What Does Love and Sacrifice Teach Us About Human Nature? The Winter of the Paper Cranes

What does love and sacrifice teach us about human nature? A family discovers that caring for one another need not mean silently abandoning the futures they want to pursue.

What Does Love and Sacrifice Teach Us About Human Nature? The Winter of the Paper Cranes

The crane was folded from an application form.

Nora discovered it while clearing the dining table, half concealed beneath a newspaper and a plate containing the remains of somebody’s breakfast. One wing bore the name of an art school. The other carried part of a question about previous experience.

She recognized the handwriting along the crease.

Her brother had filled out the form.

“Daniel?”

He was in the kitchen, attempting to persuade a worn toaster to perform one more morning of useful work.

“What’s this?”

He came through, looked at the paper bird and smiled.

“Practicing.”

She unfolded it.

He stopped smiling.

The date printed at the top indicated that applications closed in twelve days.

“I thought you weren’t applying.”

“I’m not.”

“Then why have you filled it in?”

The toaster released two pieces of bread.

Daniel returned to the kitchen.

“Changed my mind.”

Nora looked at the flattened paper.

She had heard him say this about a journey, an evening course and a proposed visit to a friend who lived on the other side of the country.

Ordinarily she accepted the explanation.

That morning she remembered their mother’s appointment the following week, the winter timetable at the community center and Daniel’s habit of volunteering to deal with every difficulty before the rest of the family had finished discussing it.

She folded the crane again.

Its wings were uneven.

She placed it beside the window.


There were three children in the Havel family.

Nora, the eldest, repaired musical instruments at a workshop in the city. Daniel worked as a graphic designer. Their younger sister, Beth, taught at a primary school in a town several hours away.

Their mother, Evelyn, lived in the house in which they had grown up.

Their father died when Beth was nineteen. Several years passed before the household acquired a pattern that no longer seemed principally concerned with his absence.

Evelyn continued working at the library until retirement. She enjoyed reading detective stories, visiting gardens and attending meetings at which residents discussed the local bus service with an enthusiasm that occasionally surprised even the people responsible for operating it.

Then she developed a condition that affected her mobility.

There were medical appointments, practical difficulties and periods during which she needed assistance with some activities. Her circumstances changed over time, and the family sought professional advice about the support that might be appropriate.

Daniel lived nearby.

He began visiting more often.

When a light needed replacing, he replaced it. When groceries were needed, he bought them. He helped arrange several appointments and occasionally stayed overnight during periods when Evelyn needed more assistance.

Nora traveled from the city on alternate weekends when she could.

Beth helped with arrangements from a distance and visited during school holidays.

Everyone contributed something.

What none of them noticed quite early enough was that their contributions had developed into an informal system whose workings they could no longer describe.

Daniel knew the system.

Daniel was the system.


The paper cranes began with their father.

On a holiday many years earlier, he purchased a little book containing instructions for folding different kinds of birds. He became unusually ambitious, although his first attempt at a crane produced an object that looked like an unopened umbrella.

Evelyn placed it on the mantelpiece.

The children learned several of the designs.

For birthdays, their father often folded wrapping paper into birds and put them beside the cake. He said it was an economical way of making a celebration look larger than it was.

After his death, the little instruction book remained in a drawer.

Daniel occasionally made cranes while talking on the telephone. He found that folding paper occupied enough of his attention to make difficult conversations slightly easier.

When Evelyn’s appointments began taking up more of his time, the kitchen windowsill filled with birds.

There were cranes made from old envelopes and from the backs of printed advertisements. One was made from a page Daniel removed from a notebook on the day he learned that an exhibition he wanted to visit had sold out.

Nora saw them whenever she came to the house.

She regarded them as evidence that her brother had retained something of their father’s sense of humor.

She did not ask what he had written on the paper before folding it.


Daniel had wanted to study illustration for years.

His work as a designer was satisfying in several respects. He liked his colleagues. He liked the process of finding a visual solution to a difficult problem. He had developed expertise in preparing publications for organizations whose budgets did not allow many mistakes.

He also drew things that had nothing to do with his employment.

There were pictures of buildings, people waiting for trains and the objects he found on windowsills. He had begun preparing a collection of illustrations based on the notebooks their father left behind.

A small art school offered a program that would allow him to develop this work.

Some of the teaching would take place in person over a period of eighteen months. It would require him to travel regularly, rearrange his employment and consider the financial implications.

He obtained information about the program.

He spoke to a colleague who had completed a similar course.

He began preparing a portfolio.

Then one of Evelyn’s appointments was moved.

The new date fell on the afternoon of an introductory session at the school.

Daniel could have asked Nora to accompany their mother.

He could have asked whether another arrangement was possible.

Instead he canceled his attendance.

He told nobody.

The appointment went well.

On the way home, Evelyn asked whether he wanted to stop for coffee.

He said yes.

They found a café beside the market.

Evelyn complained cheerfully about the price of a sandwich and told him about an author she had recently discovered.

Daniel enjoyed the afternoon.

He had also begun feeling a quiet resentment that seemed particularly unreasonable because nobody had actually asked him to cancel the session.


Nora understood something of this feeling.

During the first years after their father’s death, she had declined several opportunities because they would have taken her farther from home. One involved training with a repairer whose work she admired.

The appointment was not necessarily the best opportunity available to her. There were sound reasons to decline it.

Yet Nora knew that she had not examined all the reasons.

She had remembered Evelyn sitting alone in the kitchen. She had imagined her becoming sadder if one of the children went away.

She had stayed.

Evelyn never asked her to.

Years afterward, when Nora began making plans to establish a workshop with a colleague, she delayed telling her mother because she was uncertain how she would react.

Evelyn was delighted.

She asked questions about the premises, the rent and the arrangements for acquiring tools.

Then she went to find a photograph of Nora repairing a broken music box at the age of eleven.

Nora laughed.

She had not known the photograph existed.

It occurred to her that much of the concern she had experienced before the conversation belonged to an account of her mother she had constructed without consulting the woman herself.

She remembered the illustrator in The Lighthouse With a Spare Room, who repeatedly judged an unmade choice according to the pain it might eventually produce. Nora’s circumstances were different, but she understood the temptation to treat an imagined loss as though it had already occurred.

Now, holding Daniel’s paper crane, she wondered whether the family had been acquiring a collection of sacrifices whose intended beneficiaries knew almost nothing about them.


That evening, Nora asked Daniel to go for a walk.

The weather was cold. The pavement near the park had become slippery, so they took a longer route through the town.

She asked about the course.

He said that it would be difficult to attend.

She agreed.

Then she asked whether he wanted to.

He shrugged.

“Would’ve been interesting.”

“That’s not quite an answer.”

He laughed.

She waited.

Eventually he told her that he had been thinking about it for nearly a year.

He described the teaching, the work he hoped to develop and the people whose illustrations he had seen at a previous exhibition.

For several minutes he appeared much younger than he had at breakfast.

Then he began explaining why the arrangements would be impossible.

Nora listened.

Some of his concerns were substantial. The cost of the course would require planning. His employer might not be able to accommodate every change to his schedule. The journey would consume time.

Others concerned their mother.

He could not attend sessions on the days she had appointments. He could not be away during the periods when she might need more support.

Nora asked whether he had spoken to Evelyn about any of this.

“No.”

“Why not?”

“She’ll say I should go.”

Nora looked at him.

“Isn’t that what you’d want her to say?”

He stopped walking.

He did want her to say it.

He also feared that she would say it without explaining what the decision would cost her.

For years he had been trying to protect her from a position in which she might need to ask her children for help.

He was worried that arranging things differently would force her into precisely that position.

Nora could understand the concern.

She was not sure their mother would regard being excluded from the discussion as a particularly useful form of protection.

They went home.


On Sunday, Beth arrived with a suitcase and a container of soup.

Evelyn had invited everyone to lunch.

The table was set. Daniel had bought bread, Nora had made a pudding and Beth explained in some detail why her journey had taken forty minutes longer than expected.

For a while nobody mentioned the paper crane.

After lunch, Nora asked Daniel whether he wanted to tell the others about the course.

He looked irritated.

She immediately regretted having raised the question without agreeing on the moment beforehand.

“I can tell them myself.”

“Sorry.”

Evelyn looked at him.

“What course?”

Daniel sighed.

Then he told them.

Beth was enthusiastic.

Evelyn asked where the school was.

He answered.

She asked about the teaching schedule.

He described what he knew.

There was a pause.

“Well,” she said, “that sounds lovely.”

Daniel began explaining why he did not think he could attend.

He mentioned the appointments, the shopping and the days he needed to remain available.

Evelyn listened.

Then she said she had been considering whether to seek additional assistance anyway.

The children stared at her.

She explained that she sometimes wished to arrange an outing without asking Daniel whether he was free. She wanted to know what local transport options and support services might be suitable for her. She was interested in a group that met at the community center on Wednesday afternoons.

She had mentioned these things several times.

Daniel had generally responded by explaining that he was happy to drive her.

He was happy to drive her.

He had not understood that this was not always what she wanted.

Beth began describing several possible arrangements.

Nora interrupted.

“Could we find out what Mum actually wants first?”

Evelyn laughed.

“That would make a change.”

They looked at one another.

Then they laughed too, though Daniel found the laughter rather difficult.


The following week was not especially pleasant.

Daniel submitted an application before the deadline, with the understanding that he would consider the practical circumstances before accepting a place if one was offered.

He felt pleased.

Then he felt guilty.

At work, he found himself thinking about the mornings he might spend away from the town. During a visit to Evelyn, he noticed several things he would ordinarily have dealt with without asking.

A shelf was untidy.

There were shopping bags near the door.

The kettle contained less water than he thought it ought to contain.

He began putting things away.

Evelyn asked him to stop.

He looked surprised.

“I was going to do that when I’ve finished reading.”

He sat down.

For a while he watched her reading.

He wondered whether he had become so accustomed to noticing the things she might need that he had ceased to notice the things she preferred to do herself.

Not all his assistance had been unnecessary. Much of it remained valuable. There were tasks she could not safely or reasonably manage alone.

But he had occasionally substituted his own judgment for a conversation because doing the task himself seemed quicker.

Evelyn put down the book.

She told him that she appreciated his help.

He nodded.

Then she said that she did not want him to spend the remainder of his life waiting for a period in which she would need nothing.

He stared at the floor.

“You might need more.”

“Possibly.”

She considered this.

“Then we’ll need a better arrangement.”

He remembered the gardener in The Garden With a Gate, who had discovered that keeping a service available to others required making the responsibilities sustainable. The garden was not a family, and family care was not simply a question of establishing opening hours. But Daniel recognized something of the pressure he had felt to remain the person through whom every arrangement passed.

He told Evelyn that he had sometimes been tired.

She nodded.

“I thought you might be.”

He was surprised.

Then he told her rather more.


The family arranged a discussion with the people who were appropriately involved in Evelyn’s care and support.

They wanted to understand what assistance she might benefit from, what services were actually available, what costs could arise and which responsibilities family members could realistically share.

There was no single arrangement that removed all the difficulties.

Some services were unavailable at the times Evelyn preferred. Some options required further assessment. The costs of others needed to be considered carefully.

Beth offered to take responsibility for several administrative tasks that could be completed remotely.

Nora offered to arrange visits on specified dates rather than promise to appear whenever something unexpected happened.

Daniel agreed to continue helping with tasks that suited his circumstances.

Evelyn expressed preferences about who assisted her and when.

Several arrangements remained to be confirmed.

For the first time in years, however, the family had begun discussing its system as something that could be changed.

Not everyone was immediately satisfied.

Nora worried that Daniel still intended to take on too much. Daniel suspected that the new arrangements would eventually require him to do as much as before. Beth worried that living farther away made her contributions comparatively small.

Evelyn did not wish to become the subject of a competition in which the children measured their affection by comparing the things they had given up.

She said so.

All three looked embarrassed.

Then Beth started laughing.

“Well, at least we’ve got one thing agreed.”

They made tea.

There were still decisions to make.

They would make them as the relevant information became available.


Daniel received an offer from the school in spring.

The moment the message arrived, he was standing at a bus stop holding a bag of groceries.

He read it.

Then he read it again.

His first thought was that he should telephone Evelyn.

His second was that he ought to determine whether accepting the offer would actually be possible.

He made the telephone call anyway.

Evelyn was delighted.

She told him to bring the groceries home before the frozen things thawed.

He laughed.

Over the following fortnight, Daniel discussed the proposed timetable with his employer, reviewed his finances and considered the arrangements the family had been developing.

He was able to establish a pattern that appeared manageable, although several aspects would need to be reviewed during the course.

He accepted the offer.

At the first session, the tutor asked the students to draw an object they associated with a particular person.

Daniel drew the old instruction book.

He discovered that its proportions were much less straightforward than he had imagined.

At lunchtime, he called Nora.

“How’s it going?” she asked.

“Terribly.”

She laughed.

“Good.”

He described the drawing.

Then he asked whether Evelyn had reached the community center.

Nora said she believed she had.

Daniel wanted to know what the transport arrangements had been like.

He was quiet for a moment.

Then he asked Nora if she had decided whether to accept a commission she had mentioned the previous week.

She had.

They discussed it.

For the first time in a considerable period, the greater part of their conversation concerned something other than the tasks necessary to sustain the family.


The winter that followed was difficult.

Evelyn’s condition changed, and some arrangements that had worked reasonably well required reassessment. The family sought appropriate advice and adjusted its plans.

Daniel missed two sessions at the school.

Nora rearranged a commission.

Beth traveled home for several days.

There were occasions when all of them were tired and when the decisions they made involved genuine costs.

They did not regard the difficulties as evidence that the earlier changes had been mistaken.

They had not been establishing a system in which nobody would ever have to make a sacrifice.

They had been establishing a system in which the sacrifices could be discussed rather than silently assigned.

Daniel sometimes worried that the other students were progressing more quickly than he was.

He talked to his tutor about the work he needed to complete and considered which projects he could reasonably undertake.

He was not required to pretend that everything could be accomplished simultaneously.

One evening Nora sat beside Evelyn while Daniel worked at the dining table.

They watched him draw.

Evelyn said that it reminded her of an afternoon when their father tried to fold an enormous paper crane out of a newspaper.

Nora remembered it.

Daniel looked up.

“Didn’t it collapse?”

“Spectacularly.”

They laughed.

Nora thought of the railway worker in The Lantern at Mile Seventeen, whose duties could not be abandoned simply because she longed to see someone, yet whose longing did not cease to matter because she had responsibilities.

In their own circumstances, love was sometimes expressed through practical help that required time and effort.

It was also expressed through recognizing the legitimacy of the life from which that time and effort came.

Daniel returned to his drawing.

Evelyn asked whether anyone wanted tea.

Nora went to make it.


The exhibition took place the following autumn.

Daniel’s work occupied one wall of the school’s smallest gallery.

There were illustrations of the places his father had described in his notebooks, the objects his mother retained in the house and several scenes he remembered from childhood.

At the center was a drawing of a paper crane.

The bird was not particularly elegant. Its left wing rose higher than its right. A few fragments of printed text were visible along the folds.

Evelyn looked at it.

“That’s the one from your application.”

Daniel smiled.

“More or less.”

Beth asked whether he had kept the original.

He had.

Nora stood beside him while visitors examined the pictures.

She was proud.

She was also pleased when he told her that he hoped to develop the collection further, although he had not yet decided what form that work would take.

The family had not solved every practical difficulty.

There would be further conversations about assistance, money, travel and the things they were able to offer. Some arrangements would need to change again.

Daniel understood now that love and sacrifice revealed something complicated about human nature. People wanted to protect those they loved. They wanted to be useful, dependable and worthy of the care they had themselves received. Sometimes they gave something freely. Sometimes they gave it because they were frightened of what might happen if they did not.

Sometimes the wish to protect another person led them to make decisions that the other person would have preferred to help make.

The clockmaker in The Bell That Rang at Noon had learned that a promise gained value through being one she could genuinely keep.

Daniel was learning that receiving help could be as important a part of loving someone as offering it.

At the end of the exhibition, he carried several pictures to Nora’s car.

Evelyn waited near the entrance.

Beth was telling her about a pupil who had painted a picture of a horse that resembled a very large insect.

They laughed.

Daniel found a small piece of paper in his pocket.

While the others talked, he folded it into a bird.

Then he gave it to his mother.

She unfolded it.

There was nothing written inside.

He smiled.

This time there was nothing he needed to conceal.

Editorial note: Original fiction. All characters, institutions and events are invented. Love and sacrifice can reveal our need for connection, the wish to protect other people and the importance of respecting their autonomy as well as our own. Caring responsibilities may involve real costs, and available support differs by individual circumstances and location. Sacrifice is not a universal measure of love. Open discussion, realistic commitments, informed choices and appropriate assistance can help families share responsibilities without treating one person’s indefinite self-denial as the only acceptable arrangement.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top