The Kindness We Mistake for Weakness

A literary reflection on kindness and strength, exploring the difference between generosity and surrender, considerate boundaries, and the courage to exercise authority without cruelty.

The Kindness We Mistake for Weakness — pink flowers, a lantern and sturdy tools on a sunlit workshop bench.

The first time someone accused Arthur of being too kind, he was standing beside a broken washing machine in the basement of an apartment building.

He had been the building’s maintenance manager for eleven years. A tenant on the third floor had reported a leak, and Arthur had discovered that the machine would need a replacement part that could not be obtained until the following morning.

The tenant was angry. She had taken time away from work to finish several household tasks, and this was the second occasion that month on which something in the building had gone wrong.

Arthur listened to her complaint. He explained what he could do, apologized for the inconvenience and arranged for another machine in the building to be made available.

When she left, a younger colleague told him that he should not allow people to speak to him that way.

Arthur looked at the machine for a moment.

He had not agreed with everything the tenant had said. He had not accepted responsibility for a delay over which he exercised little control. But he had understood why the interruption mattered to her, and he had seen no advantage in making an already difficult morning more unpleasant.

What interested him was the assumption that another person’s anger required him to demonstrate his strength by becoming angry himself.

Kindness is sometimes mistaken for weakness because we evaluate a person’s response according to the force with which they resist another person’s behavior.

We pay less attention to what they have chosen to accomplish, what they have refused to become and what limits they are capable of maintaining without unnecessary hostility.

The difference between restraint and surrender

At a meeting in a small publishing company, Nadia listened while a colleague criticized a proposal she had prepared.

Some of his observations were useful. Others appeared to concern assumptions that were absent from the document. He spoke with considerable confidence, and there were moments when his manner suggested that the quality of his judgment should be apparent to everybody in the room.

Nadia could have responded by questioning his competence in front of their colleagues.

Instead, she separated the objections that deserved consideration from the ones that did not. She acknowledged an apparent difficulty with the proposed timetable and corrected his inaccurate description of the budget.

When he continued interrupting her, she asked him to allow her to finish.

The meeting ended without a dramatic confrontation. The proposal was revised, and most of its original features remained.

Afterward, a colleague told Nadia that he admired her patience, although he wondered whether being more forceful would have made her position clearer.

The conversation revealed how easily we can confuse the manner in which a person defends a position with the fact that they have defended it.

Nadia had not surrendered her judgment. Nor had she allowed the colleague’s manner to determine the manner in which she conducted herself.

She had protected the purpose of the meeting from an argument about who could exert the greatest pressure upon everybody else.

As explored in The Courage to Change Our Minds, remaining open to a reasonable objection does not require us to accept every conclusion somebody wishes us to reach.

Similarly, responding considerately to another person’s behavior does not require us to approve of that behavior.

It is possible to listen carefully to a person and disagree with them. It is possible to acknowledge their frustration while refusing their demand.

The absence of cruelty is not evidence of the absence of resistance.

How harshness acquires the appearance of authority

A young supervisor observes two experienced managers dealing with similar mistakes.

The first manager corrects an employee publicly. He raises his voice, questions the employee’s judgment and reminds everybody present of the seriousness of their responsibilities.

The second manager speaks privately to the employee involved. She establishes what happened, explains which requirements were not met and agrees upon changes that will reduce the likelihood of another mistake.

Both employees understand that their performance must improve.

But the first encounter is more readily recognized by an observer as a demonstration of authority.

Its visible features are familiar. Somebody issues a judgment. Another person receives it. The importance of the judgment appears to be established partly through the discomfort of the person to whom it is directed.

We can become accustomed to evaluating authority through such performances.

A parent who humiliates a child may be described as strict, while a parent who patiently enforces a limit may be regarded as excessively accommodating. A manager who repeatedly criticizes employees in public may acquire a reputation for strength that a more effective but less theatrical colleague does not possess.

The difficulty is that these descriptions can tell us considerably more about the behavior that has become familiar within an institution than about the quality of the decisions being made.

The important questions concern what the authority is being used to accomplish. Are the requirements reasonable? Are they communicated clearly? Do the people affected understand what must change? Are the consequences proportionate to what has occurred?

Sometimes an immediate and forceful intervention is necessary, particularly when safety is at risk.

But there is little evidence of judgment in making somebody feel smaller when the situation does not require it.

Authority can be exercised without turning another person’s dignity into an obstacle to its exercise.

Why receiving kindness can become an expectation

Arthur’s willingness to assist tenants had not always produced considerate relationships.

There were people who thanked him for resolving a problem. There were also people who gradually began treating his availability as a feature of the building for which they had paid.

One tenant frequently sent messages late in the evening about matters that presented no immediate difficulty. Another became irritated when Arthur explained that he could not perform a task unrelated to the maintenance of the property.

After several months, Arthur began changing how he communicated his availability.

He explained which situations justified an emergency call and which requests would be addressed during working hours. He stopped accepting certain additional tasks that he had initially undertaken as favors.

Some tenants welcomed the clearer arrangement. Others regarded it as evidence that he had become less helpful.

Their disappointment pointed toward an important distinction.

A generous action may be freely chosen on one occasion and gradually become expected on subsequent occasions. The conditions under which the action takes place can change without anybody explicitly discussing the change.

In The Quiet Cost of Always Being Strong, we considered how reliability can become an obligation that leaves a person with fewer meaningful opportunities to express their own needs.

Kindness faces a similar difficulty when those who benefit from it begin regarding its continuation as something to which they are entitled.

A favor does not acquire the character of a permanent responsibility simply because it has been performed several times.

Of course, there are responsibilities that genuinely belong to a person’s employment or relationships. They cannot simply be abandoned by describing their performance as excessive generosity.

What matters is identifying the actual responsibility rather than allowing every request that a person has previously accepted to become part of it.

Arthur did not need to become indifferent to the difficulties of the people living in the building.

He needed to establish an arrangement in which helping them did not make the rest of his life permanently available to them.

When kindness requires something unpleasant

A woman discovers that her friend has been borrowing money from several people without telling any of them about the other loans.

She knows that her friend’s circumstances are difficult. She also recognizes that continuing to provide money under the existing arrangement is unlikely to resolve the difficulties and may create additional ones.

She decides that she will not make another loan.

The conversation is uncomfortable. Her friend feels disappointed, and there are moments when the woman wonders whether a more generous response would have avoided the tension.

But kindness cannot always be evaluated according to whether it produces immediate comfort.

There are occasions when an honest conversation offers something of greater value than another reassuring answer. A person may need to know that their behavior has damaged a relationship. An employee may need a clear explanation of why particular work is unacceptable. A friend may need to hear that a request exceeds what another person is willing or able to provide.

Such conversations do not become kind merely because we claim to be acting in somebody else’s interests.

We can be mistaken about what another person needs. We can use the language of concern to disguise a desire to control their decisions. We can deliver a necessary criticism with unnecessary severity and subsequently defend the manner of its delivery as honesty.

A considerate refusal therefore requires attention to both its purpose and its consequences.

Is the decision genuinely ours to make? Have we explained the relevant concerns without presenting uncertain assumptions as established facts? Are we protecting a reasonable limit, or attempting to punish somebody for asking a question?

In The Difference Between Knowing and Understanding, we examined how information becomes more useful when we understand the circumstances in which it matters.

We may not know everything about the friend’s financial situation. We can recognize the limits of our involvement without deciding that we understand the whole of her difficulty.

The woman can decline to lend money. She can also remain willing, within reasonable limits, to consider other forms of assistance.

Her refusal need not establish that the relationship has ceased to matter.

The unequal price of remaining considerate

There are circumstances in which people are expected to demonstrate kindness toward those who repeatedly treat them unfairly.

An employee may be praised for maintaining a pleasant manner in the presence of abusive customers. A person within a difficult household may be encouraged to preserve harmony by overlooking behavior that would attract considerable criticism if directed toward somebody else.

In such arrangements, the language of kindness can become a means of distributing responsibility unequally.

The person experiencing the difficulty is asked to remain patient. The person causing it is permitted to behave much as before.

We should be particularly careful about praising somebody’s restraint when we have little intention of changing the conditions that make restraint necessary.

A worker who is repeatedly subjected to abuse may need more than encouragement to remain professional. They may need clear procedures for ending an interaction, support from a supervisor and consequences for people who repeatedly disregard reasonable standards of conduct.

A person living in a coercive relationship may need practical assistance and safety rather than advice about becoming more understanding.

An expectation of consideration cannot replace the conditions through which considerate relationships become possible.

As discussed in The People We Become in Different Rooms, the consequences associated with speaking and disagreeing can differ considerably according to the authority people possess within a relationship.

Some people have much greater freedom than others to demonstrate patience without placing their interests or safety at risk.

It is therefore important to distinguish kindness freely exercised from accommodation demanded by people with the power to punish its absence.

The former may express a person’s character.

The latter may reveal something about the arrangement in which they are living.

What we choose not to pass onward

Several years before Arthur began working in the apartment building, he had been employed by a company whose owner regularly spoke to employees with contempt.

Mistakes were treated as opportunities for public criticism. Questions about unfamiliar procedures were sometimes received as evidence that somebody lacked the ability to perform the work.

Arthur had learned several useful skills there.

He had also learned what it was like to spend a working day anticipating another person’s irritation.

When he eventually became responsible for supervising younger employees, he discovered how easily some of the habits of his earlier workplace could have been reproduced.

It was convenient to become impatient with a question whose answer seemed obvious. It was tempting to assume that a person who had made a particular mistake should already have known how to avoid it.

He sometimes responded less considerately than he would have liked.

But the earlier experience had given him a reason to pay attention to those responses. The fact that somebody had treated him badly did not require him to adopt the same method of exercising authority.

There is an important form of strength involved in interrupting an arrangement from which we have suffered rather than reproducing it when we acquire the opportunity to do so.

That interruption need not involve limitless patience or an unwillingness to correct somebody.

Arthur expected his colleagues to learn the work. He explained when their decisions created difficulties, and there were circumstances in which he needed to intervene immediately.

He tried to remember that the purpose of correcting a mistake was to make better work possible.

Humiliation had not been necessary for him to learn how a heating system operated.

He saw no particular reason why it should be necessary for the people he was teaching.

The morning the machine was repaired

The replacement part arrived the following morning.

Arthur installed it and tested the machine several times. He sent the tenant a message explaining that it was available again.

Later that week, she encountered him in the entrance to the building. She thanked him for arranging the alternative machine and acknowledged that she had been unusually frustrated during their earlier conversation.

Arthur accepted the thanks.

There was no guarantee that responding calmly to another person would always produce a similar acknowledgment. Some people would continue behaving unfairly regardless of the consideration with which they were treated. Others might interpret patience as an opportunity to make additional demands.

Kindness is not a reliable means of controlling other people’s conduct.

Its importance can lie elsewhere.

It can express a decision about the way we wish to treat people while leaving us free to protect the conditions under which we are prepared to engage with them.

We need not accept every request. We need not remain in every relationship. We need not pretend that another person’s difficulties remove their responsibilities.

But we can distinguish the protection of our own interests from the desire to diminish another person, and the exercise of authority from the performance of hostility.

The following afternoon, Arthur showed his younger colleague how to identify a particular fault in another machine.

The colleague apologized for not having recognized it sooner.

Arthur told him that recognizing it was precisely what they were there to learn.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top