How Does Overthinking Change a Person? The Station of a Thousand Departures

How does overthinking change a person? A railway employee haunted by journeys she never made must confront how years of regret have reshaped her relationships and her everyday life.

The Station of a Thousand Departures — ornamental gold-lettered title cover

The first train left without her at six fourteen.

The second left at six forty.

By eight, Adela Finch had watched seven trains depart from the station, although the only one she needed to catch was the eight twelve to Bellhaven.

She had bought its ticket three weeks earlier. She had packed a bag, watered the plants and asked her neighbor to collect the newspaper while she was away. Inside the bag was a blue dress she intended to wear to her brother’s wedding.

On her telephone was a message from her brother.

Can’t wait to see you.

Adela read it again.

She wondered whether he meant that he was pleased she would be there or that he was worried she might not come. There was no useful way to distinguish the two possibilities from the message. She nevertheless devoted several minutes to the attempt.

Then she checked her ticket.

The train would leave from platform five.

She knew the station well. She had worked there for fourteen years.

At the entrance to the platform, she stopped.

In the glass panel of the waiting room, she saw a reflection of a woman carrying a little green suitcase.

The woman’s face resembled hers.

The suitcase resembled one she had abandoned in a cupboard twenty years earlier.

The woman stepped onto a train that was no longer operating.

Adela closed her eyes.

When she opened them, the glass contained only her own reflection.

The eight twelve was being announced.

She went back to the ticket hall.


The station had been built near the mouth of a river. The older of its two buildings contained a vaulted roof, broad windows and a collection of wooden benches which generations of passengers had found unnecessarily hard.

Adela arrived there at twenty-three, after obtaining a position in the passenger information office.

She liked the work. She enjoyed learning the routes, helping people understand unfamiliar arrangements and solving problems that could be resolved with accurate information.

A passenger who missed a connection might need to know when another train left. A person traveling with a large suitcase might need help locating an accessible route through the station. Sometimes she could provide the information immediately. Sometimes she needed to consult a colleague.

The work was especially satisfying when somebody arrived at the office convinced that a difficult journey had come to an end and left it knowing what to do next.

Adela’s supervisor, Mervyn, taught her to distinguish between the things the office knew, the things someone else could establish and the things that could not yet be predicted.

When passengers asked whether a delayed train would definitely arrive at a particular time, she explained what the available information indicated and when they might obtain an update.

Mervyn disliked giving assurances for which the office had no basis.

“People can do something with an honest answer,” he told her.

Adela remembered the advice.

She followed it at work.

Outside the station, she increasingly found an honest answer unsatisfactory if it contained the words I don’t know.


The change began with a journey she made when she was twenty-seven.

Her mother, Florence, had been unwell. Adela arranged to travel to the town where her parents lived on a Friday afternoon. She had planned to stay for the weekend.

Before she left her apartment, her father called. Florence had been admitted to hospital. She was being assessed by the people responsible for her care.

Adela took the next available train.

During the journey, she received another call.

Her mother had died.

She sat beside the window for the remainder of the journey. A field passed, followed by a little town whose name she could not remember. There was a man sitting opposite her who was reading a newspaper.

Adela remembered the newspaper rather better than the man’s face.

Over the following months, she returned repeatedly to the morning of the journey.

If she had left before breakfast, she might have arrived earlier.

If she had visited the previous weekend, she might have spent more time with her mother.

If she had asked a different question during their last conversation, she might have learned something about the way Florence was feeling.

There were things Adela knew about her mother’s illness. There were things she did not know. There was no basis for concluding that her presence would have changed the medical outcome.

But she missed her mother.

The possibility of an earlier train became a particularly painful detail because she could imagine buying its ticket.

At certain moments, her mind seemed to present the existence of that earlier train as evidence that another ending had been available to her.

She began keeping the timetables from journeys she made.

She was not sure why.


Her brother, Peter, was three years younger.

After their mother’s death, he remained in Bellhaven for several months, helping their father with practical arrangements. He subsequently moved to another town and found employment at a school.

The siblings spoke regularly.

Then Peter became busy with work. Adela was promoted to a supervisory position at the railway station. Their father moved into a smaller house.

Their conversations changed.

There were periods in which they telephoned each other frequently and other periods in which weeks passed.

Adela sometimes found it difficult to call Peter.

She wanted to know whether he was managing his responsibilities, whether he missed their mother as she did and whether the two of them remembered the final months of her illness in similar ways.

She also wanted to make sure she did not make him sad by asking about those things.

She constructed conversations in which he became impatient. She constructed others in which he appeared grateful. On one memorable afternoon she imagined discovering that Peter was disappointed with her for a reason he had never expressed.

By the time she had considered all these possibilities, she no longer wanted to speak.

She sent a message asking how he was.

He replied that he was fine.

Sometimes she was comforted.

Sometimes she examined the word fine until it acquired an entirely different meaning.

She remembered a story about a postal worker, The Envelope With No Address, whose habit of preparing for responses she feared had left relatively little opportunity for the people around her to supply responses of their own.

Adela understood the predicament.

She wished that understanding it made a telephone call easier.


During her thirtieth year, the railway company introduced a new passenger information system.

The system recorded changes to departures and enabled the staff to update displays more efficiently. Adela contributed to the training arrangements.

She was conscientious.

She was also becoming increasingly reluctant to finish certain tasks.

After completing the required checks on an information notice, she might review it again. She would sometimes return to the office after leaving to establish whether she had put a document in the correct place.

On one evening, her colleague Nabil found her sitting in front of a record that had already been reviewed by two people.

“What’s wrong with it?”

“Nothing I’ve found.”

He looked at the clock.

“Do you expect to find something?”

She said she wanted to be certain.

Nabil asked what the additional review would establish.

Adela was annoyed.

She knew that accuracy mattered at a railway station. She knew that even a comparatively small error could inconvenience a passenger.

Nabil agreed.

He also pointed out that the notice had been checked according to the appropriate arrangements, and that if a specific concern arose they could investigate it.

Adela went home.

She continued worrying about the notice.

The next day, when it proved to be accurate, she felt relieved.

There was a curious consequence.

She attributed part of the relief to the additional checking, even though that checking had not changed anything.

Over time, the activities she performed to feel less uncertain became increasingly difficult to omit.

She began arriving early.

She stopped attending a drawing class she enjoyed.

She declined invitations to supper because she believed she had work to do.

The work was becoming less efficient.

Her efforts to protect herself from making mistakes were beginning to make her tired enough to make them.


The first unusual reflection appeared in winter.

Adela was waiting in the old station building at the end of her shift.

In the glass of a disused ticket booth, she saw a woman wearing a red coat. The woman looked younger than Adela and carried a bag with a torn handle.

Adela recognized the coat.

She had worn it on the journey during which her mother died.

The reflected woman stepped into the corridor beside a platform sign that had been removed years earlier.

Adela turned.

The corridor was empty.

She told Nabil about the experience. He listened and suggested that she arrange to speak to a qualified health professional, particularly because she had been sleeping badly and the experience distressed her.

She did.

They discussed her circumstances, the recurring thoughts about her mother and the appropriate assessment and support available.

Adela continued working within the arrangements agreed with the people concerned.

The reflection did not return for several weeks.

Then she saw a younger version of herself buying a ticket at the counter.

On another occasion, she saw Peter sitting on a bench with a green suitcase.

He had not used the station for years.

The images were brief. They did not appear to be visible to the people around her.

Adela did not know whether they were associated with the building, her own experiences or some combination of circumstances she could not explain.

She began writing down what she remembered instead of attempting to establish the explanation while standing in the station.

One afternoon, she described the images to Mervyn, who had retired but still lived nearby.

He told her that the old building contained a number of stories about people seeing journeys they had not made.

He did not know whether any were reliable.

Then he invited her to have tea.

She accepted.

For the first time in weeks, she spent an afternoon discussing things other than the station.


Peter announced his engagement in March.

He was marrying a woman named Imogen whom Adela had met twice.

She liked Imogen.

She was delighted by the announcement.

Then she began imagining the wedding.

There would be relatives she had not seen for several years. There would be conversations about their mother. There would be photographs.

She wanted to arrive early enough to help Peter with whatever needed doing.

She also wanted to avoid making him feel that she thought he could not manage the arrangements.

Peter explained that the wedding would be small, that he had arranged accommodation for her, and that she did not need to bring anything except herself.

Adela bought the ticket.

Then she began reviewing other possible journeys.

She could travel on Thursday instead of Friday. She could take a different train. She could ask her father to meet her at the station, although she did not want him to make a special journey.

She read the information about the route.

There was no significant difficulty.

She nevertheless returned to it almost every evening.

Once she found a little green suitcase in a cupboard and considered whether it would be suitable.

It had belonged to her during college. She remembered carrying it on trips to see her parents.

She sat beside it for a long time.

The wedding seemed to concern several things she could not distinguish from one another.

She was proud of Peter.

She missed their mother.

She was worried about getting there.

She was especially worried about discovering that, after all the preparations, the occasion would contain something painful she had not anticipated.

She thought of the clockmaker in The Clockmaker of Impossible Tuesdays, who tried to arrange a decision so that no uncertainty remained before he made it.

She downloaded the timetable for the fourth time.

Then she deleted the earlier copies.


On the morning of the journey, Adela arrived at the station considerably earlier than necessary.

She bought coffee.

She watched several trains depart.

When she saw the woman with the green suitcase, she became frightened.

For a moment she thought the reflection was showing her a journey she ought to have made.

She looked for it again.

There was nothing unusual in the glass.

The eight twelve was announced.

Adela returned to the ticket hall.

Nabil was standing near the information desk. He was surprised to see her.

“Aren’t you supposed to be going somewhere?”

“Yes.”

She told him that she was finding the journey difficult.

He listened.

Then he asked whether she wanted to sit down, contact someone or obtain appropriate assistance.

She said she wanted to call Peter.

They found a quiet place.

Peter answered on the third attempt.

Adela heard voices in the background.

“Everything all right?”

She began to apologize.

Then she stopped.

She told him that she was at the station and felt frightened about traveling. She was thinking a great deal about their mother.

Peter was quiet.

“Me too,” he said.

The words surprised her.

She had spent several months trying to determine whether he would want their mother mentioned on the wedding day.

He had apparently been thinking about her without Adela’s assistance.

They talked for several minutes.

He said that he wanted her there. He also said that if she could not travel that morning, they could investigate another arrangement.

Adela laughed.

“You’re getting married tomorrow.”

“Yes, that’s why I can’t come and get you this minute.”

She laughed again.

After ending the call, she spoke to Nabil.

She checked the status of the train.

It was still expected to depart from platform five.

She wanted to attempt the journey.

Nabil offered to walk with her to the platform.

She accepted.


The train arrived.

Adela found her seat.

For the first few minutes, she watched the passengers putting bags on shelves and arranging coats.

Then she looked through the window.

The information board disappeared behind the buildings of the station.

She was traveling.

She did not feel particularly relieved.

She thought of the earlier journey, and the call from her father, and the green suitcase.

A passenger opposite her opened a newspaper.

Adela felt tears come.

She sat quietly.

After a while, a member of staff asked whether she needed anything.

She said she was all right, then asked for some water.

She was grateful for it.

The landscape changed.

She had been trying, for years, to understand what would have happened had she taken an earlier train on the morning of her mother’s death.

Now she was sitting on another train, traveling toward an occasion at which her mother would not be present.

The second fact was more painful than many of the questions she had been asking.

It was also a fact she could acknowledge without needing to resolve it.

She remembered the former rescue officer in The Suit That No Longer Fit, whose loss had changed the meaning of familiar routines.

Adela’s routines had changed too.

She had begun treating ordinary departures as occasions on which something might happen that she ought to prevent.

She did not know what to do about all of those feelings.

She could continue discussing them with the professional she had been seeing.

She could also look through the window.

A little town passed.

This time she noticed its name.


Peter was waiting at Bellhaven.

He hugged her.

Then he asked whether she wanted to go to the hotel or have something to eat.

She wanted food.

They found a café.

For several minutes Peter described a complication involving the wedding flowers. Imogen’s aunt had apparently assumed that she was responsible for an arrangement that somebody else had already made.

Adela listened.

Then she laughed.

She had imagined many difficult conversations.

It had not occurred to her to anticipate this one.

Peter asked whether she was enjoying her work.

She told him about the information system, the things she liked and the occasions on which she found it difficult to stop thinking about what she had done during the day.

He listened.

Then he said that he sometimes thought about their mother’s final illness too.

He did not remember the last conversation with her clearly.

For a long time, this had troubled him.

Adela asked whether he wanted to discuss it.

He said yes, for a little while.

They did.

He remembered several things she had forgotten.

She remembered things he did not.

They could not reconstruct the whole period.

They did not try.

When the food arrived, Peter began describing the restaurant where they were having the wedding meal.

Adela was interested.

Later, she helped Imogen prepare several small gifts for the guests. Her father came to the hotel. There were conversations about Florence, and conversations about flowers, and a remarkably long discussion of the weather.

At the wedding, Adela wore the blue dress.

She was sad when she saw the empty place where she imagined her mother sitting.

She was happy when Peter smiled.

The two feelings occurred within the same few seconds.

She did not need to decide which was more legitimate.


During the following year, Adela began changing several of her arrangements.

She discussed the difficulties she experienced at work with the relevant people. She continued following the agreed checks, while recognizing when a particular concern could be addressed through an appropriate process rather than repeated reviews undertaken alone.

She continued obtaining professional support.

Some changes were difficult.

When she left the office after completing the work, she sometimes felt an intense desire to return. She learned to notice what she was worried about, distinguish specific practical problems from recurring uncertainty and discuss persistent distress with the people supporting her.

She resumed attending the drawing class.

Her first picture was of the station roof.

She had drawn the arches incorrectly.

A member of the class explained the difficulty.

Adela made another attempt.

She had forgotten how enjoyable it could be to make a mistake in a room where a person could do something interesting with it.

She also started calling Peter occasionally without first deciding what they would discuss.

Sometimes he was busy.

Sometimes they talked for forty minutes.

Once he called to say that he and Imogen were expecting a child.

Adela cried.

Then she asked whether they wanted her to visit.

She was pleased when they did.

The strange reflections became less frequent, although she did not establish what had caused them. She retained her notes and discussed them appropriately when needed.

She stopped trying to determine whether each image represented a journey she ought to have made.

She remembered the parliament clerk in The Parliament of Unfinished Questions, who had learned that repeated deliberation could obscure the practical questions that mattered.

There were journeys Adela wished she had made.

There were journeys she wanted to make now.

The second group was not going to wait indefinitely for her to finish examining the first.


On a bright morning two years later, Adela helped a passenger who had missed a train.

The man was upset.

He had intended to arrive in another town before noon, and the delay would complicate his plans.

Adela explained the available alternatives.

He considered them.

Then he bought a ticket for a later service.

“That’ll have to do.”

She smiled.

At the end of her shift, she bought a ticket for Bellhaven.

Peter’s daughter was celebrating her first birthday.

Adela had arranged to stay for two nights.

She knew the journey.

She knew the things she needed to consider.

She also knew that she might feel worried despite having considered them.

Overthinking had changed her in ways she scarcely recognized while they were occurring. It had made familiar tasks exhausting, interfered with her sleep, altered the way she interpreted conversations and reduced the time she spent doing things she enjoyed. Some of the habits had grown out of grief, some out of conscientiousness, some out of a wish to avoid further mistakes.

They had helped her feel briefly safer.

They had not made every future event more predictable.

Recovery was not a single departure from the station. There were occasions on which she returned to familiar patterns, and occasions on which she needed additional help.

She was learning to recognize them.

At platform five, she looked into the glass.

For a moment she thought she saw the green suitcase.

Then a passenger walked past carrying a bag of almost exactly the same color.

Adela smiled.

The train arrived.

She climbed aboard.

In her bag was a small present for her niece, wrapped in blue paper.

There was no particular reason to examine it again.

Editorial note: Original psychological drama with magical-realist elements. All characters, locations, institutions and events are invented. Overthinking can involve repetitive worry, rumination and attempts to obtain certainty that may affect concentration, sleep, relationships and enjoyment of activities. It can coexist with appropriate planning and conscientiousness. Experiences vary across individuals. Persistent distress, unusual perceptions or difficulties with daily functioning warrant appropriate assessment and support from a qualified health professional.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top