The Art of Leaving Things Unfinished

A literary reflection on unfinished projects, unresolved endings and the wisdom of knowing when to persist, honor a commitment, or let an earlier ambition go.

The Art of Leaving Things Unfinished — a partially drawn garden plan and pencil on a sunlit writing desk.

In a drawer beneath the window of his study, Martin kept a map of a garden that no longer existed.

He had begun drawing it fifteen years earlier, when he and his wife moved into a house with a neglected piece of land behind it. He intended to record the position of every tree, the plants they introduced and the changes they made to the paths. The map would become, he imagined, a history of the garden as it developed.

For several summers, he worked on it with considerable enthusiasm. Then there were other responsibilities. His wife became unwell, his employment changed, and the garden gradually acquired features that had never been added to the drawing.

Eventually, they sold the house.

One afternoon, while sorting the contents of the drawer, Martin considered whether he ought to finish the map. He still remembered much of the garden, and photographs might have helped him reconstruct some of its later arrangements.

He took out a pencil.

Then he noticed that what he particularly enjoyed about the drawing was the way it preserved a stage in the garden’s existence. It recorded the location of a bench they had subsequently moved and the border where they had first planted vegetables. The empty spaces belonged to the summer in which he stopped drawing.

Completing the map would have produced a more comprehensive account. It would also have turned it into a different kind of object.

Martin put the pencil away.

We are accustomed to thinking of unfinished things as evidence of something we have failed to do. But there are occasions when an unfinished undertaking deserves a different interpretation. Perhaps its purpose has changed. Perhaps its continuation would require resources we now have reason to use elsewhere. Perhaps what it already contains matters independently of the conclusion it was intended to reach.

When an ending becomes more important than the work

A woman named Clara spent several years writing an account of the town in which she had grown up.

She interviewed relatives, visited places associated with her childhood and collected photographs from people who remembered events she had been too young to understand. Her original intention was to produce a book.

The difficulty, as she approached the later stages of the project, was deciding what the book should contain.

Each interview introduced another person whose memories seemed relevant. Each photograph raised questions about the circumstances in which it had been taken. The project acquired a size that made its completion increasingly difficult to imagine.

Clara began regarding the time she devoted to it as evidence of her failure to finish.

She would return from a conversation having heard something remarkable about a person she had known since childhood, then feel dissatisfied because the conversation had created another task.

The expected conclusion had begun to influence her evaluation of experiences that possessed considerable value in their own right.

As considered in The Beauty of an Ordinary Life, the importance of an experience does not always depend upon its contribution to a more recognizable achievement.

Clara had learned things about the people around her that she might otherwise never have discovered. Some of the material she collected was already useful to others. The relationships she established through the undertaking could continue regardless of whether the book acquired its proposed form.

This did not mean that producing a finished book was unimportant. She had good reasons to want one.

But she needed to distinguish the value of that particular outcome from the value of everything she had already done.

A project can fail to reach its intended conclusion without every experience associated with it becoming a failed experience.

The cost of protecting an earlier decision

Imagine a man who has spent several years preparing to establish a restaurant.

He has invested money in training, investigated suitable premises and devoted substantial attention to developing a plan. During that period, his understanding of the work has changed. He has become aware of demands that he had underestimated and has discovered that some of the daily activities involved interest him considerably less than he expected.

He begins to wonder whether a different occupation would suit him.

What makes the decision difficult is not only the loss of the restaurant he once imagined. It is the prospect of having spent several years preparing for something he will not do.

He feels that continuing would establish that the earlier expenditure had been worthwhile.

Yet the expenditure cannot be recovered merely by making a further commitment. The relevant question concerns what the next commitment would involve and whether its likely consequences make it reasonable.

There is a distinction between honoring the effort we have made and allowing that effort to determine every subsequent decision.

In What We Owe to the People We Used to Be, we explored how earlier ambitions can continue influencing our lives even when the future we originally associated with them is no longer appropriate.

The man may have acquired knowledge about food, budgets, suppliers and the organization of work. Some of that knowledge may be useful in an entirely different arrangement. Some of it may have no obvious subsequent application.

He need not establish that every expense produced a benefit before he is permitted to reconsider his plans.

There may be circumstances in which continuing is the more reasonable choice. Perhaps he has underestimated the opportunities available or encountered a temporary difficulty that can be addressed.

But the argument for continuing needs to concern more than his reluctance to admit that he has changed his mind.

The years already spent deserve an accurate account.

The years that remain deserve an independent decision.

The obligations we cannot simply abandon

There is a danger in speaking about the freedom to leave things unfinished without distinguishing between different kinds of undertaking.

A painter may decide that a private painting no longer interests her. A contractor who has accepted payment to repair a roof occupies a rather different position.

The unfinished roof may expose another household to considerable difficulty. The people affected may have made arrangements in reasonable reliance upon the contractor’s agreement to complete the work.

Here, the decision to stop is not solely a matter of personal preference.

There are responsibilities created through our relationships with other people. Some arise from explicit agreements. Others arise from the foreseeable consequences of taking on a task upon which somebody else depends.

We can discover that an obligation has become impossible to fulfill in its original form. Illness, a change of circumstances or limitations we had not anticipated may require us to reconsider what we are able to do.

Nevertheless, the recognition that we cannot finish something does not necessarily settle what ought to happen next.

There may be a need to explain the difficulty, return money, arrange a suitable handover or provide other people with enough information to make alternative plans.

As we considered in The Courage to Change Our Minds, a revision of our intentions can create responsibilities rather than eliminate them.

It is possible to leave a position honorably without pretending that nobody will experience consequences from our departure. It is possible to acknowledge that we should not have accepted a particular undertaking while still doing what we reasonably can to address the consequences of having accepted it.

The art of leaving things unfinished does not consist in discovering a more attractive description for neglect.

It consists partly in recognizing which aspects of an undertaking belong to our freedom and which belong to commitments we have made to others.

The conclusion we keep trying to obtain from another person

Several years after a friendship ended, a woman called Isabel continued composing imaginary conversations with the friend she no longer saw.

She would explain why a particular disagreement had mattered to her. She would ask questions whose answers she could not confidently predict. Sometimes, in these imagined conversations, the friend recognized something Isabel had wanted her to recognize for a long time.

The actual friendship had ended without such an exchange.

There had been a period in which further conversation might have been possible. Isabel had made an attempt to arrange it, and the other woman had indicated that she did not wish to continue discussing the relationship.

Isabel found the absence of a satisfactory ending difficult to accept.

We often want an experience to acquire a form in which its significance becomes clear to everybody involved.

We may wish to hear why another person made a particular decision. We may want them to acknowledge the consequences of their conduct. We may hope that a final conversation will provide an explanation capable of reconciling memories that have remained difficult to understand.

These desires can be reasonable.

But another person’s participation is not always available, and it cannot necessarily be acquired through the force of our need for it.

In The Things Time Cannot Return, we explored the distinction between what might still be repaired and what can no longer be recovered in its original form.

A relationship whose ending remains difficult to understand may require us to make a similar distinction.

There are occasions when seeking clarification or practical redress is both possible and appropriate. There are also circumstances in which the continuation of the search makes our present life dependent upon a response that another person is unwilling or unable to provide.

Leaving an experience unfinished in this sense does not require us to decide that it no longer matters.

It may require us to recognize that understanding why something happened and establishing how we wish to live afterward are different undertakings.

Isabel could continue considering what the friendship had taught her. She could examine her own conduct and make different decisions in subsequent relationships.

She could do those things without obtaining the final conversation she had imagined.

When unfinished means still in progress

A teacher once told Martin that she had been learning to play the violin for nearly twenty years.

He asked whether she performed with an orchestra.

She said that she did not. She occasionally played with friends, took lessons when her circumstances made them possible and spent time learning pieces she particularly enjoyed.

There were compositions she had begun studying years earlier and might never be able to perform as well as she wished.

Martin wondered afterward what it would mean for her to finish learning the violin.

Some activities are organized around identifiable conclusions. A bridge must reach the other side of a river. An examination takes place on a particular date. A publication requires somebody to decide that its contents are ready to be made available.

Other activities have a different relationship with completion.

A person can continue developing an interest in history without expecting to reach a stage at which there is nothing more to learn. A friendship can remain valuable without producing a final achievement. Caring for a garden involves an ongoing relationship with conditions whose changes cannot be completed once and for all.

There is often a place within such activities for smaller conclusions. The violinist learns a particular passage. The gardener finishes preparing a border. The friends complete a journey they have been planning.

But those conclusions need not bring the activity itself to an end.

Treating every interest as though it were a project with a final deliverable can obscure some of the reasons we are interested in it.

The teacher had no need to decide that twenty years of playing the violin represented an insufficiently advanced stage in an undertaking she ought to have completed sooner.

She was doing something she intended to continue doing while it remained possible and worthwhile.

The fact that another lesson was available did not diminish the significance of the lessons that preceded it.

Making a deliberate ending where one is possible

Eventually, Clara decided to reorganize the material she had collected about her hometown.

Instead of attempting to produce a complete history, she prepared a modest collection of interviews concerning a particular street. She included a brief explanation of the limits of the collection and obtained permission from the people whose accounts she wished to publish.

The rest of the material was organized and stored.

Her new project was considerably smaller than the book she had first imagined. It was also something she could finish without devoting an indefinite portion of her life to the work.

This kind of decision can be useful when the difficulty lies not in the value of an undertaking but in its original definition.

A person restoring a piece of furniture may decide that making it usable is sufficient, even though restoring every feature of its original appearance is impractical. A group organizing a community event may concentrate on activities it has the resources to conduct responsibly rather than attempt to reproduce its most ambitious proposal.

A smaller completed undertaking can coexist with a larger unfinished one.

The important distinction concerns how we describe what has been achieved.

Clara could not reasonably present her collection as a complete account of the town. She had no need to do so. Its value could be assessed in relation to the experiences it actually contained.

An honest ending does not require us to conceal the distance between what we once intended and what we have eventually produced.

It requires us to make clear what has been done, what remains undone and which of those remaining things we have decided not to pursue.

There can be relief in making such a decision.

There can also be disappointment.

Both reactions can belong to a reasonable interpretation of the same undertaking.

The space Martin left on the map

When Martin’s daughter visited several months later, he showed her the drawing of the old garden.

She remembered the bench. She also remembered a tree he had removed before the photograph in the family album was taken.

They talked about the arrangement of the paths and the vegetables that had grown particularly well during one summer.

She asked why some areas of the map remained empty.

Martin explained that he had stopped working on it before the garden acquired its later form.

For a moment, he considered asking whether she could help him remember the position of a flower bed.

Then their conversation moved to the people who had visited the house, and to the meals they had eaten outside during the warmer months.

Perhaps we sometimes demand completeness from things that could offer us something worthwhile in a different condition.

A memory may remain uncertain. An ambition may have served a purpose we no longer wish to pursue. A conversation may never contain the explanation we hoped it would contain.

There is no general virtue in leaving such things incomplete. Many undertakings deserve the discipline required to finish them, and some must be completed because other people’s interests are involved.

But there is no general virtue in completion that overrides every other consideration either.

We can decide what deserves further effort by examining the purpose of that effort, the resources it requires and the responsibilities it would help us fulfill.

We can acknowledge the value of things whose intended conclusion remains unavailable.

And sometimes we can stop working on a particular account of our lives in order to pay attention to the life that continues beyond it.

Martin returned the map to the drawer that evening.

He had learned something about the garden from his daughter that he had not remembered himself.

He did not add it to the drawing.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top