At the end of every December, Martin took the previous year’s account book from the drawer beneath his desk and compared its final pages with the one he was about to close.
He had begun the practice when he and his wife, Anna, were living in a rented apartment and attempting to save enough money to purchase a house. Their circumstances had changed substantially since then. The apartment had become a small house, the small house a larger one, and the furniture they had once acquired from relatives had gradually been replaced.
On one particular December evening, Martin announced that he thought they should consider moving again.
Anna asked what was wrong with the house.
Nothing was particularly wrong with it. Martin liked the garden, the rooms were comfortable, and the railway station was close enough for him to walk there in the morning. He had recently discovered, however, that a colleague had purchased a larger property in a district he had always regarded as attractive.
He showed Anna several advertisements.
She looked at them for a while before asking what they would be able to do in another house that they could not do in this one.
Martin struggled to answer.
There were features of the other properties he appreciated. A larger kitchen would be pleasant. He liked the appearance of a particular garden. But he had not experienced any substantial difficulty with the kitchen or garden he already possessed until he had begun considering the ones available elsewhere.
For many years, the purpose of improving their circumstances had been apparent. They had needed space, security and a more dependable relationship with the expenses of ordinary life. Each improvement had addressed something they could identify.
Now the next improvement was being proposed largely because an improvement remained possible.
They did not make a decision that evening.
Martin closed the account book, and Anna went to prepare tea. As he returned the book to its drawer, he noticed how little the familiar ritual had changed despite the changes in their lives.
He was still measuring their progress in the same direction.
For the first time, he wondered whether the question he wanted the figures to answer had changed.
Enough is a difficult word because it does not describe a particular quantity. It describes a relationship between what is available to us and what we reasonably need, value or wish to accomplish. That relationship cannot always be established by discovering what more we might possess.
The distance between having little and needing little
In a small apartment across town, a woman named Mariam was also examining her expenses.
She had paid the rent, purchased groceries and reserved enough money for travel to work. A pair of shoes her son needed for school would have to wait until the following week.
Mariam was familiar with advice about appreciating what one already possessed. Much of it was agreeable in principle. It was less useful on afternoons when she needed to choose which necessary expense could be postponed.
She appreciated her son. She appreciated the friends who sometimes invited them for meals. She enjoyed the view from the window on clear evenings.
None of these appreciations made the shoes less necessary.
There is an important distinction between deciding that something we possess is sufficient and being told that a difficulty we experience ought to be sufficient.
A person whose basic needs are reliably met may discover that acquiring additional possessions contributes relatively little to the quality of an ordinary day. A person who cannot obtain a necessary service may experience a modest increase in their resources as a substantial improvement to their life.
To describe both situations simply as different attitudes toward contentment would obscure much of what matters about them.
As explored in The Things Money Cannot Measure, financial resources do not provide a complete account of the value of human experiences. Nevertheless, their availability can influence whether many of those experiences are practically accessible.
Money does not guarantee a sense of security. The absence of sufficient money can provide numerous reasons for insecurity.
A thoughtful understanding of enough must allow for this distinction.
We need not romanticize deprivation to question unnecessary accumulation. Nor need we assume that every desire for improved circumstances arises from dissatisfaction with things that ought to satisfy us.
Mariam was not failing to appreciate ordinary life when she wanted a more dependable income. She was trying to make that life easier to arrange.
For her, enough concerned the ability to meet foreseeable obligations without continually transferring one difficulty into the following week.
There was nothing extravagant about that ambition.
One of the more meaningful uses of additional resources is making it possible for people to stop spending so much of their attention on the question of whether they possess enough of them.
When the comparison moves the boundary
During his first years of employment, Martin had been delighted by his salary.
It allowed him to contribute to the household in ways that had previously been impossible. He could occasionally purchase books without considering how the expense would affect the following month. He and Anna began planning a holiday.
Several years later, an increase in his salary produced a similar satisfaction.
Over time, however, the circumstances against which he understood his position changed. He associated with people whose incomes were greater than those of the colleagues he had known earlier. Certain expenses that would once have seemed unusual began appearing entirely ordinary.
The improvement was real.
So was the movement of the boundary by which he measured it.
Human beings establish many of their expectations through observing the circumstances of other people. We discover possibilities through comparison. We recognize that a service could be better, that certain work deserves more appropriate compensation or that an arrangement we have accepted is unnecessarily difficult.
Comparison can supply useful information.
It can also make the experience of sufficiency remarkably unstable.
As explored in The Lives We Measure Against Others, the conditions under which we compare ourselves with somebody else can influence which portions of our lives become visible to us.
A visit to another person’s house may introduce a genuine idea for improving our own. It may also leave us dissatisfied with something that was serving its purpose perfectly well before the visit took place.
The difference is worth examining.
If we can identify a particular need that an improvement would address, we can consider its value alongside the other things its pursuit would require. If the proposed improvement is attractive principally because somebody else possesses it, the goal may become less dependable.
There will almost always be another person whose circumstances provide a reason to move the boundary again.
Martin had no objection to his colleague buying a larger house. He had been pleased to hear about it.
The more difficult question was why the existence of that house had acquired such importance within his understanding of his own.
He began making a different kind of comparison.
He considered the things he and Anna enjoyed doing during a typical week and asked how moving would affect them. A longer journey to work, additional expenses and several years of greater financial commitments would have consequences that did not appear in the photographs of the properties he had been examining.
He still liked the houses.
He was beginning to understand that liking something did not establish that obtaining it would make his life appreciably better.
The ambition that has acquired no stopping point
A small business owner named Rachel had started her company with two employees.
The first years were demanding. She worked long hours, occasionally postponed her own salary and spent considerable effort establishing dependable relationships with customers.
When the business became profitable, she expanded it. The expansion provided additional employment and made some portions of the work easier to organize.
Several years later, she was considering opening another location.
Her advisers believed that the opportunity was promising. Rachel believed this too. What remained unclear was whether the undertaking would produce the kind of life she wanted.
She had originally hoped to develop a company that could support its employees, provide a dependable service and give her greater independence over the arrangement of her work.
The existing business had substantially accomplished those things.
Another location might provide new opportunities. It would also introduce several responsibilities Rachel would be expected to manage, at least during the years in which its arrangements were being established.
She realized that she had never considered the possibility that the business might reach a scale at which maintaining it well would be a more meaningful ambition than increasing its size.
Growth had become the most familiar description of success.
Other forms of success had acquired relatively little attention.
In The Patience of Things That Grow, we considered how development can be valuable even when its results are difficult to recognize immediately. There is a related question about the direction in which development needs to take place.
A business can improve its services without expanding its premises. A musician can develop a more substantial understanding of a piece without attempting to perform at a larger venue. A person can become more capable of organizing their working day without continually accepting additional work.
Growth of this kind can be difficult to recognize through measures that give particular importance to expansion.
Rachel did not reject the proposal immediately.
She discussed what opening another location would make possible, what it would require from the people already working with her and whether other improvements would be more useful.
Eventually, she decided to devote a substantial portion of the available resources to training and improving the conditions under which the existing company operated.
Her advisers had not been wrong about the prospects of expansion.
She had chosen a different purpose for the company’s next stage of development.
The decision allowed her to retain an ambition without requiring that the ambition continually take the same form.
What the pursuit of more displaces
Several years earlier, Anna had begun taking a day away from her usual household responsibilities whenever her circumstances permitted it.
Sometimes she visited a friend. Sometimes she took a train to a neighboring town and spent an afternoon walking through its streets. On other occasions, she remained at home reading.
Martin enjoyed hearing about these days. He had rarely considered arranging something similar for himself.
He frequently used the available portions of his weekends to undertake additional paid work. The income had been useful when their expenses were particularly demanding. The habit had continued after those expenses became more manageable.
One Saturday, a friend invited him to spend an afternoon fishing.
Martin declined because he had agreed to complete a piece of work.
There was nothing necessarily unreasonable about the decision. He had accepted a commitment and intended to fulfill it.
The difficulty concerned a longer pattern in which relatively ordinary opportunities had repeatedly been displaced by work whose financial benefits no longer addressed a particularly important need.
As explored in If We Knew How Little Time We Had, the significance of the things we choose can become clearer when we recognize the limited character of the time through which those choices become available.
It would be unreasonable to tell somebody whose income is insufficient that they should simply devote less time to obtaining it. The freedom to decline additional work depends upon resources and arrangements that are not equally available to everyone.
Where that freedom does exist, however, it can be useful to consider what we are acquiring through the work and what we are repeatedly making unavailable through the decision to undertake it.
The benefits may justify the decision.
Sometimes they may not.
Martin began reserving several weekends on which he would not accept additional work. He discovered that the absence of the work felt slightly unfamiliar at first.
He had become accustomed to receiving a recognizable result from the time he spent.
A morning walking beside the river produced no similar entry in his account book.
Yet when he considered what he would willingly have paid to recover an earlier afternoon with someone he cared about, the absence of an entry in the book no longer seemed a particularly reliable description of the afternoon’s value.
He had acquired enough room in his circumstances to choose a different use of some of his time.
Part of the difficulty had been learning to exercise that choice.
Enough does not mean nothing must change
A volunteer at a public garden objected when its committee proposed replacing several benches.
He explained that the existing benches were quite adequate. He had used them for many years, and he saw little reason to spend money obtaining new ones.
Another member of the committee pointed out that several benches were difficult for people to rise from because they lacked suitable armrests. Their positions also made them inaccessible from portions of the path.
The first volunteer had not encountered these problems.
His judgment about the adequacy of the arrangement was accurate in relation to his own use of it. It was less adequate as a description of what the garden provided to other people.
There is a danger in allowing contentment with our own circumstances to become an argument against improvements that matter to somebody else.
An institution may possess sufficient resources to provide a service in the way its administrators have always provided it. The people using that service may nevertheless encounter avoidable obstacles.
A family may be quite comfortable with the distribution of its responsibilities because the people performing most of the work have seldom been given a reasonable opportunity to reconsider it.
Enough is therefore a question that can require more than examining our own satisfaction.
Whose needs are being considered? Which purposes is the arrangement intended to serve? What would a reasonable improvement allow somebody to do?
The committee reviewed the benches and decided to retain the ones that continued serving their purpose while replacing several others and improving access to them.
The garden did not need to become more elaborate in order to become more useful.
It needed to provide a little more of something that certain visitors had previously been unable to obtain.
A preference for sufficiency should leave room for improvements of this kind.
It is not a refusal to make things better.
It is an invitation to identify what becoming better would actually mean.
The book at the end of the year
The following December, Martin took another account book from the drawer.
He and Anna had not moved.
During the summer they had repaired a section of the garden wall, and Anna had arranged to have a small alteration made to the kitchen. The house had become a little more convenient without becoming larger.
Martin had spent several Saturdays beside the river with his friend. He had also undertaken additional work on occasions when the subject interested him or the income would serve a purpose he could identify.
The figures in the account book were still important. They helped him understand the expenses the household could manage and the resources it needed to retain.
They no longer seemed to provide quite the same account of the direction in which his life should develop.
Perhaps the meaning of enough lies partly in the freedom to recognize when the purpose of an undertaking has been substantially fulfilled, without interpreting that recognition as a failure of imagination.
We can seek better circumstances where the ones available to us are inadequate. We can develop abilities, improve arrangements and pursue interests whose value is not easily expressed through the possession of additional things.
We can also discover that some of the ambitions through which we have organized our lives deserve to change once the needs that originally gave them importance have been addressed.
There will be circumstances in which we cannot determine exactly how much is enough. The future is uncertain, responsibilities change, and prudence can provide good reasons to retain resources beyond our immediate requirements.
But the impossibility of establishing an absolutely final quantity does not mean that every opportunity to obtain more deserves the same degree of attention.
Martin closed the book.
Through the window, he could see the garden wall that he and Anna had repaired. Beyond it, several of the neighboring windows were illuminated.
He went into the kitchen.
They had arranged to have dinner with friends that evening, and there were vegetables to prepare.
The accounts could tell him whether the household could afford the meal.
They could not tell him how much the evening would be worth.
He was pleased to have discovered a question that did not require another calculation.



