The drawing had been finished for nearly an hour when Noor decided to change it.
She was preparing an illustration for a small exhibition at a community arts center. The original design was simple: a woman standing on a rooftop at dusk, looking toward a collection of windows that had begun to light up across the city. Noor liked the empty space around the figure and the quietness it gave the composition.
Then she imagined what one of her former teachers might say.
Perhaps the picture lacked detail. Perhaps the colors were too subdued. Perhaps people would pass it without noticing.
She added another building, changed the sky and adjusted the woman’s expression. When she looked at the drawing again, she could no longer identify the reason she had originally wanted to make it.
Her sister arrived that evening and asked whether she was pleased with the result.
“I think people will like it,” Noor replied.
Her sister looked at her.
“That isn’t quite what I asked.”
Noor did not know how to answer. She had spent so much time imagining the reactions of people who had not yet seen the drawing that her own response had become difficult to distinguish from theirs.
The hidden hunger for approval does not always announce itself through a desire for applause. Sometimes it is visible in the decisions we revise before anybody has criticized them, the opinions we conceal before anybody has challenged them and the things we refuse to enjoy unless another person confirms that they are worth enjoying.
It may begin with an entirely understandable wish to belong. Its consequences depend upon how much authority we eventually allow that wish to acquire.
Why being seen matters
A child runs toward a parent holding something they have made.
The object is a rough arrangement of paper, glue and color. The child is not offering it for an independent assessment of its artistic quality. They want the person in front of them to notice something they have accomplished.
The parent’s response matters because it belongs to an important relationship. Interest, encouragement and affection can help the child discover that an activity is worth continuing, that curiosity is welcome and that mistakes need not make the attempt embarrassing.
As adults, we do not necessarily become indifferent to such responses.
A friend who remembers what we have been working toward can make a difficult undertaking feel less isolated. A colleague’s appreciation can help establish that a contribution has been useful. The recognition of somebody we respect may encourage us to develop a capability whose significance we had underestimated.
There is no particular virtue in becoming entirely uninterested in the opinions of other people.
Our understanding of ourselves develops partly through relationships. We discover abilities through opportunities other people help provide. We learn about the consequences of our behavior through the experiences of those affected by it.
The desire for recognition can therefore serve a valuable purpose.
The difficulty begins when the response we receive becomes the principal means through which we determine whether our experiences, decisions or accomplishments possess any value at all.
The child may enjoy making something before showing it to a parent. Noor had enjoyed creating the first version of her drawing before imagining its reception.
Recognition can add something to an experience.
It need not become the condition under which the experience is permitted to matter.
The audience that follows us into an empty room
Noor often worked alone.
Yet her studio was crowded with imagined observers.
She could anticipate the objections of a former teacher, recall the preferences of people who had purchased her work and imagine the kinds of comments that might appear if she shared an illustration online.
Some of these considerations were useful. A person making something for a particular audience may need to understand what that audience requires. Professional work involves responsibilities that cannot be satisfied exclusively through personal preference.
But Noor was not always making professional work. Sometimes she was drawing something because it interested her.
Even then, she found herself evaluating the result according to an anticipated reception.
A similar habit can influence decisions far removed from creative work.
A person considers changing their appearance and first imagines the people who might disapprove. Someone discovers an interest that has little connection to their occupation and wonders whether pursuing it would make them appear less serious. A friend prepares to express a disagreement and rehearses the consequences of being regarded differently afterward.
Nobody needs to be physically present for the anticipated judgment to influence the decision.
In The Distance Between Living and Existing, we considered how difficult it can become to distinguish the commitments we have chosen from the expectations we have learned to satisfy.
The imagined audience can make that distinction particularly difficult. We may interpret its anticipated reaction as our own preference, forgetting how much attention we have devoted to remaining acceptable to it.
One useful question is whether we would still care about an activity if nobody we hoped to impress ever discovered that we had undertaken it.
The answer need not be yes in every case. Some activities are valuable precisely because they establish a relationship with an audience.
But where the answer surprises us, it may reveal something about the purpose we have assigned to the activity.
The praise that becomes a responsibility
A young man is widely known within his family as the person who can be relied upon.
He helps arrange appointments, assists relatives with difficult paperwork and makes himself available when somebody needs to discuss a problem.
He takes genuine satisfaction in many of these responsibilities. He also knows how warmly people respond when he fulfills them.
Over time, however, the description becomes difficult to live outside.
When he wants to decline a request, he imagines the disappointment that might follow. When he needs assistance himself, he worries that expressing the need will make other people reconsider the confidence they place in him.
He has acquired a form of recognition that depends upon continuing to behave in a particular way.
Praise can have this unintended consequence.
A child admired for academic achievement may begin interpreting an ordinary mistake as a threat to the affection connected with their performance. An employee known for accepting additional work may feel unable to acknowledge exhaustion. A friend valued for being accommodating may discover that their preferences rarely enter the arrangements they help maintain.
This does not mean that any expression of appreciation is harmful. People deserve acknowledgment for the care and effort they contribute.
It does mean that we should be careful not to make our approval of a person appear inseparable from their continued performance of a particular role.
Someone can remain generous while having no capacity to assist on a particular afternoon. A capable student can struggle with a subject. A dependable person can need rest, support or an opportunity to attend to commitments of their own.
As explored in What Makes a Life Worth Remembering?, a favorable reputation can become a demanding identity when the person carrying it feels unable to live beyond the qualities other people admire.
The young man does not have to abandon his generosity in order to establish a limit.
He may need to discover whether the people who appreciate his assistance are also capable of appreciating his independence from it.
When disagreement feels like rejection
Two friends are discussing a subject on which their opinions differ.
One expresses a position thoughtfully. The other immediately feels uneasy. The conversation has contained no insult and no threat to the friendship, yet the disagreement seems unusually consequential.
Perhaps the uneasy friend has grown accustomed to relationships in which affection was closely associated with agreement. Perhaps earlier disagreements produced extended silences or unpredictable reactions. Perhaps the opinion concerns something they regard as central to their identity.
They begin considering whether they should change their stated position.
There are excellent reasons to revise an opinion. Another person may offer information we did not possess, identify an inconsistency in our reasoning or supply a perspective we had failed to consider.
But revising a judgment because the evidence has changed is different from revising it primarily to restore another person’s approval.
The two motives can become difficult to distinguish, especially when we care deeply about the relationship.
In The Contradictions Within Us, we considered the tension between wanting the freedom to make our own decisions and wanting the reassurance of agreement from people we value.
A relationship capable of accommodating reasonable differences offers a distinctive kind of security. Its members do not have to interpret every disagreement as evidence that their connection is ending.
Not every relationship provides such conditions. Some people experience retaliation when they disagree with somebody upon whom they depend. In those circumstances, caution may be necessary; independence is not something a person can safely demonstrate at any cost.
Where respectful disagreement is possible, however, it can be useful to allow a modest difference of opinion to remain unresolved without treating it as an emergency.
The friendship may survive the fact that both people have reached different conclusions.
And each person may discover that being loved need not require becoming entirely predictable to the other.
The difference between useful criticism and a verdict
An apprentice submits a piece of work to someone with more experience.
They receive several suggestions. One concerns a technical problem they had not noticed. Another reflects a difference of taste. A third is so general that they cannot determine what change is being recommended.
If the apprentice regards all criticism as an attack, they may lose opportunities to improve.
If they regard every criticism as an authoritative judgment, they may make changes that do not serve the work.
Receiving feedback requires discernment.
What is the person assessing? What relevant experience do they possess? Are they identifying a problem whose consequences can be examined, expressing a preference or asking for a result that belongs to an agreed responsibility?
An editor may help a writer recognize that a passage is unclear. A customer can explain that an agreed feature is missing from a product. A friend may identify behavior that made a conversation unnecessarily difficult.
These are different kinds of information from the assertion that something simply does not appeal to a particular observer.
Noor’s former teacher might have offered a useful observation about the composition of the drawing. But she had changed it before the teacher had even seen it.
She was responding to an imagined verdict rather than investigating an actual suggestion.
The problem was not a failure to defend every original decision. Artists develop partly through changing their work.
It was that she had lost track of the purpose against which the changes should be evaluated.
Learning to receive approval and criticism without granting either unlimited authority involves maintaining some understanding of what we are trying to accomplish.
Feedback can help us examine that understanding.
It does not need to supply the entire thing.
The arithmetic of being noticed
A man shares a photograph online and returns to it several times during the afternoon.
At first, he is interested in hearing from friends. Later, he begins comparing the response with that received by another photograph. The number of reactions becomes a means of assessing a moment he had previously enjoyed without uncertainty.
There is nothing inherently troubling about sharing an experience or appreciating the responses it receives. Digital spaces can sustain friendships, connect people with similar interests and provide opportunities for work to reach an audience otherwise unavailable to its creator.
But a visible measure of attention can become surprisingly difficult to interpret.
A photograph may reach fewer people because of how it was distributed, when it appeared or whether its subject was familiar to the audience. A substantial response may reflect curiosity, controversy or a momentary preference rather than a considered appreciation of the thing shared.
The number cannot reveal everything about the meaning of the experience.
The danger arises when an uncertain measure of attention becomes a seemingly precise measure of personal worth.
A quiet success can begin to feel disappointing because it has produced little visible recognition. An activity attracting attention can become difficult to abandon even after it has ceased to offer genuine satisfaction.
In The Beauty of an Ordinary Life, we examined the significance of experiences whose value does not depend upon public confirmation.
That distinction becomes particularly important when opportunities for such confirmation are continuously available.
The man may still share the photograph. His friends may enjoy seeing it.
But the afternoon in which it was taken has already happened. Its meaning need not remain unresolved until the response has been counted.
Choosing something without asking for permission
Several days before the exhibition, Noor found an earlier version of her illustration.
She placed it beside the most recent one.
The finished picture possessed features she had worked hard to develop. It also contained additions that she could no longer explain in terms of what she wanted the image to communicate.
She began removing some of them.
The process did not feel like a sudden discovery of perfect confidence. She still wondered what the visitors would think. She still hoped that somebody would appreciate what she had made.
The difference was that she had established a reason for each change that did not depend exclusively upon anticipating praise.
There is a modest form of independence available through decisions like this.
A person might choose a book without asking whether its subject will impress somebody. They might express a preference in a relationship where doing so is safe. They might allow themselves to spend an afternoon pursuing something that has no obvious value to the people whose opinions they usually consult.
The resulting choices will not necessarily be satisfying. A person can discover that an independent decision was unwise. They may change their mind after encountering further information.
That possibility is important.
Developing judgment requires opportunities to experience its consequences, not merely opportunities to make decisions that other people have already agreed to support.
A need for approval does not disappear simply because we recognize it. Some patterns have developed through experiences extending across many years. Where they cause persistent distress or interfere with everyday life, appropriate professional support may be useful.
We can still begin distinguishing between recognition that offers connection, guidance or meaningful encouragement and recognition that we have begun to treat as permission to exist in a particular way.
The distinction may become clearer through small decisions whose outcomes we are able to accept without first knowing how they will be received.
The picture on the wall
On the evening of the exhibition, Noor stood at some distance from her drawing.
A few visitors stopped to look at it. Some moved on quickly. One person asked about the buildings in the background, and another said that the colors reminded them of the city in which they had grown up.
Noor appreciated the comments.
She was also aware of the people who appeared to find other pictures more interesting. Their reactions did not feel entirely irrelevant. She had brought something into a shared space and hoped that it would establish a connection with somebody.
But when her sister arrived and asked whether she was pleased with the result, Noor found that she could answer the question without first counting the people who had stopped in front of it.
“Yes,” she said. “I think it says what I wanted it to say.”
Perhaps the hidden hunger for approval is not something we need to eliminate completely. We are social beings, and the affection, attention and understanding of others can enrich the lives we are capable of living.
What deserves examination is the point at which the wish to be accepted begins determining the boundaries of our participation in the world.
We can listen to advice without requiring another person to make every decision. We can take responsibility for the effects of our behavior without treating every unfavorable opinion as proof that we have acted wrongly. We can enjoy appreciation without needing it to establish the value of every experience that matters to us.
There may always be people whose recognition we particularly desire.
We can care about their judgment while allowing some part of our lives to remain available to our own.
Noor looked at the picture again.
The space around the woman on the rooftop was quiet.
This time, she had left it that way.



