An Open Letter to Those Who Call It a Choice

A fictional woman responds to a familiar judgment after an emergency purchase leaves her household in financial difficulty. Examining the difference between genuine agency and hindsight, this letter asks us to consider the options, resources and uncertainties people faced when making decisions rather than judging them solely by their eventual consequences.

An Open Letter to Those Who Call It a Choice in dark serif lettering on vintage parchment.

Dear people who tell me that I made a choice,

You are right. I stood in the appliance shop on a wet Wednesday afternoon and signed an agreement to purchase a refrigerator. The salesperson did not hold my hand over the page. I read the amount I would have to pay each month, asked a question about delivery and accepted the terms. When the expense began to cause difficulties several months later, a relative reminded me that nobody had forced me to sign. I could hardly dispute the fact. I had been there.

The woman writing this letter, her household and the events surrounding the purchase are fictional. This is not advice about borrowing or a description of a particular lender. I have imagined an ordinary transaction because its eventual consequences invite a kind of judgment that we recognize in many other parts of life.

Our refrigerator had stopped working on Monday. My daughter discovered the problem when she opened the door before school. The interior was warmer than the kitchen, and a shallow pool of water had collected beneath the vegetable drawer. I telephoned a repair service and received an estimate that I could not immediately afford. The repairer explained that he would need to examine the machine before establishing whether it was worth repairing. The visit itself would cost something, whether he could fix the refrigerator or not.

I had a little money in reserve. It was not enough to buy a new refrigerator outright, and I had been putting it aside for an insurance payment due the following month. I had nobody nearby with space to store our food indefinitely. My working hours made shopping for fresh supplies every day awkward. For two evenings I managed with a few groceries bought on the way home and a container of ice that a neighbor kindly provided. I could have continued in that fashion for a while. I could not establish how long it would remain practical.

At the shop there was a model I could take delivery of the next morning. The arrangement offered monthly installments, and the total amount payable was greater than the price for an immediate purchase. I understood that difference. I also understood the value of a working refrigerator arriving before the weekend. I calculated that my regular wages would cover the installments if the rest of my expenses continued as expected.

They did not. The following spring my employer reduced the number of hours available to several people in my department. I found additional work eventually, but by then I had fallen behind on more than one household payment. It was during that interval that the relative made his observation about the agreement. He told me that he would never have purchased the refrigerator on those terms.

I have thought a great deal about what he meant. Was he telling me that, with his own savings and circumstances, he would have made a different decision? Was he telling me that he would have made a different decision if he had known what would happen to my wages? Or was he telling me that, standing in the same shop with the same amount of money and knowing what I knew on that Wednesday, he would have found a better course of action?

These are three different claims, and I might have been interested in discussing the last one.

When somebody refers to a decision as a choice, the word can serve several useful purposes. It acknowledges that a person has acted rather than merely been acted upon. It allows us to consider what the person understood, what alternatives were available and whether a different decision might have produced a better result. I would not wish to lose these possibilities. I have made mistakes, and I want to retain the capacity to learn from them.

But sometimes the word is offered in place of such an examination. It becomes a way of declaring that the circumstances surrounding a decision need not interest us anymore. Once we have established that a person participated in the act, we treat the whole of its consequences as an adequate description of what that person intended or deserved.

I am reminded of the distinction explored in the illusion of choice, where participants in a public consultation are offered alternatives within a question whose boundaries they did not determine. My own situation was not quite like that. Nobody had designed the particular combination of difficulties I encountered that week. The available alternatives were real, and I was entitled to select among them. The question is what those alternatives required of the person selecting them.

Waiting for a repair would have involved paying for an assessment without knowing what the assessment would establish. Buying a secondhand machine might have been cheaper, but the examples I found required arrangements for collection and offered differing degrees of reassurance about their condition. Going without a refrigerator would have postponed the expense while creating other costs and inconveniences. Buying a new one in installments offered immediate certainty about one part of the situation in exchange for uncertainty about another.

Perhaps a more resourceful person would have found an alternative I overlooked. I can accept that possibility without accepting the conclusion that such a person was available to inhabit my Wednesday afternoon. A person deciding under pressure has limited time, imperfect information and a particular history of experience. An observer examining the situation months later has an important advantage. She knows which uncertainty turned out to matter.

That advantage can make a retrospective judgment feel wonderfully simple. If the secondhand refrigerator works for ten years, buying it looks like evidence of thrift. If it fails after two weeks, the same purchase may look careless. If the installments are paid comfortably, the new refrigerator becomes an example of practical household management. If the purchaser loses wages, the transaction is remembered as the beginning of an avoidable difficulty. We are tempted to assign the wisdom of a decision according to an event that had not yet occurred when the decision was made.

Of course, some risks can be recognized beforehand. The possibility of a reduction in earnings was not unimaginable, even if I had no particular reason to expect it that spring. A careful person must consider adverse outcomes rather than assuming the most convenient future. I wish I had spent more time examining how the payments would fit into a less favorable month. I wish I had obtained another repair estimate. These are meaningful observations about my conduct. They do not establish that I could have arranged a life in which the refrigerator never failed and my wages never changed.

The mechanic in the fear of falling considers the distance between an ordinary risk and a ruinous consequence. That distance depends on the resources available to absorb an unfortunate outcome. A person with several months of savings may be able to wait for an assessment, replace an unreliable secondhand appliance or meet a payment after an unexpected reduction in earnings. A person with a smaller reserve has to be more careful, even as her ability to purchase the conditions for careful decision making becomes more limited.

I would like us to talk about that difficulty without turning every person who experiences it into an innocent child. I am an adult. I made an agreement, and I understood that it created an obligation. A community in which decisions have no consequences would be a difficult place in which to establish mutual trust. My argument is not that constraints remove all responsibility. It is that responsibility should be considered alongside them, rather than used to make them disappear.

There are kinds of support that preserve the significance of a person’s decision while improving the circumstances in which it can be made. Clear information about costs allows a purchaser to compare arrangements. Reliable repair services make an assessment less uncertain. Access to emergency assistance may give a household a little time to investigate alternatives before signing anything. A reasonable way to discuss changed circumstances can prevent an unfortunate outcome from becoming a permanent exclusion from ordinary services.

These possibilities concern the quality of the situation in which a person acts. They do not require somebody else to decide which refrigerator belongs in my kitchen. In fact, they may give me a better opportunity to make a decision of my own.

The coordinator in when compliance replaces consent discovers that an apparently voluntary signature cannot establish whether a person welcomed every condition attached to it. My signature was quite deliberate. Nevertheless, its existence tells us very little about the value of the alternatives I declined. I wanted a working appliance, not necessarily the form of payment that made obtaining one possible. It matters that I agreed to that form of payment. It also matters why it became attractive.

For those who administer the systems through which we make consequential decisions, I have a particular request. When you encounter a recurring pattern of difficulty, do not begin and end your investigation by counting the number of people who voluntarily entered an arrangement. Ask what they were attempting to obtain, what other arrangements were reasonably accessible and what happened when their expectations proved inaccurate. If many people are accepting expensive terms to meet a similar need, an examination of the need may reveal something that an examination of their individual judgment cannot.

For those of us who observe other people’s decisions from a little distance, the work is more intimate. We can try to reconstruct the moment before its outcome became known. What did the person believe would happen? What would waiting have required? Which alternatives were available in practice, rather than merely imaginable? What obligations to other people shaped the decision? We might still conclude that a mistake was made. Our conclusion will at least belong to the circumstances in which the mistake occurred.

The reflection on the price of stability asks how a useful arrangement can become difficult to leave when several necessities depend upon it. I was attempting to preserve a small part of the dependable life I had built for my daughter and myself. In doing so, I accepted a new obligation. The exchange appeared manageable on Wednesday and became burdensome the following spring. Both descriptions are true. Neither can be substituted for the other.

A year after the purchase, my daughter stuck a drawing to the refrigerator with a small round magnet. It showed a house with an unusually large window, a tree and two people standing beside a table. I remember her asking me to move the drawing a little higher so that she could attach another one beneath it. I did so. I was glad that the refrigerator worked. I was also glad that the difficult period of payments was approaching its end.

I do not want the object in my kitchen to become a monument to either my wisdom or my foolishness. It is a refrigerator. I purchased it because I needed one, under circumstances that I understood imperfectly and could not entirely control. There are things I would do differently now. There are things I would like to be different about the arrangements available to the next person standing in that shop.

So please continue to call my decision a choice. Just do not use the word to finish a conversation that ought to begin with it.

With respect for the decisions we make, and for the circumstances within which we must make them,

A woman who remembers the Wednesday before she knew the spring.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top