How does envy change a person? Envy may redirect attention from an activity we value toward the relative success of others. Its effects are not uniform: Research by Niels van de Ven (2017) found that envy can generate both motivation to improve one’s own position and motivation to undermine someone else’s. This original story explores how unexamined comparison can reshape a person’s judgment at work, and what accountability requires when those feelings influence behavior.
By the time the police telephoned the newspaper, I had already taken my colleague’s name off the story.
I told myself I was correcting an oversight. I had done the interviews after all, driven forty miles through sleet, sat in a widow’s kitchen and persuaded a reluctant clerk to show me the records. What had Felix done? He had looked at the figures, asked one question, and found the missing money.
One question. That was what I could not forgive him for.
The inspector wanted to know whether we had understood the significance of the documents we were publishing that morning.
“Both of you?” she asked.
I looked across the office. Felix’s chair was empty. On its back hung the ridiculous red scarf his daughter had made him for Christmas.
“Yes,” I said.
It was the first honest answer I had given since midnight.
The newspaper at the end of the road
The Banner occupied the second floor of a brick building between a pawnbroker and a bakery. At five every morning the smell of bread came through the stairwell, and by eight the smell of hot electrical equipment had defeated it. We published the news of a district which people from the capital considered too small to have any. There were council meetings, school concerts, businesses opening and closing, the occasional scandal, and an extraordinary number of disagreements about parking.
I had been a reporter there for thirteen years. My name was Lena Voss. I knew which people would answer a telephone before breakfast and which people would take three days to admit they had received a message. I could recognize the sound of the northern road through a car window without looking outside.
When Felix Bell arrived, he was twenty-seven and possessed a notebook containing tiny, impenetrable diagrams. Our editor, Ruth, told me to show him around.
He asked questions while I introduced him to the staff.
“How do we obtain the older council reports?”
“Through the archive. I’ll show you.”
“Are the contracts filed with them?”
“Sometimes.”
“What’s the difference between the numbers in the budget and the numbers in the final statement?”
I explained what I knew. Then I told him that if he wanted to understand the district, he should spend an afternoon walking through its market.
He did.
Two days later he returned with a notebook full of names and a bag of apples. A man who sold fruit had given them to him after explaining the cost of renting a stall.
Felix asked whether the market’s finances might make a story.
I said they might.
We worked on it together. I enjoyed discovering how quickly he could turn a pile of reports into something intelligible. I showed him how to follow up an interview when somebody gave an answer that sounded more useful than it was.
The story appeared on the front page with both our names.
My mother bought three copies.
For several months, there was very little I disliked about Felix.
A name in larger type
One April morning, Ruth called us into her office. Our article about the market had been shortlisted for a regional journalism award. She was delighted. The staff went downstairs for coffee.
Then she explained that the award committee wanted one of us to participate in a discussion about the investigation. She suggested Felix because he had developed the analysis of the records and the discussion would focus on the use of public financial information.
I understood the reasoning.
I also remembered the time I spent establishing the relationships that allowed us to understand the records in the first place.
Felix offered to ask whether I could accompany him.
I said that I was not particularly interested in going.
He looked surprised.
“Really?”
“I’ve been to enough of those things.”
That was untrue. I had attended precisely one regional journalism event, on a morning when the train was canceled and the sandwiches were stale. I had wanted to attend another ever since.
Felix went.
When the photographs appeared, I inspected each of them. There was a picture of him speaking into a microphone. There was another in which he stood beside a reporter whose work I admired. A caption described him as one of the area’s promising young journalists.
I was thirty-nine.
I had no particular desire to be described as a promising young journalist. I discovered, however, that being described that way had become a desirable thing as soon as somebody else received the description.
For several days I drafted messages congratulating him. Then I found reasons not to send them.
I thought of Nathan in The Violin Behind the Wall, whose attention began moving from the music he wanted to play toward the man he wanted to beat. I liked that story. It was easier to recognize his mistake than to close the photographs of Felix.
The following Monday he asked whether I wanted an apple.
I took one.
I spent the afternoon wishing that I had been able to refuse without making my answer sound rude.
The broken heating system
The investigation that changed our newspaper began with a telephone call from a woman named May.
She lived in a municipally owned building on the outskirts of the town. During an exceptionally cold period, the heating system stopped working. The residents had reported the problem. Temporary assistance was arranged, but there were delays in undertaking the permanent work.
May wanted to know why the repairs took so long.
I went to see her.
She served tea in a cup displaying a picture of a lighthouse. Her husband had bought the cup during a holiday. He had died two years earlier.
She showed me her correspondence about the heating. I took notes, obtained permission to examine the relevant copies and asked questions about the experiences of other residents.
May had been collecting information for several weeks. She knew the names of the people who attended meetings and could identify the dates of several visits by repair workers.
She said somebody had told her that replacement work was included in a contract agreed the previous year.
I contacted the authority and requested information.
Felix was examining the accounts connected with maintenance contracts. He had been working on a separate inquiry into expenditures in the district.
When I told him about May, he opened one of his diagrams.
“Do you know which building she lives in?”
I told him.
He pointed to a row of figures.
The building appeared to be among the premises covered by a contract whose payments included the replacement of certain equipment. The documents did not establish whether that particular work had been completed.
We requested further information.
There was a great deal we did not know. Several records required clarification. The contracting arrangements were complicated.
Over the next two months, we interviewed residents and workers, obtained documents through appropriate channels and gave the organizations concerned opportunities to respond to the matters we were investigating. We checked dates against invoices and reports; we took advice about what we could substantiate and responsibly publish.
Felix noticed that a series of payments had been classified in two different ways.
The difference turned out to be important.
We identified evidence suggesting that several charges had been submitted for work the supporting records described inconsistently. The authority commissioned a review. The contractor disputed aspects of our interpretation.
We were careful to distinguish the things the documents showed from the suspicions they raised.
Then the authority referred the matter to the appropriate investigators.
Ruth asked us to prepare the article.
The picture of the widow
May agreed to be photographed.
She wanted the picture to show the room in which she had spent most of the winter. There was a blanket across the chair. Beside it was the cup with the lighthouse.
Felix accompanied me.
He asked whether the circumstances had improved since our first visit.
May described the work that had been undertaken and the things that remained difficult.
Then she turned to me.
“You’re the one who came in the snow.”
I laughed.
I had forgotten how bad the weather was that morning.
She remembered.
Felix was making notes about the timing of the repairs.
May looked at him.
“Did you find something, then?”
He explained the records as plainly as he could.
She listened.
Then she asked whether the money would be recovered.
He said that he did not know.
She nodded.
She was interested in whether the arrangements would improve. The people living in the building wanted reliable heating, information they could understand and a way of obtaining answers when something went wrong.
On our way back to the office, Felix said that May had done an extraordinary amount of work.
I agreed.
Then he suggested including an explanation of her efforts in the article.
I added it.
There were people whose stories we published principally because they helped us tell other stories. May deserved to be recognized for the information she had gathered.
It reminded me of Ivo in The Garden of Borrowed Shadows, who had been proud of the work he undertook until somebody else’s award changed the meaning he gave to it. He eventually recognized other people’s contributions. I found the ending particularly satisfying.
In our office that evening, however, I began wondering whether the article would be regarded as Felix’s discovery.
I wanted the reader to remember May.
I wanted the reader to remember me.
I did not understand why those wishes had begun to feel like incompatible demands.
The story goes to press
The first version of the article contained two names.
Ruth read it and made several revisions. She asked us to clarify the chronology and to remove an inference that the supporting information did not establish.
We made the changes.
Felix went home shortly after ten because his daughter had been ill.
I said I would complete the final checks.
The article was scheduled for publication early the following morning. The publishing system allowed me to edit the displayed byline.
I clicked the field.
There were two names.
My own name appeared first.
For nearly two minutes I looked at them.
There were arguments I could make about why I deserved particular recognition. I had obtained the initial interview. I had carried out numerous conversations with people whose accounts mattered. I had written most of the article.
There were also arguments supporting Felix’s name.
He found the relationships in the figures that allowed the investigation to proceed. He helped verify material. He prepared sections of the analysis and took part in the reporting.
We had agreed to share the credit.
I deleted his name.
Then I changed the field that described his role in the article, moving his contribution into a general acknowledgment of research assistance.
The edition would go out under my name.
I thought about the way Ruth would react when she noticed.
I could say the byline was accidentally changed. I could describe an earlier conversation about the writing and suggest that I understood the arrangements differently.
I had developed several explanations for a thing that had not yet happened.
Then I went home.
I scarcely slept.
The telephone call
The story began attracting attention in the morning.
A regional station requested an interview. A journalist from the capital wanted to discuss the investigation. Several people sent messages thanking me for the work.
For a little while, I experienced exactly the feeling I had expected.
It was wonderful.
Then the investigator telephoned.
She had been reviewing material connected with the referral and wanted to clarify several details of our reporting. She asked whether both reporters understood the significance of the relevant documents.
I said yes.
After the conversation ended, I walked toward Felix’s desk.
His red scarf hung on the chair.
He arrived twenty minutes later.
He had seen the article.
He put his bag on the floor.
“Was that a mistake?”
I had imagined the question precisely.
Now I could not bear the expression on his face.
I could have said yes.
Then I remembered an article we had published the previous winter. A woman responsible for a public exhibition had discovered that a late alteration removed a person’s contribution from the record. The account reminded me of The Audience of Empty Coats, in which a sound editor had to decide whether protecting herself from a difficult conversation mattered more than conveying somebody else’s experience.
I had created the difficulty by making the alteration.
“No,” I said.
Felix looked at me.
I told him what I had done.
He listened.
Then he asked why.
I described the things I had been thinking about since the announcement of the earlier award.
For a while I tried to explain them in a way that would make my behavior appear less unpleasant.
He stopped me.
“Did you think I didn’t contribute?”
“No.”
“Did you think we hadn’t agreed?”
“No.”
He nodded.
He said that he wanted the byline corrected.
He also wanted Ruth to know what happened.
I agreed.
He walked toward her office.
I followed him.
The correction
Ruth did not find the circumstances difficult to understand.
She asked me to explain my actions. Then she spoke with Felix separately and reviewed the information concerning the preparation of the article.
She arranged for the byline and acknowledgment to be corrected and for an appropriate note explaining the correction to be added. The relevant people dealt with the other versions of the story as far as possible.
The correction did not reach everybody who had read the original.
I wished it could.
I apologized to Felix.
I also apologised to Ruth for deliberately changing the agreed attribution while completing the final work.
There were consequences. Ruth reviewed the arrangements under which I could publish and edit material without another person’s involvement. She explained what she expected from me and what would happen if I did not meet the requirements.
Felix did not immediately want to work with me again.
I wanted him to understand that I regretted what I had done.
He understood.
That did not determine whether he trusted me with another piece of work.
I spent several weeks experiencing a mixture of embarrassment, anger and sadness.
Some of the anger concerned me. I would find myself remembering the earlier award and imagining that my conduct might have been different if Ruth had invited me to the discussion.
I knew this was an inadequate account of what happened.
There were things I could have discussed with Ruth. There were ways I could have asked for opportunities to develop my work. There were also ways I could have expressed a legitimate concern about recognition without taking recognition away from another person.
I had not chosen those ways.
The reporter I wanted to become was not the reporter I had been that night.
The other investigation
The newspaper continued reporting on the maintenance inquiry.
We published the authority’s findings and the responses of the organizations concerned as the material became available. The relevant proceedings were not something our newspaper could determine.
May telephoned during the summer.
She wanted to know whether we would write about the residents’ meeting.
I went.
Several people wanted to discuss changes to the information provided about repairs. One man had a suggestion concerning the arrangements for contacting the management team. May had prepared a list.
She asked about Felix.
I told her that we were working on separate stories.
She said that she appreciated the care with which he had taken her questions.
I agreed.
Then she showed me the list.
We spent an hour discussing the issues.
Afterward, I walked to the bakery beneath the newspaper’s office. The woman behind the counter knew me and asked about a series of articles I had written several years earlier.
She particularly remembered one about the people who maintained a footpath beside the river.
I had almost forgotten the article.
It occurred to me that I had spent a great deal of time measuring my career through the opportunities and recognition I wanted, and considerably less time remembering the work I had already undertaken.
I could be ambitious.
I could be disappointed.
Neither required me to regard the career of a person beside me as an obstacle to the existence of my own.
During the following months, I obtained some professional support for the distress I had been experiencing. I also discussed opportunities to develop my work with Ruth. We agreed on several projects and the standards by which they would be assessed.
I wanted to learn more about analyzing records.
Felix had been particularly good at it.
I was still uncomfortable acknowledging that.
Then I spent an afternoon learning how to produce a better table.
The next edition
Two years later, Felix moved to another newspaper.
Before he left, Ruth arranged a little gathering in the office.
He thanked several people.
He mentioned things we had worked on together.
I was grateful.
I did not believe that his acknowledgment meant everything had returned to the way it was before the article.
We had slowly established a workable relationship again. There were things he was willing to discuss with me and things he preferred to undertake independently.
I respected the difference.
At the gathering, he told a story about his first week at the Banner.
He remembered a fruit seller who gave him apples.
I laughed.
Then he asked whether I remembered the photograph from the award discussion.
I did.
He said a reporter pictured beside him had asked whether he could provide information about our investigation. The conversation led him to discover several methods of examining the documents that later proved useful.
I had spent days envying a photograph without knowing what happened shortly before or after it was taken.
After the gathering, I returned to my desk.
There was an article waiting for me to finish. It concerned a woman organizing a small collection of recordings from people who remembered a railway station.
She had talked to nearly forty people.
I thought of the archivist’s story, The Archive of Unsent Postcards, whose narrator learned to distinguish information that belonged to a particular person from the story she wished to tell about them.
I checked the names in the article.
Then I checked the name of the colleague who had helped me obtain the recordings.
Both appeared where they should.
I wanted the piece to be excellent.
I hoped people would read it.
I was pleased by the prospect of somebody recognizing my work.
The desire had not disappeared.
Outside the window, people were carrying bags of bread away from the bakery.
Felix’s red scarf was gone from the back of his chair.
An hour later, I sent Ruth the article.
There were two names above it.
After the story: The Banner, its staff and the investigation are fictional. Lena’s experience distinguishes feelings of envy from the choices she makes in response to them. Recognition can be pursued without denying another person’s contribution.



