The Distance Between Living and Existing

Explore the distance between living and existing in this literary reflection on personal agency, routine, emotional engagement, identity and reconnecting with what matters.

A thoughtful woman gazing through a train window at a sunlit riverside path

The woman at the railway station had been buying the same ticket for eleven years.

She knew where the train would stop, which carriage was usually quieter and how much time she needed to reach her office from the other end of the journey. She had become so familiar with the route that she could sometimes arrive at her desk without retaining a clear memory of the journey.

One evening, a colleague asked whether she enjoyed living in the town through which they traveled.

She began to answer with information about the rent, the transport connections and the distance from her workplace. Then she realized that he had asked a different question.

Did she enjoy living there?

She knew very little about the town apart from the arrangements that made it possible for her to work somewhere else. There was a public library she had never entered. A river ran behind a row of buildings near the station. She had once intended to find out where the path beside it led.

Nothing in her life demanded an urgent transformation. She liked several of her colleagues, took pride in her work and cared about the people who depended on her. Her routines were not evidence of a failed existence.

Yet the question stayed with her.

She began wondering how many of her activities reflected things she had consciously chosen and how many survived because they had become the easiest arrangements to continue.

The distance between living and existing is not necessarily the distance between an adventurous life and a predictable one. It can be the distance between participating in the direction of our lives and gradually becoming accustomed to a direction that no longer feels like our own.

The life we describe in the language of necessity

Ask someone what they do during an ordinary week and they may provide a remarkably clear account.

They get up at a particular time. They travel to work, collect children from school, buy groceries and complete responsibilities that cannot safely be neglected.

Ask what they would like to do with a little time belonging to them, and the answer may come less easily.

There are understandable reasons for the difference. Necessity provides immediate guidance. A bill has an amount and a deadline. A person waiting to be collected from school has a recognizable need. An employer can explain what will happen if an assigned task is not completed.

A personal desire may have none of these characteristics. It may be difficult to describe, uncertain in its outcome and entirely capable of being postponed without producing an immediate crisis.

Over time, we may become exceptionally articulate about the things we must do and less articulate about the things we care to do.

This does not make our responsibilities less meaningful. Some of the obligations we carry are expressions of our deepest commitments. Caring for somebody we love may be more important to us than any activity we could undertake independently.

The trouble appears when the language of necessity becomes the only language through which we understand ourselves.

There is a difference between saying that a person needs us and being able to explain why their well-being matters to us. There is a difference between continuing an occupation because we are afraid to lose our income and recognizing the part of that occupation we have deliberately chosen to value.

Those differences may not change our schedules immediately. They can change our relationship with the lives those schedules contain.

A routine can be an expression of freedom

The familiar image of a person merely existing is often rather unfair to ordinary life.

We imagine somebody repeating inconsequential tasks while a more fortunate person travels widely, pursues exciting ambitions and continually encounters new experiences.

But repetition does not demonstrate that a person has ceased to live.

A gardener may return to the same patch of land for thirty years and encounter it differently with every season. A teacher may explain the same subject to successive groups of students while discovering new ways to understand their questions. A couple may walk together each evening without feeling that the familiarity has diminished the importance of the activity.

In The Beauty of an Ordinary Life, we considered how belonging and significance accumulate through repeated experiences. An ordinary routine can contain judgment, affection, curiosity and skill. It may be a form of life carefully developed around things a person values.

Conversely, someone with constant opportunities for novelty may feel compelled to pursue them without discovering why they matter. Travel, professional success and public recognition do not automatically establish a meaningful relationship with one’s own existence.

Freedom is not simply the availability of a larger number of activities.

It includes the ability to recognize those activities we would willingly participate in, understand some of our reasons for participating and reconsider our arrangements when those reasons no longer apply.

The gardener may choose the same patch of soil again tomorrow.

That choice can matter more than its resemblance to the choice made yesterday.

When our decisions become inherited instructions

A young man enters a profession admired by his family.

At first, he is pleased by the opportunity. He has worked hard to obtain it, and the people close to him have made sacrifices to support his education. Their happiness at his achievement becomes part of his own.

As the years pass, however, he discovers that the work demands things he finds increasingly difficult to endorse. His interests have developed elsewhere. He sometimes imagines remaining within the profession in a different capacity or pursuing something entirely unrelated to it.

What prevents him from examining these possibilities is not only the uncertainty of change.

It is his difficulty in distinguishing what he currently wants from what he has learned a person in his position ought to want.

Human beings do not develop their ambitions in isolation. Families, communities, economic conditions and educational opportunities influence our understanding of what is possible and desirable. We owe much of our capacity to act to people whose guidance preceded our independence.

But an ambition inherited from people we love does not have to remain unchanged in order for their contribution to retain its value.

The questions raised in An Open Letter to Those Who Adapt Until They Disappear have a personal counterpart here. The effort to satisfy expectations can become so familiar that an individual loses opportunities to examine the commitments directing their own behavior.

Reconsidering an inherited instruction is not necessarily rejecting the people who gave it.

Sometimes it involves asking whether their earlier advice still serves the purpose for which it was offered. A parent may have hoped their child would become secure, independent or capable of contributing to the world. Those aims may remain meaningful even if the route originally imagined changes.

The young man need not resign immediately. He can begin by making an honest inquiry into what his work means to him now.

The ability to ask that question belongs to his life, even if the answer does not produce a dramatic decision.

What happens when we stop forming preferences

A group of friends is deciding where to spend an evening.

One person says that anything is fine. Another suggests a place, and the first agrees. On the following occasion, the same thing happens.

There may be nothing wrong with this arrangement. Perhaps the person enjoys several possibilities equally or takes pleasure in allowing others to choose.

But suppose the habit extends beyond such minor decisions. Whenever someone asks what they would prefer, they first attempt to establish what answer will cause the least inconvenience.

Eventually, they may find the question itself uncomfortable.

The loss of a preference can be difficult to notice because it does not always produce conflict. Indeed, someone who rarely expresses a wish may be admired for being agreeable.

Within a relationship, this can conceal a growing inequality. The more confident person continues learning what they enjoy through the experience of making decisions. The accommodating person receives fewer opportunities to do the same.

There are circumstances in which expressing a preference is genuinely unsafe. Somebody dependent upon an unpredictable or controlling person may need to be strategic about what they reveal. Silence in such a situation can be protective rather than evidence of an insufficiently developed personality.

In relationships where respectful disagreement is possible, however, it can be worth allowing a small preference to become visible.

Choosing a book, suggesting a different route or acknowledging that we would rather spend an evening at home may seem insignificant. Such decisions offer occasions to practice noticing what actually matters to us.

Not every preference has to be fulfilled. Other people have needs of their own, and relationships involve negotiation.

But a preference that can never be acknowledged cannot meaningfully enter that negotiation.

The quiet loss of emotional involvement

There are periods when people find it difficult to feel interested in things that once attracted them.

The difficulty may follow sustained pressure, grief, illness, burnout or experiences that have demanded an extraordinary amount of emotional energy. Sometimes its causes are not immediately clear.

A person may continue working, speaking politely and caring for other people while feeling strangely distant from the activities they are carrying out.

It would be a mistake to treat that experience as a moral failure or to assume that the individual simply needs a more interesting schedule.

Persistent emotional numbness, exhaustion or loss of interest can deserve attention from a qualified health professional, especially when these experiences interfere with daily functioning. Support, treatment, rest and changes in difficult circumstances may all have a place. A philosophical reflection cannot determine the cause of such experiences in a particular person.

There is also a distinction between a temporary reduction in emotional intensity and an enduring sense that our activities no longer engage us.

A person does not have to feel enthusiastic about life every morning. Some commitments remain valuable through periods in which participation requires effort rather than excitement. A quiet or tired temperament is not necessarily evidence of a problem.

In our first reflection, What Does It Really Mean to Live?, we questioned the idea that a worthwhile life must continually feel pleasant. The distinction matters here because engagement is not identical to happiness.

We can be deeply involved in something difficult. We can feel sadness while recognizing the importance of a relationship. We can care about a task whose completion offers very little immediate pleasure.

Being engaged with life does not mean maintaining an elevated emotional state.

It may mean retaining a relationship with the things that matter to us, even when our ability to feel their importance is uneven.

The conditions that make participation possible

Imagine a worker who has very little influence over a constantly changing schedule.

On some weeks, their working hours prevent them from attending family gatherings. On others, they are too exhausted to participate in activities they might otherwise enjoy. They cannot make a dependable arrangement with a friend because they do not know when their next shift will be assigned.

Telling this person to take greater control of their life would not necessarily provide the conditions through which such control becomes possible.

Money, health, safety, time and assistance influence our practical freedom. So does the ability to rely on arrangements made by other people.

A person may care deeply about their family and possess very few opportunities to act on that affection in the way they wish. Someone may have a strong interest in study without having reliable access to the resources required to pursue it.

Those limitations do not mean their lives are of lesser value.

They do mean that meaningful participation is partly a collective concern. Workplaces, households and public institutions can expand or restrict the possibilities available to individuals.

We may be able to help someone live more fully not by offering them inspiring advice but by taking a fair share of a difficult responsibility, making an environment accessible or allowing them a predictable period of rest.

The freedom to sit beside a friend or become involved in a personal interest often rests upon arrangements that extend beyond the moment itself.

If we care about the distance between living and existing, we should care about the circumstances that make that distance difficult for some people to cross.

Becoming responsible for a small decision

One Saturday, the woman who traveled by train decided to visit the library near the station.

She had no particular reason for going. She had not identified a subject she needed to study, and there was nothing she intended to accomplish before leaving.

She walked through the building, found a shelf of books about the surrounding region and discovered an old map showing the river.

The following week, she followed part of the riverside path.

Neither experience changed her employment, her financial circumstances or the relationships she maintained. She did not acquire a new identity as a traveler or a devoted reader of local history.

What changed was the reason for her presence in those places. She was there because a question of her own had led her there.

This kind of decision does not require us to dismiss larger ambitions. Sometimes a substantial transformation is necessary, and a small activity will not address the circumstances causing a person distress.

Yet there is value in identifying decisions that are both genuinely available and recognizably ours.

A person might decide to resume a conversation they have missed, change the way they spend an occasional evening or ask whether a responsibility can be shared differently.

They may discover that the choice brings little satisfaction. That information matters too. Participating in a life includes discovering that an imagined possibility has less meaning than we expected.

As explored in When Life Does Not Follow the Plan, our ability to respond to changing circumstances need not depend upon constructing a complete new future. Sometimes it begins with discovering what can still be decided within the present.

The railway passenger could not predict where her growing curiosity would lead.

For the first time in a while, she found the uncertainty interesting.

A life that remains open to revision

The desire to live more fully can become another pressure if we interpret it as a requirement to continually improve ourselves.

There will be periods when maintaining existing arrangements is the most reasonable thing we can do. There will be occasions when a familiar routine provides comfort precisely because we do not need to reconsider it.

Not every silence conceals a lost ambition. Not every quiet existence waits for someone to rescue it through adventure.

Perhaps the more useful question is whether the arrangements of our lives remain open to examination.

Can we recognize when an earlier decision no longer reflects the person we have become? Can we express a need without treating it as a failure of generosity? Can we pursue something meaningful without demanding that it transform every other part of our existence?

The answers may differ according to our circumstances.

On Monday morning, the woman bought the same railway ticket she had been buying for eleven years.

She took it to the same platform and traveled to the office where her colleagues expected her. Her life had not become outwardly extraordinary.

But on the return journey, she looked up when the train approached the river.

She could see a portion of the path she had followed over the weekend. Beyond it lay a part of town she still did not know.

She began wondering what was there.

The distance between living and existing cannot be measured in the number of countries we visit, the ambitions we fulfill or the experiences we find exciting. It is not a judgment to pass upon somebody whose circumstances we cannot fully understand.

It concerns our relationship with the days that belong to us, the people beside us and the possibilities we are able to recognize.

Sometimes that relationship involves accepting a commitment again. Sometimes it means asking whether a commitment needs to change. Sometimes it requires help, courage or conditions we cannot establish alone.

And sometimes, on an entirely ordinary journey home, it begins with a question that has finally become our own.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top