Seventeen After School | Chapter 5 | The Sound of Silence

As 5:17 faces a choice between secrecy and trust, the friends create a safer show and confront the fears they have hidden from one another.

Cinematic title artwork for Seventeen After School: a vintage clock above a dusk-lit school corridor and an illuminated study room, with the story title in cream lettering.

The listeners had voted, and the result was not an answer.

Thirty-eight people wanted 5:17 to continue under new rules. Eleven wanted it closed. Eight preferred a longer pause. Three replies had arrived without a selection, each containing a sentence that required more attention than a number.

One said: I don’t trust you, but I miss hearing people be honest.

Another said: Stop asking us what you should do.

The third said: Maybe you can make something that doesn’t need anyone else’s secrets.

Miri printed the responses without names and laid the pages across a desk in Room 17. The three-week trial had begun that Monday. At ten minutes past five, the room was nearly full and the appointed supervisor was helping a student find a spare calculator.

“We can’t use a vote to decide whether a private person gets protected,” Sol said.

“No,” Hana agreed.

“Then what was it for?” Levi asked.

“To find out whether people still want to listen to us.”

“Do they?”

“Some do. Some don’t. Most students haven’t heard of us.”

The last fact seemed to trouble Levi more than the others. Hana wondered whether the lives they imagined for themselves had always depended too much on an audience.

“How can we be famous enough to have a scandal and not famous enough to run a radio show?”

Miri moved the page away from him.

“We weren’t famous. A photograph was.”

He did not argue.

The room felt different under the new arrangement. A supervisor sat near the entrance. Students signed in only if they had registered for the supervised-study program, while other visitors were counted without names. A kettle stood behind a safety notice. The chairs that had been removed were being returned one by one, depending on whether the facilities team needed them for examinations.

Three weeks was an awkward kind of time. Too long to feel temporary every minute, too short to build a reliable habit.

The district had agreed to review its figures at the end. Until then, the question remained open.

Hana was discovering that a promise about a room was not quite the same as a room.

At lunch, Mr. Orr asked the four students to meet him with Ms. Carden. He did not look pleased, but he also did not look as though he had summoned them for a punishment.

“I’ve listened to your correction,” he said.

Levi stared at the carpet.

“It’s appropriate that you took responsibility,” Mr. Orr continued. “It doesn’t undo what happened. You know that?”

“Yes,” Levi said.

“Good. I also listened to the first episode. Some parts were thoughtful.”

Hana resisted the temptation to say thank you too quickly.

Mr. Orr opened a folder.

“If you use school equipment, we need clear arrangements. Adult oversight, a way to report harm, no recording without specific consent, and no storing sensitive submissions in an open classroom. It cannot operate as a secret club under the school’s name.”

“So we have to stop?” Miri asked.

“You have to decide whether you want to become a proper student media project.”

Levi looked up.

“That’s an unexpectedly boring way to say we can keep going.”

“Most safeguarding is boring,” Ms. Carden replied. “That is one of its strengths.”

Sol smiled.

They went away with a list of questions rather than permission. How would they handle anonymous messages? Who could ask for a recording to be taken down? What happened if somebody sent a disclosure suggesting immediate danger? Who moderated a reply sent at midnight? How would they distinguish a story they could share from a problem that required qualified help?

It was a longer list than any of them had expected.

“Maybe the answer is no submissions,” Sol said when they returned to the cupboard.

“Then what do we talk about?” Levi asked.

“Things we know. Things we can check. Things we volunteer to say.”

“That sounds less exciting.”

“Good,” Hana said.

Levi made a face. “You both keep using that word as though it’s a compliment.”

Sol opened the old laptop. The screen’s colors had faded around the edges. On the desktop were recordings of two school concerts, a badly labeled interview with a former headteacher, and a file named FINAL_FINAL_REAL_THIS_ONE.

“Let’s not build a show around being interesting,” Sol said. “We can build it around being trustworthy.”

Miri wrote the sentence on a sheet of blue paper. Beneath it she added one word: HOW?

For a week they worked on that question.

They stopped accepting private confessions entirely. The old form was taken offline, its contents reviewed and securely deleted or routed to appropriate support through Ms. Carden where necessary. They stopped treating a collection of voices as proof of understanding. They posted a notice explaining what had changed. No one promised perfect anonymity. No one called an unlisted feed a safe place to disclose a crisis. Instead they developed a short program about the things students could discuss openly: exam pressure, borrowed uniforms, waiting for buses, the hours of the school library, and the ordinary difficulty of asking for company.

Each speaker would know exactly which words would be published. Each could withdraw consent before upload and request removal afterward. They would not record anyone else in the room without permission.

Hana found the work satisfying in a way the first burst of excitement had not been. It resembled editing sound: listening for the small distortion that could change the meaning of the whole.

But not everybody was satisfied.

Levi missed the unplanned surprise of hearing someone say the truth for the first time. He missed the shock of recognizing a feeling he had never named. When Miri suggested the next episode explain the bus timetable changes, he leaned back in his chair and sighed.

“The whole thing is becoming an announcement board.”

“Then make the announcement worth hearing,” Miri replied.

“How?”

“By remembering there’s a person waiting at the bus stop.”

Sol looked up from a drawing.

“Or we could stop trying to convince everybody that this is a radio show,” they said. “Maybe it’s a place where people can say what they choose, not what we ask them to confess.”

Levi considered that for a long time.

On Wednesday, he asked Hana to come with him to the bakery near the waterfront.

Rafi was waiting outside.

He was nineteen and had the restless, self-conscious confidence of somebody who had recently become an adult and was still hoping the world would notice. He kept looking from one of them to the other as though unsure which face he was supposed to address.

“I took the post down,” he said.

“I know,” Levi answered.

“I didn’t mean it the way people took it.”

“I know you didn’t think about how people would take it,” Hana said.

Rafi looked down.

“I said it was wrong,” he replied. “What else do you want?”

Levi’s hands had begun to shake, but his voice was steady.

“You need to stop telling people it’s a misunderstanding. You made a private thing public. You removed the part that said the writer didn’t want it read.”

“I was trying to warn people—”

“You wanted people to look at your post.”

Rafi opened his mouth, then closed it.

The truth between them was unpleasant and smaller than either boy had wanted. Nobody had planned a scandal. Two careless decisions, each defended as harmless, had turned a student’s fear into school gossip.

“I’m sorry,” Rafi said at last.

Levi nodded, but he did not offer forgiveness on behalf of anyone else.

They walked back along the waterfront in silence. The water was low, exposing stones that were covered at high tide. On the far bank, windows came on in the apartment blocks one after another.

“I used to think my job was to make everyone like me,” Levi said.

“That’s a very large job,” Hana replied.

“Apparently impossible.”

“Also that.”

He kicked a pebble into the gutter.

“I keep looking for the moment when I can say the right thing and everything goes back to before.”

Hana thought of the names people try to put away without acknowledging the people who bear them. Nothing about the photograph could be folded out of existence. The best they could do was refuse to repeat the harm.

“Maybe there isn’t a before anymore,” she said.

Levi stopped walking.

“That is the most depressing motivational speech I’ve ever received.”

“It’s not meant to be motivational.”

“Fair.”

At school the next morning, Sol had left an envelope on the editing desk.

Inside was a printed application to an art college in another city, along with three sketches of the stairwell clock and a list of portfolio requirements. The deadline was in two weeks.

Hana found Sol in the auditorium, standing on a chair to repair a paper lantern for the winter performance.

“You’re applying,” she said.

Sol looked down.

“I haven’t sent it.”

“Why not?”

“What if I get in?”

“Isn’t that the point?”

“Yes, and what if I do and then everybody here just carries on without me?”

Hana had not expected the question. Sol never sounded jealous. They were the person who remembered birthdays without making a performance of it, who brought extra pencils for people who forgot theirs, who could sit beside someone in silence without seeming bored.

“I didn’t know you were afraid of that,” Hana said.

“That’s because I spend most of my time making sure other people don’t feel left out.”

Hana held the chair steady while Sol climbed down.

“You should apply,” she said.

“I know.”

“And if you get in, we’ll still know you.”

“That isn’t the same as staying.”

“No.”

For a while they stood beside the lanterns. They were made from thin paper and wire, ordinary materials arranged to hold light. Sol had painted a different window on each one.

“You could record that,” Hana said.

Sol raised an eyebrow.

“You just told me not to make a show out of other people’s fears.”

“I mean if you wanted to. Your choice. No surprise microphone.”

Sol looked at the envelope again.

“Not today.”

“Okay.”

Miri was the next to admit that she had been afraid.

She did so on Friday while filling in a form for a school newspaper scholarship. She had missed a deadline for an essay competition because she had spent the previous week checking the room counts and responding to the committee.

“Why didn’t you tell us?” Hana asked.

“Because I was the one who said we had to be organized.”

“You’re allowed to have other things.”

“I know that as a theory.”

She put the pen down.

“I worry that if I stop being useful, nobody will need me.”

Hana sat beside her.

“I need you when you tell me I’m wrong,” she said.

“That’s useful.”

“I need you when you make a terrible joke.”

“I don’t make terrible jokes.”

“You do. You’re just selective about your audience.”

Miri laughed once, unwillingly.

“Will you help me finish the application?” she asked.

“Yes.”

“Without turning it into a project?”

“I’ll try.”

Hana was the last of the four to put words to her fear. It came to her on an ordinary evening when her mother had left for work and she was washing cups at the sink.

The school had accepted the three-week trial. The show might return. Her friends had begun telling each other things they had withheld for years. She should have felt successful.

Instead she felt a strange emptiness.

For weeks she had been the person with the equipment, the recordings and the plan. Without those, she was simply Hana, a girl whose mother worked nights and who liked the sound of old clocks.

She was afraid that being useful was the easiest way to be loved.

The thought was so plain that she almost laughed. It sounded like something she might have put on one of Sol’s blue cards. She did not write it down.

She called Levi.

“Are you busy?” she asked.

“I’m pretending to revise. It’s going very well.”

“Could you stay on the phone for a bit?”

“Do you want to tell me what’s wrong?”

“Not yet.”

“Fine.”

He stayed.

On Monday afternoon, the four met again in the recording cupboard. The new program was ready: twelve minutes on Room 17’s revised hours, the bus stop, the volunteer count and the difference between official attendance and actual use. It included a short interview with the caretaker, who had checked the heating schedule and found a way to keep the back wing open without running the entire system. Every person recorded had heard and approved their own words.

There were no anonymous confessions.

Hana placed her finger above the upload button.

“Are we doing this?” Levi asked.

Miri checked the consent forms.

Sol checked the audio.

Hana listened once more. In the middle of the program, there was a pause of five seconds after the caretaker described the students waiting beyond the locked door. The silence was not an error. It gave the listener room to imagine what a number could not describe.

“Should we cut it?” Levi asked.

“No,” Hana said. “Leave it.”

The pause stayed.

When they uploaded the new episode, they did not announce a triumphant return. They gave it a plain title: 5:17 — A Room and Its Hours.

The first reply arrived an hour later.

Thank you for saying where the bus stop is.

The second said:

I still don’t trust the show. But this was useful.

The third was from someone who had found the school annex too far away from the north exit. They offered the timings of the buses they actually caught, with a request that the information be checked against the transport notice before anyone repeated it.

Miri smiled at that.

“Somebody else is asking us to be accurate.”

“Terrifying,” Levi said.

By the end of the day they had twenty-one listens. Fewer than the first episode. More than Hana had expected after everything that happened.

She told her mother about it when they ate breakfast together before school.

“Now do you know what you’re trying to do?” her mother asked.

Hana looked toward the kitchen window, where morning light caught the edge of a glass.

“I think we’re trying to make it easier for people to find a place where they’re heard,” she said. “Without making them give us something private first.”

Her mother poured the last of the tea.

“That sounds worth doing.”

“But not at the cost of our own lives.”

“Especially not that.”

Hana returned to school carrying the old recorder, though she was not planning to use it. She had wrapped it in a scarf to keep the dust out. The stairwell clock lost its minute at 5:17, as it always did.

On the noticeboard beneath it, a new sheet had appeared.

ROOM 17: TRIAL PERIOD REVIEW — STUDENT FEEDBACK WELCOME.

Below the heading was an empty box for suggestions.

The box was not hidden.

The instructions did not ask for secrets.

For the first time, Hana wondered whether being heard could be as simple as a message finding the right place to land.

Then she noticed something else.

The box was mounted too high for the younger pupils to reach easily. The paper beside it contained three columns of small print. The timetable had been written in school-office language, with abbreviations that would mean little to somebody who had never attended a committee meeting.

Hana took out her notebook.

There was still work to do.

But the work no longer belonged only to her.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top