How does social anxiety change a person? Persistent fear of scrutiny may gradually influence someone’s choices, friendships, education, career and willingness to pursue activities they value. Avoidance can make a life appear to shrink, even when the person wants connection. These effects are not inevitable or permanent; appropriate care can help. The NHS social anxiety guide explains the impact and available treatments.
On the day she was supposed to give her sister away, Lila stood in the women’s bathroom with a small blue umbrella open above her head.
There was no water falling from the ceiling.
The umbrella had been in her bag because the morning forecast predicted showers. She had opened it without thinking. Now she was standing beneath it in a room that smelled of roses and hand soap, trying to remember how to breathe normally.
Someone knocked.
“Lila?”
It was her sister, Hannah.
“One minute.”
“You have the rings.”
Lila looked down.
The rings were in a little velvet box beside the sink.
Beyond the bathroom was a room containing one hundred and six guests, a woman holding a microphone and a collection of chairs arranged so that anybody walking between them could be seen by everybody else.
Lila had helped organize the wedding for nearly a year.
She loved her sister.
She wanted to see her get married.
She also wanted to become a person who did not have a body.
“Lila?” Hannah said again.
“I’m coming.”
She closed the umbrella.
Then she opened the door, handed her sister the rings and said something she had been avoiding for most of her adult life.
“I don’t think I can do the speech.”
Spring: the invitations
Six months earlier, the two sisters had been sitting at a kitchen table covered with scraps of paper.
Hannah wanted to make the invitations herself. She was a primary-school teacher with a deep suspicion of stationery that looked as though it had been made by a computer.
Lila was a graphic designer.
She had been making invitations professionally for nearly eight years.
“Don’t worry,” she said, “I can make them look homemade.”
Hannah laughed.
They spent the afternoon choosing a design containing a little drawing of a tree. Their father had planted a tree in the garden of the house where they grew up, and the sisters wanted something from their childhood included in the ceremony.
Their father had died three years earlier.
Hannah was going to walk into the room with Lila instead.
“Will you say something?” she asked.
“At the wedding?”
“Just something short. About Dad, maybe.”
Lila nodded.
She knew immediately that she should have asked to discuss it another time.
Instead she imagined Hannah discovering that her sister did not want to do the one thing that might replace a little portion of their father’s absence.
“Of course.”
The answer made Hannah happy.
Lila went home and spent the evening trying to imagine every possible version of the wedding.
She would enter a room. People would turn toward her. She would walk beside Hannah and then sit in a chair.
At some point she would need to stand up.
There would probably be a microphone.
She might forget what she intended to say.
Her face might become red.
People might notice her hands shaking.
She might cry in a way that made her voice sound peculiar.
She sat at the table until nearly midnight, looking at the drawing of the tree.
When Hannah called the following day, Lila told her that she was excited.
She was.
That was part of the difficulty.
Summer: a life made smaller
Lila had not always avoided so many things.
At university, she had liked working in the studio late at night. There were several other students who regularly remained there, and somebody usually brought food.
She enjoyed their conversations.
She also dreaded the presentations in which each student was asked to describe a project before the rest of the group.
At first she prepared extensively.
Then she began preparing even more extensively.
She wrote complete scripts. She memorized the scripts. She imagined questions that might be asked and wrote answers to them.
Once, during a presentation, somebody moved a chair.
She lost her place.
For several seconds she stood looking at the class.
A tutor asked if she wanted to continue.
She said yes.
When the presentation ended, her friend Marcus told her that he liked the project.
She did not hear much of what he said.
She was trying to establish whether the pause lasted five seconds or fifteen.
Over the following years, she selected projects that required fewer presentations. When she applied for work, she paid particular attention to the kinds of interactions associated with the position.
She found a job in a design company where most of her work could be undertaken at a desk.
Then she took a position that allowed her to work at home on several days.
Eventually she established a small business and worked almost entirely from her apartment.
There were many reasons to like the arrangement.
She enjoyed being able to organize her time.
She was good at the work.
She could spend an afternoon drawing without being interrupted.
She also found it increasingly difficult to attend meetings in person, telephone a new client or eat lunch beside somebody she did not know.
Each time she avoided something, she experienced relief.
She remembered the young photograph restorer in The Quiet Carriage, who wanted a job but found the journey toward it almost unbearable.
Lila understood the experience.
She was beginning to wonder how many of her decisions described the work she wanted to do, and how many described the circumstances under which she believed herself able to do it.
Hannah was not shy.
She enjoyed meeting people and had a habit of inviting newly acquainted acquaintances to tea. She was also unusually perceptive about several things that frightened Lila.
When they were children, Hannah sometimes ordered food for both of them.
Lila was grateful.
At family gatherings, Hannah began conversations with people Lila liked and brought her into them.
Lila was grateful for that too.
Their mother occasionally told Hannah that she should allow Lila to speak for herself.
Hannah said she was helping.
She was.
The sisters rarely discussed the circumstances under which the help was useful and the circumstances under which it made it easier for Lila to avoid something she wanted to be able to do.
Their father, a mechanic with little interest in parties, had understood some of Lila’s preferences.
When relatives asked why she was quiet, he occasionally replied that he had heard enough noise for one afternoon.
She loved him for it.
She did not believe her father understood everything she experienced.
There were occasions when she wanted to join a conversation very badly.
She could not explain why doing so felt difficult.
After he died, Lila stopped attending several of the gatherings she previously endured with his company.
She missed him.
She also missed the familiarity of having somebody beside her whose presence reduced the amount of attention she paid to her own.
When Hannah announced the engagement, Lila was pleased.
She liked Hannah’s partner, Sam. She wanted to become part of the lives the two would make together.
Then she learned how many people might attend the ceremony.
Her first substantial concern was that her absence would be noticed.
Her second was that her presence would be noticed.
Neither seemed to offer a particularly attractive solution.
August: a conversation that did not go as planned
Marcus contacted Lila after seeing a photograph of one of the invitations she made.
He lived in the same city and wanted to know whether she might be interested in helping with a project his small publishing business was developing.
They arranged a meeting at a cafe.
Lila arrived early.
She selected a table near the wall and examined the menu.
She wanted to order before Marcus arrived.
Then she worried that doing so would be rude.
She waited.
Marcus was wearing a coat she remembered him owning at university.
They laughed about it.
He explained that he wanted to publish a collection of illustrated essays about buildings people remembered from their childhood.
Lila was delighted.
She had spent years making drawings of the house where she and Hannah grew up.
Marcus wanted to see some of them.
She showed him photographs on her telephone.
He was particularly interested in a drawing of the kitchen.
“Would you talk about it at the launch?”
Lila looked at him.
For several seconds she considered saying yes.
Then she said that she was interested in the illustration work but found speaking before an audience difficult.
Marcus nodded.
“All right.”
He began describing other ways in which they might introduce the drawings.
Lila was astonished.
She had prepared herself for a conversation in which he found it necessary to reconsider working with her.
He was principally interested in the drawings.
She thought of the map engraver in The City Where Every Face Was a Mirror, who had learned that other people could be carrying entirely different concerns from the ones he imagined.
Marcus had come to the cafe with a project.
Lila had arrived with a collection of possible judgments.
It was fortunate that one of them was willing to discuss the project.
They made several arrangements.
When he asked whether she wanted another coffee, she said yes.
The following week, Lila contacted her doctor.
She had considered doing so before.
Each time, the idea of explaining the problem appeared to belong to the problem itself.
She was concerned that she would be asked why she operated a business if speaking to people frightened her. She was concerned that she would find it difficult to describe the extent to which ordinary activities affected her.
At the appointment, she brought a piece of paper containing several examples.
She described the presentations, the journeys she avoided, the meals she postponed and the hours she sometimes spent remembering a conversation.
She also described the wedding.
The doctor listened and discussed the available options.
Lila subsequently began working with a qualified therapist. They explored the patterns that appeared before, during and after social situations. They discussed what she feared, how she interpreted physical sensations and the ways she tried to prevent herself from appearing anxious.
Some of the practices they developed involved activities she had been avoiding, undertaken gradually and in accordance with what they agreed would be appropriate for her.
She found them difficult.
The first time she ordered coffee while somebody stood behind her, she felt as though the queue was considerably longer than it actually was.
She ordered the coffee.
The next time was not necessarily easier.
There were days when she wanted to remain at home.
There were also days when she remembered the drawings Marcus wanted to publish.
She wanted to be able to do things that mattered to her.
She wanted to stop using the weather inside her body as the only forecast for the afternoon.
September: a weather report
When the sisters were children, their father used to describe the atmosphere of the house as though it were the weather.
A disagreement about the television produced light winds.
Their mother’s discovery that nobody had washed the dishes produced a risk of thunder.
Hannah’s first attempt to bake bread resulted in extensive cloud cover and poor visibility.
The language made the children laugh.
After his death, Lila occasionally wrote similar descriptions in the margin of her notebooks.
Monday: heavy cloud near the telephone.
Tuesday: unexpectedly clear at the library.
Wednesday: storms predicted, several hours without rain.
The notes were not intended to produce a scientific account of anxiety.
They helped her recognize that an unpleasant prediction did not invariably describe what would happen, and that the feelings occurring during an activity could change.
One afternoon she showed the notebook to Hannah.
Her sister smiled at the references to their father.
Then she looked at the entries again.
“I didn’t know it was this bad.”
Lila was surprised.
She had believed her difficulties were obvious.
She had also devoted considerable effort to making them less obvious.
Hannah remembered the occasions on which Lila declined invitations.
Sometimes she interpreted them as a wish to spend time alone.
Sometimes she believed her sister disliked the people attending an event.
Lila explained that there were occasions when she genuinely preferred to be alone and occasions when she wanted to attend something but found the prospect distressing.
The two experiences did not always look different from outside.
Hannah listened.
Then she asked about the speech.
Lila felt a familiar pressure in her chest.
“I think I can do it.”
She meant that she wanted to do it.
She also meant that she did not want to discuss what might happen if she could not.
Hannah said that they could make another arrangement if needed.
Lila thanked her.
For the remainder of the afternoon, she thought about the phrase another arrangement.
She wanted to be able to stand in the room and speak about their father.
The desire had become entangled with a fear that choosing a different arrangement would reveal something unpleasant about the sort of sister she was.
October: the first draft
Lila wrote the speech in a little notebook containing a picture of a bird.
She described the tree in the garden.
She described the afternoons their father returned from work, put his coat on a chair and asked whether anybody wanted toast.
She remembered him teaching Hannah to ride a bicycle.
She remembered him helping her turn a piece of cardboard into a model of a house.
She wanted the guests to know that he was a funny man.
She also wanted them to know that he could become remarkably irritated by a cupboard door.
It was not a long speech.
She liked it.
Then she began practicing it.
She read the first sentence forty times.
She considered whether to remove a word that she occasionally found difficult to pronounce.
She recorded herself on her telephone and listened to the recording.
She disliked the sound of her voice.
She tried another pace.
Then she imagined the faces of the people listening.
Her therapist discussed the practice with her. They considered ways of preparing without making the preparation an attempt to eliminate every possibility of discomfort or uncertainty.
Lila practiced reading a portion of the speech to Marcus.
He listened.
At the end, he asked whether the tree still stood in the garden.
She said she did not know.
He liked the description.
She was astonished to discover that somebody who had heard the speech wanted to know something about the tree rather than discuss the way she read it.
She thought of the actor in The Actor Who Never Left the Stage, whose attention became so occupied by pleasing a succession of audiences that it left very little room for his own experience.
Lila had been trying to produce a speech that would make it impossible for anybody to think badly of her.
The speech concerned a person she loved.
She wanted to remember that while reading it.
The wedding: eleven minutes before noon
The rain had stopped by the time Hannah arrived at the venue.
Lila helped with several practical arrangements.
She carried flowers.
She spoke to the woman organizing the music.
She found the little velvet box containing the rings.
Then the guests began arriving.
The room became noisy.
A relative she had not seen for years approached her.
He asked how the business was doing.
Lila began answering.
Another person joined the conversation.
She lost the sentence.
She laughed in a way that sounded unnatural to her.
The relative asked whether she was excited about the wedding.
She said yes.
Then she went to find the bathroom.
Her body felt as though she had been running.
She was disappointed.
For several months she had been working on the difficulties associated with situations like this one. She had accomplished things she previously avoided.
Now she was standing beside a sink, frightened of returning to a room containing people she wanted to see.
The experience did not resemble the improvement she had imagined.
She had expected improvement to feel like a change in the weather.
She had not anticipated that she might become better able to do things while the weather remained unpleasantly familiar.
The umbrella was in her handbag.
She opened it.
For a few moments the blue fabric narrowed the room to a little circle.
Then Hannah knocked.
The choice
Hannah took the rings.
She looked at her sister.
“Is it the speech?”
Lila nodded.
Hannah asked whether she wanted to sit somewhere quieter.
They found a little room where several bags had been stored.
For a while Lila described what she was feeling.
Hannah listened.
Then she asked what Lila wanted to do.
“I want to walk in with you.”
“Okay.”
“I want you to have the speech.”
Hannah nodded.
“Would you like me to read it?”
Lila looked at her.
She did.
She also wanted, very badly, to be the person who read it.
The two wishes were not easy to separate.
They discussed several options, including the possibility that Lila might read a few lines later if she wanted to, or that Hannah might read the whole thing.
They decided that Hannah’s friend would handle the announcements and that the speech could be read without requiring Lila to stand before the room.
Lila felt relieved.
Then she felt disappointed.
Hannah squeezed her hand.
“We’re getting married, not conducting an examination.”
Lila laughed.
She remembered the museum curator in The Museum of Broken Promises, who discovered that the importance of a commitment could survive changes to the circumstances in which it was fulfilled.
Lila wanted to be beside her sister.
There were several ways of doing it.
They returned to the room.
The music began.
They walked between the chairs.
Lila felt the attention of the guests.
She looked at Hannah.
Her sister was smiling at Sam.
The two reached the front.
Lila sat down.
She was still nervous.
She was also extraordinarily pleased to be there.
At the meal, Hannah read the speech.
When she reached the passage about the cupboard door, several people laughed.
Lila cried.
She did not need to explain that the tears concerned several different experiences.
She missed her father.
She liked the way Hannah read the words.
She was sad that she had not been able to read them herself.
She was happy that they were being heard.
Later, Marcus came to the table.
He asked whether she wanted to go outside for a few minutes.
They walked across a little courtyard.
The pavement was wet.
He told her about an illustration he wanted her to make.
She was interested.
For a while they discussed the arrangement.
Then Hannah appeared wearing a pair of shoes that looked considerably more comfortable than the ones she wore during the ceremony.
She wanted a photograph of the three of them.
Lila agreed.
A guest took the picture.
In it, Hannah was laughing. Marcus was looking slightly to the left. Lila was holding the blue umbrella, which had somehow survived the afternoon without being needed outdoors.
She liked the photograph.
The following spring: the room beyond the forecast
The launch of Marcus’s illustrated collection took place the following spring.
Lila had contributed six drawings.
One depicted the kitchen of the house where she grew up. Another showed the tree in the garden.
She attended the event.
The organizers displayed the drawings. They had arranged for the contributors to speak if they wished to, and Lila had discussed her participation in advance.
She chose to say a few words about the kitchen.
Before her turn, she felt worried.
She looked at the notes she carried.
When she stood, her hands were shaking.
She told the audience that the drawing was based partly on memory and partly on a photograph.
Then she described the cupboard door.
A man laughed.
She smiled.
She stopped after two minutes.
There were things she wished she had said differently.
There were also things she had managed to say.
When she sat down, Marcus asked whether she wanted something to drink.
She did.
They went toward the table.
Later she continued working with her therapist, discussing difficulties that remained and the activities she wanted to pursue. She did not regard the evening as the conclusion of her experience.
There would be days when she found a conversation difficult.
There would be days when she chose to spend time alone because she enjoyed it.
She wanted the difference between those days to remain something she could consider.
At home, she opened the notebook.
Thursday: heavy clouds, particularly before seven.
She added another line.
Went to the launch. Talked about the kitchen. Enjoyed the pictures.
Then she closed the notebook.
Hannah had called earlier.
Lila telephoned her.
They discussed the garden of the old house, the possibility of planting another tree and a film they wanted to see together.
Neither mentioned the weather.
After the story: Lila’s experience is fictional. The wedding is not a test of her worth or recovery; her choice to adapt the speech does not invalidate her progress. Treatment for social anxiety should be individualized with a qualified professional. Being quiet or preferring solitude is not by itself a disorder.



