The Things Money Cannot Measure

A literary reflection on the things money cannot measure, the importance of financial security, and the deeper value of time, care, relationships and everyday generosity.

The Things Money Cannot Measure — an old brass key and a family photograph on a sunlit repair-shop workbench.

On the morning the valuation arrived, Yusuf was sitting in his father’s old repair shop, trying to decide what to do with a collection of keys.

The shop had been closed for six months. His father had died in the spring, and the family had agreed to sell the premises. There was little disagreement about the decision. Nobody intended to continue the business, and maintaining an empty building would have placed an unnecessary burden upon them.

The valuation was encouraging. The property was worth considerably more than his father had paid for it thirty years earlier.

Yusuf examined the document and placed it on the counter.

Then he returned to the keys.

Some belonged to cupboards that were no longer there. Others had been attached to small pieces of cardboard bearing descriptions his father had written. A particularly worn key opened the back door through which Yusuf had entered the shop after school.

While sitting there, he remembered the afternoons he had spent waiting for his father to finish work. He remembered a customer who always brought newspapers, the kettle that took an unusually long time to boil and the neighbor who occasionally came in simply because he wanted somebody to talk to.

The valuation contained useful information about the building.

It could not tell him what had happened within it.

Yusuf did not resent the distinction. The family needed to know the market value of the property. There were financial arrangements to settle, and obtaining a fair price mattered to everybody involved.

But he found himself thinking about the difference between establishing what something could be sold for and establishing what it had meant to the people whose lives had become associated with it.

The two questions were neither identical nor opposed.

They simply required different kinds of answers.

The importance of having enough

A discussion of the things money cannot measure should begin by acknowledging the things money can make possible.

Consider a household in which the income is barely sufficient to cover accommodation, food, transport and other essential expenses.

A modest increase in that income may make a considerable difference to the lives of the people involved. It may allow a parent to replace a broken appliance rather than continue improvising around its absence. It may make an educational opportunity accessible or reduce the uncertainty associated with paying a bill.

Financial security does not remove every difficulty a person encounters.

It can change the circumstances under which many of those difficulties are experienced.

A worker who has some savings may be able to leave an unsuitable position without immediately facing the loss of their accommodation. A person who can afford reliable transport may find it easier to maintain relationships with relatives living elsewhere.

It would therefore be unreasonable to ask people facing serious financial difficulty to take comfort merely in the observation that other things are important.

The existence of valuable experiences that cannot be purchased does not make the resources required for ordinary participation in life any less necessary.

In The Quiet Cost of Always Being Strong, we considered how the demands placed upon a person’s time and attention can become overwhelming when practical alternatives are unavailable. Money sometimes provides those alternatives.

The distinction worth making is not between a material life and a meaningful one.

Our material circumstances help determine which opportunities for meaningful participation are actually available to us.

Yusuf’s father had worked long hours because the shop needed to provide an income. The family had benefited from his ability to earn a living there.

Recognizing its other forms of importance did not require forgetting this one.

It required remembering that the purpose of earning a living was not exhausted by the amount that could eventually be entered on a valuation.

When a price stands in for a judgment

A woman named Claudia was considering two offers of employment.

One offered substantially higher pay. It also involved frequent travel and a degree of unpredictability concerning her working hours. The other offered less money but provided a more dependable schedule.

She spent several evenings examining the financial differences.

The calculations were useful. She knew how much each arrangement would contribute to her savings and how the additional travel might affect her expenses.

The difficulty arose when she attempted to decide what the figures meant.

She had a daughter approaching the end of her school years. Claudia enjoyed their evenings together and knew that the arrangement would probably change when her daughter moved elsewhere to study.

The higher salary was genuinely attractive. The time she might lose was also genuinely valuable.

It would have been possible to calculate an approximate amount of additional income for each evening spent away from home. Such a calculation might have clarified the practical implications of the offer.

It would not have determined whether those implications were acceptable.

There are decisions in which money provides an unusually clear description of one part of the situation. Other considerations are harder to express with comparable precision.

That difference can give the financial consideration an appearance of greater authority than it deserves.

As explored in The Lives We Measure Against Others, an achievement that is easy to describe may attract attention away from the daily circumstances through which it is produced.

A salary can be recorded in a single figure. The character of the evenings available to somebody under a particular employment arrangement cannot be described quite so readily.

Claudia needed to examine the financial consequences carefully. She also needed to give the consequences for her time a degree of consideration that did not depend upon her ability to assign them an exact monetary value.

Another person facing the same offers might reasonably reach a different conclusion.

The importance of the decision lay in recognizing what each arrangement would make possible, what it would require and which of those differences mattered within the particular life she was arranging.

The work whose value is difficult to record

For several years, a man named Louis helped his neighbor maintain a small garden.

The neighbor was elderly and could no longer perform some of the heavier tasks. Louis occasionally carried bags of soil, repaired a fence or moved containers to places where they could be watered more easily.

They often talked while he worked.

An estimate of the commercial value of his assistance would have depended upon the time involved and the cost of obtaining comparable services.

Such an estimate might have been useful if the neighbor needed to make a different arrangement. It could have provided information about the resources required to maintain the garden.

But it would have left something important out of the account.

The neighbor enjoyed the conversations. Louis had learned considerably more about cultivating vegetables than he would otherwise have known. Their relationship had acquired a familiarity that made it easier for each of them to ask for assistance when something else became difficult.

Some of the benefits involved could not be separated neatly from the particular people between whom they developed.

Similar difficulties arise when we attempt to describe the importance of unpaid care, voluntary work and the informal assistance through which many communities function.

There are sound reasons to make the economic significance of such work visible. A person who spends much of their life caring for a relative may have sacrificed income, savings or opportunities for advancement. Ignoring the financial consequences can make an already unequal arrangement appear less demanding than it is.

Recognizing the other dimensions of care does not mean treating its costs as irrelevant.

Nor does recognizing its economic significance require reducing the entire relationship to the cost of purchasing equivalent services.

The work may deserve better practical support precisely because of the importance of the people and experiences involved.

Louis’s neighbor could reasonably have needed professional assistance with the garden. Providing it would not necessarily have diminished the value of their conversations.

A fair arrangement would have allowed their friendship to continue without requiring every practical difficulty to be addressed through Louis’s availability.

It is possible to recognize the value of a relationship while also recognizing the importance of the resources that help sustain it.

When something becomes more expensive without becoming more meaningful

At an antiques market, a woman named Nora found a cup remarkably similar to one her grandmother had kept in a kitchen cupboard.

The cup at the market was in excellent condition. Its decoration was intact, and the seller explained that it belonged to a desirable collection.

Nora’s grandmother’s cup had a small chip near the handle.

Its commercial value was probably quite modest.

Nevertheless, Nora would not have exchanged it for the one at the market.

She remembered her grandmother serving tea in it on afternoons when the two of them sat beside a window. She remembered being allowed to use it after reaching an age at which her grandmother believed she could be trusted not to drop it.

The chipped cup was not valuable to her because damaged objects possess some general superiority over undamaged ones.

It was valuable because it belonged to a particular history.

In What We Choose to Carry Forward, we considered the different relationships people develop with the objects and practices they inherit.

An object can have an importance that depends upon knowledge unavailable to the person attempting to assign it a price.

Of course, that importance does not necessarily transfer to another owner. Nora could explain why she valued the cup, but somebody who had never met her grandmother would have little reason to experience it in quite the same way.

This is one reason that personal significance and market value can diverge so considerably.

It is also a reason to be careful when judging other people’s attachments.

A person may retain an object that appears to have no considerable financial worth. They may spend time restoring something that could be replaced more cheaply. They may prefer a modest arrangement whose familiarity matters more to them than the apparent advantages of a more expensive one.

These preferences do not always need to be defended as financially efficient decisions.

Where the practical costs are manageable, they can be understood through the purposes the objects or arrangements actually serve.

Nora left the market without buying the cup.

When she returned home, she took her grandmother’s cup from the cupboard.

It still held tea perfectly well.

The difference between rewarding a contribution and purchasing it

At a small organization, employees were regularly thanked for their willingness to undertake work beyond the requirements of their positions.

The manager spoke warmly about their commitment. He explained that their efforts had helped the organization through a difficult period and that he regarded their contributions as evidence of the quality of their relationships with one another.

Several employees appreciated the acknowledgment.

They also wanted their additional hours to be recognized in their pay.

There are circumstances in which appealing to the nonfinancial value of work can become a means of avoiding its financial obligations.

A teacher may care deeply about the progress of students. A nurse may find the work personally meaningful. An employee may have developed genuine friendships with colleagues.

None of these observations establishes that the person should receive less compensation for the work they perform.

The fact that money cannot fully describe the value of an undertaking is not a reason to neglect the financial arrangements surrounding it.

Indeed, some of the work that contributes most substantially to other people’s lives requires considerable training, attention and responsibility.

The people performing it may reasonably expect conditions that make its continuation sustainable.

There is a related distinction in personal relationships.

We can compensate somebody fairly for work without supposing that the payment purchases every feature of their attention, character or feelings. Paying an employee for a service does not provide an entitlement to their humiliation. Paying for a professional’s time does not establish ownership of their life beyond the arrangement.

Money can settle certain obligations.

It cannot make every other question concerning the relationship disappear.

The manager eventually reviewed the distribution of work and the arrangements for compensating additional hours.

His appreciation of the employees need not have become less sincere because it acquired a practical expression.

It may have become more credible.

The importance of recognizing what money cannot measure belongs alongside the importance of paying fairly for the things that can and should be measured.

The things we make available without an expectation of return

During his father’s years at the repair shop, Yusuf had occasionally watched him refuse payment for a particularly small task.

Sometimes the customer was someone he knew well. Sometimes it was a person who had come into the shop with a difficulty that could be resolved in a few minutes.

His father did not regard every opportunity to help as an obligation to work without payment. He charged for the work that sustained the business and could become frustrated when people assumed that a favor would always be repeated.

But he enjoyed being able to make an occasional decision that did not depend upon establishing an equivalent financial return.

There is a place in human life for exchanges of this kind.

A person may share knowledge with a neighbor, spend an afternoon helping a friend or give away an object that somebody else can use. Such decisions may produce future benefits, but their significance does not always depend upon an expectation of receiving those benefits.

As explored in The Moral Life of Small Decisions, ordinary actions can influence the quality of the arrangements through which people live together without attracting much recognition.

The freedom to offer something without calculating an exact return can be particularly valuable when it is accompanied by the freedom to decline.

A gift that has become compulsory has acquired a different character.

A relationship in which one person continually gives and the other continually expects may need a more careful examination than a simple celebration of generosity can provide.

Yusuf’s father had sometimes helped customers without charging them, and those decisions had belonged to him. He had also explained when a job would require payment.

Both practices had helped preserve the conditions under which his work and his relationships with customers could continue.

The value of his occasional generosity did not depend on a willingness to make the entire business financially unsustainable.

It was the possibility of giving something freely within an arrangement that could otherwise support itself.

The key to the back door

The day before the shop was handed over to its new owner, Yusuf walked through it for the last time.

Most of the furniture had been removed. The counter stood alone in the front room, and the shelves that had once contained tools were empty.

He had found a use for some of his father’s equipment and given other items to people who could still work with them.

The financial arrangements had been concluded.

Before leaving, he took the worn key from his pocket and looked at the back door.

It no longer needed to be opened by him.

He decided to keep the key.

Perhaps the things money cannot measure become more visible when we stop asking a financial account to provide a complete description of an experience.

We can recognize that adequate income matters, that work deserves fair compensation and that material security can make valuable choices available.

We can also recognize forms of importance whose character does not depend upon how much another person would pay to obtain them.

A friendship can make an afternoon worthwhile. A familiar object can retain the memory of somebody who is no longer present. A person’s time can matter to us in a way that cannot be replaced merely by purchasing an equivalent number of hours.

These things are not valuable because they exist in opposition to money.

They are valuable because of the purposes they serve and the histories they contain.

Yusuf turned off the lights, closed the front door and delivered the remaining keys to the estate agent.

He was glad that the sale had provided the family with a fair return on his father’s years of work.

Later that evening, he placed the old key in a small wooden box beside a photograph.

There were two different kinds of value in the decisions he had made that day.

Neither required him to deny the importance of the other.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top