

Then Isaac went to collect the equipment.

Hamid remained beside the door.

He had not decided that the old disagreement was unimportant.

He had discovered that he could speak to Isaac without asking him to answer for it.

The following autumn, Mariam organized an open day for the preserves business.

Visitors walked along an agreed route through the orchard. There were tables of jars beside the farmhouse, invitations had been distributed to local growers, and her mother had prepared considerably more food than the original plan required.

Isaac came for the weekend.

He helped put up the tables.

Joan attended with a friend.

At one point Hamid found himself standing beside her near the repaired wall.

She pointed toward a branch that hung over his garden.

“Those are nearly ready.”

He looked.

“Yes.”

For a moment neither spoke.

Then he said, “Your husband used to say they were better after the first cold night.”

Joan smiled.

“He did.”

They remembered an afternoon, long before the dispute, when both households had shared a particularly disappointing crop of apples.

They laughed.

The conversation did not last long.

They went to different tables afterward.

Mariam saw them speaking but could not hear what they said.

She did not ask.

Later her grandfather offered Isaac a plate of food.

It was such a small action that several visitors failed to notice it.

Mariam noticed.

She understood why family disapproval of love could reveal so much about human nature. The people who loved us could fear change because of experiences we had not shared. They could mistake loyalty for agreement, protection for authority, or social belonging for a duty to repeat old judgments.

They could also learn.

Not always. Not quickly. Not necessarily in time for the people affected to remain close to them.

Her grandfather’s gradual change was his responsibility.

It did not belong to her relationship as a condition of its existence.

She took Isaac’s hand.

Beyond the repaired wall, apples hung above both gardens.

For years everybody had been concerned about which side of the wall they landed on.

This year there were enough for both households.

Editorial Note

Original fiction. All characters, families, businesses and events are invented. Family disapproval of love may reveal the tension between loyalty, belonging, inherited beliefs and individual autonomy. Understanding the history of family concerns does not require accepting unfair treatment or coercion. Adult relationships deserve assessment on their actual merits rather than inherited conflicts. Reconciliation is not always possible or safe; personal boundaries and independent support remain important.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top