The first voice to reach the station after the storm belonged to a woman who had been missing for nineteen years.
Station operator Elian Rook recognized it because he had listened to recordings of her broadcasts throughout his training.
“This is Meridian Four,” she said. “We’re losing the eastern horizon.”
He stopped moving.
Meridian Four had been destroyed during the collapse of an experimental communications network. Its last transmission was preserved at every training station in the northern hemisphere.
Elian had been nine years old when it happened.
He checked the identification displayed beside the incoming signal. The instrument offered several possible origins, none of which appeared consistent with the voice he had heard.
From the adjoining room, his colleague Sera called to ask whether he needed anything.
Elian looked at the chair in which he sat. It had belonged to the station’s previous supervisor, a man whose understanding of the network Elian regarded as practically inexhaustible.
He had been appointed to the position six weeks earlier.
He thought about what the previous supervisor might have done.
Then the voice returned.
“Is anyone receiving us?”
Elian reached for the microphone.
He had no idea what the correct answer was.
He knew that somebody was waiting for one.
Before the world acquired its unusual communications network, its inhabitants transmitted information according to principles the engineers understood reasonably well.
Then a series of investigations identified a phenomenon associated with certain atmospheric disturbances. Under particular conditions, signals appeared to travel through intervals that bore no simple relationship to the distances involved.
The phenomenon was rare.
It was also potentially useful.
For several decades, researchers developed instruments intended to detect and study it. A limited network of experimental stations eventually began operating in remote regions, with strict restrictions concerning the use of its findings for ordinary communications.
Elian first heard of the stations from his older brother.
They lived in a farming district where the evening sky was particularly dark. His brother, Mat, told him that people could sometimes speak to someone on the other side of the planet without using the usual equipment.
Elian asked whether it was possible to speak to someone on the other side of yesterday.
Mat laughed.
“Maybe.”
Their mother, who was reading nearby, told them not to confuse an interesting question with an established answer.
Elian remembered the conversation.
Years later, he studied communications engineering. He became especially interested in the difficulties of interpreting signals whose origins could not immediately be determined.
His work was not glamorous.
Much of it involved recording the circumstances in which an unexpected result occurred, identifying possible problems with the equipment and explaining why an attractive interpretation could not yet be supported.
He enjoyed it.
The difficulty was that he had begun imagining that the people whose work he admired possessed a kind of knowledge that amounted to an exemption from uncertainty.
He wanted to acquire it.
He did not realize how much of his education would be concerned with discovering that it did not exist.
The training station occupied a collection of buildings near the northern coast.
Elian arrived when he was twenty-four.
There were several people in his group who had previously worked with experimental instruments. One had contributed to a published investigation. Another could describe features of the equipment Elian had only encountered in drawings.
He began reviewing the course material before breakfast.
He was thorough, and his work was generally reliable. He also became remarkably good at discovering reasons why each favorable assessment did not necessarily mean the same thing as a favorable assessment received by someone else.
When an instructor commended his record of an unexpected signal, he explained that the circumstances had been comparatively straightforward.
When a later report required substantial revision, he remembered the criticism for months.
His friend Sera noticed.
She was training in a different area of the network’s operation and occasionally asked Elian to help examine records with her.
One afternoon, he identified a discrepancy she had missed.
She thanked him.
He explained that he had encountered a similar problem during an earlier exercise.
“Useful experience,” she said.
He laughed.
“Luck.”
She looked at him.
“Would it be luck if I’d done it?”
He was quiet.
Then they returned to the records.
At the end of the course, he received an appointment.
For several days he imagined that the people responsible for making it had not properly understood the extent of his knowledge.
He wondered how they would react when they did.
The northern station at which Elian eventually worked stood on a cliff overlooking a broad stretch of sea.
Its supervisor was an engineer named Darro.
Darro had spent thirty years working with communications systems. He had a talent for explaining unfamiliar things in ordinary language, and he knew an extraordinary number of details about the network’s history.
Elian liked listening to him.
When they encountered a problem, Darro often remembered a similar one.
Elian began considering this ability as evidence that a supervisor ought to be able to remember a similar problem whenever one occurred.
He was surprised when he found Darro consulting a reference during an investigation.
“Forgot the name of something,” Darro explained.
Elian smiled.
“What?”
“Something I don’t currently remember.”
They laughed.
Darro found the reference.
Then he asked Elian whether he wanted to contribute to the assessment.
Over the following years, Elian gained relevant experience and completed the training required for additional responsibilities. He worked with the people who maintained the equipment and the specialists who studied the signals it received.
He became particularly good at describing what the available information did and did not establish.
Several colleagues sought his opinion when an observation was difficult to interpret.
He appreciated their interest.
He also feared that on some occasion they would ask a question whose answer he did not know, and the difference between the person they thought he was and the person he believed himself to be would become apparent.
The feeling became especially difficult when Darro announced his retirement.
Elian was encouraged to apply for the position.
He submitted an application, underwent the relevant assessment and received the appointment.
On his first morning as supervisor, he told Sera that he hoped the choice would prove to have been a reasonable one.
She smiled.
“I expect they’ll review your work in the usual way.”
He was not particularly comforted.
He wanted something more permanent than the usual way.
The first storm of the season arrived toward the end of autumn.
It damaged several ordinary communications links and interrupted the station’s experimental observations. Staff followed the established arrangements for dealing with the disruption, and the people responsible for the network began reviewing the effects on its various stations.
The experimental receiver remained operational.
Elian was examining its records when the voice of Meridian Four appeared.
He recognized several features of the transmission.
He also knew that recordings of its broadcasts existed. There were possible explanations involving equipment faults, interference, unintended retransmission or other circumstances that did not require the signal to have come from the missing station.
The woman’s question remained audible.
Elian acknowledged the reception without asserting an interpretation of its origin. He recorded the exchange and notified the relevant staff.
Sera joined him.
For several minutes they listened.
The woman repeated her identification and described a problem with the station’s instruments. She asked whether the northern network was operational.
Elian provided only the information authorized for the exchange and requested clarification through the appropriate procedures.
Then the transmission disappeared.
Sera looked at him.
“Is it her?”
“I don’t know.”
She nodded.
“Right.”
They began making arrangements for further investigation.
Elian remembered the astronomer in The Observatory of Uncertain Stars, whose discovery was initially significant not because its explanation was established but because it deserved examination.
He had read the story during his training.
He was beginning to suspect that discovering an unexpected signal was a rather different experience when the signal arrived while somebody expected him to decide what to do about it.
The early investigation did not establish a convincing origin for the transmission.
The station’s staff reviewed the relevant records. Specialists examined possible sources of interference. The researchers familiar with Meridian Four’s archived broadcasts compared the newly received material with the material already available.
Several phrases were similar.
Others did not appear in the known recordings.
That did not establish that they had been spoken recently.
There were incomplete archives, uncertainties concerning the receiver and possibilities the investigators had not ruled out.
The network’s director asked Elian to prepare an account of the initial findings for a meeting.
He spent much of the evening drafting the document.
Then he imagined Darro presenting the same information.
Darro would probably have identified several possibilities Elian had failed to consider.
Darro would have known what the unusual features meant.
Darro would not have found himself staring at a sentence for twenty minutes because he was worried about the impression it created.
Elian removed several qualifications from the document.
He replaced a description of the uncertainties with a more confident summary.
When Sera reviewed the draft, she asked why.
He explained that he did not want the director to think the station was making little progress.
She examined the records again.
“That’s a different question.”
He looked at her.
“What is?”
“Whether we’re making progress and whether we’ve got an answer.”
He opened the draft.
The revised wording suggested that the team knew more than the evidence established.
He had not intended to mislead anyone.
He had intended to appear like someone who knew what he was doing.
The distinction between the intentions mattered to him.
It did not adequately address the problem with the document.
He restored the original qualifications.
Then he sent the report for review.
At the meeting the following morning, a director named Orel asked whether the transmission could represent an earlier event.
Elian explained that there were speculative proposals concerning unusual relationships between observations, but that the existing evidence did not establish such an explanation.
Orel nodded.
“What would help?”
Elian described the further work the team recommended.
A specialist from another station suggested comparing records obtained during the original collapse of the network. They discussed the practical arrangements for sharing the relevant information.
The meeting continued for nearly two hours.
At its conclusion, Orel thanked Elian for the report.
He went back to his office.
For a while he felt pleased.
Then he began thinking about a question he had answered less fluently than he wanted.
Sera knocked on the door.
She asked whether he wanted supper.
He said no.
He intended to review the meeting.
She looked at the screen.
“Did we miss anything?”
“Not that I know of.”
“Then you’re probably allowed to eat.”
He laughed.
They went downstairs.
At the table, Elian remembered the captain in The Captain of Somebody Else’s Ship, who had spent part of her first months in command searching for assurance that she was the kind of person entitled to occupy her cabin.
He understood why the search was so exhausting.
There was no clear point at which it could be declared complete.
A favorable meeting might establish something about the report he had presented.
The next meeting would offer an opportunity to worry again.
Sera told him about a book she had been reading.
He listened.
He was pleased to discover that the book had absolutely nothing to do with the station.
The second transmission arrived nine days later.
The voice identified herself as Anya Lind, supervisor of Meridian Four.
She described a number of details that appeared consistent with the known history of the station shortly before the collapse.
She also mentioned a researcher whose presence there had not previously been established.
The network arranged further exchanges through appropriate channels, with particular care concerning the possibility that the communication might affect the people involved in unknown ways.
The signal did not persist long enough to permit a complete conversation.
Elian found himself becoming especially interested in a question Anya asked before the connection failed.
“Is Darro there?”
He remembered that Darro had been involved in the early development of the network.
He contacted the director to discuss whether Darro’s knowledge might be relevant to the investigation.
The director agreed.
Darro arrived at the station several days later.
He listened to the recordings and looked at the relevant records.
For some time he said very little.
Then he asked whether he could hear the first exchange again.
Elian played it.
Darro sat down.
“I knew her.”
Elian nodded.
For a moment he expected Darro to provide a compelling explanation of the phenomenon.
Darro asked whether anybody had a cup of tea.
Sera went to make one.
“Do you think it’s her?” Elian asked.
Darro looked at him.
“I’d like it to be.”
He was quiet.
“That’s not evidence, is it?”
Elian smiled unhappily.
“No.”
They listened to the recording again.
Darro described several things he remembered about Anya and the circumstances of the earlier investigations. Some could be corroborated through the records. Others were recollections that would need to be treated with appropriate care.
His knowledge was valuable.
It was not an explanation of everything.
Later, Elian asked whether he would have responded differently when the first transmission arrived.
Darro considered the question.
“Probably.”
Elian waited.
“Can’t tell you how without being there.”
They went to examine the equipment.
Over the following months, the investigators obtained additional observations.
The evidence increasingly supported the conclusion that the receiver was detecting signals associated with an unusual event, rather than merely reproducing the known archival recordings.
The precise mechanism remained uncertain.
The exchanges provided some information consistent with the possibility of contact with Meridian Four at an earlier interval in its history. There were still competing explanations and limitations concerning the interpretation of the data.
The researchers were particularly cautious about claims that a conversation could alter events that had already occurred.
There was no established method for doing so.
There were nonetheless several short conversations with the voice calling herself Anya.
During one, the station recorded an account of a problem with a set of instruments.
Darro recognized the description.
It concerned a matter the original investigation had been unable to explain fully.
He asked permission to contribute to the next exchange.
The appropriate arrangements were made.
When the signal returned, he spoke to Anya.
He identified himself.
She laughed.
“You’re late.”
Darro smiled.
For several moments they discussed a technical question whose relevance the research team had considered beforehand.
Then the transmission became indistinct.
Darro stopped speaking.
Elian waited.
Afterward, Darro went outside.
Elian joined him.
They stood beside the station’s wall, looking over the sea.
“I thought you’d know what to say,” Elian admitted.
Darro laughed quietly.
“So did I.”
He told Elian about his last conversation with Anya, about a disagreement that had never been resolved, and about the years he spent imagining the things he might have said differently.
Elian listened.
The man whose confidence he had spent years admiring had been carrying a question that none of his experience could answer.
It did not make that experience less valuable.
The signals became less frequent as winter ended.
The investigators prepared records of the observations and developed recommendations for further research. They did not claim to have established a means of rescuing the people who had been lost at Meridian Four.
The phenomenon had offered no reliable basis for such a claim.
Elian found this difficult.
He had wanted the story to end differently.
He had also imagined a particular kind of ending for himself: a discovery of such significance that nobody, including him, could question whether he deserved his appointment.
The work had produced interesting information.
It had also produced more questions.
He thought of the curator in The Museum of Borrowed Names, who had wanted to present a completed exhibition but discovered that the people connected to its objects had further information worth considering.
The value of the work did not depend on its being the last word on the subject.
Neither did Elian’s position require him to make the observations answer questions they could not answer.
The opinion of his colleagues mattered to him.
He wanted their trust.
He was beginning to recognize that earning trust could involve describing uncertainties, acknowledging mistakes and requesting assistance rather than finding ways to appear free of all three.
He continued receiving feedback on his work. He also sought appropriate support when his fear of appearing inadequate interfered with his sleep and his relationships.
The conversations helped him recognize how differently he assessed his own progress from that of the people he admired.
He was glad to have opportunities to do the work.
He no longer wanted every opportunity to become an examination of whether the preceding ones ought to have been offered to him.
The last transmission arrived on a clear evening in spring.
It contained only a few intelligible words.
Anya identified her station.
She asked whether anybody was listening.
Elian acknowledged the reception.
For a moment, the sound became clearer.
“Thank you,” the woman said.
Then the signal disappeared.
The investigators continued monitoring the relevant conditions and examining the records. No further transmission attributable to the event was identified during the following years.
Darro returned home.
Sera accepted a new research appointment, although she and Elian continued speaking regularly.
The station developed other projects.
Several yielded information of considerable interest.
Several did not.
One of Elian’s own proposals was rejected after the assessment identified difficulties he had not anticipated. He was disappointed. He discussed the reasons with the people involved, revised portions of the work and considered which questions were still worth pursuing.
For a week he privately wondered whether Darro would have prepared a better proposal.
Then he invited Darro to supper.
They discussed their gardens.
Darro’s was considerably more successful.
Elian regarded this as a fact about the gardens.
Years later, a trainee named Neris asked Elian about the first transmission from Meridian Four.
She had read the published records.
She wanted to know how he had decided what to do.
He described the procedures the team followed, the information available at the time and several things about which he had been uncertain.
Neris looked surprised.
“Weren’t you frightened?”
“Very.”
She laughed.
“I thought you’d know what to do.”
“I knew some of what to do.”
They examined the record.
Elian remembered the journalist in The Suitcase of Unclaimed Medals, who discovered that a person could achieve something and remain convinced that its recognition belonged to somebody else.
He understood why imposter syndrome could be a compelling theme in fiction. A character might possess abilities that readers could see while remaining afraid that other people had misunderstood those abilities. Every new responsibility could become both an opportunity and a threat. Success might produce relief rather than satisfaction, and a reasonable request for assistance could feel like a confession.
The tension did not require the character to possess extraordinary talents.
It required the character to have a life that mattered to her and a fear that she did not quite belong in it.
Elian had spent years imagining that the most important thing he could eventually discover was whether he deserved to sit in the supervisor’s chair.
There were more interesting questions.
Neris asked him about a feature of the transmission that had never been satisfactorily explained.
He did not know the answer.
He suggested several records they might examine.
They went to find them.
Outside the station, the evening sky was becoming dark.
The receiver remained quiet.
There was no reason to expect another voice from Meridian Four.
Elian was glad they had listened when one came.
Editorial note: Original science fiction. All characters, institutions, technologies and events are invented; the communications phenomenon is not presented as established science. Imposter syndrome, also called the impostor phenomenon, is not a formal mental-health diagnosis. In fiction it can create tension between demonstrated abilities and a character’s persistent fear of being undeserving, while exploring belonging, responsibility, uncertainty and the effects of social comparison. Constructive feedback, appropriate support and environments that permit learning and honest questions can help people experiencing these feelings.



