Past to the Future | Volume 4 | Part 1
Historical scope: The transformation of the late Roman Mediterranean from the fourth to the seventh century CE, with the main fictional narrative set in Ravenna in 547 CE. The mosaic worker Julianus, his wife Marta, their daughter Lucia and their acquaintances are invented. The buildings, political events and historical sources discussed are documented. The term medieval is used as a broad organizing label, not as a universal period boundary for every region of the world.
The piece of glass that caught the morning
Lucia had been warned not to disturb the small pieces of colored glass.
They were arranged in containers beside her father’s equipment, and she knew from experience that the colors did not always look the same when they were moved into the sunlight.
She picked up nothing. Instead, she leaned forward.
“Why is that one different?”
Her father held a small golden piece near the doorway. Its surface caught the morning light, then seemed to darken as he turned it.
“It depends on where you stand.”
She asked whether he could make an entire wall shine like that.
“Not by myself.”
He returned the piece to its container.
Outside, Ravenna was awakening. A cart carrying supplies passed through a narrow street. The voices of merchants and laborers mingled with the sounds of people attending to their households.
Lucia had never known the city as the capital of the Western Roman Empire. She had been born long after the removal of the last emperor commonly associated with its end.
Her father had grown up under the Ostrogothic kingdom. Now the city was under the authority of an emperor whose principal residence lay far away, across the sea in Constantinople.
The year was 547 CE. The great church of San Vitale was being consecrated in this period, its elaborate mosaics embodying artistic traditions and political relationships that had survived extraordinary changes.
Our fictional household was not recorded among the people who made those mosaics. Yet their imagined circumstances allow us to approach one of the most consequential transformations in history.
Lucia lived in a city where Roman traditions had not simply vanished, but where the meaning of Roman government had profoundly changed.
The year that became a boundary
A date often introduces the medieval history of western Europe: 476 CE.
In that year, the military leader Odoacer removed Romulus Augustulus from the western imperial throne. The event is conventionally used to mark the end of the Western Roman Empire.
But its significance becomes clearer when we distinguish the event itself from the much longer processes surrounding it.
Julius Nepos, a rival western emperor recognized by the eastern court, survived until 480. The Roman imperial government based in Constantinople continued. In Italy, many existing administrative arrangements, legal practices and positions of social influence did not disappear at the moment Romulus was removed.
For a person living in Ravenna, it would have been possible to wake the next morning with the same household responsibilities as before.
The political arrangements through which those responsibilities were affected might change considerably over the following years. But few would have possessed the perspective of a modern historian looking back on a conventional boundary between periods.
The Metropolitan Museum’s chronology of Italy between 500 and 1000 CE offers a useful perspective on this transformation, showing the changing political relationships alongside the continuing use and adaptation of inherited Roman material culture.
The closing chapter of Volume 2, The Ancient World Never Really Ended, made a distinction between transformations of political institutions and the much longer histories of the people who lived within them.
It is that distinction which begins our medieval journey.
A date can help us organize an immense historical subject. It cannot alone explain when a person began to live differently.
A king who needed Roman officials
Lucia’s grandfather had remembered the arrival of Theodoric’s rule in Italy.
In our fictional account, he did not recall a moment at which every familiar arrangement had been abolished. He recalled uncertainty about military power, the people able to offer protection and the obligations that households would continue to face.
Theodoric, a ruler of the Ostrogoths, defeated Odoacer and established his authority over Italy in 493. He governed a territory containing an extensive Roman population and its inherited institutions.
Members of the Roman senatorial elite continued to occupy influential positions. Administrative practices and traditions of law remained important. Royal authority, nevertheless, belonged to a political order sustained through a different combination of military and institutional relationships.
One of the most important sources for the period is the collection known as the Variae of Cassiodorus. Cassiodorus served the Ostrogothic government and assembled letters and documents associated with its administration.
The surviving collection does not reproduce every exchange through which that government operated. It is carefully shaped literary and administrative evidence. But the matters addressed in it include concerns far removed from the abstract question of whether Rome had fallen.
One letter issued in Theodoric’s name directs attention toward the condition of Roman public buildings, the allocation of water and the protection of resources associated with aqueducts. It appears in Thomas Hodgkin’s historical condensed English translation of the Variae, Book III, letter 31.
A ruler belonging to a new political order was concerned with inherited infrastructure and the people interfering with it.
The document tells us something important about the limits of a dramatic historical boundary. A change of ruler does not remove the practical requirements of government.
But it also does not guarantee that everyone experiences continuity as security. The arrangements through which land, offices and military authority were controlled continued to matter profoundly.
Theodoric’s reign was neither an unchanged continuation of the earlier Empire nor a world created entirely from nothing.
The wall that remembered more than one ruler
Lucia’s father had worked on buildings commissioned for people whose religious and political affiliations did not always resemble one another.
Ravenna preserves an extraordinary collection of monuments from the fifth and sixth centuries. They belong to periods in which the city served different political authorities, while remaining a significant center of artistic production.
The Mausoleum of Galla Placidia belongs to the fifth century. The building known today as Sant’Apollinare Nuovo originated as a palace church associated with Theodoric. San Vitale was begun during the Ostrogothic period and completed after the eastern Roman conquest of Ravenna.
The UNESCO documentation of Ravenna’s early Christian monuments identifies eight surviving structures that illustrate these changing historical arrangements.
Their mosaics demonstrate the importance of artistic knowledge that cannot be assigned exclusively to one political identity.
Making a mosaic requires numerous decisions. The design must be prepared, the necessary material obtained and the individual pieces set into a suitable surface. Their color and placement affect the finished composition.
A craftsman’s experience might remain valuable through a change of government, even if the subjects commissioned, the intended audiences or the people controlling his employment altered.
In our imagined workshop, Julianus discussed the appearance of a piece of glass without knowing that a modern visitor might classify the work he produced according to broad historical periods.
He wanted the surface to behave properly in the light.
The particular image eventually created could communicate political authority or religious meaning. Its making also embodied practical knowledge shared through many years of training.
History becomes richer when the meanings of an object are understood alongside the work that brought it into existence.
The sea that had not disappeared
Marta, Lucia’s mother, was familiar with the small differences between vessels made by local potters and those that arrived through wider commercial networks.
She could not necessarily identify where every bowl had been made. A merchant’s explanation and the appearance of an object were not reliable guides to the entire journey it had taken.
Archaeologists have other means of investigating such questions.
Ceramics survive in large quantities, and researchers use their physical characteristics, composition and distribution to examine connections between places. Imported pottery can identify economic relationships that are not always visible in preserved accounts of political events.
North African workshops, for example, produced fine red tablewares that circulated across substantial parts of the Mediterranean during late antiquity.
The Cambridge Encyclopaedia of Late Antique Art and Archaeology chapter on pottery discusses how these ceramics reveal both continuity and changes in production and exchange.
The survival of a bowl does not establish that the entire economy remained prosperous. Nor does the presence of imported goods mean that every household could afford them.
Commercial networks could continue in one region while becoming more restricted elsewhere. Political conflict, taxation, security, population changes and access to maritime routes could influence what remained available.
Ravenna’s nearby port of Classe connected the area with the Adriatic and wider Mediterranean.
Lucia’s knowledge of the sea came largely through the people and objects arriving in the city. Her family did not have to travel to every place whose products contributed to its life.
That distinction is worth preserving when examining the history of medieval trade. A connection between regions can shape the circumstances of people who never personally make the journey between them.
The people who kept the water moving
One morning Julianus returned earlier than expected. A problem elsewhere had delayed the work planned for the day.
Marta was less interested in the technical details than in the consequences for their household. Would the delay affect what her husband was paid? Would he be required to work longer on another day?
His answer depended on arrangements over which he had limited control.
Large projects and urban institutions depend upon many activities performed in the correct relationship to one another. A worker with considerable skill may still be unable to proceed if materials, access or preceding work are unavailable.
This was true of ancient Roman aqueducts, which required far more than their original construction. It remained true when later governments inherited those networks.
The history of ancient Rome’s transition from Republic to Empire introduced this issue through the movement of water and the organization of urban food supplies.
The old infrastructure of Italy was an inheritance of tremendous potential usefulness. It was also an inheritance requiring people, materials and sustained commitments.
Where a particular structure remained in operation, repair did not happen automatically. Where population or economic arrangements changed, the capacity or reasons for maintaining earlier works could change as well.
An inherited building could continue to serve its original purpose. It might be adapted, abandoned or become a source of materials for new construction.
The modern reflection An Open Letter to the People Who Keep Things Running approaches the frequently unnoticed work sustaining institutions from a contemporary perspective.
The late antique city offers a different historical setting for examining that work. Its survival and transformation depended not simply upon the persistence of old buildings but upon the ability and willingness of people to make those buildings useful.
An argument about the nature of faith
The household lived in a city where differences in Christian belief could have important political and social consequences.
Christianity had developed in the Roman world over several centuries. Imperial support from the fourth century onward transformed its public position, but Christian communities remained divided over significant theological questions.
Theodoric adhered to a form of Christianity conventionally described as Arian, more precisely associated with the Homoian tradition. Many of the Roman population of Italy belonged to the Nicene Christian tradition.
These distinctions concerned deeply held theological convictions, not merely political allegiances.
Church buildings, baptisteries and their decoration became settings in which religious identities and traditions could be expressed. The landscape of Ravenna preserves monuments associated with different Christian communities and successive political orders.
Some of the visual arrangements in these buildings were modified after changes in authority. Their present appearance must therefore be understood through more than one historical moment.
Imagine Lucia noticing an alteration in a building she had visited before. She might have asked why a familiar image had changed.
We cannot reconstruct her fictional father’s exact explanation from the historical evidence. For an actual resident, the change could carry religious, political or artistic significance, depending on that person’s circumstances.
Religious history cannot be reduced to the decisions of emperors and bishops. Households encountered worship through ceremonies, buildings, relationships and practices whose emotional importance may be difficult to recover.
At the same time, religious institutions acquired resources and responsibilities that influenced social life. Their development became one of the defining features of the centuries we are about to explore.
The emperor across the water
By the year of our story, Ravenna had already undergone another major political transformation.
Justinian I, ruling from Constantinople between 527 and 565, directed military campaigns that brought North Africa and parts of the western Mediterranean under eastern Roman control.
In Italy, the wars beginning in 535 continued for many years. Belisarius captured Ravenna in 540, but control of the peninsula remained contested.
Fighting and political uncertainty affected communities across different regions. The end of Ostrogothic resistance did not instantly establish lasting stability throughout Italy.
The imperial court’s intentions could be represented through monuments and images. In San Vitale, the famous compositions depicting Justinian and Theodora express relationships among religious ceremony, imperial authority and the visual language of the period.
Neither emperor nor empress is known to have stood physically before the Ravenna mosaics representing them.
Their images made imperial presence visible at a great distance.
Lucia might have learned of Constantinople primarily through people who spoke about the emperor, travelers acquainted with the city or objects associated with the wider imperial world.
The relationship between her daily life and that distant center was mediated through institutions rather than personal acquaintance.
In the ancient Persian chapter, we examined how delegated authority and communications could connect places whose inhabitants lived under very different local conditions. Roman rule in the sixth century offers another historically distinct example.
The restoration of imperial authority at Ravenna could possess an entirely different meaning for an imperial official, a landowner, a soldier or a person whose household had been displaced by war.
An empire’s description of its success is rarely sufficient to explain all the experiences involved in achieving it.
The years when harvests became uncertain
In the fictional household, a conversation about grain prices becomes an occasion for recalling difficult years.
Lucia’s parents had experienced the disruptions of the 530s and 540s. The precise effect upon their family is invented, but the wider historical circumstances are documented.
Researchers examining tree-ring evidence identified an unusually sustained period of cooling following major volcanic eruptions during the sixth century.
The 2016 Nature Geoscience study of the Late Antique Little Ice Age reconstructs temperature changes using records from the European Alps and the Russian Altai.
Such findings add an environmental dimension to the history of this period. They do not establish that every political upheaval, failed harvest or migration had one climatic cause.
The first historically recorded outbreak of the pandemic known as the Justinianic Plague began around 541 CE. Its subsequent spread affected parts of the Mediterranean and neighboring regions.
Disease and environmental pressures interacted with social arrangements already shaped by warfare, exchange, agricultural production and inequalities in access to resources.
The scale and consequences of the plague remain subjects of historical and archaeological debate. An estimate for one region or outbreak cannot safely be applied to every part of the former Roman world.
Lucia’s mother could not distinguish changes in harvest conditions according to the methods available to modern climate researchers. She could recognize when provisions had become more difficult to obtain.
The chapter When Scarcity Turned Space Into Strategy explored an earlier historical setting in which communities confronted uncertain resources.
The sixth century reminds us that environmental change does not have uniform consequences. Relationships, institutions and access to material reserves influence the options available to particular households.
When a manuscript acquired another life
One day Lucia accompanied her father on an errand that brought them near a person engaged in writing.
The movements seemed slow compared with the work she usually watched. She asked why anyone would spend so much time producing marks on a surface when another person might already possess the same information.
Her father explained that the second copy could be read somewhere the first one could not go.
The history of learning in the centuries following antiquity involves many different traditions of preservation and adaptation.
Cassiodorus later established a religious community at Vivarium in southern Italy, where scholarly and scribal activities became important to the intellectual program he described in his writings.
Other religious communities developed their own arrangements for learning, prayer and the activities of daily life.
The transmission of texts was not restricted to monasteries. It also involved secular and ecclesiastical officials, schools, private collections and intellectual traditions operating in different languages across the Mediterranean and beyond.
Nor did every text considered important in one historical setting survive into another.
A manuscript can be lost through neglect, damage or changes in the interests and resources of the people responsible for it. Language itself can become a barrier.
The survival of ancient texts consequently tells a history of choices and circumstances, as well as one of intellectual creation.
Our next chapters will explore some of the very different scholarly worlds that developed through the medieval centuries.
The knowledge inherited from antiquity was never simply placed in storage and retrieved unchanged centuries later. People studied it, selected from it, translated it, disputed it and brought it into relationships with new questions.
A medieval world beyond western Europe
Our story has begun in Italy because Ravenna offers an unusually vivid record of the transformations connecting Roman antiquity with medieval European history.
But it would be misleading to make the future of a single former Roman province the beginning of a universal age.
Across western Asia, the Sasanian Empire possessed its own complex political and cultural history. In the seventh century, the expansion of new Muslim political communities fundamentally transformed the relationships of the region.
In China, the Sui and Tang dynasties emerged through developments that followed the fragmentation of earlier imperial arrangements. The histories of South Asia likewise followed their own varied political, religious and commercial paths.
Aksum in northeastern Africa participated in networks linking inland communities and surrounding maritime regions. Across the Americas, societies continued to build cities, maintain intellectual traditions and form new political relationships without reference to the events in Italy that European historians use to define the Middle Ages.
The significance of a historical date is therefore dependent upon the questions being asked and the people whose experiences are being examined.
This volume uses the medieval world as a way of exploring a broad span of human history, not as a claim that every region entered the same age at the same moment.
Our journey will move between societies and across overlapping centuries. It will distinguish the periods appropriate to their histories rather than treating them as delayed versions of a European chronology.
Where the golden light fell
At the end of the day, Julianus brought Lucia to a place where she could observe a completed section of mosaic from a distance.
She recognized colors she had seen in the workshop. But the wall did not look like the collection of individual pieces she remembered.
It seemed to change as they moved.
“Now do you understand?” her father asked.
She nodded, although she was not quite sure what he expected her to understand.
The pieces had not lost their individual properties. Each contributed to something that could only be seen when the relationships among them became visible.
A historian looking back on the centuries surrounding the end of western imperial rule encounters a similarly complicated landscape.
Some Roman institutions disappeared. Others continued under new authorities or acquired new purposes. Different groups established forms of government, religious life and economic relationships that could not simply be described as repetitions of antiquity.
The past became material for new arrangements.
The medieval world was not merely an interval between ancient achievements and modern ones. It contained its own innovations, conflicts, intellectual traditions and possibilities.
To understand its significance, we must look beyond the familiar image of an empire falling. We must examine the people who continued to live, work, travel and make decisions after the supposed ending.
Lucia’s father had learned his craft before many of the events that would shape her future.
She would grow up in a different political world.
And someone younger than herself might someday see the golden light on the wall without knowing how many changes had occurred while the pieces were being brought together.
In the next chapter, we will travel to Constantinople and explore the Eastern Roman Empire that continued long after the western imperial throne had disappeared.
Series navigation: Volume 4 index | Volume 2 — Ancient Civilizations | Past to the Future.



