What Are the Most Powerful Stories About Romantic Compatibility? The Two Harbors of Ilyra

What makes stories about romantic compatibility powerful? In a harbor that travels between two shores, a navigator and an illustrator must decide what kind of life they can truly share.

What Are the Most Powerful Stories About Romantic Compatibility? The Two Harbors of Ilyra

The harbor of Ilyra possessed an unusual property: it could be found in two different places, depending on the hour at which a ship approached it.

At the first light of day, it occupied a narrow bay beneath the mountains of the eastern coast. After sunset, it appeared beside a city of towers on the shores of the western sea.

The ships that entered during the day departed from the western shore at night. The warehouses, the people who worked in them and the houses within the ancient harbor walls traveled with the water.

Nobody knew why.

The inhabitants had developed a prosperous trade around the phenomenon and a complicated timetable for the arrival of relatives.

Those who lived beyond the harbor walls remained where they were.

This was the source of a particularly difficult question confronting Dima and Soren on the morning they intended to purchase a house.

The house possessed three bedrooms, a small balcony and an excellent view of the eastern mountains.

It did not travel with the harbor.

Soren liked it immediately.

Dima looked through the window.

“What happens to the sea at night?” she asked.

The owner laughed.

“It goes away.”

Soren smiled.

Dima did not.


They had met seven years earlier aboard a vessel carrying books and ceramics to the eastern coast.

Dima was its navigator. Soren, an illustrator, had been commissioned to prepare drawings of the harbor’s unusual structures.

He was standing on deck when she told him that a tower he was drawing would cease to be visible in eight minutes.

“Where will it go?”

“Depends which coast you’re on.”

He looked at his unfinished drawing.

“That’s very inconvenient.”

She laughed.

He asked whether he could see the charts.

She showed him those that were appropriate to share, explained the timings and told him about the old instruments used to determine the harbor’s position.

For the remainder of the journey he drew pictures of things she found unremarkable.

A rope wound around a post. A little window in the bridge. A cup whose handle had been repaired.

She liked his drawings.

He liked the way her explanations made the world seem larger.

When they arrived at Ilyra, they went to a restaurant near the harbor gate. They discussed books, islands they had visited and the difficulty of persuading restaurant owners that a person who had eaten enough did not necessarily dislike the food.

During the following year, Soren traveled with her twice.

They wrote to each other when she was away.

He established a studio on the eastern shore, where he accepted commissions from publishers and occasionally taught drawing. Dima continued working on merchant vessels, eventually obtaining a position that allowed her greater choice over the voyages she undertook.

They were delighted whenever their schedules brought them together.

They were equally delighted, sometimes, by the things they did separately.

Their friends regarded this as a particularly fortunate relationship.

Then Dima received an offer to take command of a vessel operating between distant ports.

At almost exactly the same time, Soren began looking for a house.


Soren was tired of rented rooms.

He had lived in eleven of them during his adult life. Several contained beautiful windows. One had a kitchen sink so small that washing a plate was effectively impossible.

He wanted a place where he could store his drawings, grow a tree and decide what color to paint a door without obtaining permission.

He began saving.

The eastern coast appealed to him for reasons that were partly practical and partly difficult to describe. His mother lived in a nearby town. Several friends had settled there. He knew the people who worked in the library and the small shop whose owner kept an astonishing collection of old printing equipment.

He also liked the landscape.

At the end of each day, when the harbor disappeared, a broad expanse of pale sand became visible beyond the old walls. Birds gathered there, and the mountains seemed to rise out of the empty horizon.

Soren had made dozens of drawings of that view.

He wanted to continue looking at it.

Dima liked the eastern coast too.

Her favorite moment, however, occurred shortly before sunset, when the water changed color and the familiar buildings on the western shore began appearing at the harbor entrance.

She had spent her childhood in several cities. Her parents operated a trading business, and the family moved whenever circumstances required it. She remembered the pleasure of arriving in a place she did not know.

She also remembered the frustrations of moving when she had wanted to stay.

As an adult, she had chosen work that allowed her to decide when to travel and when to return.

She did not regard a permanent home as an unattractive idea.

What she feared was a life in which most of her choices would eventually be organized around a single location.

She had told Soren some of this.

He remembered the conversations.

He had assumed that she would continue traveling while the house remained available for her return.

She had assumed that a shared home might be somewhere from which both could readily reach the kinds of work they wanted.

Neither realized quite how different those assumptions were.


After viewing the house, they went to the market.

Soren bought bread.

Dima examined a display of fruit brought from the western coast on the previous evening.

“Do you like it?” he asked.

“The house?”

“Yes.”

“It’s lovely.”

He smiled.

She waited.

Then she said, “It’s rather far from the western docks.”

He looked surprised.

“Only when they’re on the other side.”

She laughed.

“That happens every night.”

Her new command would involve departures from several western ports. Some voyages would begin at Ilyra, but others would require her to travel farther along the coast before joining the vessel.

The house on the eastern shore would introduce substantial complications. The harbor’s passage was frequent, but it was not available at every hour, and the transport arrangements beyond its walls were limited.

Soren suggested that she could stay near the western docks before particularly early departures.

She nodded.

She could do that.

She could also live nearer the western docks and avoid making a separate journey every time she wanted to come home.

He asked whether she thought they ought to look at more houses.

“Yes.”

He put the bread in his bag.

They walked back toward his studio.

For the first time that morning, he felt resentful.

He had not been looking merely for a house. He had been looking for a version of their future that he had imagined so often it had acquired the emotional significance of something they already possessed.

He thought of the couple in The Apartment With Two Clocks, whose shared affection could not make one apartment accommodate two completely different working lives.

The problem had seemed rather obvious when it belonged to other people.

He found it less obvious when it concerned a balcony he had already imagined filling with plants.


Dima invited Soren to travel with her on one of her remaining voyages before beginning the new appointment.

He accepted.

The ship left Ilyra shortly after sunset, carrying equipment to two islands and a consignment of paper to a western city.

The first evening was beautiful.

The second was extraordinarily cold.

On the third, Soren discovered that drawing aboard a moving vessel was considerably less enjoyable than drawing pictures of one.

He spent most of the day attempting to find a position in which his pencil did not roll away.

Dima was busy.

They met at meals and occasionally walked together on deck. He enjoyed hearing her describe the work. He also found that he had little desire to undertake anything resembling it himself.

At the first island, they visited a shop selling small wooden boats.

Soren bought one for his mother.

Dima asked whether he would like to travel to the northern islands with her at some future date.

“Perhaps.”

He examined the little boat.

Then he said, “Do you ever want to stop?”

“Stop what?”

“Going places.”

She looked at him.

“Sometimes. That’s why I come home.”

He nodded.

For a moment he was tempted to ask whether she would want to travel less often if they had a house together.

He remembered that she had applied for a job which would require considerable travel.

There was already a fairly clear answer available.

Rather than asking the question, he told her something he had not previously explained: he wanted more ordinary time together.

He liked their reunions. He would also like evenings in which nothing especially important was happening.

He wanted the experience of being able to invite her for supper without consulting a maritime schedule.

Dima listened.

She had been imagining that a regular place to return to would be sufficient for him.

She understood now that he wanted something about the distribution of their time, not merely its geography.

They bought coffee near the harbor.

Then they returned to the ship.


In the western city, Dima’s sister, Lale, invited them to dinner.

Lale worked in a school situated near the old city walls. Her partner maintained equipment at the harbor. They had two children, a narrow apartment and a habit of beginning conversations about household expenses at particularly unsuitable moments.

After supper, Soren helped the children with a drawing.

Dima and Lale washed dishes.

Dima described the house on the eastern coast.

“Are you going to buy it?”

“No.”

“Does Soren want it?”

“Yes.”

“Do you?”

“Not really.”

Lale looked at her.

“Then I suppose it’s useful that you haven’t bought it.”

Dima laughed.

She explained that she did not wish to disappoint him. He had been looking forward to settling somewhere. She could understand the pleasure he found in the idea.

Her sister listened.

Then she asked whether Dima actually wanted the new appointment.

“Yes.”

“Why?”

Dima described the vessel, the freedom it would give her over certain professional decisions and the routes she hoped to travel.

Lale smiled.

“You sound quite certain.”

“I am.”

“Then why do you keep talking as though you’ve been ordered to go?”

Dima stopped washing the plate in her hands.

She had been explaining the difficulties of the appointment as though they were unfortunate circumstances over which she had little influence.

In fact, she had chosen to apply.

She was excited by the job.

She had concealed this enthusiasm because she was afraid Soren would interpret the strength of it as evidence of the weakness of her love.

Her sister dried the plate.

“Tell him you’re happy about it.”

Dima nodded.

She remembered the restaurant owners in A Recipe for Different Winters, whose business partnership became strained when they discovered that their ambitions had not been as similar as they once imagined.

Dima did not want Soren to discover her choices only when their consequences reached his studio.

She wanted him to know why she was making them.


They returned to Ilyra on a clear morning.

The eastern mountains appeared behind the harbor wall. Soren stood on deck, recognizing the buildings, and felt a pleasure so considerable that he began smiling before the ship had reached its berth.

Dima saw him.

“Happy?”

“Very.”

She smiled too.

Later, in his studio, they looked through the drawings he had made on the voyage.

Several depicted the mountains. Others showed fragments of the ship, the people working aboard it and the little wooden boat he had bought.

Dima particularly liked a drawing of an empty chair on deck.

“It was yours,” he said.

She looked at him.

“You weren’t sitting in it.”

She laughed.

They made supper.

Then they began discussing the future.

Dima told him how much she wanted the appointment. Soren told her how much he wanted a settled home. They examined several possible arrangements without immediately trying to choose one.

There were properties within Ilyra’s traveling harbor. Most were expensive, and some were unsuitable for establishing a studio of the size Soren wanted.

There were homes on the western coast that would make Dima’s voyages more convenient. Soren could move his work, though several of his regular commissions and important friendships were connected to the eastern shore.

They could also live in separate places and continue meeting whenever their schedules permitted.

Soren regarded that possibility with considerable reluctance.

He had enjoyed their relationship as it had existed.

He was hoping for a different one.

Dima understood.

She, too, wanted more time with him. She was less certain about how much of her work she would be willing to change to obtain it.

They did not agree that evening.

But they were able to finish supper without behaving as though the discussion had been an examination one of them had failed.


The following month, a storm damaged part of Ilyra’s eastern harbor gate.

The officials responsible for the structure restricted access to several areas while assessments took place. Passenger arrangements changed. Some of the usual routes were unavailable for weeks.

Soren had agreed to meet Dima on the western shore during a brief interval between two voyages.

He could not reach the harbor at the appropriate time.

They spoke by telephone.

“Tomorrow?” he asked.

“I’m leaving tomorrow.”

He nodded, although she could not see him.

“Of course.”

She heard the disappointment.

She began apologizing.

He told her there was no reason to apologize for the storm.

Then he said he was tired of their conversations ending with a new date.

Dima was quiet.

She knew that the arrangements were sometimes difficult for him. She had also spent a great deal of time traveling to see him and adjusting her schedule when possible.

She did not want either person’s efforts to become invisible.

“I am trying,” she said.

“I know.”

They remained silent.

After the call, Soren walked to the old harbor entrance.

The water was calm. Workers were examining part of the damaged structure from a distance.

He thought of the people in The Last Seat on the Night Train, whose friendship and romantic feelings did not immediately provide an answer to the practical question of how they wished to live.

He had once imagined that the strength of a relationship could be demonstrated by its ability to survive difficult circumstances.

He had not considered that people might legitimately prefer not to arrange their lives around surviving the same difficult circumstances indefinitely.

He went home.

That evening he ate alone.

The room was pleasant.

He wished Dima was in it.

Both facts were true.


When the harbor reopened fully, they spent a week in a small rented apartment within its walls.

The owner had warned them that some visitors found the transition between the eastern and western views disorienting.

Soren found it delightful.

Dima found the apartment inconveniently small.

The kitchen contained two chairs, one of which had to be moved whenever somebody wanted to open the refrigerator. Soren arranged drawing materials on a table beside the window. Dima discovered that the journey to the western docks was indeed much easier.

For several days they considered whether a permanent home inside the harbor might be possible.

They visited properties.

They examined the prices.

One place had a large room suitable for a studio, but its monthly cost exceeded what they considered prudent. Another was affordable, but occupied a building whose management prohibited the kinds of activities Soren needed to undertake there.

A third had possibilities.

They discussed it for two evenings.

Then Dima asked whether Soren would be happy if she was away for several weeks at a time even if they had found the ideal home.

He considered the question.

“Sometimes.”

She smiled.

“What about most of the time?”

He looked toward the window.

“I don’t know.”

They had been so interested in the geographical problem that they had occasionally neglected the one concerning time.

A better location could make their reunions easier.

It could not make the voyages shorter.

Soren remembered the couple in The Room We Never Painted, who had discovered that wanting a shared home did not resolve a fundamental disagreement about what they wanted their future to contain.

His own circumstances were different.

There were still arrangements worth exploring.

But he understood why a desirable house could not be allowed to become an answer to every question about the relationship.

He asked Dima whether she intended to continue accepting long voyages indefinitely.

She said she did not know.

He nodded.

There was no reason to answer an uncertain future with a promise neither could responsibly make.

They agreed on an arrangement for the next year.

He would look for a home he could afford independently on the eastern coast. She would take the appointment and make suitable arrangements near her usual ports. They would plan time together in advance, discuss changes honestly and review whether the relationship continued to meet their needs.

It was not the future either had initially imagined.

It was a future they were both willing to try.


Soren bought a small house near the eastern library.

It did not have the beautiful balcony he remembered seeing on the first viewing. It did have a room suitable for his work and a garden large enough for a tree.

Dima helped him move.

They chose a color for the front door.

He painted it.

She took a photograph before leaving for her first long voyage.

For several months the arrangements worked well.

Then Dima accepted an extension to a journey which meant that a visit they had planned would no longer be possible.

She told him.

He was disappointed.

They discussed it.

He explained that he did not wish to become a person whose ordinary happiness depended on the next opportunity to see her. She explained that she did not want to feel that accepting work she enjoyed was a recurring act of harm.

Neither accused the other of being unreasonable.

Both recognized that their preferences were consequential.

At the end of the year they reconsidered the arrangements.

Soren had begun teaching regularly at the library. Dima’s work was going well. They still loved each other.

He asked whether she wanted to continue the relationship in its present form.

She looked at him.

“I want to be with you.”

He smiled sadly.

“So do I.”

Then they discussed how much of a shared life they actually wanted, and what they could offer one another without repeatedly abandoning something important.

Eventually they decided to stop being a couple.

They did not make the decision because the year had contained nothing good.

They made it because the good things were insufficient to make the pattern of their lives satisfactory to both of them.

Soren took a walk after Dima left.

He passed the harbor gates shortly before sunset.

The western towers were beginning to appear.

He had drawn that moment many times.

He stood and watched until the water changed.


Years later, Dima entered the eastern harbor on a ship she had helped design.

She had continued traveling. Eventually she began working on a combination of technical projects and shorter voyages, an arrangement she found particularly satisfying.

The eastern city contained several buildings she did not remember.

Soren’s drawings were being displayed at the library.

She went to see them.

Among the earliest pieces was a pencil drawing of a chair on the deck of a ship. She recognized it immediately.

Soren was speaking to a visitor when she entered.

He saw her.

They smiled.

Afterward they went for coffee.

He told her about his teaching, his garden and a woman he had been seeing for several years. Dima told him about her work and some of the places she had visited.

They were glad to know each other.

They did not attempt to establish that they would have been happier if their decisions had been different.

When they parted, Dima walked toward the harbor.

Powerful stories about compatibility, she thought, were not always stories in which two people discovered a way of remaining together. Sometimes they were stories in which the characters learned what they could honestly offer. Sometimes love helped people recognize a difference rather than eliminate it.

There were no guarantees about the life she had chosen.

Neither had there been guarantees about the other one.

She looked back at the mountains.

Soren had gone home to a house she remembered helping him paint.

She was going to a ship.

The harbor lay between them.

For a few hours, both shores belonged to the same view.

Editorial note: Original fantasy fiction. All characters, locations, institutions and supernatural phenomena are invented. Stories about romantic compatibility can be powerful because genuine affection may coexist with different values, needs and visions of an ordinary life. Practical compromises may support a relationship when both people freely accept them; differences that repeatedly undermine essential needs may call for a different decision. Compatibility is not a measure of a person’s worth, and a respectful separation does not invalidate the affection that preceded it.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top