At nine on the morning the museum opened its new wing, a bronze plaque fell off the wall and landed at the feet of the woman whose name was engraved on it.
Dr. Amira Venn bent to pick it up.
For six years she had researched the collection, negotiated loans, supervised the cataloguing of objects and argued about the width of doorways. She had helped bring together a team of conservators, historians, designers and technicians whose combined work had transformed an abandoned railway warehouse into a museum.
Her name appeared on the plaque because she was its founding curator.
It looked remarkably like a mistake.
“Don’t worry,” said a technician named Pavel. “We’ll put it back.”
Amira turned the plaque over.
There were two little strips of adhesive on the back.
She had spent much of her adult life expecting that the authority attributed to her would prove to be held in place by something equally inadequate.
She handed it to Pavel.
“Perhaps something stronger?”
He laughed.
Then the museum’s director came through the door with news that a visitor had arrived carrying a letter which might change the provenance of the most important object in the exhibition.
Amira checked the time.
The opening ceremony began in three hours.
The museum of Lorne had acquired a considerable collection of objects during the preceding century, not always with the care that later generations considered appropriate. The collection included domestic utensils, manuscripts, paintings, machinery and several items whose descriptions had become more elaborate with each successive catalogue.
Amira had first entered the building at thirteen.
Her father drove a delivery van. Her mother worked in a school kitchen. Neither had been to university, although both possessed a considerable interest in things they had never studied formally.
On rainy afternoons her father sometimes took her to the museum. He particularly liked an old clock whose mechanism operated behind a glass panel.
Amira was more interested in a little ceramic bird.
Its label indicated that it had been recovered from a house near the northern border. There were several questions about its age and its original use.
She asked her father why the museum did not know.
He examined the label.
“Perhaps nobody’s found out yet.”
She liked that explanation.
At university, many years later, she remembered it whenever a lecturer presented a question that appeared to have already occupied several generations of scholars.
She loved the idea that an institution could preserve something without possessing a complete understanding of it.
The difficulty was that the same principle became much less attractive when she considered her own place in such an institution.
Her first semester at the university contained innumerable occasions on which she appeared to be learning two subjects at once.
One concerned the history of material culture.
The other concerned how to behave in a room containing people who seemed already to understand the history of material culture.
Several classmates had visited important collections overseas. One knew a curator personally. Another had been encouraged to study ancient languages while still at school.
Amira had spent her final summer before university working at a supermarket.
When the lecturer asked whether anyone had read a particular book, she watched three hands rise.
She wrote down the title.
Then she went to the library.
The work was interesting. She did reasonably well, then rather well. She learned how to examine a reference, follow an argument and identify the difference between a possibility and a supported conclusion.
Her tutor, Professor Belen, encouraged her to undertake a research project.
Amira accepted.
On the day she received her first excellent assessment, she called her parents.
They were delighted.
Afterward, she reread the tutor’s comments and identified several reasons why the result might not be a reliable indication of her abilities. The question had suited her interests. The tutor had been sympathetic to her subject. A friend had helped her locate a useful book.
The assessment did establish that she had completed the work successfully.
Amira seemed determined to establish something else.
When a later essay received a lower mark, she did not subject the result to comparable scrutiny.
She remembered it for years.
Her first museum position involved cataloguing a collection of household objects.
The work was sometimes tedious. A wooden spoon might arrive with no accompanying documentation, while a remarkably ordinary chair might possess a history extending over five generations.
She learned to distinguish the information supplied by donors from the information that could be independently corroborated.
Her colleague Vika was particularly good at locating administrative records. Amira helped her examine inscriptions on several objects. Together they established the likely history of a box containing letters from an industrial district.
Their supervisor thanked them.
Amira immediately began describing Vika’s contribution.
Vika interrupted.
“Yes, and yours.”
Amira laughed.
She was quite comfortable acknowledging work that belonged to somebody else.
She found it difficult to acknowledge work that belonged to her.
One afternoon she read a story called The Captain of Somebody Else’s Ship, in which a newly appointed captain spent considerable effort explaining why her qualifications did not quite establish her suitability for the position she held.
Amira liked the captain.
She also recognized the unusual arithmetic by which the woman transformed each success into an exception and each mistake into a general principle.
She put the book down.
Then she returned to a report she had prepared for her supervisor and removed her name from its title page, replacing it with the name of the department.
There were occasions on which departmental attribution was appropriate.
This was not one of them.
She knew it.
She sent the report anyway.
The bronze mask arrived at the museum in a consignment donated by a private collector.
It represented a human face with closed eyes. The metal had darkened considerably, and there were marks near the edges suggesting that the object had once been attached to something else.
An early inventory described it as a ceremonial object from the valley of Neral.
The collector’s family believed it had been acquired during a journey in the 1930s.
Unfortunately, the available documentation established neither the precise circumstances of its acquisition nor the basis for the ceremonial interpretation.
Amira found the mask interesting for reasons that did not require her to settle either question immediately. Its manufacture displayed features worth studying, and there were possible comparisons in several other collections.
She contacted specialists and representatives of organizations associated with the region.
Over time, the museum assembled a more careful record of what could be established and what remained uncertain.
The mask was selected for the new exhibition, which concerned the relationships between objects, their makers and the people who subsequently preserved them.
The identification on its label was explicitly provisional.
One afternoon the director examined the draft text.
“Quite a lot of uncertainty,” he remarked.
“Yes.”
“Visitors like a story.”
Amira agreed.
She also explained that she did not think the museum knew enough to tell the story the previous catalogue offered.
The director listened.
Then he approved the revised wording.
On the way home, Amira felt an enormous relief.
She had been imagining a conversation in which her objections would be understood as evidence of her limited knowledge.
Instead, the limited knowledge was a fact about the collection.
She had been appointed to help the museum recognize such facts.
When the new wing was proposed, Amira was asked to apply for the curatorial position.
She believed she would enjoy the work.
She also believed there were many reasons she ought not to obtain it.
The position involved leading a team, contributing to decisions concerning the exhibition and representing the project in discussions with other institutions. She had relevant experience, but she had never previously held a position of precisely that kind.
Her friend Vika asked whether the other applicants had.
“Some probably have.”
“Some probably haven’t.”
Amira smiled.
She remembered the bellmaker in The Bellmaker’s Unfinished Note, whose tendency to imagine the consequences of failure made it difficult to recognize the ordinary opportunities available to her.
Amira prepared the application.
She was invited to an interview.
One member of the panel asked what she would do if the exhibition contained a claim whose supporting evidence was inadequate.
She described a process of reviewing the relevant material, seeking appropriate advice and addressing the claim in language that reflected what the museum could establish.
The panel asked several additional questions.
She answered them.
Then she returned home convinced that another applicant would have described the process with considerably greater authority.
She received the offer the following week.
Her father bought a cake.
Her mother telephoned several relatives.
Amira spent the evening thinking that the panel had perhaps been unable to find the candidate it originally wanted.
She did not want to disappoint her parents by describing this possibility.
She ate the cake.
The visitor who arrived on the morning of the opening was a woman named Liora.
She had traveled from a town in the valley of Neral after hearing about the exhibition through an organization the museum had consulted.
She brought a letter written by her grandfather in 1948. It described an object that resembled the bronze mask and referred to its removal from a workshop following a period of political unrest.
A photograph accompanied the letter.
Amira examined the material.
The resemblance was significant, but it did not immediately establish that the photograph showed the object in the museum’s collection. There were features worth comparing, and the location and circumstances described in the letter required further investigation.
Liora explained that her family believed the mask had belonged to her great-grandmother, who made objects for theatrical performances.
She was not seeking to interrupt the opening.
She wanted the museum to take the information seriously.
Amira thanked her.
Then she looked at the clock.
There were two hours and thirty-five minutes until the ceremony.
She thought of the guests expected to arrive, the director’s speech and the photographs in which she would stand beside the central display.
For a moment she wished that Liora had arrived the following morning.
Then she became ashamed of the wish.
She asked Vika to join them.
They arranged to record the information with Liora’s permission and to establish how the relevant material could be examined appropriately.
Amira contacted the director.
She explained the situation.
He was distressed by its timing.
So was she.
Neither could change the time at which the letter was written, the time at which Liora read about the exhibition, or the time at which the visitor arrived at the museum.
They could decide what to do with the information now.
The director suggested that they leave the existing label in place until the new material could be examined.
Its wording was provisional.
Amira agreed that the available information did not justify immediately replacing the earlier description with Liora’s account.
But she was concerned that the opening speech referred to the mask in a way that would give the ceremonial interpretation greater apparent certainty than the label itself.
They examined the proposed text.
A passage described the ancient rites for which the object was believed to have been intended.
The phrase had appeared in several earlier drafts.
No one had established an adequate basis for it.
Amira had previously asked for its removal from the exhibition materials. She had not reviewed the final version of the speech.
The director put down the pages.
“We’ll change it.”
She was relieved.
Then he asked whether she wanted to add a short explanation of the new information to her own remarks.
She considered the possibility.
The matter needed to be handled carefully. Liora’s family history was not a convenient dramatic addition to an opening ceremony, and the museum had no reason to disclose personal information without permission.
Amira arranged to discuss the options with Liora.
They agreed that the exhibition could refer generally to newly available material requiring further examination, without identifying the family or asserting a conclusion that had not yet been established.
Amira prepared a short amendment.
Her hands were shaking.
She remembered the advocate in The Trial of the Invisible Crown, whose kingdom had acquired the habit of treating the visible appearance of certainty as evidence of truth.
Amira had been worried about standing in front of the museum’s supporters and admitting that the institution did not possess a complete understanding of its central exhibit.
It was precisely the kind of admission she hoped the new exhibition would encourage.
For a moment she laughed.
Then she went to find the director.
The ceremony was well attended.
Amira stood beneath the bronze plaque, which Pavel had secured to the wall using a more suitable arrangement.
She described the work the project involved and thanked the people who contributed to it.
She spoke about the collection’s histories, the questions the museum had investigated and the ones that remained unresolved.
Then she mentioned the newly available material.
“It is a useful reminder,” she said, “that an exhibition is not necessarily the last occasion on which an institution learns something about its objects.”
The audience listened.
A representative of a funding organization later asked whether the object would need to be removed from the exhibition.
Amira explained that the next steps would depend on the findings of the investigation and the applicable arrangements, including consideration of any ownership or other concerns that arose.
The representative nodded.
There were several other questions.
Some concerned the exhibition.
One concerned the location of the toilets.
The ceremony concluded.
Amira went into the office.
For several seconds she sat very still.
She had expected the admission of uncertainty to feel like a particularly public failure.
Instead, she was principally interested in seeing the photograph again.
Then Vika came through the door.
“Well?”
“Nobody asked me to leave.”
Vika laughed.
“Did you think they would?”
Amira smiled.
“Frequently.”
They went back into the exhibition.
Over the following year, the museum worked with appropriate specialists and with people connected to the object’s possible history.
The photograph contained details that matched marks visible on the mask. Correspondence from another collection suggested that objects made for theatrical use in the region had sometimes been described by later owners as ceremonial artifacts.
Further material supported portions of Liora’s family account.
Other questions remained difficult to resolve.
The museum updated its records and the public interpretation of the object. It also examined the circumstances of its acquisition and considered the appropriate steps through its established procedures, incorporating relevant specialist and legal advice as required.
Amira was pleased with the progress.
She was also troubled by the fact that the museum had previously retained a description whose basis was so uncertain.
During a staff discussion, she began explaining why she should have discovered the relevant history earlier.
Vika listened.
Then she asked what information had actually been available to Amira before Liora contacted the museum.
They examined the sequence of events.
There were certainly improvements the museum could make to its research and outreach arrangements. There were questions it ought to have asked earlier. There were also documents it could not have examined until their holders agreed to provide access.
The distinction mattered.
Amira wanted the institution to learn from what happened.
She did not want that work to become another opportunity to conduct a comprehensive investigation of her own inadequacy.
She remembered the astronomer in The Observatory of Uncertain Stars, who had learned that the evidence in a scientific investigation did not owe its investigator a permanent assurance of competence.
Amira’s work concerned the mask.
It concerned its makers and the people who might have legitimate interests in its history.
She had a responsibility to do that work carefully.
There was no corresponding responsibility to emerge from every investigation with an improved opinion of herself.
The following autumn, a student named Nadi entered the museum’s training program.
She was interested in the history of textiles and had spent several years working in a family business repairing clothes.
During her first week she asked Amira whether her practical experience would be useful.
“Very.”
Nadi nodded.
Then she explained that the other trainees appeared to know more about the collections than she did.
Amira recognized the details of the conversation before the young woman finished describing them.
She decided not to tell Nadi that she was undoubtedly more capable than the people with whom she was comparing herself.
They did not possess the information needed to establish that claim, and there was no particular reason to establish it.
Instead, they talked about the requirements of the program, the experience Nadi already possessed and the areas in which she wanted to develop her knowledge.
They discussed where she could obtain guidance.
Nadi asked if it was all right to consult the records during a meeting.
“Certainly.”
She smiled.
Amira remembered the library she had visited after the first lecture at university.
She remembered the title she had copied into her notebook while three hands rose around her.
She hoped the young woman would learn to treat the opportunity to obtain information rather differently.
After the meeting, Amira returned to her office.
She took out the report she had prepared many years earlier and found the title page.
The department’s name appeared at its head.
She smiled.
Then she opened the new report on which she was working.
Its authors were listed individually, with their respective contributions described where appropriate.
Her own name was among them.
She left it there.
At the museum’s tenth anniversary, Amira’s parents attended a small gathering.
Her father was particularly interested in the old clock, which had been moved to another gallery.
Her mother wanted to see the bronze plaque.
They stood beside it for a while.
“Well,” her father said, “that’s you.”
Amira laughed.
The plaque did not describe the whole of her work. It did not identify every person involved in the project. It could not establish that every decision she had made was a good one.
There were many things it could not do.
It did identify one of the people who helped establish the exhibition.
For years she had wanted her achievements to provide an explanation of why she was entitled to belong among people whose work she admired.
She understood now that the experience commonly called imposter syndrome revealed something about the difficulty of recognizing oneself as a participant in a world whose inhabitants were often encountered through their accomplishments rather than their uncertainties.
People saw the qualifications, the titles, the papers, the exhibitions and the performances.
They did not necessarily see the evenings during which somebody looked up a word, requested assistance, reconsidered an explanation or began a task again.
Those evenings belonged to the history of the accomplishment.
They did not have to be removed to make it legitimate.
Amira took her parents to see the textile collection.
A visitor was asking a member of staff about an unfamiliar object.
The staff member listened.
Then she consulted the records.
Amira smiled.
There were still a great many things the museum did not know.
That was one reason she liked working there.
Editorial note: Original fiction. All people, institutions, objects and historical records in this story are invented. Imposter syndrome, also known as the impostor phenomenon, describes feelings of fraudulence or undeserved success despite evidence of competence. It can illuminate human sensitivity to belonging, social comparison and evaluation, and the tendency to discount personal contributions. It is not a formal mental-health diagnosis. Supportive environments, accurate feedback, recognition of different routes into a profession and appropriate professional support may be helpful when such feelings cause significant distress.



