On his first morning as a supervisor, Daniel moved the chair from behind his new desk to the side of it.
He remembered how uncomfortable he had felt in that office when his previous manager had summoned him. The desk had always seemed to establish the nature of the conversation before either person spoke. One person possessed information and authority. The other waited to discover what was required of him.
Daniel had promised himself that he would do things differently.
For the first few months, he did. He explained decisions, encouraged his colleagues to raise concerns and occasionally stayed late to help them finish work that would otherwise have remained their responsibility.
Then the department began missing its targets. Senior management wanted quicker results. Two experienced employees left, and Daniel found himself repeatedly explaining problems to people who expected him to solve them.
One afternoon, a young employee named Marcus came to his office to discuss a change in the weekly schedule.
Daniel barely looked up.
“We all have problems,” he said. “You need to make it work.”
The young man hesitated before leaving.
Something about the sentence disturbed Daniel later that evening. He remembered hearing almost precisely the same words in that office seven years earlier, when he had asked his own manager for a little flexibility.
At the time, he had been furious.
Now the words belonged to him.
Why do we become what we once disliked? The question is uncomfortable because it challenges the assumption that recognizing a fault in somebody else is sufficient to prevent us from developing it ourselves.
Our disapproval may be entirely sincere. It may still fail to survive the circumstances in which maintaining it becomes difficult.
When the position changes, the explanation changes
From one side of a decision, its consequences can be painfully visible.
An employee whose request has been dismissed knows the difficulty that led them to make it. A child whose explanation has been interrupted knows what they were attempting to say. A customer who has been kept waiting understands the other responsibilities affected by the delay.
From the other side, the same event may appear to belong to a different collection of problems.
The supervisor is considering the demands of a department. The parent is attempting to finish several necessary tasks. The person serving customers is dealing with limitations that cannot easily be explained to everyone waiting.
A change in position can reveal genuine complexities we had previously been unable to see.
This matters because not every alteration in our judgment represents a departure from our values. Sometimes we learn that an earlier criticism failed to account for something important. We become more capable of recognizing the competing responsibilities within a difficult situation.
But there is another possibility.
We may begin regarding the circumstances that explain our behavior as sufficient reasons why other people should accept its consequences.
Daniel now understood pressures his former manager had rarely discussed with him. He knew how difficult it could be to maintain flexibility when staffing was inadequate and deadlines were approaching.
That knowledge did not make the young employee’s difficulty disappear.
In An Open Letter to Those Who Confuse Stability With Justice, we considered the difference between preserving an arrangement and establishing that the arrangement is fair. The problem also emerges in personal decisions. Making a system easier to manage does not automatically make the experience of everybody living within it acceptable.
Daniel had acquired an explanation for behavior he once disliked.
What he had not yet established was whether that explanation justified repeating it.
The principle that was easier to practice without power
A person who has never been responsible for making a particular kind of decision may develop a clear understanding of how the decision ought to be made.
Some of that understanding can be valuable. People affected by authority often notice consequences that those exercising it overlook.
But a principle can acquire an entirely different weight when practicing it begins to carry a personal cost.
Imagine a woman who has always criticized favoritism. She believes opportunities should be distributed according to defensible criteria rather than personal relationships.
Years later, she is responsible for selecting someone for a desirable position. Among the applicants is a person she has known for a long time. She understands their circumstances, trusts their intentions and knows how disappointed they will be if they are unsuccessful.
The other applicants possess circumstances she does not know nearly as well.
It becomes tempting to reinterpret the decision as an exception rather than an abandonment of the principle. Surely the person she trusts is a reasonable choice. Surely personal knowledge offers some information that cannot be obtained from a formal application.
Those considerations may sometimes be relevant. The danger lies in allowing them to replace a consistent examination of the candidates simply because the emotional cost of doing so is uncomfortable.
It is easier to oppose an unfair advantage when we are not in a position to grant one to somebody we care about.
The same difficulty accompanies many other convictions. Listening is easier when we are not exhausted. Accepting criticism is easier when our reputation does not appear to be at risk. Sharing authority is easier when we do not fear the decisions another person might make.
The test of a principle is not that applying it never becomes complicated.
It is whether we continue to regard it as relevant after the complications begin affecting us personally.
How a reaction becomes a habit
A mother hears herself speaking sharply to her child.
The words bring back a memory of conversations in her own childhood. She remembers promising that she would never talk to another person in that tone.
Yet the behavior has returned at a moment when she was tired, overwhelmed and unable to think of another response quickly enough.
We do not always develop our ways of responding through conscious agreement with the examples available to us.
Some become familiar because we have repeatedly encountered them. We learn what an argument sounds like, which words tend to end a conversation and how authority is expressed within the environments in which we grow.
Later, we may sincerely reject some of those practices while retaining habits of response we have not had sufficient opportunity to replace.
This does not mean a person’s history determines everything they will do. Nor does it establish that harmful behavior is acceptable because its origins can be understood.
It suggests that rejecting a pattern intellectually may be only one part of changing it.
Someone who wishes to handle disagreement differently may need to learn what to say when they feel criticized. A person accustomed to responding to uncertainty with control may need to develop ways of expressing concern without demanding obedience.
These alternatives can feel unfamiliar. In demanding circumstances, we may return to an established response before we have become practiced at another one.
In the earlier essay What Remains When Everything Changes?, we explored the ways inherited practices can survive without our clearly recognizing their origins. The same kind of continuity can preserve things we consciously wish to leave behind.
The mother’s recognition of her own tone offers an important beginning. But recognition alone cannot ensure that she will respond differently tomorrow.
She can apologize to the child, consider the conditions in which the reaction occurred and practice a more respectful way of expressing frustration.
If the pattern continues or causes significant harm, additional support may be appropriate.
The intention matters. So does the work necessary to give that intention a different form.
The fear of becoming the person who cannot cope
When Daniel accepted his new position, he had imagined proving that a department could be managed without the dismissiveness he had previously encountered.
The difficulty was that he had also imagined being successful.
As pressure increased, these ambitions began competing with one another. A conversation about an employee’s difficulties might reveal problems senior management expected him to resolve immediately. An admission of uncertainty could be interpreted as evidence that he was unable to carry out the responsibilities assigned to him.
He began shortening conversations whose outcomes he could not easily control.
At first, these decisions seemed temporary. There would be more opportunities to listen when the staffing problem had been resolved. He would explain the situation properly after the deadline passed.
But the periods in which he felt sufficiently secure to behave as he had intended became increasingly rare.
There is a peculiar danger in associating our values entirely with the kind of person we hope to appear to be.
If we regard ourselves as someone who is always capable, admitting difficulty can begin to feel more threatening than the difficulty itself. If we believe that good people are never unfair, recognizing our own unfairness can become a challenge to our entire identity.
We may then defend our conduct not because it deserves defense, but because acknowledging it would disturb the description through which we understand ourselves.
A more useful commitment might allow us to recognize that we are capable of acting contrary to our values without treating that recognition as the end of our moral life.
We are responsible for what we do, including things we once believed we were incapable of doing.
Accepting that responsibility requires a certain willingness to be disappointed in ourselves without becoming so concerned about the disappointment that we refuse to examine its cause.
When everyone around us does it
A new employee joins an organization in which people occasionally make cruel jokes about a colleague.
At first, the employee finds the conversations uncomfortable. They do not participate. Sometimes they leave the room when the subject arises.
Over time, however, other circumstances influence their response. The people involved are helpful in other situations. They include individuals whose approval could affect the employee’s prospects. The jokes are presented as a familiar feature of the workplace rather than as something requiring serious attention.
Eventually, the employee laughs at one of them.
The action may seem minor. But it changes the nature of the employee’s participation. Their earlier discomfort is no longer quite so easy to maintain because acknowledging the cruelty now requires acknowledging their own contribution to it.
The need to belong can influence our behavior in ways that an isolated statement of our convictions would not predict.
There are circumstances in which opposition carries genuine risks. A person may lack the security necessary to challenge someone with considerable authority. Another may have been placed in an environment where raising a concern is likely to produce retaliation.
It is important not to judge every silence as though speaking were equally safe for everyone.
Yet the pressures that help explain conformity do not remove the need to consider what our conformity is helping to sustain.
The subject of An Open Letter to Those Who Adapt Until They Disappear concerns the accommodations people make within demanding arrangements. An uncomfortable dimension of those accommodations is that some can affect not only our own lives but the lives of people with even less influence than we possess.
Where a direct challenge is unsafe, there may be other options: declining to participate, offering private support, seeking trustworthy advice or documenting a concern when doing so is appropriate.
No single response will suit every situation.
But it is worth noticing when the desire to remain acceptable begins requiring us to treat something we previously recognized as wrong as though it were merely ordinary.
The exceptions that slowly become our rules
Imagine a man who takes considerable pride in being dependable.
When he makes an arrangement with somebody, he generally keeps it. He regards other people’s time as something deserving respect.
Then he encounters a period in which his commitments become difficult to manage. He cancels a meeting at short notice and offers a reasonable explanation. The person affected understands.
Several weeks later, he cancels another. Then another.
Each occasion possesses circumstances through which the decision can be explained. What he has not considered is the pattern those occasions have created for the people around him.
From his perspective, he is dealing with a series of exceptional difficulties.
From theirs, he has become somebody whose promises can no longer be treated as reliable.
Much behavior that we once disliked in others develops through exceptions we have never examined together.
A person makes a sarcastic remark because they are annoyed. They dismiss a concern because they are busy. They excuse an unfair decision because the circumstances appear unusually difficult.
One instance may reveal relatively little about the character of an entire relationship.
Repeated instances acquire a different significance.
We may still hold the principle through which we originally understood ourselves. We simply keep finding reasons why this particular occasion does not require us to apply it.
That is why the quality of our intentions cannot be established exclusively by asking what we believe.
Sometimes we need to examine the arrangements our actions have produced.
The man may genuinely value reliability. If he has become unable to keep certain commitments, a more reliable response might involve making fewer promises, explaining his limitations in advance and acknowledging the inconvenience he has already caused.
Preserving the value does not require preserving the earlier appearance of capability.
It may require a more honest understanding of what he can actually undertake.
The people who can tell us what we cannot see
A friend who knows us well may notice a change before we recognize it.
They may observe that our conversations have become increasingly dismissive, that we are less interested in hearing disagreement or that we speak about other people’s problems with a confidence we did not formerly possess.
Receiving such information can be difficult, especially if we believe the change reflects experience and greater understanding.
Not every criticism is accurate. Some people interpret the establishment of a reasonable boundary as selfishness. Others may resent a change that reduces their influence over our decisions. We should not assume every unfavorable judgment deserves to determine our behavior.
But there is value in maintaining relationships in which our conduct can be questioned without making the continuation of the relationship entirely dependent upon agreement.
In What Makes a Life Worth Remembering?, we considered the importance of allowing other people to interpret the effects of our lives. They may encounter consequences that do not appear in our own account of what we intended.
The same distinction applies before a legacy has been established.
A supervisor can believe that they encourage open communication while their employees have learned to avoid bringing them unwelcome information. A parent may consider themselves patient while their child has developed an elaborate understanding of which subjects must never be raised.
The experiences of others do not provide a complete account of our character.
They can offer evidence about the effects of our behavior that our intentions alone cannot supply.
Listening to that evidence need not mean surrendering our judgment. It means including something in our judgment that would otherwise remain inaccessible.
Becoming different when it is inconvenient
The next morning, Daniel asked Marcus to return to his office.
He explained that he had responded poorly the previous afternoon and wanted to understand the scheduling difficulty more clearly.
Marcus was initially cautious. He had received an instruction and did not know whether discussing it again might create another problem.
Daniel listened.
It turned out that part of the difficulty could be resolved by exchanging two assignments. Another part remained complicated, because several employees had legitimate reasons for preferring the same schedule.
They did not arrive at a perfect solution.
Daniel did, however, recognize that the young man had brought him information rather than merely presenting an obstacle to the completion of his work.
In the following weeks, he began examining some of the ways the department handled requests. He could not grant everyone the arrangements they wanted. He could provide clearer explanations, establish more consistent procedures and give people a way to raise difficulties before decisions became final.
Some of those changes required conversations with senior management that he found uncomfortable.
That discomfort was part of the point.
He had wanted to be a different kind of supervisor. Remaining different meant more than retaining the opinion that his earlier manager had behaved badly.
It meant creating practical conditions through which he could act differently when the pressures associated with the position made his intentions difficult to maintain.
None of this guaranteed that he would never repeat the mistake.
But the mistake no longer belonged exclusively to a memory through which he could criticize somebody else.
It had become something for which he was capable of taking responsibility.
We become what we once disliked for many reasons: familiarity, pressure, fear, ambition, the desire to belong and the gradual convenience of judging our own circumstances differently from those of other people.
Understanding those reasons is worthwhile when it helps us identify where our behavior can change.
It becomes less useful when it merely supplies more convincing explanations for continuing as we are.
Perhaps the task is not to become someone whose convictions are never tested by life. It is to become sufficiently willing to examine the person we are becoming, particularly at the moments when looking away would be easier.
The chair in Daniel’s office remained beside the desk.
This time, he made sure there was someone sitting in it before he made the decision.



