An Open Letter to Systems That Reward Obedience

A fictional ceramics apprentice discovers that the highest marks go to trainees who follow a demonstration exactly, even when the materials demand a different response. Through a disputed assessment and a damaged batch of bowls, this letter distinguishes responsible discipline from unquestioning obedience and considers what institutions lose when they discourage independent judgment.

An Open Letter to Systems That Reward Obedience printed in dark serif lettering on vintage parchment.

Dear examiners who gave me excellent marks for keeping quiet,

The bowl that earned my highest assessment had a crooked foot. It was a small imperfection, visible only when the bowl stood on a flat surface. I had noticed it during the demonstration and wanted to correct it, but our instructor had appointed a particular time for finishing the base. The assessment sheet rewarded adherence to the demonstrated sequence. I followed the sequence, submitted the bowl, and received a mark that pleased everyone except the person who would eventually try to eat from it.

I learned ceramics at an imagined training workshop. The apprentices, assessments, and objects in this letter are fictional, not an account of an existing qualification or a guide to ceramic production. I write because the difference between performing an instruction and understanding its purpose became particularly clear to me through the things we were learning to make.

Our instructor, Mr. Venn, had worked with clay for decades. He could look at the thickness of a vessel and notice an error that remained invisible to most of us. His demonstrations saved us from making many predictable mistakes. I admired the patience with which he introduced unfamiliar techniques. There was a sound reason for beginners to follow a carefully explained method before attempting to improvise.

There were also requirements we were not permitted to alter. Equipment had to be used under appropriate supervision, and the workshop maintained rules to protect everyone inside it. A person’s desire to experiment did not give them permission to disregard necessary safeguards. I accepted those boundaries then and continue to accept them now.

The difficulty appeared in the space between those boundaries and our instructor’s preferences. We were evaluated not only on whether our work was safe and sound, but on how closely our actions resembled the actions demonstrated to us. It became difficult to distinguish a required procedure from a convenient habit. An apprentice who asked why something was necessary sometimes received the same impatient response as someone who had refused to do it.

My friend Nessa was especially good at noticing differences in the material we received. She had worked briefly in a family pottery before entering the programme. When a batch of clay behaved differently from the previous one, she asked whether we should reconsider part of our planned work. Mr. Venn told her that the exercise was intended to teach consistency.

She was not proposing an unsafe alteration. She wanted to discuss whether a change in the material called for a change in our approach. Her question remained unanswered. Later, when the instructor evaluated our pieces, he described hers as promising but noted that she needed to respect the established method.

The published reflection on how systems teach behavior through consequences describes much of what followed. We observed which actions brought approval, then modified our behavior accordingly. Some of us became skilled at asking questions only when the instructor appeared receptive. Others learned to save their questions until we were alone. We were becoming competent at interpreting the expectations of a powerful person, even where those expectations had little connection with the object on the bench.

I enjoyed my reputation as a reliable apprentice. My assessment records contained words such as disciplined, consistent, and receptive. I could finish an exercise without attracting unwanted attention. If a demonstration appeared incomplete, I waited for somebody else to mention the omission. If an instruction seemed to contradict an earlier one, I tried to reproduce what I thought the examiner wanted to see.

There is a peculiar comfort in such a form of success. You do not have to decide whether an action is the best response to a situation. You have to discover whether it is the approved response. Responsibility appears to belong to the person who supplied the instruction, and recognition belongs to the person who carried it out. The arrangement can make uncertainty feel less frightening, particularly to someone whose future depends upon an assessment.

But the clay did not recognize the arrangement. It responded to its own condition, to the environment of the workshop, and to the actual treatment it received. It had no reason to reward our conformity. Our bowls could be flawed even when our assessment sheets were full of favorable marks.

During a group project, we were given material that differed noticeably from the stock we had used in earlier exercises. Several apprentices mentioned its unfamiliar behavior to one another. We continued preparing the work according to the timetable because none of us wanted to be the person responsible for an interruption. When our instructor eventually examined the batch, he identified problems that required several pieces to be discarded before they could be completed.

Nessa said that we had noticed the difference earlier. The instructor asked why we had not brought it to his attention. I remember looking at the surface of my unfinished bowl rather than answering. We had been told that independent observation was essential to our profession. We had also learned, through repeated experience, that observations inconsistent with an approved demonstration were inconvenient.

The distinction discussed in the letter on compliance as participation became difficult to ignore. We had participated enthusiastically in the training programme. Our attendance was good and our work was generally submitted on time. Yet the institution had sometimes mistaken our readiness to comply for evidence that we had acquired the judgment the training was meant to develop.

Mr. Venn was not delighted by this discovery. He had believed that his insistence on consistency was helping inexperienced apprentices develop dependable habits. He explained that he had seen beginners attempt changes they did not understand, and he feared that too much freedom too early would leave them without a sound foundation. His concern was legitimate. Our difficulty did not require us to dismiss his expertise.

We needed a clearer account of which decisions belonged to the learner, which required supervision, and which were governed by firm requirements. We needed to understand how questions about a method could be raised without being interpreted as objections to the instructor’s authority. Most of all, we needed assessments that examined the reasons for our actions rather than treating every departure from a demonstration as the same kind of mistake.

The workshop director invited several instructors and apprentices to reconsider the assessment criteria. We discussed what an exercise was supposed to teach. Some exercises genuinely required an apprentice to demonstrate a prescribed method. Others were intended to develop an ability to assess an unfamiliar piece of work. The criteria had not always distinguished the two purposes clearly.

We retained supervised demonstrations and necessary safeguards. Alongside them, we introduced opportunities for apprentices to describe an observed problem, explain a proposed response, and receive guidance before acting where authorization was needed. In selected exercises, the assessors considered the quality of that explanation as part of the result. A learner could receive credit for recognizing that the appropriate action was to stop and consult somebody with greater expertise.

The change made assessments more demanding. An instructor could no longer rely entirely on a checklist of actions performed in the correct order. Apprentices had to articulate what they had noticed and what they understood about the consequences of a choice. Some of us found that uncomfortable. We had become accustomed to receiving approval without exposing the uncertainties in our reasoning.

Nessa surprised me by defending several of the original exercises. She believed that reproducing a difficult technique accurately was valuable and that a person should not claim originality merely because they had failed to acquire a skill. Her argument helped me understand that the alternative to excessive obedience was not a permanent celebration of disagreement. Independent judgment requires knowledge, evidence, and the humility to discover that somebody else’s explanation is better than your own.

This is where the earlier reflection on accountability lost through the division of responsibility becomes relevant. An organization cannot simply demand that individuals take responsibility for outcomes while discouraging them from exercising the judgment those outcomes require. It must establish authority clearly, provide suitable training, and make it possible to raise a concern before a preventable problem becomes expensive.

I have since encountered similar questions in other imagined workplaces: a junior employee evaluating an unusual request, a new colleague discovering an inconsistency in a record, a trainee noticing that a familiar procedure does not fit the circumstances before them. Each person needs an appropriate way to distinguish ordinary uncertainty from a matter requiring attention. Their managers need to know when a question represents useful information rather than a challenge to personal status.

A system that rewards obedience above these distinctions may enjoy a reassuring period of quiet operation. Its meetings proceed smoothly, and instructions are carried out without prolonged discussion. But the quietness tells managers little about what their colleagues have noticed and decided not to mention. The institution may be losing valuable information at precisely the moment it feels most confident in its own authority.

This does not mean that every question must result in a policy change. A responsible instructor can explain why a suggestion is unsuitable. A supervisor can make a decision after considering evidence and expect colleagues to follow it within their legitimate duties. What matters is whether the process allows a relevant observation to reach the decision maker and whether disagreement can be evaluated on its merits.

At my final assessment, I was given a piece of work whose condition required me to explain what I had noticed before proceeding. I hesitated. An older version of myself would have searched the examiner’s expression for a clue to the desired answer. Instead, I described the uncertainty and indicated which part of the decision I did not yet know enough to make independently. We discussed it, and I continued under the agreed conditions.

The finished bowl was not particularly beautiful. Its proportions were modest, and a more experienced potter could have produced a finer object. But it stood steadily on the table. I understood considerably more about why it did so than I had understood when I received my earlier excellent mark.

Dear examiners, I hope you will keep teaching the methods that deserve to be learned. Explain the purpose of a requirement, and insist on the boundaries that protect people. But leave room for the observations that demonstrate a learner has begun to understand the world beyond the demonstration.

Your finest students may not always be the ones who give you the easiest afternoons. They may be the people who have learned to address a difficulty before it becomes a damaged batch, and who can explain their reasoning without confusing confidence with certainty.

Teach them to recognize legitimate authority. Then teach them what that authority needs from a person who is paying attention.

With respect for the craft and the questions that keep it alive,

An apprentice whose bowl finally stands straight

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top