The Weight of What We Throw Away

A literary reflection on waste, repair and the weight of what we throw away, exploring the hidden life of possessions and the responsibilities behind our everyday choices.

The Weight of What We Throw Away, with a weathered wooden radio and loose components on a sunlit repair bench.

The radio was on the pavement when Arthur noticed it.

Someone had placed it beside a collection of broken furniture outside a house whose occupants were preparing to move. Its wooden case had been scratched, and one of the knobs was missing. Arthur recognized the design. His parents had owned a radio from approximately the same period.

He asked the man carrying a chair out of the house whether he might take it.

The man was pleased to be rid of it.

At home, Arthur placed the radio on his workbench. He had spent much of his working life repairing electrical equipment, although he no longer attempted unfamiliar repairs without appropriate information. He examined the case, found the manufacturer’s details and contacted a specialist who knew more about equipment of that age.

The radio would require work. It was not a particularly valuable model, and it would have been considerably easier to buy a modern device capable of receiving more stations.

Arthur was interested in restoring it anyway.

Several weeks later, after the necessary work had been completed safely, the radio stood on a shelf in his sitting room. He occasionally listened to it while reading the newspaper. He enjoyed the wooden case and the rather deliberate turn of the dial.

His daughter asked whether he thought everybody should repair the things they were about to discard.

He said that he did not. He had the time for this particular undertaking, liked the object and knew somebody who could help him with it.

Then he began wondering what would have happened to the radio if he had walked past it.

There are things we throw away because they have ceased to serve a useful purpose. There are others whose usefulness we have become unable or unwilling to recognize. The difference is not always easy to establish.

What leaves a household does not necessarily leave the world. It enters a different arrangement, one in which the costs of its existence may become the responsibility of people whose names we will never know.

The distance between a bin and its contents

A woman named Farida began working in a shop that sold household goods.

At the end of each day, she helped dispose of damaged packaging, unsold products and other material that had accumulated during the hours the shop was open. Some of the goods were unusable. Others had minor defects that prevented them from being sold under the usual arrangements.

Once the containers had been collected, the shop looked orderly again.

Farida eventually realized that she knew very little about what happened to their contents.

The practical achievement of waste collection is that it allows a large number of people to live and work without being surrounded by the material they no longer need. There are sound reasons why we appreciate the service and why its reliability matters.

Its success can also make it difficult to see the consequences of the decisions to which it responds.

Something is gone from a kitchen, a workplace or a street. We experience that absence as the completion of the task.

But the discarded material may still need to be transported, sorted, processed or stored somewhere. The people doing that work encounter the object in circumstances very different from those in which we originally used it.

In The Things We Hold in Trust, we considered how the ordinary availability of shared resources depends on work that frequently remains invisible to the people benefiting from it.

Waste has a similar history. Its removal from our immediate surroundings does not eliminate the labor, resources or environmental consequences associated with it.

Farida discussed the goods with her manager. They identified several products that could be returned to the supplier and others that could be made available through an appropriate donation arrangement.

There were still things they had to discard.

But they had begun making distinctions that their previous method of clearing the shop had not required them to make.

The appearance of an empty storeroom was no longer their only measure of whether the work had been completed well.

When replacement is the reasonable decision

In a small apartment, a father named Daniel was trying to decide whether to repair a washing machine.

It had failed several times during the previous year. The latest repair would be expensive, and the technician could not establish how much longer other components were likely to remain serviceable.

Daniel had two children, limited space and a demanding working schedule. During the periods when the machine was unavailable, washing clothes required several journeys to a laundrette.

He decided to replace it.

There is a danger in discussing the value of repair as though everybody possesses a similar amount of time, money, knowledge and flexibility.

A person who has a workshop and enjoys investigating faults can make decisions unavailable to somebody living in a small rented room. Somebody with sufficient savings can risk paying for a repair that may not succeed. A household without those resources may need to choose the arrangement that provides greater immediate reliability.

The environmental consequences of manufacturing and discarding products deserve attention. So do the circumstances within which people make decisions about the products available to them.

In The Things Money Cannot Measure, we examined why an apparently straightforward financial judgment may not describe all the consequences of an arrangement.

Repair involves a similarly complicated collection of considerations. A repair that initially appears inexpensive may require significant additional work. Replacement that seems convenient may involve costs extending beyond the purchase price.

There are also safety considerations. Some objects should not remain in use merely because they possess emotional significance or can apparently be made to function again.

Daniel could obtain information about responsible disposal and select a replacement suited to his household’s needs. He did not need to regard another unsuccessful repair as the only acceptable demonstration of concern about waste.

If repair is to become practical for more people, it needs to be supported by products that can reasonably be maintained, access to suitable parts and dependable services.

The responsibility cannot rest entirely upon the person whose appliance has stopped working on a Sunday evening.

The objects that have finished their particular work

When Margaret’s mother moved into smaller accommodation, the family spent several weekends sorting the contents of her house.

Among the objects were clothes that no longer fitted, kitchen equipment she had not used for years and books she had retained since leaving school.

Margaret was reluctant to discard much of it.

She remembered some of the clothes being worn on holidays. She associated a particular set of bowls with meals the family had eaten together. Each object appeared to contain part of a history that would become less accessible if the object left the house.

Her mother approached the work rather differently.

She chose several things she wanted to keep, then offered some of the others to people who might use them.

There were objects with which she was pleased to have finished.

As explored in What We Choose to Carry Forward, preserving what we have received need not require keeping every object in the circumstances in which we first encountered it.

A book can acquire another reader. A coat can become useful to somebody who has never heard the story of its previous owner. An object whose original purpose can no longer be fulfilled may be adapted for something else.

Not everything can be passed on responsibly. There are damaged or unsuitable objects for which another household would merely become the next place of storage. Offering them as gifts does not necessarily make their disposal somebody else’s reasonable responsibility.

But where an object retains genuine usefulness, allowing it to leave our possession can be a form of care.

Margaret’s mother kept two of the bowls.

She was pleased to learn that her neighbor wanted the others.

The meals they had contained remained part of her memory. She did not need all the bowls to remain in the same cupboard in order to remember them.

The decision made before something arrives

At a market, a man named Julian regularly purchased small tools for projects he intended to undertake.

He enjoyed imagining the work. Occasionally he found an object whose price was so attractive that buying it seemed more reasonable than leaving it behind.

Over several years, a drawer in his garage became filled with equipment he had scarcely used.

Julian was not especially wasteful in his treatment of the objects. He kept them clean and protected them from damage.

The waste had begun rather earlier.

He had acquired things whose usefulness depended upon projects he had never seriously decided to undertake.

It can be easier to discuss waste at the moment when we are preparing to discard something than at the moment we are deciding whether to acquire it. The first occasion gives us an object whose presence has become inconvenient. The second presents us with a collection of possibilities whose difficulties have not yet appeared.

A new piece of equipment suggests an activity we might enjoy. An additional garment promises an occasion on which it might be appropriate. A purchase made at a favorable price appears to offer a benefit even when we have little use for the thing being purchased.

As considered in The Moral Life of Small Decisions, the consequences of ordinary choices may become more apparent after the convenience associated with making them has disappeared.

Julian began asking himself what he actually intended to do with a tool before buying it. He considered whether something he already owned could serve the purpose or whether he could borrow equipment for a task he expected to perform only once.

He still made purchases whose usefulness was uncertain. There were interests he wanted to explore, and he did not need to establish the complete future history of every object before acquiring it.

But he became more interested in the distinction between an actual requirement and the pleasure of imagining one.

Repair and reuse can extend the life of an object.

Deciding not to acquire an unnecessary object can prevent a much earlier difficulty.

The radio on the shelf

One afternoon, Arthur’s grandson asked whether he could listen to the old radio.

Arthur showed him how to turn the dial. They found a station broadcasting a piece of music neither recognized and remained beside the shelf for several minutes.

Later, Arthur returned to the workbench. There was a broken lamp he had decided not to repair. Its condition and the cost of making it safe did not justify continuing the undertaking.

He arranged to dispose of it appropriately.

Perhaps the weight of what we throw away is not a weight we can accurately establish by counting the objects we have kept.

We can become so attached to the possibility of finding a use for everything that our homes become difficult to inhabit. We can also discard useful things without considering what their replacement requires or where the discarded material will go.

Between these possibilities lies the work of making considered decisions.

What purpose could an object still serve? What would restoring it require? Is there somebody who would genuinely find it useful? Would keeping it create responsibilities we cannot reasonably undertake? And do we understand enough about the arrangements through which it will leave our possession?

There will be occasions when the most sensible decision is to let something go.

There will be others when a little more attention reveals that the usefulness of an object has not ended merely because the first arrangement in which we encountered it has changed.

Arthur did not intend to restore every radio he found on the pavement.

He was glad that he had stopped for this one.

In the sitting room, the music continued playing for a little longer.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top