What We Did Not Choose | Chapter 7

A family wedding. Assigned seats. Nowhere to go and no version of the evening that did not involve being in the same room for five hours. Chapter 7 of What We Did Not Choose.

What We Did Not Choose | Chapter 7

Chapter 7: What Families Do Not See

She found out about the wedding on a Wednesday.

Her mother mentioned it the way she mentioned things she had known for some time and had been selecting the right moment to reveal.

Casually.

Over the phone.

While also asking about something unrelated, so that the wedding information arrived inside a longer sentence and therefore could not be treated as its own event requiring its own reaction.

“Your cousin Nadia’s engagement party is Saturday. I told Aunty Rehana we would all come. I ran into Ahsan’s mother at the market, and she will also be there with the family, so I thought you should know.”

Zara held the phone.

“You thought I should know,” she said.

“Just so you are not surprised,” her mother said pleasantly.

“How long have you known they were invited?”

A pause.

“Sometimes,” her mother said.

Zara closed her eyes.

“Ammi.”

“It is Nadia’s engagement,” her mother said.

“It is a family occasion.”

“I cannot uninvite the Maliks.”

“I did not ask you to uninvite anyone.”

“You are using the voice,” her mother said.

“I do not have a voice.”

“You have had the voice since you were nine years old,” her mother said with the authority of someone who had been cataloguing evidence for nineteen years.

Zara said she would be there at seven.

She told Ahsan that evening.

His reply came quickly.

I know. My mother told me this morning.

She typed: And you did not say anything.

His reply: I was waiting to see how you wanted to handle it.

She stared at that for a long moment.

She typed: We handle it normally. It is a family occasion. We are two people who know each other. That is all.

He replied: Alright.

Then, after a moment, the grey again?

She put the phone down.

She picked it up.

She typed: Blue.

She did not examine why she told him that.

The engagement party was at a hall in Gulberg that Aunty Rehana had booked, with the specific aim of hosting someone who had been planning her daughter’s engagement since the daughter’s birth.

It was large, very bright, and full of the specific energy of a Pakistani family occasion, which was equal parts celebration, catching up, and the gentle competitive assessment of who had aged well and who had not.

Zara arrived with her parents at seven fifteen.

She wore blue.

She found her cousins.

She hugged Nadia, who was incandescent in the specific way of people on the day something they have wanted for a long time has finally arrived.

She ate something from a passing tray.

She talked to her aunt about the hospital.

She did not look for him.

She was aware of the moment he arrived anyway.

Not because she was watching the door.

She simply became aware, the way you become aware of a change in the temperature of a room, that he was in it.

She did not turn around for four minutes.

When she did, he was across the hall, standing with his parents and a cousin she did not recognise, wearing something dark, listening to something someone was saying with his particular quality of actual attention.

He had not looked for her either.

She knew the moment he found her because something in his posture changed.

Almost nothing.

Almost imperceptible.

But she had been paying attention to Ahsan Malik for six weeks, and she noticed it.

The evening moved the way family occasions moved.

In waves.

Periods of being absorbed by one group of people and then gently redistributed to another.

She was redistributed, at some point around eight thirty, to a table near the back of the hall where several of the older aunties had established themselves with tea and the sustained and pleasurable activity of discussing everyone else.

He was at the same table.

She did not know how this had happened.

She had a reasonable suspicion about who had arranged the seating.

She sat down.

He looked at her.

“Blue,” he said.

Very quietly.

Only she could hear it.

She picked up her tea.

Around them, the aunties were deep in a conversation about someone’s renovation that had apparently gone very wrong and required no input from either of them.

“Your mother,” she said.

“Mine too,” he said.

They sat in the particular charged quiet of two people who have said difficult, honest things to each other in a car park and are now sitting at a family table surrounded by relatives who are watching without appearing to watch.

“Nadia seems happy,” he said.

“She is,” Zara said.

“She has known him for three years,” she said.

“They chose each other.”

She had not meant it to land the way it did.

But the word chose sat between them, and they both looked at it.

“Does that matter to you?” he said.

“Choosing,” he said.

She wrapped her hands around her cup.

Around the base.

She noticed herself doing it and did not stop.

“I spent a long time building a life that was entirely my own choices,” she said.

“Every decision.”

“Every direction.”

“Medicine, the city, the apartment, the way I take my tea.”

“All of it mine.”

“And then my mother laid out a gold outfit on my bed, and I wore grey and walked into a room full of people I did not choose to be in.”

She paused.

“And somehow,” she said.

“Somehow the thing I did not choose is the thing I cannot stop thinking about.”

“And I do not know what to do with that.”

“Because a person who builds their whole life on choosing should be able to choose this clearly.”

“And I cannot.”

She stopped.

The auntie to her left laughed loudly at something.

The hall continued its warm oblivious noise.

Ahsan was looking at her with the expression that had no name.

The one that had appeared in the kitchen on the first night and had been appearing at intervals since then, when she said something he had not expected, did not know what to do with, and was not going to pretend otherwise.

“Zara,” he said.

She looked at him.

“You are choosing,” he said.

“Every Thursday,” he said.

“Every text.”

“Every blue outfit.”

“You are choosing.”

“You have been choosing for six weeks.”

“The only thing you have not done is decide to call it that.”

The auntie to his right tapped his arm to ask him something about his work.

He turned.

He answered.

The conversation moved elsewhere.

Zara sat very still with her tea.

The hall around her was full of light and music, and the particularly beautiful noise of people who loved each other gathered in the same room.

Nadia was laughing across the hall with her soon-to-be husband, the laugh of someone in the middle of the thing they wanted, not approaching it, not looking back at it, but in the middle of it.

Zara watched her.

Then she looked at the man sitting beside her, who had just told her she had been choosing all along without calling it choosing.

And she thought about the grey dupatta on the first evening.

And the cold tea she had stayed to drink.

And the dupatta she had left behind.

And the coffee place every Thursday.

And the blue.

She had been choosing.

She had been choosing since the moment she sat across from him in the Malik sitting room and said neither of them wanted to be there.

She had been choosing ever since.

Later, when the evening was ending, the hall was beginning its slow warm dispersal, and they ended up near the exit at the same moment.

His parents were saying goodbye to her parents, the four of them were doing the extended Pakistani farewell, which could last anywhere between five minutes and half an hour, depending on how much there was to say.

They stood slightly apart from the parents.

Close enough to be part of the group.

Far enough to be briefly, quietly, separate from it.

“Same time Thursday,” she said.

She said it first.

She had never said it first before.

He was still for a moment.

Something crossed his face that she felt in her chest before she could name it.

“Same time Thursday,” he said.

Outside, the Lahore night was doing what it always did.

Being enormous and indifferent and entirely unaware of the small, specific, impossible thing that had just quietly decided to become real.

She walked to the car with her parents.

She did not look back.

She was smiling.

She let herself.


End of Chapter 7

Chapter 8 is coming soon.

Subscribe to 786 Web Stories so you do not miss the night he does not call and what that silence reveals about everything.

Reading from the beginning?

Start with Chapter 1.

Catch up with Chapter 2, Chapter 3, Chapter 4, Chapter 5, and Chapter 6.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top