The Importance of a Fair Hearing

A literary reflection on the importance of a fair hearing, examining how we listen, weigh evidence, reconsider first impressions and make responsible judgments about others.

The Importance of a Fair Hearing, with two empty chairs and a small table in a peaceful garden.

The envelope had been waiting on the headteacher’s desk since Monday morning.

It contained a letter from the father of a student who had been excluded from a school excursion. According to the account given to him, his son had behaved disrespectfully toward a teacher during a lesson.

The father wanted to discuss the decision.

Mrs. Ellis had already spoken to the teacher. She knew that there had been considerable disruption in the classroom and that the student, a boy named Aaron, had responded angrily when asked to leave his seat.

She had no particular reason to doubt the teacher’s account.

Nevertheless, before replying to the letter, she arranged to speak to Aaron.

He acknowledged that he had raised his voice. He also explained that he had been trying to retrieve a piece of paper another student had taken from him. He had attempted to explain this to the teacher, but his explanation had been interrupted when the room became noisy.

When Mrs. Ellis subsequently spoke to several people who had witnessed the incident, she discovered that both the teacher and Aaron had described events that had genuinely occurred.

Neither account, by itself, had provided a satisfactory explanation of what happened.

Aaron’s response still deserved attention. So did the conduct that had preceded it.

The decision concerning the excursion was reconsidered.

What interested Mrs. Ellis was the ease with which the original account could have become the only one anybody needed to hear.

It had come from somebody she knew to be conscientious. It had described conduct similar to behavior she had encountered before. It had provided an apparently sufficient explanation of an incident during an exceptionally busy week.

Yet a reasonable explanation is not necessarily a complete one.

The importance of a fair hearing becomes apparent in precisely such circumstances. It involves giving people a genuine opportunity to contribute to an account of events that may have consequences for them, even when the people responsible for reaching a decision already possess a convincing account of their own.

An account that arrives first

At a small furniture business, a customer telephoned to complain that a delivery had arrived several days later than agreed.

The person answering the telephone apologized and promised to investigate. A colleague explained that the driver had failed to collect the furniture at the expected time.

For a while, the delay was understood as a problem with the driver.

When the owner spoke to him, she discovered that the furniture had not been ready for collection on the agreed morning. His schedule involved several other deliveries, and returning later that day would have prevented him from completing two of them.

Some communication had undoubtedly been inadequate.

Its inadequacy was distributed across several people.

The account that reaches us first can acquire a particular importance because it establishes the terms in which subsequent information is considered. Once we have understood an incident as an example of carelessness, for instance, another person’s explanation may be received principally as an attempt to excuse that carelessness.

We can become considerably less interested in discovering whether the original description was accurate than in deciding whether the explanation is sufficiently persuasive.

As explored in Why We Judge What We Do Not Understand, the familiarity of a possible explanation can make it attractive before we possess sufficient knowledge to evaluate it.

A fair hearing need not begin with the assumption that every account is equally accurate. Information arrives with different degrees of reliability. Documents, independent observations and established facts may provide compelling reasons to question particular statements.

But the advantage of being heard first ought not to become an advantage in determining whose subsequent account is allowed to matter.

The owner of the furniture business eventually altered the procedure through which completed orders were assigned to deliveries.

She also spoke to the customer again.

Had she treated the first explanation as a sufficient conclusion, she might have addressed the conduct of the driver while leaving the source of the difficulty substantially unchanged.

The difficulty of speaking under judgment

A woman named Imogen worked at an organization whose administrative procedures had recently changed.

Several employees were encountering problems with the new arrangements. When she was asked to attend a meeting about a document she had completed incorrectly, she prepared a series of notes explaining what had happened.

At the meeting, her supervisor asked why she had failed to follow the instructions.

Imogen began describing the instructions she had received from two different departments. The supervisor interrupted her to explain that the procedure was quite straightforward.

She attempted to clarify which part had been difficult.

The conversation continued in a similar manner.

Afterward, the supervisor concluded that Imogen had been unable to provide a convincing explanation.

There is a difference between allowing somebody to speak and establishing circumstances in which they can reasonably give an account of what has happened.

A person may be nervous, unfamiliar with the language in which the conversation is taking place or uncertain about which details the listener considers relevant. They may know something important while possessing relatively little experience of presenting information under pressure.

The clarity with which an account is delivered does not necessarily establish its accuracy.

As considered in The Things We Cannot Explain to Each Other, explaining an experience can require a considerable amount of work, especially when the person listening has not encountered its circumstances.

This does not mean that every hesitation should be treated as evidence of truthfulness, or that a confident statement should automatically be regarded with suspicion.

It means that the manner in which somebody speaks is only one portion of the information available to us.

Imogen’s supervisor could have asked which written instructions she was referring to, allowed her to consult her notes and examined the points on which the guidance appeared inconsistent.

The resulting conversation might still have revealed a mistake that Imogen was responsible for making.

What it would have provided was a more dependable basis for understanding the mistake.

The opportunity to offer a fair account is particularly important when another person possesses considerable authority over the consequences that will follow.

The person exercising that authority has responsibilities concerning not only the conclusion they reach but also the conditions under which the relevant information becomes available to them.

Taking an account seriously without accepting every conclusion

At a meeting of residents, a woman named Farah complained about the way deliveries were being made to a neighboring building.

Vehicles sometimes remained in front of the entrance to her property. She had found it difficult to leave the house on several occasions, and she believed that the people responsible for organizing the deliveries had been deliberately inconsiderate.

The representative of the neighboring building listened to her account.

He acknowledged the difficulty she described and agreed to investigate the delivery arrangements. He did not agree that the obstruction had necessarily been deliberate.

Farah initially interpreted his reservation as a refusal to take her seriously.

In fact, the complaint contained several distinct propositions. There was the account of what had occurred, the description of its consequences and the conclusion she had reached about the intentions of the people responsible.

Each deserved consideration. They did not all require the same evidence.

As explored in The Wisdom of Not Knowing, responsible judgment sometimes depends upon distinguishing what we can reasonably establish from what remains uncertain.

The representative could acknowledge that Farah had experienced a significant inconvenience without claiming to know the motives of people whose accounts he had not yet heard.

He subsequently discovered that the delivery company had been given instructions that were difficult to follow at busy times. Several drivers had made choices that appeared convenient without considering their consequences for the adjoining properties.

The arrangements were changed.

Farah’s experience had been important to understanding the problem, even though her initial explanation of the intentions involved had not been established.

Listening fairly does not require accepting every interpretation attached to an experience. It requires recognizing which portions of the account deserve attention and examining them with appropriate care.

We can acknowledge the difficulty somebody has experienced without making a premature judgment about the character of another person.

Equally, we should not use uncertainty about another person’s motives to dismiss a consequence that is already sufficiently clear.

The obstruction mattered regardless of whether those responsible had intended to create it.

When the opportunity to respond has practical limits

At a community organization, a volunteer named Michael became aware that several people were dissatisfied with a decision he had made about the use of a public room.

He was willing to explain his reasons. During the following month, however, he found himself attending several meetings in which the same objections were repeated.

Some participants believed that the decision could not fairly be concluded until they were satisfied with his explanation.

The organization had an obligation to consider their concerns. It also had other responsibilities that were becoming increasingly difficult to fulfill.

A fair hearing is not necessarily an indefinitely continuing conversation.

There are decisions that need to be made within a reasonable period, and there may be legitimate reasons for limiting the material or the people involved. Privacy, safety and the need to protect those who have reported harmful conduct can affect how information is shared.

Fairness does not require somebody to confront a person they fear or disclose private details to everybody who expresses an interest in them.

What matters is whether the people whose interests are affected have an appropriate opportunity to provide relevant information and challenge significant inaccuracies, through arrangements suitable to the circumstances.

As considered in The Importance of Being a Witness, accurate accounts are often easier to obtain when the people providing them are not expected to accept unreasonable personal risks.

Michael’s organization eventually arranged for a member who had not participated in the original decision to review the objections, consult the available records and explain the resulting conclusion.

Some participants remained disappointed.

Their disappointment did not necessarily establish that the review had been unfair.

There is a difference between the right to have a concern considered and the right to require that the resulting decision correspond to our preferences.

The organization could provide a clear account of what had been examined, what had been established and which matters remained outside the scope of the review.

It did not need to guarantee agreement.

A process can be fair without resolving every dissatisfaction the people participating in it bring to the conversation.

The conversation after the decision

Several weeks after the school excursion, Mrs. Ellis encountered Aaron in the corridor.

He was carrying something he had made during a lesson, and they spoke briefly about it.

Later that afternoon, she met the teacher who had originally reported the classroom incident. They discussed an arrangement through which students could raise concerns without interrupting the work of the class.

There was something to learn from the incident that did not depend upon making either the student or the teacher into its principal explanation.

The teacher had been dealing with a noisy classroom. Aaron had responded inappropriately to a difficulty he had been unable to explain. Other students had contributed to the disruption.

A more complete account had allowed the school to consider those circumstances together.

Perhaps this is one of the values of giving somebody a fair hearing.

It does not guarantee that we will discover information capable of changing a decision. There will be occasions when a careful investigation confirms the account we initially received. There will be occasions when it reveals that somebody has acted in a way that requires serious consequences.

But the opportunity to hear relevant information before reaching a conclusion can protect us from confusing the convenience of an explanation with its completeness.

It can make our decisions more accurate. It can also make it easier for the people affected by them to understand which things have been considered and why a particular conclusion has been reached.

When the consequences are significant, that distinction matters.

Mrs. Ellis could not promise that every disagreement at the school would be resolved to everybody’s satisfaction.

She could try to ensure that a student’s position did not become irrelevant merely because the first account of an incident had arrived from somebody whose judgment she generally trusted.

On her desk that afternoon was another envelope.

She opened it.

There was a person whose account she had not yet heard.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top