Why Is Nostalgia Such a Compelling Theme in Fiction? The Archive of Unsent Postcards

Why is nostalgia such a compelling theme in fiction? Unsent postcards in a postmaster's archive reveal an unexpected side of a woman her granddaughter thought she knew.

The Archive of Unsent Postcards — gold-lettered ornamental story cover

Why is nostalgia such a compelling theme in fiction? It allows a story to bring the past into conflict with the present. A character may miss a person, place or earlier version of themselves while discovering that their memories are incomplete. Experiments reported by Sedikides and colleagues (2016) suggest that nostalgia can strengthen a sense of continuity between past and present through feelings of social connection. Fiction can explore both that comfort and the complications of remembering.


The first postcard arrived thirty-two years after it should have been sent.

It showed a lighthouse on an island I had never heard my mother mention. On the back, beneath a row of blue stamps that were no longer valid, someone had written:

Dear Elise,

The weather is dreadful. The lighthouse keeper says this is what the sea looks like when it has something to tell us. I think he wants us to stop complaining.

I will be home on Friday.

Love, Mother.

I turned the card over.

My grandmother’s handwriting was small and severe. She had always written the word love as though doing so required a degree of engineering.

She was dead. My mother was dead. The house to which the postcard was addressed had been demolished.

Yet the card had found me.

A note came with it, from a woman working at the county archive. She had been examining the personal papers of a retired postmaster. The collection contained a box of unsent correspondence from which she had identified a connection to my family.

She wanted to know whether I would be interested in viewing the material.

I looked at the lighthouse.

When I was young, my mother sometimes described a summer in which my grandmother left home for a week. She told me that she spent most of it worrying about her.

I did not remember her mentioning the island.

The room above the post office

My grandmother Teresa lived in the seaside town of Bellwater for most of her adult life. She ran a small alterations business from the front room of her house, hemmed dresses, repaired coats and argued with a man who wanted to pay for every purchase with coins.

My grandfather left when my mother, Elise, was eleven.

There were a number of reasons for the separation, and the portions of its history I heard as a child were principally the ones my mother believed appropriate to describe.

Grandmother rarely mentioned him.

She appeared to possess the ability to make an entire household operate according to a schedule she kept inside her head.

At seven she made tea. At eight she opened the curtains. At nine customers began arriving. Nobody in the family knew whether she enjoyed this arrangement.

During holidays, my mother brought me to the house.

Grandmother would give me a little box of buttons and ask me to arrange them according to color. She would then use the time I spent doing this to describe what everybody else in the family ought to be doing.

I adored her.

I also found her somewhat terrifying.

For years I treated these experiences as different varieties of the same affection.

The post office stood at the end of the street. It occupied a narrow building above which the postmaster rented a room to visitors.

My grandmother and the postmaster, whose name was Arthur, had been friends for a long time. They went to dances when they were young. Later they became the sort of friends who complained to one another about the condition of their respective cupboards.

When Arthur died, his son donated a collection of photographs and documents to the archive under agreed terms.

The postcards had been found in a tin box beneath his desk.

The archivist, Paula, explained that most of the correspondence was personal. She had obtained appropriate permission to examine the items and contact people whose family histories appeared to be represented. Several matters concerning access and ownership still needed to be resolved.

She showed me the postcard she had copied.

The original remained at the archive.

“There’s a second one,” she said.

I looked toward the table.

She placed a photograph of a card beside the lighthouse.

It showed a mountain railway.

On the back, in the same little severe handwriting, were the words:

I wish you were here.

No name followed them.

The woman in the photograph

I am a fairly competent editor.

I make books about real people’s lives, sometimes by helping writers identify the things a reader needs to understand and sometimes by asking whether they have accidentally assigned a relative two different birthdays.

I had not imagined becoming the person unable to distinguish the versions of her own family’s story.

I remembered my grandmother as an exceptionally practical woman.

I remembered my mother describing her as someone who loved her family very much and was occasionally unable to understand why any member of it would want to live differently from her.

I did not remember Grandmother traveling for pleasure.

The photograph on the mountain card intrigued me.

Paula explained that several other cards showed places quite far from Bellwater. The dates, where they appeared, extended over a period of nearly five years.

My mother had left home during that period to train as a librarian.

She wanted to live in a larger city.

Grandmother had been unhappy about the decision.

I remembered Mother describing an argument at the kitchen table. She told me that she had spent an entire evening trying to explain why the work interested her.

Grandmother asked what would happen to the business if she went away.

Mother replied that she had not arranged her life around inheriting the business.

The two became angry.

Mother left the room.

The story changed a little whenever I heard it.

At fourteen I found it amusing.

At twenty-two, when I moved away to work, Mother told it again.

I thought she was reminding me how fortunate I was.

Now I was looking at a postcard my grandmother had apparently written while Mother was preparing to leave.

I wondered whether she had intended to send it to her daughter.

Paula pointed toward the envelope in which it was found.

There was no indication of the recipient.

It occurred to me that I was already writing a book in my head.

In the book, my grandmother went away because she wanted to understand her daughter’s wish to go away.

She wrote a tender letter.

Then she decided not to send it because she was unable to express her feelings.

It was a plausible story.

It was also something I had invented.

The archive of unsent postcards

The cards fell into several groups.

Some had been addressed to Mother. Several had been written to Arthur. A few bore no indication of a recipient.

The postmaster’s own notes mentioned a practice among several travelers who exchanged cards without necessarily posting them. Sometimes a person wrote a card during a journey and brought it back to Bellwater. Cards were collected in a tin so that they could be read together over tea.

Paula had spoken to Arthur’s son, who remembered his father occasionally reading the cards aloud.

He was less certain about which cards belonged to which person.

Grandmother’s lighthouse card contained instructions about several ordinary things. The front room should remain closed if the weather was wet. A customer might arrive on Thursday. There was soup in a particular container.

It also contained a little joke.

The mountain card was shorter.

A third card depicted a city square.

Dear Elise,

They have a library with a staircase that goes up and down in the middle of the building. It is rather handsome, although I cannot understand why anyone would arrange a staircase that way.

I thought you might like it.

On the back of another card, she had written a description of a railway journey. The carriage was cold. The person opposite her had a little dog in a bag. She did not know whether the dog had bought a ticket.

I laughed.

I remembered my grandmother complaining about dogs in shops.

In the card, she was delighted by the dog.

I thought of the cinema owner in The Last Screening at the Blue Lantern, who learned that a photograph of his mother contained a whole afternoon about which he knew almost nothing.

The picture of my grandmother remained familiar.

The world outside its frame was becoming larger.

The blue coat

I went to Bellwater the following weekend.

The house in which Grandmother lived had been replaced by a block of apartments. The old post office was a cafe. There was a sign above the door depicting a letter with wings.

I found my aunt Nora near the harbor.

Nora was my mother’s younger sister. She had lived in Bellwater for most of her life and still remembered several people who brought clothing to Grandmother.

I showed her the copied cards.

She smiled when she saw the lighthouse.

“She hated that trip.”

“Why?”

“Because she couldn’t find anybody to make a decent cup of tea.”

Nora told me about a friend of Grandmother’s who organized a series of inexpensive trips for people interested in visiting different parts of the country. Grandmother initially declined. She worried about the business and household expenses.

Then Nora offered to help with several of the things that needed doing.

Grandmother went.

She enjoyed the train journey more than she expected.

She did not enjoy the weather.

Afterward she traveled a few more times.

I was surprised.

“Mother never told me.”

“Your mother went on one of the trips.”

I looked at Nora.

“When?”

“The one with the mountain railway, I think.”

Nora remembered them coming home with a photograph of a dog. Mother bought a coat in a shop beside the station. Grandmother said it was too expensive.

“She wore it the following winter.”

I remembered the coat.

It was blue.

Mother had kept it for many years, even after the lining became worn.

On one occasion she asked whether I wanted it.

I declined, partly because it did not suit me and partly because I preferred to choose my own clothes.

I thought of the house inherited by two cousins in The House That Remembered Summer, whose memories of family holidays led them to imagine different futures.

My mother had wanted me to have a coat.

I did not know whether she wanted me to know why it mattered.

Nora opened her handbag.

She produced a picture of herself standing beside the shop where Grandmother worked.

“Did you ever like the sewing?”

“Not particularly.”

She laughed.

“Neither did she, by the end.”

A conversation beside a window

The cards invited a number of questions.

I could have asked Nora to answer all of them.

I wanted particularly to know whether Grandmother and Mother had resolved the argument concerning the choice of work.

Nora remembered them continuing to disagree occasionally.

She also remembered Grandmother visiting Mother in the city.

She knew there had been conversations concerning the business. She could not supply a complete account of them.

Then she told me about the window in Mother’s first rented room.

Grandmother disliked its curtains.

She offered to make another pair.

Mother refused.

The following month, Mother asked whether she could help with the kitchen curtains instead.

Grandmother agreed.

I wanted Nora to tell me that the exchange represented the settlement of their differences.

She told me that the curtains were green.

There were things I would never know.

For a while I wondered whether I ought to have asked Mother more questions when she was alive.

I remembered the conversations we had.

We talked about the books she liked. We talked about the cost of groceries. We talked about a person in the street whose dog had become particularly interested in a wheelbarrow.

Sometimes she told me something about Grandmother.

Sometimes I asked another question.

Sometimes I was distracted by the things I was doing.

It was tempting to regard every ordinary conversation as a missed opportunity to conduct an interview.

Then I remembered a Saturday when we spent two hours watching a film neither particularly liked.

It was not an especially informative afternoon.

She had put her feet on the sofa and given me a piece of cake.

I was glad we spent it together.

Nora offered to make tea.

I accepted.

She went into the kitchen.

Through the window I saw a woman walking along the road with a little dog.

For a moment I was interested in whether the dog would try to enter the cafe.

Then Nora returned.

The story that was not mine to finish

Back at the archive, Paula and I examined the available material again.

We had identified the likely recipients of several cards and obtained additional information concerning the trips. Several remained unidentified.

The mountain card was among them.

I had wanted to establish that it belonged to Grandmother and Mother during their trip together.

Nora thought this might be the case.

There was not enough information to be certain.

Paula asked if I wanted to contribute a short reflection to a project about the history of the post office.

I was interested.

My first version was sentimental.

I described my grandmother as a woman who, after years of sacrificing everything for her family, finally discovered the joy of traveling. I described the postcards as messages she could not bring herself to send.

Then I read it again.

The account was attractive.

The evidence did not establish several of its claims.

I remembered Emil in The Bell at the Bottom of the Lake, who had needed to distinguish a history he could support from a story he wanted to tell about himself.

I wrote another version.

I described receiving the copy of the lighthouse card. I described the grandmother I remembered, the information about the trips and the things I learned from Nora.

I did not presume to identify every reason Grandmother wrote the cards.

I mentioned the mountain image and said that the intended recipient remained unknown.

I also included the joke about the weather.

Paula read the new version.

She liked it.

Then she asked whether I wanted to include a photograph of Grandmother’s sewing machine.

I did.

There were parts of my grandmother’s history that could be represented by postcards and parts that could not.

The sewing machine was still in Nora’s spare room.

The following Sunday I took a photograph of it.

The little island

I booked a trip to the island.

I was careful not to expect the experience described in the postcard. The journey had changed. There were different arrangements for visitors, and the old lighthouse was now accessible only under particular conditions.

I went with Nora.

She was delighted by the prospect of spending a day somewhere else.

We traveled across the water on a morning when the sky looked quite promising.

By the time we arrived, it was raining.

Nora laughed so hard that the woman sitting beside us asked what was funny.

We explained.

She lived on the island and found the story of the lighthouse keeper entertaining.

She wanted to know whether we had ever visited before.

Neither of us had.

She suggested a cafe.

We went there.

The tea was excellent.

For the remainder of the afternoon we walked near the harbor, examined a little museum and obtained a view of the lighthouse from a public path.

I wanted to take a photograph resembling the postcard.

Several things had changed.

The weather was different.

There was a boat in the foreground that did not appear in the earlier photograph.

I took the picture.

Then Nora asked whether I wanted to visit a shop selling cards.

We chose two.

She wrote to her granddaughter.

I wrote to a friend.

The card said:

The weather is dreadful. We have found excellent tea. Nora thinks I should stop trying to take a photograph of the lighthouse and come indoors.

She was right.

At the bottom I wrote that we would be home on Friday.

I posted the card before leaving the island.

A shelf for the future

The archive eventually made several of the cards available for public viewing under the arrangements agreed with the people concerned.

There was a little exhibition about correspondence in Bellwater.

A visitor described collecting postcards with her father. A young man asked whether the places shown on several cards still existed. Somebody recognized a railway station.

Nora attended the opening.

I showed her the reflection I contributed.

She laughed at the joke about the dog.

Then she corrected a detail concerning the name of a shop.

We informed Paula.

A little collection of visitors began discussing the alterations business.

Several remembered Grandmother.

One remembered her helping repair a dress.

Another remembered her refusing to repair one because there was not enough material left to make the necessary alteration.

Both were fond of her.

I liked hearing the second account.

It seemed to contain something I had not adequately represented: my grandmother could disappoint somebody without becoming less interesting.

When the exhibition ended, I looked at the lighthouse card once more.

It was an ordinary rectangle of paper.

It had become important because it contained a voice I had expected never to hear in quite that way again.

It did not contain the woman.

The woman existed in the recollections of people who knew her, in the things she did, in the possibilities that mattered to her and in the consequences of choices the rest of us had only partly understood.

No collection could contain all of it.

I thought of the designer in The Town in the Snow Globe, who discovered that a beloved miniature could be precious without becoming a complete account of the world.

On the way home, I bought a little wooden box.

I intended to use it to keep the postcards I received.

There were several old cards in a cupboard.

There would be others.

My friend telephoned that evening.

The card from the island had arrived.

She laughed at the description of Nora insisting that I come indoors.

Then she asked whether I wanted to go somewhere with her the following weekend.

I suggested the railway museum we had been meaning to visit.

There was a cafe near its entrance.

We agreed on Saturday.

I put the box on a shelf.

Then I went to find my coat.


After the story: Bellwater, its archive and the correspondence are fictional. The story does not suggest that every unanswered family question has a discoverable answer. It explores the relationship between memory, evidence and the stories through which we understand people we love.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top