What Are the Most Powerful Stories About Love and Sacrifice? The Violin Beneath the Floor

What makes stories about love and sacrifice powerful? An archivist discovers a forgotten violin and uncovers the choices that shaped two women's lives after a wartime evacuation.

What Are the Most Powerful Stories About Love and Sacrifice? The Violin Beneath the Floor

The violin was discovered on a Tuesday afternoon, underneath the floorboards of a house scheduled for demolition.

A carpenter named Olek found it while removing a section of damaged timber. Its case was wrapped in a faded tablecloth. There was a photograph tucked beneath one of the straps and an envelope containing a little money that had ceased to be legal tender more than sixty years earlier.

The photograph showed two young women standing outside the house.

One held a violin.

By the following morning, the case had been delivered to the municipal museum, which was recording objects recovered from the district before the remaining buildings were removed. An archivist named Lucienne examined the accompanying information.

The address was familiar.

She had grown up in the adjoining street. Her grandmother, Amalia, had known several of the people who lived in that house.

Lucienne looked at the photograph.

The woman holding the violin resembled Amalia in a way that made her sit rather abruptly.

She took the photograph to the window.

On its reverse someone had written two names.

Amalia and Klara, before the journey.

Lucienne knew a great deal about her grandmother’s life after the journey.

She knew almost nothing about the journey itself.


Amalia had worked as a seamstress for forty-two years.

She lived in a small apartment near the market, where she kept a particularly good sewing machine, a collection of recipes she rarely consulted and thirteen plants of which only eleven were generally alive.

When Lucienne was a child, she frequently visited after school.

Amalia taught her to sew a button onto a shirt and to make a particular kind of cake without measuring the flour.

She also knew a considerable quantity of music.

She hummed passages while she worked. Sometimes she stopped in the middle of a tune and, after a moment, began a different one.

On one occasion Lucienne asked whether she had played an instrument.

“A little.”

“Which one?”

“The violin.”

“Can you play for me?”

Amalia smiled.

“I’ve not got one.”

Lucienne asked why.

“Never got another.”

The answer was not quite an explanation.

At twelve, Lucienne accepted it.

Years later, when she was studying the history of the city, she began asking older relatives about the period during which much of the eastern district had been evacuated.

Amalia spoke about the crowded stations, the journey inland and the house in which she subsequently lived. There were subjects she did not wish to discuss.

Lucienne respected that.

She assumed there would be another opportunity, whenever her grandmother felt ready.

Amalia died without providing further information about the violin.

The family placed a recording of some music she liked among the objects chosen for her memorial.

Lucienne thought she knew why the music mattered.

The photograph suggested that there were things about it she had not considered.


The museum’s conservator examined the instrument.

It had suffered considerable damage from moisture, but certain identifying features remained visible. There was a handwritten repair mark inside the case. Several strings had been removed. Its bow was missing.

Lucienne was assigned to establish what could reasonably be learned about its ownership and history.

She began with the address.

During the years before the evacuation, the house had been occupied by several members of the Varga family. A girl named Klara Varga appeared in a school register. Her father had worked at a printing firm, and her mother maintained a little business selling household goods.

Amalia’s family lived nearby.

The two girls were the same age.

An announcement preserved in the local newspaper described a recital at a school hall. Both had performed. Amalia played a short piece on the violin; Klara accompanied her on the piano.

The newspaper editor had apparently considered one of the other performers more interesting. The recital occupied three sentences, two of which concerned a young man who played the trumpet.

Nevertheless, the details were useful.

Lucienne found a second reference, published four years later.

Amalia had received an invitation to undertake further musical study in another city.

She stared at the little paragraph.

Her grandmother had never mentioned it.

The announcement had been published eleven weeks before the order to evacuate parts of the district.

Lucienne began constructing a story from those details.

Amalia must have been unable to take up the place. The violin must have been hidden during the evacuation. Her grandmother’s life must have been shaped by the loss of something she would otherwise have loved.

It was a plausible explanation.

It was not yet an established one.

She made a note distinguishing the available records from the conclusions she was tempted to draw.

Then she went to see her father.


He was sitting in his garden examining the hinges of a little shed.

Lucienne showed him the photograph.

He recognized Amalia immediately.

“Klara,” he said.

“You knew her?”

“Met her once.”

Lucienne was surprised.

He remembered a woman visiting the apartment when he was about nine. She wore a particularly impressive hat and brought a parcel containing a book.

Amalia had been pleased to see her.

The visit lasted an afternoon.

The two women spoke privately for much of it. Lucienne’s father remembered being asked to fetch bread and discovering, when he returned, that both women were laughing.

He had not seen Klara again.

“Why not?”

He shrugged.

“People went different places.”

He looked at the photograph once more.

Then he asked whether the violin could be repaired.

Lucienne explained that an assessment was ongoing.

He was quiet.

“I always thought she sold it.”

“Did she tell you that?”

“No.”

He smiled.

“She told me not to ask.”

Lucienne laughed.

She understood the distinction.

Her father put the photograph down.

“She was happy, you know.”

Lucienne looked at him.

“I know.”

“Not all the time. Nobody is.”

He returned to the hinges.

On the journey home, Lucienne remembered the wing donor in The Weight of a Borrowed Wing, whose life after a consequential gift could not be described accurately by treating his loss as the only significant thing about him.

She hoped to avoid doing that to Amalia.

She wanted to know what happened.

She did not want to make the life her grandmother actually lived into an unfortunate substitute for the one Lucienne imagined.


The first letter arrived from a retired teacher called Marta.

A notice about the discovery had appeared on the museum’s website, accompanied by the photograph and a request for relevant information. Marta contacted the museum to explain that Klara had been her mother’s cousin.

She had several family papers that might be useful.

Lucienne arranged to examine them with her permission.

Among the papers were photographs of a music school, a small appointment diary and several letters sent by Amalia to Klara after the evacuation.

The letters were mostly concerned with ordinary things.

A woman they both knew had married. A package had arrived. A friend was looking for a particular book. Amalia complained that the room in which she was living was cold.

One letter was different.

I have been thinking about the train. Please don’t keep saying that I ought to have gone. I know what I decided. What I don’t know is whether the decision could have been different if we had all been given a little more time.

Lucienne read the passage twice.

The letter was dated several months after the evacuation.

In another, written the following year, Amalia told Klara that she hoped she was continuing her lessons.

And don’t be ridiculous about playing the piece, she added. Play it better than I did. That is what I would like.

Marta examined Lucienne’s expression.

“Something interesting?”

“Possibly.”

They discussed the papers, made appropriate records of the materials and obtained permission for copies of selected documents to be retained.

There was still no clear account of the journey.

But it was becoming apparent that the two women’s circumstances had diverged.

Klara had continued studying music.

Amalia had not.


The district had been a very different place in the autumn of the evacuation.

Contemporary records established the broad sequence of events. As the danger increased, authorities announced arrangements intended to move civilians away from several areas. Transport was limited. The instructions changed on more than one occasion.

Families attempted to make decisions using information that was frequently incomplete.

The museum possessed accounts written by residents who left during the same period.

One remembered walking to a station carrying two bags of clothes. Another remembered being directed to a different building after discovering that the arrangements originally announced were no longer available. Several wrote about trying to locate relatives from whom they became separated.

Amalia’s younger brother, Stefan, was eight years old.

His name appeared in a later registration record alongside hers.

Their mother appeared in the same record on a subsequent date.

Their father was not recorded there.

Lucienne knew that he died during the conflict, but the family had little reliable information about the circumstances.

She examined a collection of administrative records relating to the music school.

The documents were incomplete.

There was a list of students expected to arrive before the beginning of term. Klara’s name appeared with a note recording that she had reached the city.

Amalia’s appeared beneath it.

No arrival was recorded.

Lucienne began to imagine the scene at the station.

She could see her grandmother standing beside a child, holding a ticket. She could see Klara waiting at a carriage door. She could imagine the moment in which Amalia might have decided that she could not leave.

The scene was vivid.

That was precisely what made it dangerous as evidence.

She wrote a second note.

Possible explanation. No direct account located.

She closed the records.

Outside, the museum’s courtyard was full of people eating lunch.

Lucienne went to join them.


At home, her daughter, Elise, was preparing an application for a place on a course in another country.

Elise wanted to study the history of architecture. The program would last two years, and she was trying to establish whether she could afford it.

Lucienne wanted her to go.

She also wanted her to remain within a distance that would allow them to meet on Sunday afternoons.

She found it difficult to express both wishes without making one sound like an objection to the other.

When Elise told her that she had completed the application, Lucienne congratulated her.

Then she began asking questions about the cost of accommodation.

Elise answered several.

Eventually she laughed.

“You’re going to ask me the price of every apartment in the city, aren’t you?”

Lucienne smiled.

“Possibly.”

She told Elise about the violin.

Her daughter was interested.

Then she asked whether Amalia had wanted to attend the school more than she wanted to stay with Stefan.

Lucienne looked at her.

“I don’t know.”

Elise nodded.

“That’s difficult, isn’t it?”

It was.

A person might love somebody and still wish for an opportunity that would take her away. She might choose to give up the opportunity and grieve it afterward. She might make a decision under circumstances in which no alternative appeared acceptable.

These possibilities were not mutually exclusive.

Lucienne remembered the railway worker in The Lantern at Mile Seventeen, whose affection for her husband did not remove her responsibilities to other people.

In Amalia’s case, the surviving records did not yet establish exactly how the choice had been made.

Lucienne hoped to find out.

She was also beginning to understand that she wanted an answer for reasons that concerned something besides the museum.

She wanted to know whether her grandmother had loved a life that she nevertheless chose to leave behind.


A second collection of papers became available several weeks later.

They belonged to a family who had been neighbors of the Vargas. Among the documents was an account written by a woman named Irene after she returned to the district.

She remembered leaving on the same day as Klara.

Amalia and Stefan had intended to go with them.

Their mother was supposed to follow after making arrangements for another relative, but the transport plan changed. Stefan was frightened and had been ill the preceding evening.

Irene remembered Amalia deciding to remain with him until she could establish where their mother was.

She remembered Klara offering to stay as well.

Amalia urged her to leave.

There were other people with whom Klara could travel. Amalia hoped to join her when the situation became clearer.

Irene did not describe the violin.

She did not remember seeing either woman carrying an instrument.

Lucienne read the account with considerable care.

It had been written several years after the events, and several details could not be independently established.

Still, it provided evidence that the separation involved immediate uncertainty about a child and his mother’s whereabouts.

The story was different from the one Lucienne had been imagining.

Amalia had not necessarily chosen between becoming a musician and caring for a brother for the rest of her life.

She had chosen, at a particular moment, not to leave a frightened child before knowing what the next arrangement would be.

The longer consequences followed from circumstances she could not then predict.

When the family eventually reached the inland town, the school had already begun its term. The practical arrangements for pursuing music were no longer those Amalia had considered earlier.

There was work to find.

There were rooms to obtain.

There was a family trying to live in circumstances that had changed.

Lucienne sat for a long time looking at the account.

She thought of how frequently the consequences of a sacrifice were described as though they had all been selected at the moment the sacrifice was made.

Some were not.


The museum received a letter from a woman named Petra.

She was eighty-one, lived in a different region and had learned of the violin through one of her children.

Klara had been her mother.

Petra was willing to speak about what she remembered.

Lucienne arranged a visit.

Petra’s apartment contained photographs of several orchestras, a cabinet of music and a piano on which stood a collection of small ceramic animals.

“My mother wasn’t a very good piano teacher,” she said.

Lucienne laughed.

“She was impatient with beginners. She knew what she wanted to hear and couldn’t quite remember why we couldn’t produce it.”

Petra described Klara’s career.

She had completed her studies, worked as an accompanist and later taught at a school. There had been periods when she earned very little money. There were opportunities she declined because of other obligations. She loved some of the work and disliked some of it.

She occasionally spoke about Amalia.

She remembered trying to persuade her to return to music.

After the conflict, Klara offered to help her obtain a violin and make inquiries about lessons.

Amalia was pleased by the offer.

She declined it.

At that point she was developing a sewing business. She had acquired clients, made friends among the other workers and become interested in making clothes for people whose requirements were difficult to accommodate.

Music remained important to her.

It was no longer the profession she wanted to pursue.

“Did Klara understand?” Lucienne asked.

Petra smiled.

“Eventually.”

She remembered an argument between the two women during a visit. Her mother had been insisting that Amalia possessed a talent she should not waste.

Amalia apparently explained that she would be interested in deciding for herself what counted as a waste.

For the next hour, the women scarcely spoke.

Then they went to buy a cake.

Petra laughed.

“My mother told that story quite often.”

Lucienne thought about Daniel, the designer in The Winter of the Paper Cranes, whose family had to learn that protecting somebody meant listening to what that person actually wanted.

Klara’s gratitude and affection had evidently been genuine.

So was Amalia’s right to decide what she wanted to do with the years that remained.


Petra had one more thing to show her.

It was a small notebook containing lists of pieces Klara intended to perform, notes concerning pupils and several recollections written toward the end of her life.

One page concerned the evacuation.

She had written that she and Amalia placed the violin under the floor because the arrangements for transporting luggage were uncertain, and because they expected to return within a few weeks. The house contained other belongings that were hidden or left behind.

Klara regretted that they had not taken the instrument.

She had subsequently acquired other things.

She could not replace the violin for Amalia because Amalia did not want a replacement.

There was a final sentence.

I think I spent too long imagining the life she had given me, instead of asking about the one she was making.

Lucienne read it quietly.

The account supplied a possible explanation for the location of the instrument, consistent with the other information the museum had obtained. It could not resolve every question about the events.

It did give her something more valuable than a dramatic conclusion.

It gave her two women who had continued changing after the afternoon in which they were separated.

Petra asked whether the violin would be displayed.

“Possibly. We’d have to establish the appropriate arrangements.”

“Would you play it?”

Lucienne shook her head.

“It isn’t in suitable condition.”

Petra nodded.

Then she went to the piano.

She played a few notes from a piece her mother used to practice.

Lucienne recognized the tune.

It was one Amalia had hummed while sewing.

She began crying.

Petra stopped.

“No, please.”

Petra continued.

When she finished, neither woman spoke for a moment.

Then Lucienne asked whether she wanted tea.


The museum prepared a small exhibition after the research and the arrangements concerning the object were completed.

The violin remained in its existing condition, supported appropriately within a case. The conservator explained that the display did not require an attempt to make it playable.

Beside it were copies of the photograph, several extracts from the family papers and a careful account of the circumstances that could be established.

The uncertain details were identified as uncertain.

Lucienne resisted the temptation to give the exhibition a title suggesting that Amalia had sacrificed her entire future.

Instead she called it Two Lives After the Train.

There were pictures of Klara’s school and of Amalia’s sewing business. One photograph showed Amalia standing beside a woman wearing a coat she had made. Both looked extraordinarily pleased.

Her father attended the opening.

He stood for a long time examining the violin.

Then he looked at the photograph of his mother beside the coat.

“She liked that one.”

Lucienne smiled.

“Did she?”

“Talked about it for weeks.”

They laughed.

Elise came too.

She had received an offer from the university and was considering the practical arrangements.

Lucienne asked how the decision was going.

Elise described what she knew about the costs and the possibilities for assistance.

Her mother listened.

Then she said she hoped Elise would choose the course if it was something she genuinely wanted and could arrange.

Elise hugged her.

“I’ll miss you.”

Lucienne smiled.

“I’ll miss you too.”

She did not explain that another person’s pleasure required her to conceal her own sadness.

She remembered the clockmaker in The Bell That Rang at Noon, whose understanding of generosity changed when she recognized that keeping a promise did not require her to become responsible for every possible consequence.

Lucienne could offer help with the journey.

She could not make the journey on her daughter’s behalf.


Several months after the exhibition closed, Lucienne attended a concert with her father.

One of the pieces was the one Petra had played.

She listened.

She thought of Amalia at seventeen, standing outside a house with a violin. She thought of the frightened child at the station, the sewing machine beside the market and the woman who laughed with an old friend before buying a cake.

Powerful stories about love and sacrifice, she understood, were not necessarily stories in which somebody lost everything for another person.

Sometimes they were about choices made with insufficient time, the unexpected consequences of an act of care, or the difficult freedom of the person who received it.

Sometimes the person who made the sacrifice wanted to be known for something else afterward.

The language of heroism could be generous.

It could also become another way of refusing to ask what a person wanted.

The music ended.

Lucienne’s father took her arm.

They walked out of the hall.

Elise had called that morning from her new city. She liked the course. She had become friends with a student whose apartment contained remarkably little furniture.

Lucienne intended to call her again on Sunday.

For now, she and her father were going to find somewhere to eat.

There was a restaurant opposite the station.

She had never been there.

They decided to try it.

Editorial note: Original historical-style fiction. The characters, city, institutions, evacuation and documentary records are invented. Powerful stories about love and sacrifice can explore competing responsibilities, irreversible loss, gratitude and the continuing agency of people who give or receive care. A sacrifice made during constrained circumstances need not define the entirety of a person’s later life. Love does not create an automatic duty to abandon one’s goals, and gratitude does not require lifelong repayment.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top