Why Do People Struggle With Envy? The Violin Behind the Wall

Why do people struggle with envy? A violinist preparing for a career-defining audition discovers that his fiercest competitor has moved into the apartment next door.

The Violin Behind the Wall — gold-lettered ornamental story cover

Why do people struggle with envy? Envy can arise when another person’s advantage brings attention to something we want but do not have. The feeling can be painful, particularly when the comparison concerns an important ambition or part of our identity. Research by van de Ven, Zeelenberg and Pieters (2009) distinguishes between envy that motivates people to improve their own position and envy that motivates them to diminish another person’s advantage. How we respond to the feeling matters more than pretending we never experience it.


During a rehearsal in the days before the audition, a violin began playing behind the wall of my apartment.

The passage was one I knew intimately: twelve measures from the piece I had been practicing for six months. I had spent the entire afternoon trying to make the last note sound as though it belonged to the beginning of the next phrase.

The person on the other side of the wall was making it sound effortless.

I put down my bow.

Then I heard the musician stop, repeat two notes, and begin again.

That was how I discovered that the new tenant in apartment twelve was my closest competitor.

Her name was Elara Moss.

Two weeks earlier, we had been shortlisted for a position in the same chamber ensemble.

I wanted to know why she had chosen this building. I wanted to know whether she was practicing the same version of the piece I was practicing.

Most of all, I wanted her to make a mistake.

When she did, I laughed.

It was a small, spiteful laugh, and nobody was present to hear it.

Except, of course, the woman on the other side of the wall.

She stopped playing.

Then she knocked.

When I opened the door, she asked whether it was a bad time to practice. I told her it wasn’t. She thanked me and went back to her apartment. I closed the door, ashamed that she had mistaken my laughter for a sign that she was disturbing me.

A note held too long

I grew up in a town that had one music school and a violin teacher who liked competitions.

My name is Nathan Rell.

When I was eleven, I could play several pieces that impressed adults who did not play the violin. My teacher was pleased. My mother was particularly delighted by the fact that a child who spent so much time making noises nobody could enjoy had begun making noises that somebody could enjoy.

There were four children in my class.

We took turns performing at little gatherings in the hall above the school.

One afternoon a girl called Rachel played a piece that I had recently learned.

She played it better than I did.

I knew this before the teacher said so. The sound possessed a quality I had been trying to reproduce. I was astonished that Rachel could make it happen.

I also wanted the teacher to find something wrong with it.

The teacher said that Rachel had made considerable progress.

I felt miserable.

On the journey home, my mother asked why I was quiet.

I told her that I was tired.

She believed me.

For the next fortnight, I tried to discover how Rachel produced the sound. I listened carefully. I asked my teacher about the relevant passage. I practiced.

My playing improved.

There were occasions in which another person’s success gave me a piece of information about something I wanted to learn.

There were also occasions in which I experienced the success principally as information about the distance between what I was and what I hoped to be.

I learned to distinguish these experiences much later.

At nineteen, I was admitted to a conservatory. The other students could do things with instruments that I had not imagined possible.

For most of my first autumn, I was alternately delighted and horrified by this discovery.

I began making friends.

Then I began making comparisons.

The apartment with the thin walls

Elara moved into apartment twelve on a Saturday.

The building stood beside a tramline that rattled the windows whenever a large vehicle passed. It was inexpensive by the standards of the city, and several people who worked in the arts lived there at different times.

She had obtained the apartment through a friend.

We recognized each other when I opened my door.

“Nathan?”

“Elara.”

She smiled.

“Sorry about the noise.”

I told her that I was accustomed to hearing instruments in the building.

She asked whether the audition piece was mine too.

I nodded.

There were several required excerpts. Each candidate also prepared a piece of their choice. We had selected the same one.

Elara laughed.

“That’s going to be interesting.”

I did not laugh.

I imagined hearing her practice every evening until the audition. I imagined losing sleep. I imagined discovering precisely how much better she was.

She asked whether I wanted to discuss an arrangement for practicing at different times.

I agreed.

We established times that suited us reasonably well while taking account of the building’s rules and the needs of other residents.

Then she asked whether I knew a shop nearby where she could obtain a particular item.

I showed her the route.

For a moment she was simply a person who had moved into an unfamiliar building and wanted to buy something.

As soon as I closed my door, she became the person who could get the job I wanted.

What the job meant

The chamber ensemble had been established in Port Aven thirty years earlier.

I attended its concerts whenever I could. It was known for programming music from different periods and performing arrangements that made me hear familiar pieces in unfamiliar ways.

I wanted to join it for several reasons.

The work itself appealed to me. The position would provide a more predictable income than the collection of engagements I was currently undertaking. I would be able to plan ahead. I could reduce the amount of teaching I did and spend more time performing.

It was not simply a matter of pride.

Then there was pride.

Two musicians with whom I attended the conservatory had already obtained positions in ensembles. An acquaintance had recently received an award. My closest friend, Jules, was preparing to record a collection of pieces he had written.

I was pleased for them.

Sometimes.

I found it difficult to describe the different feelings that occurred when somebody announced an achievement.

There was pleasure that an expensive course, a difficult rehearsal or a long-held ambition had led to something the person wanted.

Then there was a sudden sensation of being left behind.

I thought of the young architect in The Architect of the Second City, whose efforts to establish her competence eventually made it difficult for her to express the things she did not know.

I had a similar difficulty whenever a musician spoke about something that interested me.

If the musician knew more than I did, I could listen.

I could also spend the conversation trying to provide evidence that I knew something too.

Jules once described an arrangement he had written.

I pointed out a difficulty associated with playing one of its passages.

He examined the passage.

“Good point.”

I should have been pleased that I had made a useful observation.

Instead I was particularly pleased that the arrangement had a difficulty.

The distinction was not especially flattering.

The photograph

Three days after Elara moved into the building, the ensemble posted photographs of the shortlisted musicians.

Elara appeared in the second photograph.

She was standing beside a window in a dark dress, holding her violin.

The caption mentioned several of the performances in which she had participated.

I examined the list.

Two engagements were at places I particularly wanted to perform.

One was a competition at which I had been unsuccessful.

The photograph received a large number of favorable comments.

Mine received fewer.

I began examining the comments with a level of attention that I had not devoted to the music that afternoon.

A person I knew had congratulated Elara.

He had not congratulated me.

For several minutes I tried to identify the significance of the omission.

Then I opened a recording of her playing.

I wanted to find a mistake.

There was a difficult passage near the middle in which she used a different approach from mine. I initially interpreted the difference as a weakness in her playing.

I listened again.

The approach made sense.

I wanted to learn why she chose it.

I also wanted to find a reason why it should not succeed.

Later that evening I wrote a message to Jules describing the recording.

I made a rather unkind observation about the way Elara played a particular phrase.

He replied that he liked the recording.

I was disappointed.

Then he asked whether I wanted to have supper.

I said I was busy.

I was not.

I had intended to practice.

Instead I spent nearly an hour listening to the sounds coming from apartment twelve.

An afternoon with a borrowed violin

On Thursday, Elara knocked on my door.

Her usual violin had developed a problem that required attention from the person who maintained it.

She had arranged for that person to examine it. In the meantime, she was going to rehearse at a room provided by a friend, using another instrument she owned.

She wanted to know whether I had seen a message from the building’s manager about a planned interruption to the supply of electricity.

I had.

We discussed it.

Then she asked whether I had ever used the rehearsal room.

I said I had.

I liked the room.

I told her that it could be quite cold.

She smiled.

She showed me the violin she intended to use.

It had belonged to her grandmother. The instrument was considerably less valuable than the one she regularly played, but she enjoyed its sound.

She began explaining what she liked about it.

I found myself imagining how inconvenient it would be for her if the repair took longer than expected.

Then I imagined her arriving at the audition with the older instrument and sounding less impressive than she had on the recordings.

I disliked discovering how much I wanted this to happen.

Elara asked whether I would like to try playing the instrument.

I was curious.

I agreed.

The sound was not particularly similar to the sound made by my own violin.

I played several measures.

She listened.

Then she asked why I had made a particular choice about the phrase.

I explained.

She tried it.

The passage sounded rather beautiful.

She laughed.

“That works.”

For a moment I felt the astonishment I had experienced at eleven when Rachel played something exceptionally well.

Then I remembered the audition.

I wanted to tell Elara that I had shown her a particularly useful idea.

I also wanted to establish that she had learned it from me.

She thanked me.

I went back to my apartment.

I could still hear the passage in my head.

I found myself playing it differently.

The message

A week before the audition, the ensemble sent the candidates additional information about the arrangements.

Each candidate was assigned a time.

There would be a short conversation, followed by the performance and a further discussion of selected matters if the panel wished.

I knew approximately when Elara would be there because she told me while we were discussing the practice schedule.

Then a member of the ensemble’s administration informed us that a portion of the schedule might change. The candidates would receive individual confirmation.

On the following afternoon, a message arrived on my telephone from a person who worked at the venue.

He had mistaken me for another musician with a similar surname. The message concerned access to the building and mentioned a change to a time.

I contacted the appropriate person and explained the mistake. He confirmed that I should disregard the message.

Then I found myself imagining another possibility.

I knew Elara was rather worried about the scheduling arrangements. If I told her that our times had changed, I might persuade her to obtain further confirmation. She might become anxious.

There were a number of ways I could justify telling her about the message.

It concerned the venue.

We were both attending the audition.

I had no obligation to explain immediately that it had been sent to me in error.

I began composing a text.

Have you seen the time change?

I stared at the words.

Then I deleted them.

I did not want to lose the position to Elara.

I also did not want to obtain it by attempting to make her less prepared.

There was no grand revelation in that moment.

I wanted to send the message.

I chose not to.

Then I telephoned Jules.

We went to a restaurant near the station.

During the meal I told him that I had been having difficulty listening to Elara practice.

He nodded.

“Is she good?”

“Yes.”

“Better than you?”

“I don’t know.”

He laughed.

I was annoyed.

Then he asked what music I was preparing.

I began explaining the passage.

For the first time in several days, I was talking about the music rather than the person with whom I was competing.

The broken string

On the morning of the audition, a string on my violin broke while I was preparing to leave.

I had a suitable replacement.

I installed it and attended to the instrument. The process took longer than I expected.

I was frightened that I would arrive late.

Elara was leaving the building when I reached the entrance.

She asked whether I was all right.

I told her what happened.

She looked at the time.

She had arranged transportation to the venue. There was room for another passenger.

She offered to take me.

I accepted.

During the journey we discussed the weather, the tramline beside the apartment and a particularly confusing notice the building’s manager had put near the entrance.

Then Elara asked whether my family would attend the performance if I got the position.

I said that I hoped they would.

She described her grandmother.

The woman had taught her several things about music. She was no longer well enough to travel easily.

Elara wanted to play in a concert that her grandmother could attend.

I thought of the musician in The Orchestra of Unanswered Letters, whose performance involved wishes and relationships that an audience could not infer from the outcome of a single audition.

I had assumed that Elara needed the position less than I did.

I did not have enough information to make such a judgment.

I knew that I wanted the position.

I could tell that she wanted it too.

At the venue, we thanked the driver.

Then we went to the places assigned to us.

The audition

I played well.

I knew this because, for much of the performance, I was interested in the sound I was making.

There were mistakes.

The third excerpt contained a passage I would have preferred to play differently. A member of the panel asked me to repeat another passage with a change in the way I approached it.

I did.

During the conversation, the members asked several questions about my work.

I found their interest in a recording I had made particularly encouraging.

When the performance ended, I thanked them.

Outside, I wanted to know how Elara had played.

I knew that obtaining the information would not change what I had done.

I went home.

For several days I imagined receiving the offer.

I also imagined reading her name in the announcement.

When the email arrived, I was repairing the case for my violin.

The ensemble thanked me for attending.

It had offered the position to another candidate.

The email invited me to obtain feedback through an established arrangement if I wished.

I put down the screwdriver.

I sat at the table.

An hour later, Elara sent me a message.

She had received the offer.

She wanted to tell me before the announcement appeared.

I read the message.

My first thought was that she should not have had the opportunity to make the recording I disliked.

My second was that the panel must have been particularly interested in the kinds of performances mentioned in her biography.

My third was that I wanted to be quite certain that I had not made a mistake with the third excerpt.

I sat for a long time.

Then I wrote:

Congratulations. I know how much work went into it. I hope you enjoy the position.

The message was sincere.

The disappointment was sincere too.

Neither made the other disappear.

The work that remained

The following week, I obtained feedback about my audition.

The panel described several strengths. It also noted aspects of my playing that it believed could develop further in relation to the kind of work the ensemble undertook.

I did not agree with all of the observations immediately.

I discussed them with a musician whose advice I trusted.

Some were useful.

I found the process difficult at first because I had wanted the feedback to establish that the wrong decision was made.

It did not.

I had also wanted it to establish that I was not good enough to work in an ensemble.

It did not do that either.

I thought of the map engraver in The City Where Every Face Was a Mirror, who had spent an extraordinary amount of time interpreting other people’s expressions as judgments about his entire character.

I had been treating the result of an audition as a judgment about the significance of my entire working life.

There were decisions I could make about the work I wanted to do.

There were also outcomes I could not determine.

I applied for other opportunities. I continued teaching and undertook several engagements that interested me.

Jules asked whether I would be willing to help with his recording.

I wanted to.

When we examined the passage we had discussed over supper, he explained how he had revised it.

I played it.

The revision was excellent.

I told him so.

There was a time when I would have been particularly interested in identifying the portion of the revision for which I could claim responsibility.

That afternoon I was interested in hearing it again.

Through the wall

Elara began working with the ensemble in spring.

Some evenings I heard her rehearsing.

The sound was different from the one I heard when she moved into the building because she was preparing different music.

On one afternoon I recognized a passage from a piece I particularly liked.

I listened.

She stopped and repeated two notes.

Then she began again.

I opened my own case.

Several months later, she asked whether I wanted to attend a concert.

Her grandmother would be there.

I went.

Elara played beautifully.

For portions of the evening I could remember the email informing me that I had not received the position. There were things about her playing I wanted to be able to do.

I did not mistake the feeling for proof that she should not be standing there.

After the concert, I met her grandmother.

She wanted to know how I knew Elara.

“Through the wall,” I said.

Elara laughed.

We explained.

Then her grandmother asked what music I played.

I told her.

She was particularly interested in the recording I was making with Jules.

I gave her information about it.

On the journey home, I thought of the bellmaker in The Bellmaker’s Unfinished Note, whose difficulties with confidence became more manageable when the value of the work no longer depended on proving an uninterrupted history of success.

I did not know whether I would ever join the ensemble I wanted to join.

I hoped I would.

I had also discovered several other things I wanted to do.

At home, I took out the violin.

I began playing the twelve measures.

The last note did not sound quite as I wanted it to.

I adjusted the phrase.

Then I began again.


After the story: Nathan, Elara and the ensemble are fictional. Losing an opportunity may evoke envy alongside sincere admiration and disappointment. Experiencing a feeling does not oblige someone to act on it.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top