The Freedom of Not Having the Last Word

Why do we need the last word? Reflect on the urge to be understood, the strength of leaving futile arguments, and the difference between peace and surrender.

The Freedom of Not Having the Last Word — two empty chairs and old family photographs on a sunlit dining table.

The argument between the two brothers began with a cupboard.

Their mother had recently moved into a smaller apartment, and they were helping her decide what should happen to the furniture she could no longer accommodate. Victor thought the cupboard should be given to their cousin. His younger brother, Alan, believed it would be better to sell it and give the money to their mother.

Each had reasons for his preference. Neither proposal was particularly unreasonable.

By the middle of the afternoon, however, they were discussing an occasion twelve years earlier when Victor had borrowed a car and returned it later than expected. Alan remembered a telephone conversation that Victor insisted had never taken place. Their mother had gone into another room to make tea.

Eventually, she returned and told them that she had already decided to give the cupboard to a neighbor.

The brothers continued arguing.

Their original question had been answered. What remained was the much less manageable question of which of them had been the more considerate person throughout the history of their relationship.

On the journey home, Victor began composing another explanation of what he had intended to say. He imagined sending his brother a message that would establish the distinction between his actual position and the position Alan had attributed to him.

At a traffic light, he realized that he had spent most of the afternoon attempting to correct his brother’s understanding of an argument whose practical consequences had ceased to exist.

There is a particular freedom in recognizing when we have said enough.

It does not require us to stop caring about what is true. It asks us to consider whether another sentence is likely to make the truth clearer or merely prolong our involvement in a disagreement that has acquired a purpose of its own.

When an argument changes its subject

At a meeting of a local historical society, a woman named Frances questioned the date assigned to a photograph in an exhibition.

She had found a document suggesting that the photograph had been taken several years later than the accompanying description claimed. The person who had prepared the exhibition disagreed with her interpretation.

For a few minutes, their conversation concerned the evidence.

Then the organizer mentioned the considerable amount of work he had devoted to preparing the exhibition. Frances replied that she was familiar with the history of the building represented in the photograph. Another member recalled an earlier occasion when the organizer had made a similar mistake.

The discussion became increasingly difficult to follow because the people participating in it were no longer attempting to settle quite the same question.

The date of the photograph could be investigated. The organizer’s competence, Frances’s knowledge and the relative importance of their contributions to the society were more complicated matters.

Arguments frequently acquire additional subjects without the people involved being fully aware of the change.

A disagreement about the time at which somebody arrived home becomes a disagreement about whether they respect their partner. A question about an individual’s performance at work becomes an examination of their character. A correction of an inaccurate statement becomes a contest over who possesses the greater authority to speak.

Sometimes these additional matters genuinely deserve attention. A recurring failure to fulfill an agreement may reveal a problem that cannot be addressed by discussing individual incidents in isolation.

But it is useful to recognize when a conversation has changed its subject.

In The Courage to Change Our Minds, we considered how a judgment can become associated with the reputation of the person who has expressed it. Once that association becomes sufficiently strong, reconsidering an ordinary conclusion may feel like surrendering something much larger.

Frances wanted the date to be accurate. The organizer wanted the value of his work to be recognized.

Those aims were not necessarily incompatible. They became difficult to reconcile when each person began treating the other’s aim as a threat to their own.

The most useful contribution to their discussion might have been a question about which matter they were presently trying to settle.

The wish to be understood correctly

A man tells a friend that he cannot attend a gathering.

He explains that he has several commitments that weekend and needs some time to prepare for the following week. His friend responds by suggesting that he has become less interested in maintaining their friendship.

The man feels obliged to correct this interpretation.

He explains the commitments in greater detail. He mentions other occasions on which he has made time for the friendship. He sends another message after their conversation has ended, hoping that an example will establish what his earlier explanation failed to convey.

The desire to be understood accurately is not trivial.

Another person’s interpretation can affect a relationship. An incorrect account of our conduct may influence how other people respond to us. There are circumstances in which leaving an accusation unanswered would have serious professional or personal consequences.

Yet we cannot always obtain the understanding we seek merely by continuing to supply explanations.

Somebody may already possess the information they need to understand our decision but remain disappointed by it. They may interpret our reasons through experiences we know very little about. They may believe that acknowledging the reasonableness of our position would require them to abandon a complaint they are not ready to reconsider.

As explored in The Things We Cannot Explain to Each Other, sincere efforts at communication can leave a distance between two people’s experiences without establishing that either person has failed to speak or listen adequately.

There is a difference between providing a reasonable explanation and acquiring control over the conclusions another person draws from it.

The first may be our responsibility. The second is generally beyond our authority.

The man could clarify that declining the invitation was not intended as a rejection of the friendship. He could suggest another occasion to meet. If there was a wider concern about their relationship, he could consider whether it deserved a separate conversation.

But he could not ensure that his friend would immediately interpret the decision in the way he hoped.

A further explanation might eventually be useful. It might also be an attempt to obtain, through repetition, an assurance that the other person was not presently able to give.

When the final word belongs to a responsibility

There are occasions when allowing an inaccurate statement to remain unchallenged is not a reasonable choice.

An employee is incorrectly accused of failing to complete a safety inspection. A parent notices that a school has recorded information about a child that could affect the assistance the child receives. A person discovers that somebody has published an account of an event that seriously misrepresents their conduct.

In such circumstances, a correction can have consequences that extend beyond the satisfaction of being understood correctly.

There may be a record that needs to be amended, a decision that needs to be reconsidered or other people whose interests depend upon the availability of accurate information.

It would be mistaken to regard every persistence in disagreement as a private difficulty with pride.

The relevant question is what another contribution is intended to accomplish.

If the employee needs the organization’s records to reflect the inspection that actually occurred, providing relevant documentation and following an appropriate procedure may be more useful than repeatedly engaging with the person who made the accusation.

If a public statement has caused harm, the correction may need to reach the people who encountered the original statement.

The importance of the matter can establish a reason to continue even when the conversation has become unpleasant.

In The Difference Between Peace and Avoidance, we examined the danger of treating the disappearance of a disagreement as evidence that the circumstances which produced it have improved.

Disengaging from an unproductive exchange need not mean abandoning the underlying issue.

Some matters can be addressed more effectively in another setting, with clearer evidence or through a process designed to establish responsibility.

The freedom of not having the last word is not the freedom to neglect what still needs to be done.

It can be the freedom to stop treating a particular argument as the only place in which necessary work can occur.

The audience we begin to imagine

Victor had occasionally disagreed with his brother in the presence of friends or relatives.

He noticed that an argument acquired a different character when other people were listening.

A remark he might have ignored during a private conversation became something he felt obliged to answer. A small correction appeared more important if he suspected that somebody else had noticed the original statement.

He wanted not only to establish what he believed was true but to prevent the people present from acquiring an unfavorable account of him.

There are understandable reasons for caring about the judgments of others. A person’s reputation may affect their opportunities, their relationships and the degree of trust placed in them.

But there are also occasions when the imagined judgment of an audience becomes larger than anything that is actually occurring.

The people seated around a dinner table may not remember a disagreement with anything approaching the detail with which the participants remember it. A person reading a discussion may recognize its complexity without forming a definitive opinion about which contributor was more reasonable.

Meanwhile, the person involved may spend hours preparing a response to an interpretation nobody has expressed.

In The Hidden Hunger for Approval, we considered the influence that other people’s evaluations can acquire when they become a measure of decisions whose consequences deserve independent examination.

The same influence can keep an argument alive after its useful possibilities have diminished.

We may continue speaking because we want the people listening to know that we could have answered a particular criticism. We may fear that silence will be interpreted as defeat, even though the question under discussion no longer has much practical significance.

A person can take reasonable steps to protect their reputation without treating every unfavorable interpretation as something they must personally pursue and correct.

Sometimes the most accurate account of our character is produced through the accumulation of our conduct rather than through the conclusion of a particular conversation.

That account develops too slowly to offer much satisfaction during an argument.

But it may be more dependable than the impression we are attempting to secure with another reply.

What it means to leave an exchange without agreement

At the end of a long conversation, two colleagues discover that they have different views about how an organization should allocate a portion of its budget.

They understand one another’s reasons. They have identified the principal uncertainties, and each has accepted that some of the other’s concerns deserve consideration.

Neither has changed their recommendation.

The organization has a procedure for making the eventual decision. Both can contribute to that procedure without continuing their private discussion indefinitely.

There is no substantial failure of communication here.

Yet people often feel that a conversation has remained incomplete if its participants have not reached a common conclusion.

This expectation can be especially difficult when the disagreement involves values rather than the interpretation of a particular fact. Two people may understand the same circumstances and attach different importance to their features. One may regard security as the principal consideration. Another may believe that the possibility of a worthwhile improvement justifies accepting greater uncertainty.

Further information might alter their views.

It might not.

The useful accomplishment of their conversation may be that each has become capable of describing the other’s position without caricaturing it.

That accomplishment deserves recognition independently of whether either person eventually adopts the position they now understand more accurately.

Of course, there are arrangements in which a shared decision is necessary. The people responsible for a household, an organization or a joint undertaking cannot always resolve a difficulty by proceeding independently.

They may need to negotiate, establish a fair decision-making process or accept a compromise that leaves each of them with some dissatisfaction.

But even in those arrangements, agreement about what to do does not necessarily require agreement about every reason for doing it.

We can accept a workable decision without abandoning our account of the considerations that ought to have received greater attention.

And we can sometimes leave a conversation knowing more than we knew before without requiring that the other person regard our conclusion as their own.

The response we do not send

Several days after the argument about the cupboard, Victor received a message from Alan concerning the time at which they would next visit their mother.

Attached to the practical information was a short remark about their earlier disagreement.

Victor began typing a response.

He explained why the remark was inaccurate, described the sequence of the afternoon’s events and added something about the difficulty of discussing practical matters with a person who repeatedly introduced unrelated grievances.

He read the message.

It was not entirely unreasonable. Much of what he had written reflected his genuine understanding of what had occurred.

But he could also imagine the response it was likely to produce.

Alan would correct a different detail. Victor would explain why the correction was beside the point. The practical question of when they would visit their mother would become part of another discussion about their respective characters.

Victor deleted most of the message.

He confirmed that Sunday afternoon would be convenient and asked whether Alan could bring some boxes for the remaining possessions.

There was no dramatic feeling of release.

For a while, he remained irritated by the remark he had chosen not to answer.

Nevertheless, the irritation gradually became less prominent as he attended to other things. He discovered that an unanswered remark did not have to become an unfinished task occupying the rest of his evening.

This was not a decision that every future disagreement with Alan should be ignored.

There were matters between them that deserved serious discussion. There might be circumstances in which Victor would need to challenge an assumption or establish a clearer limit.

But there was no particular reason why those matters had to be addressed through the exchange of messages about Sunday’s visit.

Sometimes the decision not to answer is useful precisely because it leaves open a better occasion for speaking.

Sometimes it is simply a recognition that another sentence would serve no worthwhile purpose.

Distinguishing between those possibilities can return a considerable amount of attention to the parts of our lives in which that attention is still useful.

The afternoon without a verdict

On Sunday, the brothers finished packing the contents of their mother’s old apartment.

Alan brought more boxes than they needed. Victor discovered a collection of photographs behind a piece of furniture they were moving.

For a time, they sat on the floor examining them.

They disagreed about the year in which one photograph had been taken. Their mother, who was standing beside the doorway, supplied the answer.

Then they continued packing.

Perhaps the freedom of not having the last word begins with a more accurate understanding of what the last word can accomplish.

We cannot always obtain acknowledgment of what we intended. We cannot guarantee that another person will interpret our silence generously. There will be occasions when protecting something important requires persistence, evidence and a willingness to remain involved in an uncomfortable disagreement.

But we can distinguish those occasions from the ones in which we are chiefly attempting to secure the satisfaction of having answered everything.

We can correct what deserves correction without assuming that every objection requires an immediate reply. We can maintain a conviction without requiring another person to endorse it. We can reconsider a position without treating the change as a defeat.

And we can recognize when the practical work of a relationship deserves more of our attention than the effort of establishing who has understood its history more accurately.

Victor and Alan carried the last box down the stairs.

Their mother asked whether they would like to stay for dinner.

Neither brother had obtained the final account of the earlier argument that he might once have wanted.

There were potatoes to peel, a table to set and several photographs their mother wanted them to see.

They stayed.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top