What Does Fear of Rejection Teach Us About Human Nature? The Festival of Unchosen Doors

What does fear of rejection teach us about human nature? In a town where doors remember accepted and unanswered invitations, a craftsman must learn what those marks cannot tell him.

The Festival of Unchosen Doors — Fear of Rejection, gold lettering on a decorative dark blue background

By the time the festival began, someone had painted a black circle on the door of Ansel’s workshop.

It was not the customary mark.

In the town of Elver, people decorated their doors once a year with branches, ribbons and pieces of colored glass. During the Festival of Invitations, visitors could knock on any participating door. What happened after the knock was entirely up to the person inside.

Some doors opened onto music. Others opened onto a table set with food. An artist might invite a stranger to see an unfinished picture, while a carpenter might ask someone to help assemble a bench for the square.

There was one peculiarity.

The doors remembered.

A door that had opened during the festival retained a little golden mark for each invitation accepted. A door that had remained closed acquired a silver mark. The marks faded over the following year.

Ansel had spent much of his adult life repairing these doors.

He disliked looking at the silver marks.

Now he stood outside his own workshop, examining the black circle.

His apprentice, Mila, arrived carrying a basket of ribbons.

“What’s that?”

“I don’t know.”

She put down the basket.

Behind the workshop, something moved. Ansel heard a familiar scraping sound, followed by three gentle knocks.

There was nobody standing in the passage.

Then the black circle began to disappear.

Where it had been, a silver mark remained.

Mila stared at it.

“The festival hasn’t started.”

Ansel knew.

He also knew, with considerably more certainty than the circumstances warranted, whose rejection the door had been remembering.


The oldest doors in Elver had been made from trees growing along the northern ridge.

According to the town’s records, the trees possessed the unusual property of retaining traces of certain experiences associated with the objects made from them. Researchers had identified several limitations in the phenomenon, and the inhabitants of Elver had developed customs around the properties that could be observed reliably.

The festival marks reflected whether a participating door opened in response to a knock made during the festival.

They did not identify the visitor. They did not establish why a door remained closed. They did not reveal how the residents felt about their guests.

There were households that kept their doors closed because a child was sleeping. There were people who participated for an hour, then went out to visit somebody else. Occasionally a door remained closed because its owner was standing in the garden and did not hear the knock.

The town’s festival committee explained these things every year.

Its explanations were less widely discussed than the marks themselves.

Children counted the golden marks on the houses of their friends. Shopkeepers occasionally compared their results. There were people who regarded silver marks as evidence of something regrettable about the inhabitants of a building.

Ansel knew how the materials worked.

He also knew how it felt to be standing on a doorstep, waiting for a sound that did not come.

His father had taught him to repair the doors when he was young.

“Don’t confuse a door with the people behind it,” his father would say.

Ansel had always considered this advice particularly easy to follow when he was working with a piece of wood.

The rest of the time it presented difficulties.


When Ansel was twelve, he made a lantern for a girl named Evi.

They attended school together, and he liked the way she drew pictures of animals that looked slightly annoyed to be animals. He thought she might enjoy a lantern decorated with one of her drawings.

He spent three afternoons making it.

On the evening of the festival, he went to her house.

Several children were already there.

He knocked.

Evi’s older brother opened the door, looked at the lantern and asked what it was for.

Ansel explained.

The boy laughed.

Then he called Evi.

She appeared in the hallway.

Ansel offered her the lantern.

She said she did not want it.

She had already made plans to go out with her friends and apparently did not know what to do with the object he was holding.

Ansel nodded.

He went home.

His father found him sitting in the workshop.

“Didn’t go well?”

“No.”

His father examined the lantern.

“That’s nicely made.”

Ansel became angry.

He had not made it so his father could admire the joints. He had made it for somebody who did not want it.

His father listened.

Then he asked whether Ansel wanted to keep it.

For several days, Ansel did not know.

Eventually he took it to the market, exchanged it with a trader for a little quantity of wood, and made something else.

He continued seeing Evi at school.

She was not obliged to accept the lantern, and he did not try to persuade her to do so.

Nevertheless, for years afterward he remembered the laughter of her brother whenever he considered offering somebody something that had required a great deal of effort.

He began preferring gifts that looked as though they had required very little.


At twenty-eight, Ansel established his own workshop.

He repaired furniture, made fittings for buildings and occasionally constructed pieces for exhibitions. He enjoyed work that required him to investigate the history of an object.

Mila joined him as an apprentice several years later.

She was curious, practical and willing to ask customers questions that Ansel sometimes found difficult.

One afternoon a woman brought in a damaged cabinet.

Ansel examined it and described two possible approaches to the repair.

The woman chose the less expensive one.

When she left, Ansel looked at his notes.

“I should’ve offered that first.”

Mila asked why.

“She didn’t like the other one.”

“She liked the cheaper one.”

He nodded.

Mila returned to her work.

Ansel remained beside the counter.

There was a difference between a customer deciding that an option was unsuitable for her requirements and a customer expressing dissatisfaction with the person who presented it.

He understood the distinction.

He did not always experience it.

When a customer accepted a proposal, he was relieved. When a customer declined one, he sometimes spent a considerable part of the evening reviewing the conversation.

He wanted to know what he could have said differently.

There were useful things to consider about such exchanges. He might be able to explain a proposal more clearly or identify a more suitable arrangement.

But there were occasions when no improvement to his explanation would make a person want the thing he offered.

He disliked those occasions.

He remembered the portrait painter in The Portrait With No Signature, who had begun withholding her work from the people she hoped would see it.

Ansel sometimes did something similar.

He produced designs he liked, then kept them in a drawer because he could imagine a customer preferring something else.

Mila had never seen most of them.


The previous year’s festival had been especially difficult.

Ansel’s friend Fen had moved into a house near the river. The two had known each other since their training and occasionally worked together on projects involving the restoration of old buildings.

Fen invited Ansel to several gatherings during the winter.

Ansel accepted one invitation and declined three.

There were reasons for his decisions. Once he had promised to finish a repair. On another occasion he had been tired.

On the third, he simply imagined that the other guests would know Fen better than he did.

At the festival, Ansel went to Fen’s house carrying a little wooden ornament.

He knocked.

The door remained closed.

A silver mark appeared beside its handle.

Ansel waited for several seconds.

Then he left.

He told himself that he had probably misunderstood the extent of their friendship.

Later that evening, Fen sent a message asking whether Ansel had been to the workshop.

Ansel replied that he had been busy.

Fen did not know that he had visited the house.

For several months their conversations concerned work rather than the things they used to discuss while walking home.

Ansel found this disappointing.

He also believed that he had behaved sensibly.

He was protecting himself from the discovery that Fen did not particularly want to see him.

He did not consider that Fen might have acquired a similar impression of his preferences.

By the following spring, both men had become very good at arranging appointments that ended as soon as the work was finished.


The black circle on the workshop door concerned Mila.

It turned out to be a mark produced by a piece of damaged wood that she had incorporated into the door during a supervised repair. The original section had come from an older participating door, and the materials had responded unexpectedly to a change in temperature.

A specialist from the town’s conservation office examined it.

He explained that the appearance did not establish that anyone had actually knocked at the workshop that morning.

It was a residual effect of the older material.

The silver mark would probably fade.

Ansel listened.

“How old?”

“The timber? Perhaps eighty years.”

“And the mark?”

“We don’t know.”

The specialist made a record of the finding and arranged to consider the issue with people who studied the phenomenon.

Mila was embarrassed.

She had helped select the piece of wood under Ansel’s supervision.

“I should’ve noticed.”

“What?”

“That it might do that.”

Ansel smiled.

“Did anybody know it might do that?”

She shook her head.

They discussed the repair. There were several things they could investigate, and the specialist offered advice about how the material might be assessed.

After he left, Mila returned to the ribbons.

Ansel continued looking at the mark.

He had spent the morning treating it as evidence of something about the way other people regarded him.

It was evidence of something concerning wood.

He thought of the woman in The Envelope With No Address, who had discovered that much of the certainty she experienced in anticipating an unwanted response belonged to her rather than to the people she was trying to understand.

He wanted to know whether he had done something comparable with Fen.

He picked up his telephone.

Then he put it down again.


The festival began the following evening.

Ansel had agreed to make his workshop available between six and eight. Visitors could examine several objects he was repairing and see a collection of pieces Mila had made during her training.

Mila invited her family.

She also invited a woman from the library who was developing an exhibition about local crafts.

Ansel was less pleased by the second invitation.

He had several designs he would have liked to show the woman.

He did not particularly want her to see them.

“Shall I put these out?” Mila asked, holding three drawings she had found in a folder.

He examined them.

One showed a little cabinet intended to hold books. Another described a chair with an unusual arrangement of its back. The third showed a writing desk he had been thinking about for nearly two years.

“They’re not finished.”

“Are they meant to be?”

He considered the question.

The exhibition concerned the development of objects, including drawings and exploratory work.

It was apparently a suitable place for something unfinished.

He nevertheless found it difficult to imagine the drawings being examined.

Mila waited.

“Maybe those two,” he said.

She placed them beside the other exhibits.

At six, the first visitor knocked.

The door opened.

A golden mark appeared.

Ansel smiled.

During the first hour, eleven people came, arriving in nine separate groups.

Several were interested in the restoration work. A child asked an extraordinary number of questions about a hinge. An elderly man wanted to describe a cabinet he had owned many years earlier.

The woman from the library arrived shortly before seven.

She looked at the drawings.

Ansel explained the proposed chair.

She listened.

Then she said that it did not fit the exhibition she was preparing.

He felt the familiar disappointment.

She asked whether he wanted to discuss a different project with her in the future.

For a moment, he scarcely heard the question.

He had been waiting for the answer about the chair.

“Yes,” he said eventually.

They arranged a time to speak.

The woman looked at Mila’s work and asked several questions about it.

Then she left.

Ansel examined the drawing.

He still liked it.

He was surprised that this remained possible.


At eight, Mila went home, and Ansel began putting the objects away.

There were nine golden marks on the door.

There was also the silver one that had appeared before the festival began.

He considered closing the workshop for the evening.

Then a boy knocked.

He was carrying a little wooden animal with a damaged leg.

His name was Taren.

He wanted to know whether Ansel could repair it.

Ansel examined it.

The damage was relatively simple, although he wanted to consider whether the proposed repair would be suitable for the toy.

He explained that he could look at it on Monday.

The boy thanked him.

Then he looked at the golden marks.

“Have you got more than us?”

“Don’t know.”

“Our door’s got seven.”

Ansel smiled.

“That’s a lot of numbers.”

Taren asked whether a house with fewer golden marks was less popular.

Ansel thought about the question.

“It might have been open for less time.”

The boy nodded.

“Or people didn’t like it.”

“Possibly.”

Taren looked worried.

Ansel said that a door could be closed for many reasons, and that somebody declining an invitation was not necessarily deciding whether the person making it was worth knowing.

The boy considered the answer.

Then he asked whether Ansel liked the wooden animal.

“Very much.”

Taren smiled.

He left.

Ansel remembered the archivist in The Room Where Echoes Waited, who had learned that incomplete traces of human behavior could easily acquire meanings supplied by the people examining them.

The marks on the door were rather like the sounds in the room.

They disclosed something limited.

People supplied the rest.

He collected his coat and went to the square.


Fen was standing beside a stall selling bread.

Ansel saw him from a considerable distance.

For a moment he considered walking to the other side of the square.

Then Fen waved.

Ansel went over.

They discussed the festival and several repairs they were considering. Fen bought two pieces of bread and offered one to Ansel.

They walked toward the river.

Ansel asked whether Fen remembered the previous festival.

“Bits of it.”

“Did you stay at home?”

Fen laughed.

“Not long. I went to my sister’s.”

Ansel was quiet.

Then he told him that he had visited the house.

He described the ornament and the mark that appeared.

Fen looked surprised.

“Why didn’t you tell me?”

Ansel said that he thought Fen might not want to see him.

They stopped beside the river.

Fen explained that he had invited Ansel to several gatherings, then assumed that Ansel preferred meeting him at work. He had not wanted to continue making invitations that seemed unwelcome.

Ansel laughed, rather unhappily.

For months, each had been responding to an interpretation the other had not intended.

Neither had known enough to establish what he believed.

They talked for a long time.

Fen said that he would like to see Ansel more often.

He also said that he was sometimes busy and did not always enjoy gatherings as much as Ansel appeared to imagine.

Ansel told him that he occasionally found large groups difficult.

Fen nodded.

“Coffee, then?”

“Yes.”

They arranged to meet the following week.

On the way home, Ansel noticed that he was still feeling embarrassed.

He had spent considerable effort explaining something that might have been resolved by a question many months earlier.

He was glad he had asked it now.


The exhibition at the library opened in autumn.

Ansel contributed two drawings and a small example of his restoration work. Mila contributed several objects she had made during her training.

One of Ansel’s drawings had been declined by the organizer.

It concerned a project outside the exhibition’s scope.

He was disappointed, particularly because he had spent a long time preparing it.

He asked whether the organizer had any observations that might be useful.

She explained the reasons for her decision.

He listened.

Then he took the drawing back to the workshop.

He did not immediately decide whether it ought to be altered.

There were reasons he liked it that the exhibition was not intended to consider.

The following week a customer asked about the drawing.

Ansel described it.

They discussed whether a piece based on it might be suitable for the customer’s requirements.

Eventually the customer chose something different.

Ansel was disappointed again.

He went to meet Fen for coffee.

He was discovering that the experience of receiving an unwanted answer did not necessarily diminish the importance of the next thing he wanted to do.

He had also begun speaking to a counselor after recognizing how much time he spent reviewing conversations and how frequently his fear of rejection prevented him from considering opportunities.

The conversations helped him examine the distinction between an unwanted response, a reasonable concern about an unsafe or hostile situation, and a prediction formed in the absence of adequate information.

He thought of the captain in The Captain of Somebody Else’s Ship, who was learning to assess the actual responsibilities and circumstances of her work instead of treating every difficulty as a judgment of her right to be there.

Ansel wanted to develop a comparable understanding of the invitations he offered and received.

He did not want to make people responsible for reassuring him that he mattered whenever they preferred something else.

Nor did he want to treat every rejection as trivial.

Some were painful.

He had wanted the drawing to be selected.

He could acknowledge the disappointment and continue working.


At the next festival, a child stopped outside the workshop and asked Ansel why there were no branches above the door.

He explained that he was not opening the workshop that year.

“Why?”

He had been working on a substantial restoration project and wanted an evening away from the building.

The child seemed surprised.

“Are you going somewhere?”

“Yes.”

He was going to see a performance at the village hall with Fen and Mila.

He put a little notice beside the door explaining that the workshop was closed.

Then he went to meet them.

There were people he passed who appeared disappointed that he would not be displaying his work that evening.

He understood their disappointment.

He still wanted to see the performance.

On the way, they went past Evi’s house. She had returned to the town several years earlier and now taught children at the school.

She was hanging ribbons outside her door.

Ansel waved.

She waved back.

He considered telling her about the lantern.

Then he decided that he did not particularly need to discuss it.

The girl who declined it had been a child. The boy who made it had been a child. Both had gone on to live lives containing things the other knew almost nothing about.

There might be reasons to speak about the memory.

There was no requirement that Evi provide a different answer in order for Ansel to enjoy the evening.

At the hall, Fen asked whether he wanted a seat near the front.

Ansel said he preferred the back.

Mila wanted the middle.

They found three seats in the middle.

Ansel laughed.

He understood what the fear of rejection could teach about human nature. People needed connections, wanted their efforts to be valued, and cared about the opportunities through which they made their lives. They sometimes tried to protect those things by avoiding the very exchanges that might help them develop.

A request could be reasonable and still be declined.

A refusal could be painful without establishing the worth of the person who received it.

There would also be situations in which distance, caution or an ending were appropriate.

The task was not to make every door open.

It was to recognize which doors one wanted to approach, which invitations one wished to accept, and which decisions belonged to somebody else.

The musicians came onto the stage.

When the first piece ended, Ansel clapped.

He did not count the people who clapped with him.

Editorial note: Original fantasy fiction. All characters, locations, customs and supernatural phenomena are invented. Fear of rejection can reveal the importance people place on belonging, acceptance and interpersonal connection. Previous experiences and social circumstances may influence expectations, but anticipating rejection is not the same as knowing another person’s intentions. Respecting boundaries, tolerating ordinary disappointment and seeking appropriate support when fear substantially affects daily life can help people make choices without requiring universal approval.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top